"The word was a god"?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Wrangler

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2021
22,254
9,712
113
58
Shining City on a Hill
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Didn't you say Jesus isn't the Savior?
No. I said that in John 1:1c, the proper interpretation is that the authority of God extends to his words and commands, making his literal word "a god," that which has authority over others.

While it is fine to interpret other verses metaphorically, not all verses that contain the word "word" refer to the person of Jesus. The authority of the words of one in authority, is like when you were a kid and told your sibling, "Ma said dinner is ready." It is not the authority of the speaker to the sibling but the authority of the one who originally said those words that give the words authority and weight that the listener better obey or there will be consequences.

This explains why v 45 has Phillip saying to Nathaniel, we've found the very person Moses wrote about; the words of God are put in a person among Israel God raised as spelled out in Deuteronomy 18:15-18. Read that and see how Moses prophecy is verified in v14. It is the authority of God words that Jesus speaks, in fulfillment of the prophecy of Deuteronomy. If you don't agree with this, kindly explain v45.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: The Learner

rebuilder 454

Well-Known Member
Jul 15, 2023
6,101
1,547
113
71
robstown
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
No. I said that in John 1:1c, the proper interpretation is that the authority of God extends to his words and commands, making his literal word "a god," that which has authority over others.

While it is fine to interpret other verses metaphorically, not all verses that contain the word "word" refer to the person of Jesus. The authority of the words of one in authority, is like when you were a kid and told your sibling, "Ma said dinner is ready." It is not the authority of the speaker to the sibling but the authority of the one who originally said those words that give the words authority and weight that the listener better obey or there will be consequences.

This explains why v 45 has Phillip saying to Nathaniel, we've found the very person Moses wrote about; the words of God are put in a person among Israel God raised as spelled out in Deuteronomy 18:15-18. Read that and see how Moses prophecy is verified in v14. It is the authority of God words that Jesus speaks, in fulfillment of the prophecy of Deuteronomy. If you don't agree with this, kindly explain v45.
That is watchtower doctrine.
In the Greek it says ".....God was the word"

The Bible needs no muddying up.
 

Jack

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
17,455
6,501
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
No. I said that in John 1:1c, the proper interpretation is that the authority of God extends to his words and commands, making his literal word "a god," that which has authority over others.
Quoting Wrangler: "Jesus is my savior but not the Savior"
Post 114
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Learner

rebuilder 454

Well-Known Member
Jul 15, 2023
6,101
1,547
113
71
robstown
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Quoting Wrangler: "Jesus is my savior but not the Savior"
Post 114
He posted watchtower doctrine.
If he is that decieved, then other things in his doctrine, are naturally, way off.
 

Wrangler

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2021
22,254
9,712
113
58
Shining City on a Hill
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Quoting Wrangler: "Jesus is my savior but not the Savior"
Post 114

Dude! I thought you were referring to what I wrote in this thread.

Interesting! He even flat out denied saying this, "Jesus is my savior but not the Savior"
I don't deny saying it but to bring it up is a hijack of this thread's topic. I'd be happy to discuss further in PM but I'm sure what I wrote in that other thread was eloquent and articulate even though you disagree.

Sad that you could not answer my question regarding explaining v45 if you disagree. Implied in your writing is that you deny the literal word of god is itself, a god for it has authority.
 

Jack

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
17,455
6,501
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Dude! I thought you were referring to what I wrote in this thread.

I don't deny saying it but to bring it up is a hijack of this thread's topic. I'd be happy to discuss further in PM but I'm sure what I wrote in that other thread was eloquent and articulate even though you disagree.
Ok, Jesus is not THE Savior, according to you Jesus is not GOD! AGAIN, No Christian would say such a thing! A JW would for sure! Are you JW? According to the Bible Jesus is God! The CYB Statement of Faith agrees with me.
Sad that you could not answer my question regarding explaining v45 if you disagree. Implied in your writing is that you deny the literal word of god is itself, a god for it has authority.
Implied in your mind, not mine. The Bible is the written Word of God! See, I even wrote "God" the right way! My comments are in line with this thread! You say Jesus is not God. The Bible and I say He is!
 

