Not sure how you read scripture, but Matthew 21:43 absolutely says that God will replace the negligent Israel with other nations that will produce fruit. If you are a Jew, don't be offended, it happened. You are one of the spiritual minded that saw the right path and are happily moving with Jesus in your life. Good going.Luke 1:32-33 says nothing about church replacing Israel. It actually is establishing and endorsing Israel. V 32 says give Him the throne of David, well this is fulfilling prophecy that a king from the house of David/who represents the tribe of Judah will always be on the throne who is our King Messiah Jesus. Who is of the line of David through Mary and Joseph. This is why they were in Bethlehem at the time of His birth because of the census called they were all required to go to their homeland/tribe to be counted Bethlehem is in the land allotted to Judah as is Jerusalem way back when they first entered and conquered Canaan and the land was split up into the 12 tribes. V 33 He will rule over the House of Jacob. Well this is just another way of saying Israel/the house of Israel. Confirming the prophecies in Ezekiel 37 where the two houses of Israel that were one then divided will be bought into one again establishing Israel again and Jesus our Messiah will rule and reign as King. Praise God
Matt 21:43 The context is a parable. A parable is a story told to make a point. Yes many rejected Him as Messiah. The kingdom can be taken from those that reject Him. This is what Paul talks about in Rom 11 about being grafted in even the natural branches that were broken off can be grafted back in to the olive tree. Olive tree represents Israel. Paul also warns Gentiles who have been grafted in not to be prideful and remember that we don't support the root the root supports us. Yes even the people involved in Judaism need to receive the redemption of Messiah these who do are the natural branches who were broken of and grafted back in through our Messiah. Trust me there are many many many Jews/Judaism accepting and receiving Jesus as the Messiah. But Matt 21:43 again is not saying the church has replaced Israel.
There are no contradictions in the word of God. Reject the false man-made doctrine of man about replacement theology, it is ugly deceptive and plain evil.
Shalom Friend
By the way, I am from the house of Ephraim, you are from the house of Judah in the House of Israel, so I understand what you are thinking.