A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Because she asked, How can this be since I've never had sex? If she expected to have sex with Joseph, and she expected this to be a normal human reproductive process, she wouldn't have asked the question like she did.

Now...

When did Mary get pregnant? Soon, or many months later?

We know the answer. It was soon.

Mary, according to Catholic dogma, was perfect in every way. So she wouldn't have had a wrong assumption.

Would Mary have been CORRECT to assume that Gabriel meant that she would get pregnant soon? Yes or no?

Gabriel doesn't give a timetable. But whether Mary ultimately became pregnant soon is not the point under discussion. The question is why, at the moment Gabriel announced: "You will conceive and bear a Son," Mary would infer a pre-consummation conception rather than a conception through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph.

Appealing to the fact that She later turned out to be correct does not answer that question, because Mary did not yet know the conclusion when She asked: "How will this occur, since I know not man?" The issue is not whether a pre-consummation conception eventually occurred. The issue is why that should be regarded as the natural inference from Gabriel's announcement in the first place.

You keep answering: "Mary asked the question because She thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation." I understand that explanation. What I'm asking is the prior question:

Why would Mary draw that conclusion from Gabriel's words, rather than understand the announced conception as something that would occur through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph?

That is the explanation I keep asking for.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You claim that auxiliary programs and traditions are fine "as long as what they do meets biblical standards," yet you instantly disqualify the communion of saints because there isn't an explicit verse commanding it.

That’s like saying: "Driving a car to church is totally fine even though cars aren’t in the Bible, but using GPS navigation on your way there is a sin because no apostle ever used a satellite map."


May be you tell us specifically what you mean by 'biblical standards'.
I do not disqualify the communion of saints. We are to fellowship one with another. But there is no biblical warrant for praying to people in heaven. NONE! NOr angels! We have only one mediator and one intercessor in heaven! and it isn't Mary, or Michael or Joseph, or Jude etc.etc.etc.

And it is nowhere even close to driving a car and calling GPS a sin. I thought better of you than that silly example.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
In the scene of Jesus on the cross,
The “bystanders” are presented as allies of Jesus, since one of them gave Him a drink, in the next verse (Matthew 27:48). The next verse (27:49) again shows that this was common belief at the time: “But the others said, ‘Wait, let us see whether Eli’jah will come to save him.'


Thus, it was believed that one could pray to one such as Elijah (who had already died thousand years ago), and that he had power to come and give aid.
1. It was a Roman soldier and not an ally who gave Jesus the vinegar/wine.
2. They did not pray to Elijah nor did Jesus. If it was a common belief- then show from Scripture how it is common.

  • Deuteronomy 18:10–11 forbids “consulting mediums or spiritists or inquiring of the dead” and calls such acts detestable to the Lord Bible Hub Bible Hub+1.
  • Leviticus 19:31 and 20:6 likewise prohibit sorcery and necromancy Bible Hub Bible Hub.
  • Jesus instructs, “pray to your Father” (Matthew 6:9–13) Bible Hub Bible Hub+1.
  • Paul tells believers to “make known to God” their requests (Philippians 4:6) BibleAsk BibleAsk.
  • Luke 16:19–31 depicts a fixed “chasm” between the living and the dead, showing the dead cannot receive help Bible Hub Bible Hub.

Nobody. nowhere taught it is okay to pray to the dead.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Another scene:
Jeremiah 15:1 Then the LORD said to me, Even if Moses and Samuel stood before me, my heart would not turn toward this people. Send them away from me and let them go

God did not tell Israelite not to pray to Moses or Samuel, the context is even when they asked for Moses and Samuel for help, God will not turn towards the Israelites.

Again, GOD does not see Moses and Samuel dead people! They are 'alive' in heaven and would offer help as intercessors.
C'mon! Are you that benighted? Yes we know they are both dead and alive. And no you need to learn how to read in context. these passages do not even imply that Israel prayed to Moses or Samuel! You should be better than that!
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
We have only one mediator and one intercessor in heaven! and it isn't Mary, or Michael or Joseph, or Jude etc.etc.etc.
Jesus performed his first miracle in Wedding of Cana. In this event, we already see Mary acting as intercessor.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If we are going to audit what is done "in Jesus's name" that fails to glorify the Father, let's look at the mirror.

