Does "Until" Mean What You Think It Means? (Matthew 1:25)

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You're still shifting the burden of proof. The claim made in the OP was not: "Matthew 1:25 proves perpetual virginity." The claim was:

"Matthew 1:25 does not, by itself, prove that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth."

Originally, you argued that the word until settled the matter. Since then, you've explicitly agreed that until does not always connote a subsequent action, citing Michal as an example, and you've repeatedly argued that context determines how until functions. Therefore, we agree on the very point I set out to defend: the word until by itself does not settle the question.

You now believe the context of Matthew 1 requires the conclusion that Joseph later had sexual relations with Mary. I disagree because I believe the context of Matthew 1:18-23 is focused on establishing the Virgin Birth by excluding Joseph from Jesus' conception. So the debate is no longer about the meaning of the word until. The debate is about which contextual reading better explains Matthew's purpose.

As for "97 out of 100 people," popularity is not an exegetical argument. The question is not how many people read a verse a certain way. The question is what Matthew intended to communicate. My contention remains exactly what I stated in the OP:

Matthew 1:25 tells us what did not happen before Jesus' birth. It does not explicitly tell us what happened afterward.

If you want to argue that Joseph and Mary later had marital relations, you're free to make that case. But you can no longer claim that conclusion follows merely from the word until, because you've already acknowledged that the word does not always function that way.
Matt 1 does speak of the virgin birth. Verse 25 so the before and after sexuality of Joseph and Mary surrounding Jesus birth! Once againyou fail to prove that the until here means Joseph never had sex with Mary, when the normal reading (exegetically as well) shows they had sex afterwards
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Matt 1 does speak of the virgin birth. Verse 25 so the before and after sexuality of Joseph and Mary surrounding Jesus birth! Once againyou fail to prove that the until here means Joseph never had sex with Mary, when the normal reading (exegetically as well) shows they had sex afterwards

You're now making a contextual argument, not a grammatical one.

Earlier you argued that the word until itself settled the matter. You have since acknowledged that until does not always connote a subsequent action and that context determines how the word functions. Fine. We agree on that.

But from that point forward, simply saying that the "normal" or "usual" reading is that Joseph had sex with Mary afterward is not an argument. It is your conclusion. The question is why Matthew's context requires that conclusion.

My contention remains that the immediate context of Matthew 1:18-25 is focused on establishing that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit and not by Joseph. Matthew repeatedly emphasizes Joseph's non-involvement in the conception, culminating in:

"And knew her not till she had brought forth her firstborn son."

That statement perfectly serves Matthew's stated purpose.

So we're no longer debating the meaning of the word until. You've already conceded that context determines how until functions.

We are now debating which reading best explains Matthew's purpose. You believe Matthew intended verse 25 to tell us that Joseph later had sexual relations with Mary. I believe Matthew intended verse 25 to exclude Joseph as the father of Jesus and thereby safeguard the Virgin Birth.

Merely asserting that your reading is the "normal" reading does not demonstrate that Matthew intended it.

My point from the beginning has been much narrower than the one you're asking me to defend. I have not argued that Matthew 1:25 proves perpetual virginity. I have argued that Matthew 1:25, by itself, does not prove that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth.

Once you acknowledge that until does not always imply a subsequent action and that context must determine its force, the real question becomes:

What in Matthew's context requires the conclusion that Joseph later had sexual relations with Mary, rather than simply establishing that Joseph was not the father of Jesus?

That's the question I've been asking all along.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You're now making a contextual argument, not a grammatical one.

Earlier you argued that the word until itself settled the matter. You have since acknowledged that until does not always connote a subsequent action and that context determines how the word functions. Fine. We agree on that.

But from that point forward, simply saying that the "normal" or "usual" reading is that Joseph had sex with Mary afterward is not an argument. It is your conclusion. The question is why Matthew's context requires that conclusion.

My contention remains that the immediate context of Matthew 1:18-25 is focused on establishing that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit and not by Joseph. Matthew repeatedly emphasizes Joseph's non-involvement in the conception, culminating in:

"And knew her not till she had brought forth her firstborn son."

That statement perfectly serves Matthew's stated purpose.

So we're no longer debating the meaning of the word until. You've already conceded that context determines how until functions.

We are now debating which reading best explains Matthew's purpose. You believe Matthew intended verse 25 to tell us that Joseph later had sexual relations with Mary. I believe Matthew intended verse 25 to exclude Joseph as the father of Jesus and thereby safeguard the Virgin Birth.