PinSeeker

Well-Known Member
Oct 4, 2021
4,645
1,113
113
Nashville
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
...I said that in John 1:1c, the proper interpretation is that the authority of God extends to his words and commands, making his literal word "a god,"
There is no definite article... 'the' or 'a'... in the original Greek. However... yes, that's perfectly okay in the translation to English, if one understands "a god" in the sense of the one true God, and, as John goes on to say, that this "Word..." ~ The Father's Word ~ "...became flesh and dwelt among us... Jesus Christ... God the only Son, Who is at the Father’s side was made flesh." The Father's Word cannot ~ cannot ~ be separated from Him. The Son and the Father are One in each other (John 10:30).

While it is fine to interpret other verses metaphorically...
This is not "metaphorical."

... not all verses that contain the word "word" refer to the person of Jesus.
Agreed, but this is non sequitur. There are many words in the Bible that, when used in different contexts, mean different things.
.
The authority of the words of one in authority, is like when you were a kid and told your sibling, "Ma said dinner is ready." It is not the authority of the speaker to the sibling but the authority of the one who originally said those words that give the words authority and weight that the listener better obey or there will be consequences. This explains why v 45 has Phillip saying to Nathaniel, we've found the very person Moses wrote about; the words of God are put in a person among Israel God raised as spelled out in Deuteronomy 18:15-18. Read that and see how Moses prophecy is verified in v14. It is the authority of God words that Jesus speaks, in fulfillment of the prophecy of Deuteronomy. If you don't agree with this, kindly explain v45.
Ah yes, verse 45... The words of God were not merely "put in a person among Israel." <smile> Yes, see above; God's Word became flesh, so Jesus is the full embodiment of God's Word, which cannot be separated from Him. It is God Himself... the Father's Word made manifest in the Person of Jesus Christ.

Moses, Wrangler, and all the other prophets of old, spoke God's Word as given to them by God. Jesus was the greater Prophet, Who, unlike them, spoke His own Word, i.e., John 14:15 ~ "If you love Me, you will keep My commandments."

To put it even more clearly, the prophets of old said, over and over again, "Thus says the Lord" ~ so they were relaying God's Word; this is what the writer of Hebrews is saying in Hebrews 1:1 in saying, "Long ago, at many times and in many ways, God spoke to our fathers by the prophets"... Jesus is the Person by which God has spoken to us, as the writer of Hebrews is saying in Hebrews 1:2, "...but in these last days (God) has spoken to us by His Son, Whom He appointed the Heir of all things, through Whom also He created the world."

Which spawns, in my mind, this last... rhetorical... question... Could the Father create the world through a mere man... through any part of His creation, through one of His creatures... through a created being? Well no, absolutely not. Back to John 1, "All things were made through (Christ Jesus), and without Him was not any thing made that was made. In Him was life, and the life was the light of men."

Just to use Moses as another example, Wrangler, he was a "type," a shadow, of the true Savior to come. God gave His Law to Moses, who then relayed it to the Israelites of old. But Jesus is the Law, the perfect and full manifestation of it ~ "the law of Christ," as Paul says in Galatians 6:2 ~ so Jesus is the Greater Moses, and the true Law Giver. And David, too; Jesus is the Greater David in that He is our true Forever King of God's Israel.

Grace and peace to you, Wrangler.
 

Jack

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
17,455
6,501
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Defensive and insecure?! LOL!

If the Trinity were not explicitly stated in Scripture (but it certainly is), then it would be mere speculation.

Of course Jesus was a Jew. He is also God manifest in the flesh; He is the great I AM; He is God with us, etc..
Absolutely!
 
