I don't identify as a "Christian"

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Matthias

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
32,415
24,230
113
Kentucky
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Do you mean something like do I consider the Bible to be "The Word of God"?

Yes.

Do you me like an actual place?

Yes.

I will be living and in that serving The Father in whatever capacity that requires.

Who is “The Father” you are referring to? In the Bible he is Jesus’ God and my God (John 20:17). That’s binding for me but it isn’t for you.

How long is a piece of string Matthias.

What I’m interested in learning is how long you know your string to be.

If there a point to these questions please share that with me.

I’m just trying to get to know you better.
 
  • Like
Reactions: talons

talons

Well-Known Member
Oct 18, 2024
1,530
2,365
113
Alabama
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
To clarify my position.
  • I have a relationship with my Father (The Father.)
Welcome to the forum @Eternal Entity .

Yes , surely we do if we have taken Jesus as our savior .
I walked the path of The Son to gain that relationship.
Let me see if I understand you correctly .
Christ's walk was life , death on the cross and resurrection . Would you say you are born again , the old man is dead ?
I do not call myself a Christian. A couple of reasons for this is because Jesus was never recorded as using that label for his followers and because the religion built around his name is acknowledged by me to have always been unnecessary to my beginning and developing relationship with my Father (The Father.)
Instead of Christian it could be , I am a person of the Way , I am a follower of Jesus , but we must be born again in any case . The part I bolded and enlarged has raised some questions from me .

Are you Jewish ?

That part I bolded is the eye blinking moment for me in what you have said because without the Christian religion how would you ever find out about your savior Jesus Christ ?

I would ask you who started this religion built around His name ?
 

Angelina

Seer - eagle
Staff member
Admin
Feb 4, 2011
44,208
31,311
113
Hawkes Bay
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Female
Perhaps. Or even, most likely?

That is interesting and may have a bearing on differencials.

Thank you for explaining how you believe things to be.
In the context you offer re that belief, I would say that Jesus is the mediator in the sense that he is the one who introduces the follower of the Son to The Father and in doing so "job done".
That is the short succinct reply. The map from one point to the other is a whole book of stories.
May your walk be toward that end.

In Love

Thank you, @Eternal Entity. That does help me understand your position more clearly.

If I've understood you correctly, you see Jesus as a mediator in the sense that he introduces the follower to the Father, and once that relationship is established, the purpose of the mediation has been fulfilled.

The reason I find that interesting is that it differs from how I understand Christ's role. As I read Scripture, Christ is not only the one who brings us to the Father but also the one who continually intercedes for us and remains our mediator.
So perhaps one of the "differentials," as you have mentioned, is not whether Jesus mediates but whether his mediation is something completed at introduction or something ongoing.

Would that be a fair discription/distinction?

And when you speak of your relationship with the Father, do you see that relationship as being grounded in Christ's ongoing work or mainly in the relationship itself once established?

I'm interested in understanding the map you mentioned, because it seems we're using some of the same words but perhaps drawing different routes between them. coffee:

Your buddy
Angie!
 
  • Like
Reactions: talons

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
Thank you, @Eternal Entity. That does help me understand your position more clearly.

If I've understood you correctly, you see Jesus as a mediator in the sense that he introduces the follower to the Father, and once that relationship is established, the purpose of the mediation has been fulfilled.

The reason I find that interesting is that it differs from how I understand Christ's role. As I read Scripture, Christ is not only the one who brings us to the Father but also the one who continually intercedes for us and remains our mediator.
So perhaps one of the "differentials," as you have mentioned, is not whether Jesus mediates but whether his mediation is something completed at introduction or something ongoing.

Would that be a fair discription/distinction?
Yes Angie. Would that distinction tell you that I am not a Christian? Or perhaps it might tell you that I am not a Christian in the way that you are?
And when you speak of your relationship with the Father, do you see that relationship as being grounded in Christ's ongoing work or mainly in the relationship itself once established?
What do you think Christs ongoing work is?
I'm interested in understanding the map you mentioned, because it seems we're using some of the same words but perhaps drawing different routes between them. coffee:
You appear to be perplexed about that? Do you think all paths are or should be the same?
Your buddy
Angie!
In Love
Eternal Entity!
:)
 

Angelina

Seer - eagle
Staff member
Admin
Feb 4, 2011
44,208
31,311
113
Hawkes Bay
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Female
Yes Angie. Would that distinction tell you that I am not a Christian? Or perhaps it might tell you that I am not a Christian in the way that you are?