Merely asserting that your reading is the "normal" reading does not demonstrate that Matthew intended it.

My point from the beginning has been much narrower than the one you're asking me to defend. I have not argued that Matthew 1:25 proves perpetual virginity. I have argued that Matthew 1:25, by itself, does not prove that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth.

Once you acknowledge that until does not always imply a subsequent action and that context must determine its force, the real question becomes:

What in Matthew's context requires the conclusion that Joseph later had sexual relations with Mary, rather than simply establishing that Joseph was not the father of Jesus?

That's the question I've been asking all along.
Whast in Matthews context? The very sentence inspired. The normal reaction is they had sex afterwards. You need to prve they didn't. The Scripture speaks against your hypothesis. Try again.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Then let see another example from the scripture:
Deuteronomy 34:6:
“No one knows his [Moses’] burial place until(ἕως (heōs) this day.”

Does it mean that 'on this day' we know the burial place of Moses?
'No one knows the burial place of Moses' persists with the use of word 'until (heos)'!


Give you one more example:
Matthew 28:20: “I am with you always, until the end of the age.” Clearly, the 'until' does not imply He will leave afterward.

So, what @Moonwood said in #1 is correct.
Well as you re-cited this, let me answer again. UNtil is not used throughout Scripture as you and moonwood suggest. And every time it is used with an end in view the context always defines that something will continue until another event occurs.

Once again, Moses tomb was unknown up to that day. That day limits until.
Jesus being with us to the end of the age, As we know from other Scriptures, time is in view and not eternity. So Jesus was saying He would be with us as long as time existed, there would never be a time when He was not with us in time.

But MAtthew 1 is a completely different construct. It explicitly shows that abstinence was a temporary thing. Remember Matthew wrote th after jesus was born, so he was commenting on what most likely Mary had conveyed to HIm.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Well as you re-cited this, let me answer again. UNtil is not used throughout Scripture as you and moonwood suggest. And every time it is used with an end in view the context always defines that something will continue until another event occurs.

Once again, Moses tomb was unknown up to that day. That day limits until.
Jesus being with us to the end of the age, As we know from other Scriptures, time is in view and not eternity. So Jesus was saying He would be with us as long as time existed, there would never be a time when He was not with us in time.

But MAtthew 1 is a completely different construct. It explicitly shows that abstinence was a temporary thing. Remember Matthew wrote th after jesus was born, so he was commenting on what most likely Mary had conveyed to HIm.
go back to #41

You cut into a discussion without following previous posts, and then blah...blah..and blah
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
The NATURAL and NORMAL reading of Matthew's words in Matt 1:25, "but knew her not until she had given birth to a son. And he called his name Jesus" is that Joseph didn't consummate their marriage until after Jesus was born. I know "until" *can* be understood differently, but the natural context of a young couple getting married is that they're going to have sex to consummate the marriage. So Mary's words, "I know not a man" so how can I get pregnant and then Matthew's comment that Joseph "knew her not until she had given birth" are best, most naturally, understood to mean that he waited to consummate the marriage until after Jesus was born. You have to have very specific reasons why this most natural and normal reading of the text doesn't actually mean that.

I don't think you've actually addressed the argument made in the opening post. My claim was not that Joseph and Mary definitely never had marital relations after Jesus' birth. My claim was that Matthew 1:25 does not, by itself, establish that conclusion.

You wrote:

"I know 'until' can be understood differently..."

And that is precisely the point. The argument in the thread is not that until can never imply a later change. It's that the word itself does not require a later change. Consider:

"Michal the daughter of Saul had no child until the day of her death." (2 Samuel 6:23)

No one concludes that Michal began bearing children after she died. In that passage, until marks a boundary without implying that the previous condition was reversed afterward. So the question is not whether until can sometimes be followed by a change. Of course it can. The question is whether the word itself proves a change. My argument is that it does not.

Therefore Matthew 1:25 tells us with certainty that Joseph did not know Mary before Jesus' birth. What it does not do is explicitly tell us what happened afterward. At that point, the argument is no longer:

"Matthew 1:25 explicitly teaches that Joseph later knew Mary."

but rather:

"I think Joseph later knew Mary because that would be natural and normal for a married couple."