Modern Non-Denominational Megachurch Branding: Complete with corporate marketing teams, coffee bars in the lobby, and fog machines on stage—none of which glorify the Father any more than a medieval hymn.

b92a7d1b43f1e2aa1317a972d85ae351

Is that a performance or a worship?
Well it sure looks like a performance. But you are diverting by saying "Well look what other churches do". You should be concerned about yur own walk with god and what you allow or disallow before God! God will take of the mega churches that have strayed from HIm.

If that is a church service, I am concerned. If it is a concert- no big deal.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
C'mon! Are you that benighted? Yes we know they are both dead and alive. And no you need to learn how to read in context. these passages do not even imply that Israel prayed to Moses or Samuel! You should be better than that!
Then in the transfiguration scene, Jesus was the one to contact with the deads.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Well it sure looks like a performance. But you are diverting by saying "Well look what other churches do". You should be concerned about yur own walk with god and what you allow or disallow before God! God will take of the mega churches that have strayed from HIm.

If that is a church service, I am concerned. If it is a concert- no big deal.
But here, you are very concerned with what the Catholic Church doing!
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
You are trying to read Mary's mind in how she was thiinking. this is not proof, but mere conjecture. Try again.

I'm not reading Mary's mind. I'm reading Luke's text.

Luke tells us four things:
  1. Gabriel announces, "You will conceive and bear a son."
  2. Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
  3. Gabriel answers by describing divine action: "The Holy Spirit will come upon you."
  4. Gabriel reinforces the answer by appealing to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception and concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."
Those are not my conjectures. Those are the actual details Luke records.

My question is about the connection between those details.

If Mary expected ordinary marital relations with Joseph and Gabriel never said the conception would occur before those relations, why does Mary present her virginity as the explanation for her difficulty?

More importantly, why does Gabriel answer with a miraculous conception rather than saying anything about future relations with Joseph?

Saying "you're reading Mary's mind" does not answer the question. I'm not appealing to information outside the text. I'm asking you to explain the logic of the text itself.

Luke gives Mary's question. Luke gives Gabriel's answer. Luke gives the appeal to Elizabeth's naturally impossible conception. Luke gives the conclusion, "For nothing will be impossible with God."

How do those elements fit together if Mary's expectation was simply that she would eventually conceive through ordinary marital relations with Joseph?

That's the question I've been asking from the beginning.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I'm not reading Mary's mind. I'm reading Luke's text.

Luke tells us four things:
  1. Gabriel announces, "You will conceive and bear a son."
  2. Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
  3. Gabriel answers by describing divine action: "The Holy Spirit will come upon you."
  4. Gabriel reinforces the answer by appealing to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception and concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."
Those are not my conjectures. Those are the actual details Luke records.

My question is about the connection between those details.

If Mary expected ordinary marital relations with Joseph and Gabriel never said the conception would occur before those relations, why does Mary present her virginity as the explanation for her difficulty?

More importantly, why does Gabriel answer with a miraculous conception rather than saying anything about future relations with Joseph?

Saying "you're reading Mary's mind" does not answer the question. I'm not appealing to information outside the text. I'm asking you to explain the logic of the text itself.

Luke gives Mary's question. Luke gives Gabriel's answer. Luke gives the appeal to Elizabeth's naturally impossible conception. Luke gives the conclusion, "For nothing will be impossible with God."

How do those elements fit together if Mary's expectation was simply that she would eventually conceive through ordinary marital relations with Joseph?

That's the question I've been asking from the beginning.
You are putting thoughts in Marys' head! but you really suck at being a mind reader.

Luke if focused on teh virgin birth and not what Mary and Jospeh did do sexually after! We have beat this horse dead!
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Luke is focused on teh virgin birth and not what Mary and Jospeh did do sexually after!

Exactly. That is precisely my point.

The challenge I presented was never about what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus' birth. The challenge was about Luke 1:34-37 and the logic of the Annunciation narrative.

You accused me of reading Mary's mind. I'm not doing that. I'm pointing to the sequence of events Luke records:
  1. Gabriel announces that Mary will conceive.
  2. Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
  3. Gabriel answers with divine action by the Holy Spirit.
  4. Gabriel appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception.
  5. Gabriel concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."
Those are Luke's words, not my speculations.

