OzSpen said:
Let me get this clear (with a broader application): There are Christians who won't make cakes for those who commit adultery and engage in other sexually promiscuous activity. But they'll do it for those who do not engage in such adultery and promiscuity. And they don't consider this violates the second great commandment.
The two great commandments are articulated in Mark 12:30-31 (ESV): 'And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength.’ 31 The second is this: ‘You shall love your neighbour as yourself.’ There is no other commandment greater than these"'.
So what does it mean to love your neighbour? Do you want it to mean to endorse their promiscuous sexual activity which God has forbidden, whether that be adultery, sexual promiscuity and homosexuality?
What's wrong with a gay baker refusing to do business with Christians? If that's his choice, then he'll gain that reputation in the town and suburb so that Christians will know not to do business with him.
By the way, what is your definition of 'love' in 'love your neighbour'?
Oz
My definition of the second great command is that if I wanted a cake made for me and was denied because I am Christian I would feel very very badly. I would think just because of me being Christian you can hate my faith so much that you won't even bake a cake? Not a cake? What else would you deny? If I fell ill you'd not call emergency services? You'd just let me expire? How absolutely cruel you could be only because I'm Christian?
Then I think if I would not like that for me, could I do it to someone else? The cake is immaterial at that point. My own beliefs, my own ethics, my own consciousness is called into question.
Am I really loving myself by giving up what I know is true just to prove that someone is doing wrong? What of the straight adulterers? Should I hold my love from them? What of the other sinners?
Should I turn myself into something I would detest just to prove the point that I'm more righteous than another? What profit is in that? Sounds like I'm the servant in the parable of a certain king. That I won't forgive the debt of another after mine is. That if I were God I'd only make the rain fall on the just and not unjust.
No.
I refuse.
Completely refuse.
I will not only make their cake. I will make it the best cake I could. I'd give them the most awesome cake. Because despite their choices I love myself to be perfect (teleios) and to love them and treat them as I would want for myself.
The King came for all, not just the righteous. He laid down his life, journeyed to sheol and then came back for the unrighteous.
Least I can do is make a cake.
Least I can do is love as I would desire to be loved.
And then pray that God moves in their life.
Who am I do only show love to those whom love me? I profit nothing from that.