I was once a non-believer of Jesus; however, I had encountered his divine intervention throughout my life. What offended me personally about Christianity was being told that I was a sinner and, because of that, needed to repent of my sins and ask Jesus into my life as my personal Lord and Savior.
I was being told that without him, and without the forgiveness made possible through his shed blood, I remained in sin, and the consequence of that sin was death.
It bothered me because I had never heard this story before. I had never heard that God had sent his Son on my behalf, that there was a penalty for sin, or that sin had brought about a separation between God and humanity.
It was difficult to receive because this was a story I had never known. It was outside everything I had grown up knowing and was not part of my culture or upbringing.
Looking back, I can understand why it was confronting. I was being introduced to an entirely different understanding of God, sin, and my need for a Savior. What initially offended me was what eventually caused me to consider that there was far more to life than God's divine intervention but a personal relationship with God through his Son, Jesus.