A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
674
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
So why wouldn't the more natural inference be that the announced conception would occur through those expected marital relations? In other words, why should Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the ordinary marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

The fact that she asked it itself indicates that she expected something quite out of the ordinary.

You argue that Mary's question shows She had already inferred that Gabriel was announcing something out of the ordinary, namely a conception before consummation.
My question is what led Her to make that inference.

Gabriel merely says:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

At that point, according to your own position, Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph and future marital relations.
So why would the fact that She asks a question be evidence that She had already concluded the conception would occur before those expected marital relations?
That seems to assume the very point under discussion.
In other words:

Mary asks:

"How will this occur, since I know not man?"

You explain the question by saying that She had already inferred a pre-consummation conception.
But when I ask why She made that inference, the answer seems to be:

"Because She asked the question."

That is the point I still find unresolved.

What in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to conclude that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph?
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
181
58
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The Protoevangelium of James tells us that Joseph and Mary are not normal couple.
You do more readings and see a bigger picture.

The protoevangelium of James declares itself to have been written by James, supposedly the half-brother of Jesus, the leader of the church in Jerusalem. The last lines read, "And I James that wrote this history in Jerusalem, a commotion having arisen when Herod died, withdrew myself to the wilderness until the commotion in Jerusalem ceased, glorifying the Lord God, who had given me the gift and the wisdom to write this history. And grace shall be with them that fear our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory to ages of ages. Amen."

Of course, it is not possible for this to have been written by James, since he was long since dead by the time that this document was written (between 120-150 AD, with most scholars leaning towards 150). The oldest existing manuscript is dated to the 3rd century, possibly even the early 4th century.

The book had so little going for it that Eusebius didn't even mention it in his list of books - in ANY of his lists of books. Based on how he classified other books, Eusebius would have classified this book - had he mentioned it at all - as spurious. Not as heretical, as it contained some orthodox ideas, but rather as a non-historical legend. Origen (circa 240 AD) was the first person we know of to mention its existence at all. It was not considered for canonicity due to late authorship, dubious attribution, and theological concerns raised by early church leaders. Pope Innocent (405 AD) condemned this text on the grounds that it was a pseudepigraphal forgery falsely claiming apostolic authorship, alongside concerns that it was being used by certain groups to promote unorthodox teachings.

So it has blatant falsehoods, contradicts Scripture in numerous places, was a forgery, was never remotely considered to be canonical, was only first mentioned more than 200 years after Christ's death, and was condemned by Pope Innocent because of theological concerns and was a psuedograph and a forgery.

I mean, other than that, yeah, it's greaaaaaaaaat.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
181
58
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You argue that Mary's question shows She had already inferred that Gabriel was announcing something out of the ordinary, namely a conception before consummation.
My question is what led Her to make that inference.

Gabriel merely says:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

At that point, according to your own position, Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph and future marital relations.
So why would the fact that She asks a question be evidence that She had already concluded the conception would occur before those expected marital relations?
That seems to assume the very point under discussion.
In other words:

Mary asks:

"How will this occur, since I know not man?"

You explain the question by saying that She had already inferred a pre-consummation conception.
But when I ask why She made that inference, the answer seems to be:

"Because She asked the question."

That is the point I still find unresolved.

What in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to conclude that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph?

I know you find it unresolved. You will never find it resolved until I agree with your position. I'm not going to just keep repeating myself ad infinitum. Your questions have been answered multiple times. Either you simply do not have the mental capacity to understand it, or you lack the will to understand it. It's one or the other.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
181
58
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
And on the topic of whether Catholics worship Mary, here are some excerpts from the first ex cathedra statement ever uttered by a pope, by Pope Pius IX in 1854 in "Ineffabilis Deus".