What do you think Christs ongoing work is?

You appear to be perplexed about that? Do you think all paths are or should be the same?

In Love
Eternal Entity!
:)
Hi @Eternal Entity, Good questions.

No, I don't think that distinction alone tells me whether you are or are not a Christian. It tells me that we understand Christ's mediating role differently, but I wouldn't reduce a person to a single theological point.

As for Christ's ongoing work, I understand Him as continuing to intercede for his people and to remain our mediator before the Father. I also understand the Christian life as something lived through the ongoing work of the Holy Spirit, whom Christ sent to dwell within believers and lead them into truth.

Regarding the paths question, I would say that everyone's journey can be very different. Our experiences, questions, and testimonies vary greatly.

Where I would differ is that I don't believe differing journeys necessarily imply differing routes to the Father. From my understanding, the believer's relationship with the Father is through the Son and lived in communion with God by the Holy Spirit.

So my interest is not whether our stories look the same, but whether we mean the same thing when we speak of the Father, the Son, and the relationship between them.

With love and respect. :clmSmlx
Angelina
 
  • Like
Reactions: talons

rockytopva

Mod
Staff member
Dec 31, 2010
6,556
3,406
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
My testimony is similar to George Clark Rankin in which I was first introduced to a lifeless Christianity...


Like GC Rankin, after a time in quality revival the good Spirit finally came through.... I was born in North Carolina on a Marine Corp base and traveled the US. As a pre-teen we moved to the North where I was brought up in a cold, dull, dry, Protestant church and considered myself an Agnostic Atheist, but went to church for fear of eternity. I would look out at the winter Michigan tundra and wonder what was more dead and lifeless... The winter scenery out the windows or the church I was in. The At seventeen I moved here to Virginia staying at my grandmother's, and attending the local Pentecostal Holiness church. My old Pentecostal Holiness pastor was an old evangelist turned pastor. He really knew how to get wonderful evangelist for revival. One summer day as a teenager I was reading Nikki Cruze's Run Baby Run after a wonderful revival and I heard a voice speaking to the heart..."Put the book down" Not realizing what was happening I continued to read. I was sleeping next to an open outside door and the kady-dids were singing their praises to God very loudly. The voice spoke again... "Put the book down!" I then put the book down and heard the voice speak yet again... "Where is all the strife, hatred, and bad feelings?" I examined the heart to find nothing there but pure beauty. I thought to myself, "Oh my! I got exactly what those people got!"

Without the Good Spirit of God I would have remained an atheist.
 

Riven

Well-Known Member
Jul 6, 2024
1,464
1,130
113
38
Florida
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Greetings Reader.

I joined this forum today. In the membership form I was asked how I identify religiously and was given a list of options, and chose the one which most closely mirrored my position - that being "Agnostic".

What I think is true:

I exist within a created thing.
I have many good reasons why I think this is true.

Since I think this is true, that would make me a "Theist" - because IF I think I exist within a created thing, THEN this implies a Creator/Creators.
Perhaps in that context, I might be an Agnostic Theist.
I do not self identify as being a "Christian" for many reasons. I have no problem with others who self identify as being Christian, for whatever reasons they chose to do so.
Truely, the "self identification" doesn't mean much to me, but I understand it means something to others, so that they may be able to better pinpoint who I am in relation to who they believe they are. Such is the nature of human interactions on that level.
To flip that, others who self identify as being "Christians" when they interact with me, the label doesn't really mean a lot to me in any significant way. This is because there are so many "types" of Christians, and many of those do not agree with one another most of the time and that is just one of the reasons why I do not self identify as being "Christian".
Are there any others hereabouts think in a similar way about this?

Peace.
EE
Hello, @Eternal Entity .

I'm curious. Why do you think the universe was created?
 

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
I’m just trying to get to know you better.
I must say I had a wee chuckle about that Matthias.
The irony being that you are a long standing member of this message board

Well-Known Member​

Joined May 4, 2022
You have made 32,402 posts in that time and have received 24,224 likes yet in this very thread there are other long standing members who were not aware of your position on things - who did not "know" you.

What do you think was the reason for that and do you think that anyone really can truly know anyone else and do you think your questions and the way you ask them are really going to help you to know me?
 

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
Hi @Eternal Entity, Good questions.

No, I don't think that distinction alone tells me whether you are or are not a Christian. It tells me that we understand Christ's mediating role differently, but I wouldn't reduce a person to a single theological point.