Those are two different arguments.
The thread is addressing the first claim.
So my question remains:

What is it in Matthew 1:25 itself that establishes a change after Jesus' birth, rather than an expectation being brought to the text from what we regard as normal married life?
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I don't think you've actually addressed the argument made in the opening post. My claim was not that Joseph and Mary definitely never had marital relations after Jesus' birth. My claim was that Matthew 1:25 does not, by itself, establish that conclusion.

Sure. But in the context of the passage and the culture, it is the best reading of that passage.

You wrote:

"I know 'until' can be understood differently..."

And that is precisely the point. The argument in the thread is not that until can never imply a later change. It's that the word itself does not require a later change. Consider:

"Michal the daughter of Saul had no child until the day of her death." (2 Samuel 6:23)

No one concludes that Michal began bearing children after she died. In that passage, until marks a boundary without implying that the previous condition was reversed afterward. So the question is not whether until can sometimes be followed by a change. Of course it can. The question is whether the word itself proves a change. My argument is that it does not.

Therefore Matthew 1:25 tells us with certainty that Joseph did not know Mary before Jesus' birth. What it does not do is explicitly tell us what happened afterward. At that point, the argument is no longer:

"Matthew 1:25 explicitly teaches that Joseph later knew Mary."

I haven't made this argument. I've said that my view represents the best reading of the passage, not that it "explicitly" teaches my view.

but rather:

"I think Joseph later knew Mary because that would be natural and normal for a married couple."

Those are two different arguments.
The thread is addressing the first claim.
So my question remains:

What is it in Matthew 1:25 itself that establishes a change after Jesus' birth, rather than an expectation being brought to the text from what we regard as normal married life?

Can you look at this verse in the larger context please? At least TRY?
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
go back to #41

You cut into a discussion without following previous posts, and then blah...blah..and blah
So prove that the until in MAtthew 1 means never had sex after Jesus was born. If you want to use the argument of Moses tomb, show how it is the same point of Matthew 1.

You won't be abl;e to , but try anyway! they are different sentences with different constructs using the word until. You should know that if you graduated grammar school.
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Sure. But in the context of the passage and the culture, it is the best reading of that passage.



I haven't made this argument. I've said that my view represents the best reading of the passage, not that it "explicitly" teaches my view.



Can you look at this verse in the larger context please? At least TRY?

I am looking at the larger context. In fact, my argument from the beginning has been based on the larger context of Matthew 1. The context focuses on one issue: establishing the Virgin Birth.

Matthew explains that Mary's child was conceived by the Holy Spirit (Matthew 1:18-23), and then adds that Joseph "did not know her until she had given birth to a son" (Matthew 1:25). That statement directly serves Matthew's purpose of excluding Joseph from Jesus' conception.

What I'm asking is where the larger context establishes the additional conclusion that Joseph and Mary necessarily began marital relations afterward.

You have said it is the "best reading" because it would be normal for a married couple. But that is an argument from what we regard as ordinary marital expectations, not something the text itself explicitly states.

My point has never been that Joseph and Mary definitely abstained permanently. My point is simply that Matthew 1:25 does not by itself settle the question.

So when you appeal to the larger context, can you identify something in Matthew's context that requires the conclusion that marital relations began after Jesus' birth?

In other words, what textual feature in Matthew 1 moves the argument from:

"Joseph did not know her before Jesus' birth"

to:

"Therefore Joseph did know her after Jesus' birth"?

Unless such a feature can be identified, it seems the conclusion is being drawn from what we think would normally happen in marriage rather than from what Matthew actually says.
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I am looking at the larger context. In fact, my argument from the beginning has been based on the larger context of Matthew 1. The context focuses on one issue: establishing the Virgin Birth.

Matthew explains that Mary's child was conceived by the Holy Spirit (Matthew 1:18-23), and then adds that Joseph "did not know her until she had given birth to a son" (Matthew 1:25). That statement directly serves Matthew's purpose of excluding Joseph from Jesus' conception.

What I'm asking is where the larger context establishes the additional conclusion that Joseph and Mary necessarily began marital relations afterward.

You have said it is the "best reading" because it would be normal for a married couple. But that is an argument from what we regard as ordinary marital expectations, not something the text itself explicitly states.
My point has never been that Joseph and Mary definitely abstained permanently. My point is simply that Matthew 1:25 does not by itself settle the question.

No kidding. And I agree with you - Matthew 1:25 alone does not necessarily settle that question. If you pulled Matthew 1:25 out all by itself and looked at it, even though the most natural reading would imply that after Jesus was born, they did in fact have sex. It doesn't PROVE it.