  • Like
Reactions: David1701

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Here is one for your watchtower workbook;
Why did GOD, ( the deity Jesus), have to be crucified.
IOW, WHY DID IT HAVE TO BE GOD ON THE CROSS ?
WHY COULD IT HAVE NOT BEEN "A GOOD MAN" ON the cross?
AHEM...A CREATED BEING?
QUOTE
"My purpose is not to diminish Jesus. I believe He is the promised Messiah, the Son of God, and the one whom God has exalted above all"

All watchtower agents such as yourself are here on a Christians site to DIMINISH JESUS.
You do so with clever watchtower teaching.
It reeks of nasty cult propaganda, hoping those that are unschooled, like yourself, will fall into that empty erroneous heretical religion.

The debate ends with your denial of WHO THE CREATOR IS, AND WHO GOD SAYS JESUS IS.

Your compilation of verses, and twisting anything not mentally palatable for your false doctrine is YOUR TRAINING.

It is DIABOLICAL AND EVIL.
Your response contains a number of serious accusations, but very little engagement with the Scriptures I presented.

First, you are mistaken in assuming that my understanding of Scripture comes from the Watchtower. My conclusions are based on my own examination of the biblical text. Disagreeing with the traditional understanding of Jesus does not automatically make someone a Jehovah's Witness, nor does it establish that their interpretation is false.

Second, calling an interpretation "diabolical," "evil," or "heretical" does not demonstrate that it is incorrect. That requires an argument from Scripture.

I have not denied Jesus' identity as the Messiah, the Son of God, or His exalted position. What I am questioning is whether certain passages actually teach what later theological traditions claim they teach.

I raised specific questions about ego eimi in John 8:58, its use elsewhere in John's Gospel, the language of Exodus 3:14, and the messianic context of John 8:56. You have not addressed any of those points.

You also accuse me of denying who the Creator is. That is another subject worthy of careful examination, but it deserves the same attention to context and language rather than simply assuming the conclusion.

Jesus Himself addressed the Father as "the only true God" (John 17:3). Surely we should be able to examine those words without being accused of diminishing Christ.

I am willing to have my understanding challenged by Scripture. In fact, that is precisely why I participate in these discussions. But I would ask that you challenge what I actually believe and the biblical arguments I present, rather than assigning me beliefs, affiliations, and motives I have not expressed.

If my interpretation is wrong, demonstrate it from the text. Personal accusations are no substitute for biblical exegesis.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Where is this copied from and pasted?
What watchtower site.?
Show us the link.
There is no Watchtower link to provide because this was not copied from a Watchtower website.

This is my own writing, drawn from a manuscript I have been developing through years of studying Scripture. My conclusions come from examining the biblical text, not from adopting the teachings of a religious organization.

What I find interesting is that rather than addressing the substantial biblical arguments presented, you immediately assume they must have come from the Watchtower.

I have cited Acts, Romans, Hebrews, and Corinthians, examined the relevant Greek terminology, and even acknowledged where traditional Nicene interpretations differ from my understanding. I have also identified passages where legitimate interpretive disagreements exist.

Surely these arguments deserve a response more substantial than an accusation about their supposed source.

Let me ask you a straightforward question: When Peter declares in Acts 2:36 that "God has made this Jesus, whom you crucified, both Lord and Messiah," what do you understand God actually did?

Was Peter describing an appointment and exaltation, or merely announcing something that had already been true from eternity? And more importantly, what in Peter's words establishes your interpretation?

I am not asking you to agree with me. I am asking you to examine the text and explain why you believe my reading is incorrect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wrangler

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Here is one for your watchtower workbook;
Why did GOD, ( the deity Jesus), have to be crucified.
IOW, WHY DID IT HAVE TO BE GOD ON THE CROSS ?
WHY COULD IT HAVE NOT BEEN "A GOOD MAN" ON the cross?
AHEM...A CREATED BEING?
You ask an important question: Why did it have to be God on the cross? Why couldn't it have been a man?

I would suggest that we begin by asking how Scripture itself answers that question, rather than assuming a particular theological answer before examining the text.