As for Christ's ongoing work, I understand Him as continuing to intercede for his people and to remain our mediator before the Father. I also understand the Christian life as something lived through the ongoing work of the Holy Spirit, whom Christ sent to dwell within believers and lead them into truth.
So, if I understand you here, you do not have a direct relationship with The Father, but an indirect one through The Son?
If that is the case, then yes, we have a different relationship with The Father. THat is not a problem through my understanding of the dynamics involved, and may be the key reason why I am not a Christian, if indeed being a Christian has to do with the one dynamic and not the other.
Regarding the paths question, I would say that everyone's journey can be very different. Our experiences, questions, and testimonies vary greatly.
Agreed. To underline that observation, there is not a thing in this universe exactly the same as any other.
Where I would differ is that I don't believe differing journeys necessarily imply differing routes to the Father. From my understanding, the believer's relationship with the Father is through the Son and lived in communion with God by the Holy Spirit.
From my understanding, while this is relevant, I think of it in terms of "those who are suckling the milk" and "those who are eating the meat" which is reflective of the observation that individuals experiencing the human experience are able to choose where on the spectrum they feel most comfortable in being.
So my interest is not whether our stories look the same, but whether we mean the same thing when we speak of the Father, the Son, and the relationship between them.
What do you think about that and why...
With love and respect. :clmSmlx
Angelina

In Love
Eternal Entity.

:)
 

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
My testimony is similar to George Clark Rankin in which I was first introduced to a lifeless Christianity...


Like GC Rankin, after a time in quality revival the good Spirit finally came through.... I was born in North Carolina on a Marine Corp base and traveled the US. As a pre-teen we moved to the North where I was brought up in a cold, dull, dry, Protestant church and considered myself an Agnostic Atheist, but went to church for fear of eternity. I would look out at the winter Michigan tundra and wonder what was more dead and lifeless... The winter scenery out the windows or the church I was in. The At seventeen I moved here to Virginia staying at my grandmother's, and attending the local Pentecostal Holiness church. My old Pentecostal Holiness pastor was an old evangelist turned pastor. He really knew how to get wonderful evangelist for revival. One summer day as a teenager I was reading Nikki Cruze's Run Baby Run after a wonderful revival and I heard a voice speaking to the heart..."Put the book down" Not realizing what was happening I continued to read. I was sleeping next to an open outside door and the kady-dids were singing their praises to God very loudly. The voice spoke again... "Put the book down!" I then put the book down and heard the voice speak yet again... "Where is all the strife, hatred, and bad feelings?" I examined the heart to find nothing there but pure beauty. I thought to myself, "Oh my! I got exactly what those people got!"

Without the Good Spirit of God I would have remained an atheist.
Thank you

rockytopva

for your short witness.
Interestingly, it reminded me of my own reading of that book - in my early-mid teens. The first 12 years of my life I experienced life in what is regarded as NZ's worst suburb - I spent most of my time running fast, talking fast or taking a beating. I was not a fighter.
Nicky was - and did not hold back when it came to inflicting damage on others with the knife.

I admit that the first part of his story influenced me - perhaps even impressed me. When I was moved to stay with my Uncle (mum's/mom's brother) a long way from where I was brought up, I had the same thing to deal with - for different reasons - but being bullied anyway. I drew on Nicky's witness - (before he was exposed to David) and without going into details I decided to use a compass (those used for technical drawing) to deal with a bully by stabbing him with it a few times.
The results were that I learned the anger and such response did not fix anything and I paid for my transgression in the playfield by taking yet another beating.
I have never been an atheist. I have been a Cultural Christian, went through the Christian dynamic and eventually moved on. Often the Church (generally speaking) teaches there is only "either or" One is either a believer or an atheist.

I am not religious, and certainly am not an atheist.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rockytopva

Angelina

Seer - eagle
Staff member
Admin
Feb 4, 2011
44,208
31,311
113
Hawkes Bay
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Female
So, if I understand you here, you do not have a direct relationship with The Father, but an indirect one through The Son?
If that is the case, then yes, we have a different relationship with The Father. THat is not a problem through my understanding of the dynamics involved, and may be the key reason why I am not a Christian, if indeed being a Christian has to do with the one dynamic and not the other.

Agreed. To underline that observation, there is not a thing in this universe exactly the same as any other.

From my understanding, while this is relevant, I think of it in terms of "those who are suckling the milk" and "those who are eating the meat" which is reflective of the observation that individuals experiencing the human experience are able to choose where on the spectrum they feel most comfortable in being.

