You wonder because you do not know. But I know. What does that tell you?
Scott, I appreciate the time you've spent explaining your understanding. I recognize that you see something profound in the relationship between God, His Word, and His creation.
But I think we've reached a point where our discussion would benefit from returning directly to Scripture.
You've used several analogies involving mirrors, light, and chess pieces. I understand what you're attempting to illustrate, but an analogy cannot establish the nature of the relationship between the Father and Son. That must come from what Scripture actually says.
Consider how consistently the New Testament speaks about that relationship.
John 17:3: Jesus addresses His Father as "the only true God" and distinguishes Himself as Jesus Christ, whom the Father sent.
1 Timothy 2:5: Paul writes that there is "one God, and one mediator also between God and men, the man Christ Jesus."
Acts 2:22: Peter describes Jesus as "a man attested to you by God" through miracles and signs that God performed through Him.
Acts 3:13: Peter declares that the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob "has glorified His servant Jesus."
Acts 17:30–31: Paul tells the Athenians that God has appointed a man through whom He will judge the world and has furnished proof by raising Him from the dead.
Notice the consistent pattern.
God sends Jesus. God performs miracles through Him. God appoints Him. God raises Him. God glorifies Him.
Jesus is the one sent, empowered, appointed, raised, and glorified.
These are not illustrations I've invented. They are descriptions given by Jesus and His apostles.
Now, I recognize that you understand these distinctions as manifestations of a deeper divine unity. But that is precisely what I am asking you to demonstrate from Scripture.
Why should we understand these repeated distinctions as something other than genuine relationships between the Father and His Son?
When Jesus says, "Not my will, but yours, be done" (Luke 22:42), why should we understand that as a reflection of one divine individual rather than the genuine obedience of the Son to His Father?
And when Paul describes the Son ultimately subjecting Himself to God so that God may be all in all (1 Corinthians 15:28), why should we understand that distinction as merely an appearance?
You have suggested that I question these things because I do not know, while you possess the answers.
I would suggest that acknowledging the limits of our understanding is not the same as lacking faith.
Paul himself wrote, "For now we see in a mirror dimly" (1 Corinthians 13:12, ESV).
Perhaps that is an especially appropriate reminder in a discussion involving so many mirrors.
I have spent many years examining Scripture, and one thing that study has taught me is the importance of distinguishing what the biblical authors actually wrote from what we conclude their words must mean.
I would rather leave a question open where Scripture leaves it open than claim certainty based upon an interpretation I cannot demonstrate from the text.
I respect your convictions, Scott. I simply ask that we examine these passages on their own terms and allow Scripture, rather than our analogies, to guide our conclusions.