So when you appeal to the larger context, can you identify something in Matthew's context that requires the conclusion that marital relations began after Jesus' birth?

In other words, what textual feature in Matthew 1 moves the argument from:

"Joseph did not know her before Jesus' birth"

to:

"Therefore Joseph did know her after Jesus' birth"?

Unless such a feature can be identified, it seems the conclusion is being drawn from what we think would normally happen in marriage rather than from what Matthew actually says.

Yeah, the fact that the Gospels (and Matthew in particular) references Jesus' brothers and sisters.

Put all this into the pile of evidence:

- The normal expectation for young couples getting married was that they were going to have sex.

- Mary's expectation seems to be that she was going to get pregnant soon, which is why she asked how that's possible since she has never had sex. And, for like the 20th time now, which you guys CONTINUE to absolutely IGNORE, is that this expectation of Mary (if she had it) would have been 100% correct, since that is, in fact, what happened.

- Matthew 1:25 says that they didn't consummate the marriage until Jesus was born.

- Matthew (and other gospels) say Jesus had siblings.

Put all that together - that is the larger context - and by far the best explanation is as I've suggested.
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
And I agree with you - Matthew 1:25 alone... doesn't PROVE it.

Since you agree that Matthew 1:25, by itself, does not settle the question, then I think we've already established the main point I set out to demonstrate.

If you pulled Matthew 1:25 out all by itself and looked at it, even though the most natural reading would imply that after Jesus was born, they did in fact have sex.

Matthew 1:25 says that they didn't consummate the marriage until Jesus was born.

You say:

"If you pulled Matthew 1:25 out all by itself and looked at it, even though the most natural reading would imply that after Jesus was born, they did in fact have sex."

and:

"Matthew 1:25 says that they didn't consummate the marriage until Jesus was born."

But notice the distinction between those two statements.

In the first, you say the verse implies that Joseph and Mary later had marital relations.

My question is: does that implication come from the text itself, or from your prior expectation that a young married couple would ordinarily consummate their marriage? Because my point has been that Matthew 1:25 explicitly tells us what did not happen before Jesus' birth. What it does not explicitly tell us is what happened afterward.

If the implication comes from the word "until," then the argument needs to show that until itself establishes a subsequent change. But that is the very point under dispute.

If, on the other hand, the implication comes from your understanding of what normally happens in marriage, then the conclusion is not being derived from Matthew 1:25 alone. Rather, it arises from Matthew 1:25 combined with an expectation about ordinary married life.

So my question remains the same: what is it in Matthew 1:25 itself that establishes the conclusion that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth, rather than that conclusion being inferred from what we would normally expect of a married couple?
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Since you agree that Matthew 1:25, by itself, does not settle the question, then I think we've already established the main point I set out to demonstrate.





You say:

"If you pulled Matthew 1:25 out all by itself and looked at it, even though the most natural reading would imply that after Jesus was born, they did in fact have sex."

and:

"Matthew 1:25 says that they didn't consummate the marriage until Jesus was born."

But notice the distinction between those two statements.

In the first, you say the verse implies that Joseph and Mary later had marital relations.

My question is: does that implication come from the text itself, or from your prior expectation that a young married couple would ordinarily consummate their marriage? Because my point has been that Matthew 1:25 explicitly tells us what did not happen before Jesus' birth. What it does not explicitly tell us is what happened afterward.

If the implication comes from the word "until," then the argument needs to show that until itself establishes a subsequent change. But that is the very point under dispute.

If, on the other hand, the implication comes from your understanding of what normally happens in marriage, then the conclusion is not being derived from Matthew 1:25 alone. Rather, it arises from Matthew 1:25 combined with an expectation about ordinary married life.

So my question remains the same: what is it in Matthew 1:25 itself that establishes the conclusion that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth, rather than that conclusion being inferred from what we would normally expect of a married couple?

I'm not answering this question for the thousandth time.
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
I'm not answering this question for the thousandth time.

You have said that Matthew 1:25 itself doesn't prove that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth.

But you've also said that Matthew 1:25 itself naturally implies it.

My question is: what specifically in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication?

When I've asked that, you've appealed to normal marital expectations, Mary's expectation of pregnancy, Jesus' siblings, and the larger context. But those are additional considerations outside Matthew 1:25 itself.