What do you think about that and why

Hmm... :IDK:@Eternal Entity, I think there's a possible gap in the way you’re building your conclusion.
You start with "If the universe is created, that implies a Creator" and then move into “agnostic theism” as a reasonable label. That part of the reasoning is coherent on a philosophical level. The issue comes after that, because you then treat “Creator” as if it can remain an abstract conclusion without necessarily engaging with revelation or identity.

That’s where your position becomes questionable because it assumes that you can affirm causation while remaining neutral to what that cause actually is or what it has said about itself.

If there is a Creator in the stronger sense you’re implying, then the question isn’t just "does one exist?” but “has this Creator acted, spoken, or revealed Himself?” At that point, pure agnosticism starts to lose coherence, because neutrality about identity becomes harder to maintain once revelation is in view.

On your other point, about not calling yourself Christian, I actually think you’re right that labels can be inconsistent across people. But the Christian claim itself isn’t primarily a label issue; it’s a claim about Christ’s identity and authority. So avoiding the term doesn’t really sidestep the underlying question; it just postpones it.

Also, I noticed in your reply to others you tend to step back from being “known” or defined by what people think they understand about you. I get that instinct. But philosophically, it also means you’re keeping yourself protected from conclusions that your own reasoning might already be pointing toward.

So I’d ask you directly: if the Creator is not just inferred but real, what would actually stop him from being knowable rather than only inferred?

Because at that point, “agnostic theism” stops being a final position and becomes an unfinished one. I will catch up with you tomorrow, my friend. - AngelN a :clmSmlx
 

rockytopva

Mod
Staff member
Dec 31, 2010
6,556
3,406
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Thank you

rockytopva

for your short witness.
Interestingly, it reminded me of my own reading of that book - in my early-mid teens. The first 12 years of my life I experienced life in what is regarded as NZ's worst suburb - I spent most of my time running fast, talking fast or taking a beating. I was not a fighter.
Nicky was - and did not hold back when it came to inflicting damage on others with the knife.

I admit that the first part of his story influenced me - perhaps even impressed me. When I was moved to stay with my Uncle (mum's/mom's brother) a long way from where I was brought up, I had the same thing to deal with - for different reasons - but being bullied anyway. I drew on Nicky's witness - (before he was exposed to David) and without going into details I decided to use a compass (those used for technical drawing) to deal with a bully by stabbing him with it a few times.
The results were that I learned the anger and such response did not fix anything and I paid for my transgression in the playfield by taking yet another beating.
I have never been an atheist. I have been a Cultural Christian, went through the Christian dynamic and eventually moved on. Often the Church (generally speaking) teaches there is only "either or" One is either a believer or an atheist.

I am not religious, and certainly am not an atheist.
After church one day Robert Sheffey's soul felt full and the morning sermon had opened his eyes to something. The minister had preached long and eloquently. His theme was that most of mankind did not respond to the call of God because they did not feel His lovingkindness." - Jess Carr's Saint of the Wilderness (the calling of RS Sheffey)

"His theme was that most of mankind did not respond to the call of God because they did not feel His lovingkindness." I have got to believe that feeling some kind of good spirit is an absolute necessity. We have simply got to believe that God is on our side.
 

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
Hmm... :IDK:@Eternal Entity, I think there's a possible gap in the way you’re building your conclusion.
You start with "If the universe is created, that implies a Creator" and then move into “agnostic theism” as a reasonable label. That part of the reasoning is coherent on a philosophical level. The issue comes after that, because you then treat “Creator” as if it can remain an abstract conclusion without necessarily engaging with revelation or identity.

That’s where your position becomes questionable because it assumes that you can affirm causation while remaining neutral to what that cause actually is or what it has said about itself.