First, I have no Watchtower workbook, nor am I defending Watchtower theology. I am examining what the biblical authors actually wrote.

Now, consider your question.

1. Scripture specifically identifies the humanity of Jesus as essential to our redemption.

Paul writes:

"For since death came through a man, the resurrection of the dead comes also through a man" (1 Corinthians 15:21, NIV).

Notice Paul's reasoning. Death entered through a man, Adam, and resurrection comes through a man, Jesus Christ.

Paul develops this further in Romans 5:19:

"For just as through the disobedience of the one man the many were made sinners, so also through the obedience of the one man the many will be made righteous" (NIV).

Paul does not explain redemption by saying that God Himself had to die because only a divine being could satisfy God's requirements. Instead, he draws a deliberate parallel between two men: Adam, whose disobedience brought death, and Christ, whose obedience makes righteousness possible.

Why should we replace Paul's explanation with a different one?

2. Hebrews makes Christ's identification with humanity central to His saving work.

Hebrews 2:14 explains that because God's children share flesh and blood, Jesus likewise shared in their humanity so that through death He might overcome the one who holds the power of death.

Hebrews 2:17 goes further, explaining that He had to be made like His brothers and sisters in every respect so that He might become a merciful and faithful high priest.

The argument is not that Jesus had to possess the divine essence to redeem humanity. The author's emphasis is on His genuine participation in our human condition.

It is precisely as one of us that He suffers, obeys, dies, and becomes our high priest.

3. Paul explicitly calls the mediator a man.

"For there is one God and one mediator between God and mankind, the man Christ Jesus" (1 Timothy 2:5, NIV).

Notice the distinction Paul makes. There is one God, and there is one mediator between God and humanity, whom Paul identifies as "the man Christ Jesus."

The following verse explains that this same mediator gave Himself as a ransom for all.

I am not suggesting that Jesus was simply an ordinary good man. That misrepresents my position entirely.

He is the uniquely appointed Messiah, the Son of God, without sin, obedient unto death, and the one through whom God accomplishes humanity's redemption.

But why should we assume that His sacrifice could only be effective if He were ontologically God?

4. Scripture repeatedly identifies God as the one who accomplished redemption through Jesus.

Consider Acts 2:22–24.

Peter identifies Jesus as a man accredited by God through miracles, wonders, and signs that God performed through Him. He then explains that Jesus was crucified and that God raised Him from the dead.

The distinction is not incidental.

God accredits Jesus. Jesus obeys and dies. God raises and exalts Him.

Likewise, 2 Corinthians 5:19 describes God as reconciling the world to Himself in Christ.

God is the author of our salvation, and Jesus is the one through whom that salvation is accomplished.

5. Your question assumes something that first needs to be demonstrated.

You ask why it had to be God on the cross.

I would ask where Scripture explicitly states that only someone who is God by nature could provide an acceptable sacrifice for humanity's sins.

That may be an inference within a particular theological system, but an inference is not the same thing as an explicit biblical statement.

Scripture emphasizes Christ's sinlessness, obedience, sacrifice, and God's acceptance and exaltation of Him. These are the very things that make His saving work unique.

None of this diminishes Jesus. Quite the contrary. His willing obedience, suffering, and death are extraordinary precisely because He remained faithful to His Father through everything He endured.

So I will return your question with one of my own:

If the apostles teach that death came through one man and resurrection comes through another, that righteousness comes through the obedience of one man, and that our mediator is "the man Christ Jesus," why must we insist that redemption required God Himself to die?

Please show me the passage that establishes that requirement.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Wrangler

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Like us, Jesus as a Son of Man, born of a women, was born under that original creation...in the image of God. How you or any of us would define all that, isn't really the point or issue. The purpose is the point, and the means is in that same image, wherein Christ had/has a role. That role is greatly to lead by example...therefore, He came saying "Follow Me", and showed us many things on what that looks like...including how to pray, etc., etc.