So I'm still unclear on what feature of Matthew 1:25, taken by itself, is supposed to imply that Joseph and Mary later had marital relations.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You have said that Matthew 1:25 itself doesn't prove that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth.

But you've also said that Matthew 1:25 itself naturally implies it.

My question is: what specifically in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication?

When I've asked that, you've appealed to normal marital expectations, Mary's expectation of pregnancy, Jesus' siblings, and the larger context. But those are additional considerations outside Matthew 1:25 itself.

So I'm still unclear on what feature of Matthew 1:25, taken by itself, is supposed to imply that Joseph and Mary later had marital relations.

The natural and normal condition of a young married couple is a cultural cue. You have to have extraordinary evidence that Mary and Joseph were planning on NOT ever having sex as a married couple, something not found or indicated or hinted at anywhere in Scripture. Don't give me the protoevangelium of James either. That's not scripture, it's a forgery, it was written in the mid 2nd century, it contradicts Scripture in at least three distinct places, and was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405AD.

The text uses the term "know not a man" (or similar) appears twice in the gospel narratives surrounding Jesus' conception and birth.

Luke 1:34 - "And Mary said to the angel, “How will this be, since I am a virgin?" (lit. "since I know not a man")
Matt 1:25 - "(Joseph) knew her not until she had given birth to a son. And he called his name Jesus."

While there are some exceptions to this rule, the natural and normal reading of this - especially given the context, which is that married couples always expect to consummate their marriage with sex - is that Joseph held off having sex with her until Jesus was born, and then they started having sex like every other normal married couple in the world.

That HAS to be the default understanding, especially combined with the texts that talk about Jesus' siblings, UNLESS you have clear textual reasons NOT to understand it this way.

What you guys are doing is starting with the legend spun by the protoevangelium of James and working that back into the text, and trying to find reasons why this normal, natural understanding of the text ought not be understood that way.

Then, of course, you guys take Mary and turn her into this deified superhero, the Queen of Heaven, the co-redemptrix, more holy than holiness itself, immaculately conceived, sinless, perfect, and yes - someone we should pray to, according to Pope Pius IX in his "infallible" dogma from 1854.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLT63

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
But you've also said that Matthew 1:25 itself naturally implies it.

My question is: what specifically in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication?

The natural and normal condition of a young married couple is a cultural cue.

You say Matthew 1:25 implies that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus was born. If that's the case, then you should be able to identify what in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication.

That's what I've been asking you to do.

Instead, you appeal to normal expectations of marriage, cultural considerations, Mary's expectation of pregnancy, Jesus' adelphoi, and the larger context. Those are all arguments outside Matthew 1:25 itself.

You've also said:

"I agree with you - Matthew 1:25 alone... doesn't PROVE it."

So, at this time, you have not shown what in Matthew 1:25 itself implies your conclusion, and you have acknowledged that Matthew 1:25 alone does not prove it.
 
Last edited:

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,566
2,881
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
A common claim is that Matthew 1:25 proves Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth because Joseph "did not know Her until She had given birth to a son."

But that argument assumes something the text itself never says.

In Matthew 1:25, "knew" (ginosko) is a standard biblical idiom for sexual relations. The question is not the meaning of "knew," but the meaning of "until" (heos).

In Koine Greek and throughout Scripture, heos does not inherently imply that the opposite condition began afterward. Sometimes a change follows the stated boundary; sometimes it does not. The word itself does not determine the outcome.

For example, before the flood Noah remained in the ark until the waters receded, after which he left the ark. The change comes from the context, not from the word "until" itself.

Consider also 2 Samuel 6:23:

"Michal the daughter of Saul had no child until the day of her death."

No one concludes that Michal began bearing children after she died. Here, "until" marks a boundary, not a reversal of the previous condition.

Matthew uses the same construction. His concern is not Joseph and Mary's later married life. His concern is the Virgin Birth.

The surrounding context makes this clear. Matthew has just explained that Mary's child was conceived by the Holy Spirit (Matthew 1:20-23). Then he adds:

"He did not know Her until She had given birth to a Son."

The purpose is to exclude Joseph as the source of the conception and reinforce the fulfillment of Isaiah 7:14. Matthew is safeguarding the truth of Christ's divine origin, not making a statement about what happened after the Nativity.

Matthew 1:25 tells us what did not happen before Jesus' birth. It tells us nothing about what did or did not happen afterward.