If there is a Creator in the stronger sense you’re implying, then the question isn’t just "does one exist?” but “has this Creator acted, spoken, or revealed Himself?” At that point, pure agnosticism starts to lose coherence, because neutrality about identity becomes harder to maintain once revelation is in view.
Hmm Angelina - I think perhaps you have not fully understood my calling my "faith" Agnostic as explained already. Would you say the same as you have above, to someone who states they are a Theist? If not, then please feel free to think of me as a theist with agnostic tendencies.
On your other point, about not calling yourself Christian, I actually think you’re right that labels can be inconsistent across people. But the Christian claim itself isn’t primarily a label issue; it’s a claim about Christ’s identity and authority. So avoiding the term doesn’t really sidestep the underlying question; it just postpones it.
I acknowledge that is what you think. I don't think the same. You are simply stating that only those who do not avoid calling themselves Christians can think of and understand the identity and authority of The Christ.
My choice not to self identify as a Christian has nothing to do with avoiding The Christ. - The Head of which - is The Father.
Also, I noticed in your reply to others you tend to step back from being “known” or defined by what people think they understand about you. I get that instinct.
Do you see The Truth re that instinct?
But philosophically, it also means you’re keeping yourself protected from conclusions that your own reasoning might already be pointing toward.
What conclusions might these be Angelina?
So I’d ask you directly: if the Creator is not just inferred but real, what would actually stop him from being knowable rather than only inferred?
It is not a matter of stopping The Creator. The Father niether intrudes upon an individual humans will to prevent nor rejects that same will to allow.
Because at that point, “agnostic theism” stops being a final position and becomes an unfinished one. I will catch up with you tomorrow, my friend. - AngelN a :clmSmlx
Have I not already answered that Angelina? Did I not say that we are all agnostic about some things and that I am not myself agnostic about existing within a created thing and what that implies?

Sleep well and dream wonderful.

In Love.
 

PeterAndroz

Active Member
May 15, 2026
486
114
43
42
Mt Compass Adelaide
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Hmm Angelina - I think perhaps you have not fully understood my calling my "faith" Agnostic as explained already. Would you say the same as you have above, to someone who states they are a Theist? If not, then please feel free to think of me as a theist with agnostic tendencies.

I acknowledge that is what you think. I don't think the same. You are simply stating that only those who do not avoid calling themselves Christians can think of and understand the identity and authority of The Christ.
My choice not to self identify as a Christian has nothing to do with avoiding The Christ. - The Head of which - is The Father.

Do you see The Truth re that instinct?

What conclusions might these be Angelina?

It is not a matter of stopping The Creator. The Father niether intrudes upon an individual humans will to prevent nor rejects that same will to allow.

Have I not already answered that Angelina? Did I not say that we are all agnostic about some things and that I am not myself agnostic about existing within a created thing and what that implies?

Sleep well and dream wonderful.

In Love.
Do you place your faith/trust/belief in only the death/burial/resurrection of Christ for the forgiveness of your sins so that you can enter Heaven ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: talons

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
Hello, @Eternal Entity .

I'm curious. Why do you think the universe was created?
The reasoning which leads to the conclusion is quite complex. Ultimately it gets down to anything that has a beginning is by definition something which was created. I have seen argument which say that the universe could have always existed, but since this is not a scientific certainty, or something that scientists claim, then - to go with that flow, the alternative is that it was created. Some have argued that the universe could have spontaneously come into being, but that does not adequately explain consciousness.
I have a fuller argument which I am thinking of posting in this - the Non-Christian General Discussion Forum, perhaps sometime soon.
 

Matthias

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
32,415
24,230
113
Kentucky
Faith
Other Faith
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I must say I had a wee chuckle about that Matthias.

1781432177744.jpeg


The irony being that you are a long standing member of this message board

Well-Known Member​

Joined May 4, 2022
You have made 32,402 posts in that time and have received 24,224 likes yet in this very thread there are other long standing members who were not aware of your position on things - who did not "know" you.

“Well-known“ -> is simply a category title here, assigned mechanically and automatically after a member reaches a certain number of posts.

I don’t have the statistics on how many members have earned the category title but, unless they post frequently in the few forums where I have posting privileges, I may know very little if anything about them. (While I have the ability to read posts in the “Christians Only” forums, I have those forums closed / blocked out.)

A ”well-known” member isn’t known well unless their messages are read and a conversational relationship is developed.

What do you think was the reason for that …

I don’t seek them out (see above) and they don’t post frequently in the forums where I have posting privileges. Only they could tell you how often they read my posts. My contact with them is extremely limited.

… and do you think that anyone really can truly know anyone else …

I do.

… and do you think your questions and the way you ask them are really going to help you to know me?

How well I get to know you depends on how you choose to respond to my questions and to questions asked by others.
 

Jay Ross

Well-Known Member
Jun 20, 2011
9,393
3,502
113
QLD
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
@Eternal Entity

How many posts one makes does not indicate whether or not that member is wise or foolish in their understanding. I was an accepted member of this forum for a long time, but I did not post at all until the forum, I was an active member of, was closed down. Someone else from that closed down forum, who joined after I had begun posting here, now has just over 39,000 acknowledged posts, while I only have just under 9,400 acknowledged posts.