"As if these splendid eulogies and tributes were not sufficient, the Fathers proclaimed with particular and definite statements that when one treats of sin, the holy Virgin Mary is not even to be mentioned; for to her more grace was given than was necessary to conquer sin completely.[24] They also declared that the most glorious Virgin was Reparatrix of the first parents, the giver of life to posterity; that she was chosen before the ages, prepared for himself by the Most High, foretold by God when he said to the serpent, “I will put enmities between you and the woman.”[25]-Unmistakable evidence that she crushed the poisonous head of the serpent." Thus declaring that in fact it was Mary, not Jesus, that crushed the serpent's head, in direct contradiction to Gen 3:15, which says that the Messiah (seed of the woman) will crush the serpent's head.

"the Blessed Virgin was, through grace, entirely free from every stain of sin, and from all corruption of body, soul and mind; that she was always united with God and joined to him by an eternal covenant; that she was never in darkness but always in light; and that, therefore, she was entirely a fit habitation for Christ, not because of the state of her body, but because of her original grace." If perfect Jesus required a perfect mother to bear her, then a perfect Mary would, by logical extension, also need a perfect mother to bear her. For how can someone as perfect as Mary be borne in a sinful, corrupted womb of a sinful, corrupt woman?

"Speaking of the conception of the Virgin, they testified that nature yielded to grace and, unable to go on, stood trembling. The Virgin Mother of God would not be conceived by Anna before grace would bear its fruits; it was proper that she be conceived as the first-born, by whom “the first-born of every creature” would be conceived. They testified, too, that the flesh of the Virgin, although derived from Adam, did not contract the stains of Adam, and that on this account the most Blessed Virgin was the tabernacle created by God himself and formed by the Holy Spirit, truly a work in royal purple, adorned and woven with gold, which that new Beseleel[26] made. They affirmed that the same Virgin is, and is deservedly, the first and especial work of God, escaping the fiery arrows of the evil one; that she is beautiful by nature and entirely free from all stain; that at her Immaculate Conception she came into the world all radiant like the dawn. For it was certainly not fitting that this vessel of election should be wounded by the common injuries, since she, differing so much from the others, had only nature in common with them, not sin. In fact, it was quite fitting that, as the Only-Begotten has a Father in heaven, whom the Seraphim extol as thrice holy, so he should have a Mother on earth who would never be without the splendor of holiness." Again, such majesty is bestowed on Mary that she is, without question, the most perfect person ever to live, apparently, completely and utterly free from sin or its influence in every conceivable way. And thus this violates Romans 3:23, which says, "for ALL have sinned and fall short of the glory of God."

"They have frequently addressed the Mother of God as immaculate, as immaculate in every respect; innocent, and verily most innocent; spotless, and entirely spotless; holy and removed from every stain of sin; all pure, all stainless, the very model of purity and innocence; more beautiful than beauty, more lovely than loveliness; more holy than holiness, singularly holy and most pure in soul and body; the one who surpassed all integrity and virginity; the only one who has become the dwelling place of all the graces of the most Holy Spirit. God alone excepted, Mary is more excellent than all, and by nature fair and beautiful, and more holy than the Cherubim and Seraphim. To praise her all the tongues of heaven and earth do not suffice." She's more holy than the angels. She is so amazing that heaven itself does not have the words to do her justice. She is "more holy than holiness". She is "singularly holy". God is holy, but Mary....oh my goodness, she surpasses even the definition of holiness itself! This violates Revelation 15:4, which says, "Who will not fear, O Lord, and glorify your name? For you alone are holy."


"Let all the children of the Catholic Church, who are so very dear to us, hear these words of ours. With a still more ardent zeal for piety, religion and love, let them continue to venerate, invoke and pray to the most Blessed Virgin Mary, Mother of God, conceived without original sin." So contrary to the claim that Catholics don't pray TO Mary, but just ask Mary to pray FOR US, Pope Pius IX here literally - in this, the official church DOGMA in an infallible Papal decree - instructs Catholics to pray TO Mary, not just ask Mary to pray FOR US.
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
674
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
I know you find it unresolved. You will never find it resolved until I agree with your position. I'm not going to just keep repeating myself ad infinitum. Your questions have been answered multiple times. Either you simply do not have the mental capacity to understand it, or you lack the will to understand it. It's one or the other.