Now you've responded by saying that Luke is focused on the virgin birth.

I agree.

But that means my question remains unanswered:

If Mary's expectation was that She would eventually conceive through ordinary marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke portray Her virginity as the difficulty, and why does Gabriel answer with miraculous conception and an appeal to divine impossibility?


Simply saying "Luke is focused on the virgin birth" doesn't resolve the issue. It highlights it.

The entire discussion concerns why Mary asks the question she asks and why Gabriel gives the answer he gives.

If you believe the answer is obvious, then explain the connection between Mary's reference to not knowing a man and Gabriel's appeal to divine intervention.

That's the textual question I've been asking from the beginning, and it still hasn't been addressed.
 
Last edited:

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
That's a nonsense reply.

Mary RIGHTLY assumed that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant soon. In fact, that's precisely what Gabriel MEANT, and that's precisely what did, in fact, happen.
You are putting thoughts in Marys' head! but you really suck at being a mind reader.
(I borrowed words from @Ronald Nolette )
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,763
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I do not disqualify the communion of saints. We are to fellowship one with another. But there is no biblical warrant for praying to people in heaven. NONE! NOr angels!
Since, by your statement that there is no Biblical warrant for asking for intercession from those in Heaven - can YOU show me where the Bible teaches Sola Scriptura?

I'll wait right here for your Biblical response . . .

We have only one mediator and one intercessor in heaven! and it isn't Mary, or Michael or Joseph, or Jude etc.etc.etc.
Jesus IS our only Mediator since only HIS sacrifice can bring bring peace between us and the Father.
HOWEVER - we are ALL called on to be intercessors for one another . . .

James 5:16
Therefore confess your sins to each other and PRAY FOR EACH OTHER so that you may be healed.
The prayer of a RIGHTEOUS PERSON is powerful and effective.
(Only those in Heaven are truly righteous because they are FULLY sanctified.
WE here on earth are being DAILY sanctified and conformed to God’s will (Heb. 10:14) . . .)

Matthew 5:44

But I tell you, love your enemies and PRAY FOR THOSE WHO PERSECUTE YOU

Romans 10:1

Brothers and sisters, my heart’s desire and PRAYER TO GOD FOR THE ISRAELITES is that they may be saved.

1 Timothy 2:1
I urge, then, first of all, that PETITIONS, PRAYERS, INTERCESSION AND THANKSGIVING BE MADE FOR ALL PEOPLE

Colossians 1:9

For this reason, since the day we heard about you, WE HAVE NOT STOPPED PRAYING FOR YOU.
We continually ask God to fill you with the knowledge of his will through all the wisdom and understanding that the Spirit gives
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Well it sure looks like a performance. But you are diverting by saying "Well look what other churches do". You should be concerned about yur own walk with god and what you allow or disallow before God! God will take of the mega churches that have strayed from HIm.

If that is a church service, I am concerned. If it is a concert- no big deal.

yes, it is sunday service, 10:00am

Looking like it is a worship of a popular pastor!
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Gabriel doesn't give a timetable. But whether Mary ultimately became pregnant soon is not the point under discussion. The question is why, at the moment Gabriel announced: "You will conceive and bear a Son," Mary would infer a pre-consummation conception rather than a conception through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph.

I've already given reasons. You don't like those reasons. Too bad.

The fact is, if Mary assumed she would be pregnant soon.... SHE WAS RIGHT.

If you are correct and Mary assumed she would be pregnant later, SHE WAS WRONG.

Mary is perfect and never erred, according to your church's dogma.

Appealing to the fact that She later turned out to be correct does not answer that question, because Mary did not yet know the conclusion when She asked: "How will this occur, since I know not man?" The issue is not whether a pre-consummation conception eventually occurred. The issue is why that should be regarded as the natural inference from Gabriel's announcement in the first place.

You keep answering: "Mary asked the question because She thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation." I understand that explanation. What I'm asking is the prior question:

Why would Mary draw that conclusion from Gabriel's words, rather than understand the announced conception as something that would occur through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph?

That is the explanation I keep asking for.

It's been given to you a dozen times and you keep asking the same question over and over as if it hasn't been given.

Inescapable conclusion: You are not discussing this in good faith.