But that existence, like us--being created in the image of God--is a great mystery, not to be explained away or confused as even being its own reality. The fact that this is all we have yet known, doesn't make it more than it actually is. No, but God called it "image." Just an image. Meaning, that we can look to heaven and pray as if speaking to someone or no one there...but even for Christ, the experience would be more like looking back through the mirror (or the glass darkly)--even at Himself--in a similar but strange act of what? Of actually looking within--as He said, "the kingdom of God is within you." My favorite, is "Men of Galilee, why do you stand gazing up into heaven?"

Meanwhile, this "image" world is passing away, and what was for a time (times, and half a time) was merely image and spirit, "but then face to face."
I agree that Jesus came to show us how to live and that His example includes teaching us how to pray. But I don't see how that answers the question I raised.

You suggest that when Jesus prayed to the Father, He was, in some sense, looking inward or even speaking to Himself. But is that what the biblical text actually says, or is that an interpretation being brought to the text?

Consider Jesus' prayer in Gethsemane: "Not my will, but yours, be done" (Luke 22:42). He clearly distinguishes His own will from that of the Father. In John 17:3, He addresses the Father as "the only true God" and identifies Himself as the one whom the Father sent.

And this distinction doesn't disappear after His resurrection. Jesus tells Mary, "I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God" (John 20:17).

I understand your appeal to mystery and to humanity being created in God's image. But neither seems to require us to reinterpret these statements as Jesus addressing Himself. In fact, the consistent language of Scripture seems to present a genuine relationship between the Father and His Son.

So I would return to my original question: What in the text itself indicates that Jesus was speaking to Himself rather than to His Father, whom He repeatedly identifies as someone distinct from Himself?

I think we should allow the language of Scripture to establish that relationship before introducing a broader explanation of what it might mean.

In what way are we to understand Jesus as the second Adam? These are honest questions Christians have the right to ask!
 
Last edited:

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male

3. John 20:28​

Thomas answered Jesus:
Thomas certainly addresses Jesus as "my Lord and my God" (John 20:28). No one dismiss that statement. But we must also consider what Jesus Himself says in the very same chapter. In John 20:17, He calls the Father "my God," and in John 20:31, John explains that his purpose in writing this comment or statement! That we might believe Jesus is "the Christ, the Son of God." Not God Himself!

Whatever Thomas intended by his declaration, shouldn't we interpret it in light of Jesus' own words and John's own stated purpose for actually writing it and putting it in this very letter, rather than assume it means Jesus is the same God whom He calls His Father?

Think about it
 

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,016
7,384
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I agree that Jesus came to show us how to live and that His example includes teaching us how to pray. But I don't see how that answers the question I raised.

You suggest that when Jesus prayed to the Father, He was, in some sense, looking inward or even speaking to Himself. But is that what the biblical text actually says, or is that an interpretation being brought to the text?

Consider Jesus' prayer in Gethsemane: "Not my will, but yours, be done" (Luke 22:42). He clearly distinguishes His own will from that of the Father. In John 17:3, He addresses the Father as "the only true God" and identifies Himself as the one whom the Father sent.

And this distinction doesn't disappear after His resurrection. Jesus tells Mary, "I am ascending to my Father and your Father, to my God and your God" (John 20:17).

I understand your appeal to mystery and to humanity being created in God's image. But neither seems to require us to reinterpret these statements as Jesus addressing Himself. In fact, the consistent language of Scripture seems to present a genuine relationship between the Father and His Son.

So I would return to my original question: What in the text itself indicates that Jesus was speaking to Himself rather than to His Father, whom He repeatedly identifies as someone distinct from Himself?

I think we should allow the language of Scripture to establish that relationship before introducing a broader explanation of what it might mean.

In what way are we to understand Jesus as the second Adam? These are honest questions Christians have the right to ask!
Thank you for you manner of addressing the issue--very kind and appreciated!

It is true that Jesus did not actually say to Himself, "Self, (your will not mine be done, etc)."