I understand your explanation. In fact, I've repeatedly acknowledged that if Mary expected normal marital relations with Joseph, and if She inferred that Gabriel meant conception before consummation, then Her question makes sense. So the issue has never been whether I understand your explanation. The issue is the same question I've been asking throughout the discussion:

Why should Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph?

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

And you've argued that Mary expected a normal marriage and future marital relations. Therefore my question is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words. You've suggested several reasons for that inference, including the suddenness of the announcement, Gabriel's presumed tone, and the fact that Mary asked the question She did. But none of those explain why Mary would infer that the announced conception would occur before those expected marital relations rather than through them.

If you believe you've already answered that question, that's fine. But asking why one inference should be preferred over another is not evidence of a lack of understanding. It is the very point under discussion.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
207
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
The protoevangelium of James declares itself to have been written by James, supposedly the half-brother of Jesus, the leader of the church in Jerusalem. The last lines read, "And I James that wrote this history in Jerusalem, a commotion having arisen when Herod died, withdrew myself to the wilderness until the commotion in Jerusalem ceased, glorifying the Lord God, who had given me the gift and the wisdom to write this history. And grace shall be with them that fear our Lord Jesus Christ, to whom be glory to ages of ages. Amen."

Of course, it is not possible for this to have been written by James, since he was long since dead by the time that this document was written (between 120-150 AD, with most scholars leaning towards 150). The oldest existing manuscript is dated to the 3rd century, possibly even the early 4th century.

The book had so little going for it that Eusebius didn't even mention it in his list of books - in ANY of his lists of books. Based on how he classified other books, Eusebius would have classified this book - had he mentioned it at all - as spurious. Not as heretical, as it contained some orthodox ideas, but rather as a non-historical legend. Origen (circa 240 AD) was the first person we know of to mention its existence at all. It was not considered for canonicity due to late authorship, dubious attribution, and theological concerns raised by early church leaders. Pope Innocent (405 AD) condemned this text on the grounds that it was a pseudepigraphal forgery falsely claiming apostolic authorship, alongside concerns that it was being used by certain groups to promote unorthodox teachings.

So it has blatant falsehoods, contradicts Scripture in numerous places, was a forgery, was never remotely considered to be canonical, was only first mentioned more than 200 years after Christ's death, and was condemned by Pope Innocent because of theological concerns and was a psuedograph and a forgery.

I mean, other than that, yeah, it's greaaaaaaaaat.
Although Protoevangelium of Jame is not in the canon, and pseudepigraphal, it does not mean it has no relevant oral traditions preserved.

The Bible says Joseph and Mary traveled to Bethlehem, but it never mentions a donkey. The Protoevangelium specifically describes Joseph saddling a donkey for Mary to ride. A scene commonly presented in western churches, including MANY MANY Protestant denominations.


IMG_0643.jpeg


While the Gospel of Luke mentions a manger, it never specifies a stable or a cave. The Protoevangeliumstates that Mary gave birth inside a dark cave outside Bethlehem, which is why Eastern Orthodox icons always show the Nativity in a cave.
IMG_0644.jpeg
This is often seen in Orthodox icons.
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
181
58
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Although Protoevangelium of Jame is not in the canon, and pseudepigraphal, it does not mean it has no relevant oral traditions preserved.

It may have some value. It cannot be trusted as Scripture is trusted, because there are elements of the protoevangelium of James that are in direct contradiction with infallible Scripture, and it's a forgery to boot. (i.e., James most certainly did not write it, despite it being claimed in the text that he did).

So why would I trust this legend it tells?

The Bible says Joseph and Mary traveled to Bethlehem, but it never mentions a donkey. The Protoevangelium specifically describes Joseph saddling a donkey for Mary to ride. A scene commonly presented in western churches, including MANY MANY Protestant denominations.