I, for one, do not identify as a "Chrisitan" but rather I identify as a "Disciple of Jesus." I identify as a disciple because I believe that I am teachable and that I am willing to learn about what It means to be one of God's righteous Saint. I do not believe in a "NEW" Covenant, but rather I believe in a "refurbished" covenant where the process of my salvation has been changed to reflect Christ's death on the cross during His first Advent.

I have an affection for @Matthias because of his honesty in what he posts and how he expresses what he believes.

Choose your friends carefully on this forum.

Shalom
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matthias

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
View attachment 85682




“Well-known“ -> is simply a category title here, assigned mechanically and automatically after a member reaches a certain number of posts.

I don’t have the statistics on how many members have earned the category title but, unless they post frequently in the few forums where I have posting privileges, I may know very little if anything about them. (While I have the ability to read posts in the “Christians Only” forums, I have those forums closed / blocked out.)

A ”well-known” member isn’t known well unless their messages are read and a conversational relationship is developed.



I don’t seek them out (see above) and they don’t post frequently in the forums where I have posting privileges. Only they could tell you how often they read my posts. My contact with them is extremely limited.



I do.



How well I get to know you depends on how you choose to respond to my questions and to questions asked by others.
I consider FriendShip to being the most sacred of Ships. WE shall see how that may develop.

In Love

EE
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matthias

Eternal Entity

New Member
Jun 12, 2026
22
7
3
63
Timaru
Faith
Agnostic
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
@Eternal Entity

How many posts one makes does not indicate whether or not that member is wise or foolish in their understanding.
My point didn't mention either wisdom or foolishness in their understanding.
I did mention the irony of making many posts and people not knowing one's position.
I was an accepted member of this forum for a long time, but I did not post at all until the forum, I was an active member of, was closed down. Someone else from that closed down forum, who joined after I had begun posting here, now has just over 39,000 acknowledged posts, while I only have just under 9,400 acknowledged posts.
Okay. Do you mean this Non-Christian area re "Forum"?
I, for one, do not identify as a "Chrisitan" but rather I identify as a "Disciple of Jesus." I identify as a disciple because I believe that I am teachable and that I am willing to learn about what It means to be one of God's righteous Saint. I do not believe in a "NEW" Covenant, but rather I believe in a "refurbished" covenant where the process of my salvation has been changed to reflect Christ's death on the cross during His first Advent.
How do those who call themselves Christians generally respond to this position?
I have an affection for @Matthias because of his honesty in what he posts and how he expresses what he believes.
Can you direct me to some of those post you respect where he has shared his position?
Choose your friends carefully on this forum.
A nice serendipity here - I had just finished writing in reply to Mathias that "I consider FriendShip to being the most sacred of Ships. WE shall see how that may develop."
Universal Balance and Harmony

In Love

EE
 

complete

Well-Known Member
Nov 26, 2017
3,601
3,368
113
78
UK
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Female
Greetings Reader.

I joined this forum today. In the membership form I was asked how I identify religiously and was given a list of options, and chose the one which most closely mirrored my position - that being "Agnostic".

What I think is true:

I exist within a created thing.
I have many good reasons why I think this is true.

Since I think this is true, that would make me a "Theist" - because IF I think I exist within a created thing, THEN this implies a Creator/Creators.
Perhaps in that context, I might be an Agnostic Theist.
I do not self identify as being a "Christian" for many reasons. I have no problem with others who self identify as being Christian, for whatever reasons they chose to do so.
Truely, the "self identification" doesn't mean much to me, but I understand it means something to others, so that they may be able to better pinpoint who I am in relation to who they believe they are. Such is the nature of human interactions on that level.
To flip that, others who self identify as being "Christians" when they interact with me, the label doesn't really mean a lot to me in any significant way. This is because there are so many "types" of Christians, and many of those do not agree with one another most of the time and that is just one of the reasons why I do not self identify as being "Christian".
Are there any others hereabouts think in a similar way about this?

Peace.
EE

Hello there @Eternal Entity,

I am a Christian because I believe that the Lord Jesus Christ is the Son of God: That He lived, died and rose again to God's right hand, thus fulfilling His Fathers will for Him, and opening up the way for lost sinners to find forgiveness and peace with God, thereby receiving the promise of God, which is life everlasting; and now I await His manifestation in glory, when I, as a member of the church which is His body, will appear with Him there. This is my hope, based on what is recorded in the written word, through faith in the Living Word: because God has said it and I believe it.

Thank you.
In Christ Jesus
Chris