But if we understand that He was our example sent to "follow"--why would He do that? Why would He address or pray to Himself, as if we are also to address and pray as we too are our own God? He wouldn't. What He would do, is to show Himself as us, a man, and Him addressing the Father as a man addressing God. Which is indeed the relationship we are to have with the Father also. So...He did it perfectly. But if we make that example into another "Self"--or even a different person, then who are we to "follow"--if that man acted like He was praying to Himself?

That is why I brought up man being created in the "image" of God--because even the Son of Man would fully qualify to worship Him of whom He is an image of.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
How can some miss the fact of the trinity?
Non negotiable truths .
What other pillars of the faith do you not believe?
When you speak of "non-negotiable truths," I have to ask: Non-negotiable according to whom, and in what century?

Consider a little Christian history.

In 1519–1520, seven people were burned as heretics in Coventry, England. John Foxe records that the charge against them was teaching their children the Lord's Prayer and the Ten Commandments in English. Among them was a widow named Smith, who was about to be released until authorities discovered those words written in English on a piece of paper hidden in her sleeve.

In 1536, William Tyndale, who devoted his life to making Scripture available in the language ordinary people could understand, was executed as a heretic. Much of his translation survives in our English Bibles today.

And as late as 1543, the English Parliament passed a law restricting who could read the Bible in English. Craftsmen, laborers, servants, and most women were forbidden to read it privately or publicly.

Think about that. People were condemned as heretics in a religious climate where even teaching children the Lord's Prayer and the Ten Commandments in their own language could be treated as evidence against them. Religious authorities LIKE YOU believed they were defending the true faith.

Today, we recognize how profoundly wrong those restrictions were.

I'm not suggesting that every traditional Christian teaching is mistaken. But history should make us very cautious about declaring any interpretation beyond examination simply because religious authorities have accepted it.

The question isn't whether a teaching has been declared non-negotiable. The question is whether it is true.

And if Scripture is our authority, shouldn't we be willing to examine even our most cherished beliefs against what it actually says?
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Thank you for you manner of addressing the issue--very kind and appreciated!

It is true that Jesus did not actually say to Himself, "Self, (your will not mine be done, etc)."

But if we understand that He was our example sent to "follow"--why would He do that? Why would He address or pray to Himself, as if we are also to address and pray as we too are our own God? He wouldn't. What He would do, is to show Himself as us, a man, and Him addressing the Father as a man addressing God. Which is indeed the relationship we are to have with the Father also. So...He did it perfectly. But if we make that example into another "Self"--or even a different person, then who are we to "follow"--if that man acted like He was praying to Himself?

That is why I brought up man being created in the "image" of God--because even the Son of Man would fully qualify to worship Him of whom He is an image of.
Thank you for your thoughtful reply. I appreciate both your kindness and your willingness to explore these questions together.

I certainly agree that Jesus showed us what a perfect relationship with the Father looks like. His obedience, humility, and prayer life are examples we should follow.

But I wonder whether we are overlooking an important distinction. Jesus can be our example in prayer while also genuinely praying to someone other than Himself. The two are not mutually exclusive.

When Jesus says, "Not my will, but yours, be done" (Luke 22:42), I understand that as a genuine expression of His submission to the Father, not simply a demonstration of how we should pray.

And this brings me back to Jesus as the second Adam. Paul presents Christ as the last Adam (1 Corinthians 15:45), and in Romans 5:19 contrasts the disobedience of the first man with the obedience of the one man, Jesus Christ.

Adam was created in God's image, but he was never God Himself. Jesus, as the last Adam, succeeds where the first failed through His perfect obedience to the Father.

So here is what I'm trying to understand from your perspective: If Jesus is genuinely obedient to the Father, why should we understand the Father and Son as the same individual rather than as the Father and His obedient Son?

I don't ask that to challenge your sincerity. I simply want to understand how your interpretation follows from the words of Scripture. I think we both agree that Scripture, rather than our assumptions, should guide us toward the truth.