View attachment 93315


While the Gospel of Luke mentions a manger, it never specifies a stable or a cave. The Protoevangeliumstates that Mary gave birth inside a dark cave outside Bethlehem, which is why Eastern Orthodox icons always show the Nativity in a cave.
View attachment 93316
This is often seen in Orthodox icons.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
207
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
It may have some value. It cannot be trusted as Scripture is trusted, because there are elements of the protoevangelium of James that are in direct contradiction with infallible Scripture, and it's a forgery to boot. (i.e., James most certainly did not write it, despite it being claimed in the text that he did).

So why would I trust this legend it tells?
There are scholars who claim Paul did not write Hebrew, and some of his epistles. Mathew was not the author of HIS gospel.
Are you not going to trust those scriptures?
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
181
58
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I understand your explanation. In fact, I've repeatedly acknowledged that if Mary expected normal marital relations with Joseph, and if She inferred that Gabriel meant conception before consummation, then Her question makes sense. So the issue has never been whether I understand your explanation. The issue is the same question I've been asking throughout the discussion:

Why should Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph?

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

And you've argued that Mary expected a normal marriage and future marital relations. Therefore my question is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words. You've suggested several reasons for that inference, including the suddenness of the announcement, Gabriel's presumed tone, and the fact that Mary asked the question She did. But none of those explain why Mary would infer that the announced conception would occur before those expected marital relations rather than through them.

If you believe you've already answered that question, that's fine. But asking why one inference should be preferred over another is not evidence of a lack of understanding. It is the very point under discussion.

The Bible doesn't tell us in very specific terms WHY Mary asked what she asked. The question we are trying to answer is WHY Mary asked what she asked. I'll sum this up again.

My view: Mary and Joseph were a normal young Jewish couple that was betrothed, but had not yet consummated their marriage by having sex. They, like every other couple that's basically ever existed, planned on having sex when they reached that point. So when Gabriel showed up and told her she would be pregnant, she thought something like, "I've never had sex, and I won't have sex until months from now when we consummate the marriage, so how can I possibly get pregnant under those circumstances?" The idea being that she must have thought Gabriel meant she would be pregnant SOON, before consummating their marriage. It turns out, such an assumption on Mary's part WOULD HAVE BEEN 100% CORRECT (a point you STILL haven't even acknowledged), because that's exactly what did, in fact, happen. Then, according to Matt 1:25, they waited to have sex until after Jesus was born, and then had a fairly normal sex life as a married couple, and produced more children, according to numerous passages in Scripture that refer to Jesus' siblings.

Your view: Mary and Joseph were NOT a normal young Jewish couple. Mary was born to a remarkable woman who consecrated her unto the Lord, such that both her mother and Mary herself vowed that Mary would never have sex. How Joseph felt about that, we are never told (I guess he was okay with marrying someone he not only would never have kids with, but that he would never even have sex with...very, VERY odd for that time - and ANY time in human history actually). So when Gabriel showed up and told her she would be pregnant, she wondered how that would be possible since she'd never had sex - and never WOULD have sex. And Matt 1:25 really means that Joseph never did, and never would, have sex with her. So the references to other siblings of Jesus were either cousins or kids Joseph had from a previous marriage - something never mentioned in Scripture anywhere. (We get this idea from a document that is a mid 2nd century forgery, contradicts Scripture itself in three places, and contains factual and theological errors sufficient that a Pope in 405 condemned the text, but sure, let's trust it!) And Mary, as it turned out, wasn't just consecrated to the Lord by her mother Anne, she actually was perfect, sinless, holy beyond holiness itself, never stained by the "sin" of having sex (or something like that), was really the one who crushed the head of the serpent, was the co-redemptrix, was the mother of heaven, was so holy and glorious that heaven itself hasn't sufficient words to describe her, never ever sinned or was stained by original sin, was perfect in every way, is someone we are called to pray to (says Pope Pius IX in his infallible ex cathedra statement on Mary in 1854), and was assumed bodily into heaven, and rules the universe as the Queen.


Which of these is the best explanation?
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
181
58
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
There are scholars who claim Paul did not write Hebrew, and some of his epistles. Mathew was not the author of HIS gospel.
Are you not going to trust those scriptures?