Matthew does not tell us what happened after Jesus' birth. Therefore, the verse itself cannot be used as proof that marital relations did occur afterward. That conclusion must come from somewhere other than Matthew 1:25.

The verse establishes the Virgin Birth. It does not tell us whether Joseph and Mary later had marital relations. Reading that conclusion into the text goes beyond what Matthew actually says.
You're making a comparison with words translated from two different languages.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You say Matthew 1:25 implies that Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus was born. If that's the case, then you should be able to identify what in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication.

That's what I've been asking you to do.

It's the context.

Instead, you appeal to normal expectations of marriage, cultural considerations, Mary's expectation of pregnancy, Jesus' adelphoi, and the larger context. Those are all arguments outside Matthew 1:25 itself.

You've also said:

"I agree with you - Matthew 1:25 alone... doesn't PROVE it."

So, at this time, you have not shown what in Matthew 1:25 itself implies your conclusion, and you have acknowledged that Matthew 1:25 alone does not prove it.

"Proof" is quite a high bar to clear when there are Biblical disputes. We are working with "best evidence".

Matt 1:25, given the context of what was going on, is best understood that Joseph didn't have sex with Mary until Jesus was born, and then they had did have sex like every other married couple. If it was to be understood that Joseph and Mary would NEVER have sex, why wouldn't Mary say that? And why would the Bible go out of its way to say that Joseph didn't have sex with Mary until Jesus was born? There's literally no point. Just say that Mary would never have sex because of her sanctified consecrated position and status. But IT NEVER SAYS THAT.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLT63

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Questions for @beechan and @Moonwood :

1) Why did Mary act surprised that she, of all people, would have this privilege? If she was "more holy than holiness" and she had been consecrated by Anne to God for this kind of service, and she had never sinned, wouldn't she have thought something like, "Well, this kinda makes sense"?

2) Did Mary, in fact, get pregnant SOON after Gabriel told her she would be? Wouldn't a perfect, wise, holy, inerrant Mary have sniffed that out of Gabriel since that was, in fact, what Gabriel actually meant, and also what actually happened?

3) Do you agree with every word of Pius IX's ex cathedra document on the Immaculate Conception? Or are there some that you disagree with or need, uh, "updating"? (LOL)
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
You said:

"If you pulled Matthew 1:25 out all by itself and looked at it, even though the most natural reading would imply that after Jesus was born, they did in fact have sex."

So, I asked:

"What specifically in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication?"

You say:

It's the context.

More specifically, you gave normal expectations of marriage, cultural considerations, Mary's expectation of pregnancy, Jesus' adelphoi, and the larger context as an answer to my question. But those are all arguments outside Matthew 1:25 itself, and I asked you what specifically in Matthew 1:25 creates the implication that Joseph and Mary had marital intercourse after Jesus' birth. So, unless you can identify what feature of Matthew 1:25 itself creates that implication, you haven't shown that your conclusion is implied by Matthew 1:25 itself.

Regarding the thread topic, you've already agreed with my main point:

"I agree with you - Matthew 1:25 alone... doesn't PROVE it."

Therefore, we agree that Matthew 1:25 alone does not settle whether Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth.

Thank you for participating in the thread.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You said:

"If you pulled Matthew 1:25 out all by itself and looked at it, even though the most natural reading would imply that after Jesus was born, they did in fact have sex."

So, I asked:

"What specifically in Matthew 1:25 creates that implication?"

You say:



More specifically, you gave normal expectations of marriage, cultural considerations, Mary's expectation of pregnancy, Jesus' adelphoi, and the larger context as an answer to my question. But those are all arguments outside Matthew 1:25 itself, and I asked you what specifically in Matthew 1:25 creates the implication that Joseph and Mary had marital intercourse after Jesus' birth. So, unless you can identify what feature of Matthew 1:25 itself creates that implication, you haven't shown that your conclusion is implied by Matthew 1:25 itself.

Regarding the thread topic, you've already agreed with my main point:

"I agree with you - Matthew 1:25 alone... doesn't PROVE it."

Therefore, we agree that Matthew 1:25 alone does not settle whether Joseph and Mary had marital relations after Jesus' birth.

Thank you for participating in the thread.

I never, not once, claimed that Matthew 1:25 "alone" settles this question. That you somehow claim this as some sort of victory is bizarre at best.

I've made the comprehensive argument, and 1:25 is certainly an important piece of it. How you somehow missed that in all of this, I'll never, ever know.