Those have already been accepted into the Canon. Protoevangelium of James has not been.

How do you know Matthew wasn't the author of his gospel?

Does Hebrews ever claim itself that Paul wrote it?

A far, far cry from the text itself saying that James wrote it, when James most certainly did not write it.

Pope Innocent condemned the protoevangelium in 405 AD. Surely the Lord wouldn't lead a pope, a successor of Peter, astray on this, would He?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
207
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Pope Innocent condemned the protoevangelium in 405 AD. Surely the Lord wouldn't lead a pope, a successor of Peter, astray on this, would He?
wow.....bravo!
all of a sudden........the Catholic Popes are infallible! (even to a Protestant)
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
207
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Those have already been accepted into the Canon. Protoevangelium of James has not been.
While Pope Innocent I officially slapped a condemnation on the Protoevangelium of James in 405 AD to keep it out of the biblical canon, the Western and Eastern Church quietly kept using its traditions anyway.

The Protoevangelium is an early 2nd-century text that popularized legendary details not found in the Gospels such as the names of Mary's parents (Joachim and Anne), her upbringing in the Temple, and the idea of Joseph as an older widower with children from a previous marriage. (also see #449)

Rejecting a book from the canon doesn't stop Christians from preserving its cultural and traditional folklore.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
207
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
"Let all the children of the Catholic Church, who are so very dear to us, hear these words of ours. With a still more ardent zeal for piety, religion and love, let them continue to venerate, invoke and pray to the most Blessed Virgin Mary, Mother of God, conceived without original sin." So contrary to the claim that Catholics don't pray TO Mary, but just ask Mary to pray FOR US, Pope Pius IX here literally - in this, the official church DOGMA in an infallible Papal decree - instructs Catholics to pray TO Mary, not just ask Mary to pray FOR US.

If someone says 'I prayed to X,' modern listeners automatically assume X is being treated as God.


The English word 'pray' has undergone a semantic shift over the centuries. In the early 19th century when Pope Pius IX reigned, the linguistic definition of 'to pray' historically meant simply 'to ask, petition, or entreat' (derived from the Latin precari).
For hundreds of years in English, you could 'pray' to anyone—a king, a judge, a neighbor, or God. It meant making a formal or earnest request to a person of authority or a peer.


It happened in a Shakespeare play: 'I pray you, tell me the way'.You angrily accusing them of worshiping a stranger on the street as a deity.

You're leaning entirely on the modern, narrowed English definition of 'pray' while ignoring both historical linguistics and the actual Latin text
 
Last edited:

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
207
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
My view: Mary and Joseph were a normal young Jewish couple
By bringing in the tradition told in Protoevangelium of James, Mary and Joseph were not normal , young couple.

Go and read yourself, don't just 'sola on your few scripture'.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,002
5,026
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Yes, you are speaking of Greek.
But Matthew was written in Hebrew, and Hebrew does not have a word for 'cousins' to distingush defferent level of kinships, just the word 'adelphos'.
We do not know if it was written in Hebrew. It is suggested because its theme reached to Jews. If it was to Jews in Israel it could have been Hebrew. But if Jews scattered through the empire, it would have been Greek.

Also we know that a Greek manuscript of Matthew dated to 59AD so they would have known of syngenes and anepsios for adelphos, as some apostles were still alive as well as wwitnesses.

And you are wrong about there not being a word for cousin or far kinfolk. The words are bnei dodim and bnei doda and first appeared in Esther and were used in the 4th and 5th Century B.C>
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,002
5,026
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The web site clearly stated that all these are spiritual guides, draw us closer to GOD. Are you always rejecting things that draw you close to GOD?
View attachment 93285
Any spiritual thing that draws us closer to God MUST meet biblical standards! If the bible doesn't teach it, it is false doctrine and must be resisted!

This devotion to Mary goes much further than just a mere veneration. Romanism has dedicated 1000's of churches to Mary. that is not mere veneration . If you do not wish to call it worship, then it is a highly obsessive problem.