Two Witnesses - A Biblical Perspective

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,170
1,076
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
1,000 represents a large number, in today's world the word used would be Billion years

The scripture below shows the interpretation, is it one literal day or a thousand literal years?

It's "Neither", its showing the human man that God is outside of time, it's that simple

2 Peter 3:8KJ
8 But, beloved, be not ignorant of this one thing, that one day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day.

Your claims are 100% "Wrong" Revelation 1:20 and "Seven Candlesticks" has absolutely no association with Revelation 11:3-4 "None"
Just as post #109 above shows, your magic wand and bag of tricks are empty, "exposed"

You continue to deny the "Fact" that Revelation 11:3-18 teaches that the (Two Witnesses) have literal physical bodies that die, and these bodies are raised from the dead as a literal world watches, your trying to sell ice in the North Pole in the middle of winter and it ain't working

You need to look into the mirror and follow your own advice, Zechariah 4:11-14 gives the interpretation for the word "Candlestick(s)" and it clearly states the interpretation as being (The Two Anointed Ones) that are also seen in Revelation Chapter 11 as having literal physical bodies that die and these dead bodies are raised from the dead and ascend to heave in the sight of a literal world watching, your private interpretation on it being the "Church" is Laughable, Non-Existent, and that's being honestly nice

Jesus Is The Lord

(yawning). Here you go again.

You keep declaring yourself victorious while STILL refusing to reconcile the very Scriptures placed before you. Repeating “laughable,” “exposed,” and “100% wrong” is rhetoric—not exegesis.

First, 2 Peter 3:8 does not prove that the thousand years of Revelation 20 must be 1,000 literal calendar years. In fact, your appeal to that verse undermines your own rigid literalism:

“One day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day.”

Peter's point is obviously not a mathematical conversion formula. It demonstrates that biblical numerical language must be understood according to its context and purpose. So merely seeing the number “1,000” does not settle whether Revelation 20 intends a literal chronological measurement.

Second, your claim that Revelation 1:20 has “absolutely no association” with Revelation 11:4 is astonishing. It is the SAME BOOK using the SAME SYMBOL!

Revelation 1:20:

“The seven candlesticks which thou sawest ARE the seven churches.”

Revelation 11:4:

“These are the two olive trees, and the two candlesticks standing before the God of the earth.”

You cannot simply wave Revelation 1:20 away because it causes problems for your interpretation. God has already demonstrated within Revelation that a candlestick can represent a corporate church. That fact does not disappear when you reach chapter 11.

And Zechariah 4 does not rescue you. Zechariah calls them “the two anointed ones.” It does NOT say, “These are two individual supernatural men who will appear thousands of years from now during a future tribulation.” You are importing that conclusion into the text and then calling it the text's “interpretation.”

Likewise, saying the witnesses have “bodies,” “die,” “stand,” and “ascend” does not automatically establish your literal interpretation. Revelation repeatedly portrays corporate spiritual realities through individual, physical, and visible imagery. Babylon is portrayed as a woman. The Church is portrayed as a bride. Churches are candlesticks. Satan is a dragon. Nobody concludes that Babylon must therefore be one literal woman or Satan a zoological reptile because they perform actions in John's vision.

That is precisely why Revelation must be interpreted by comparing Scripture with Scripture, not by mechanically declaring every action literal whenever it suits your prophetic system.

So before announcing that my “bag of tricks is empty,” deal honestly with the text YOU continually avoid:

Why does God explicitly define candlesticks as churches in Revelation 1:20, and why should that inspired definition suddenly become irrelevant when John sees candlesticks again in Revelation 11:4?

Answer the question! Until you actually answer that question rather than dismissing it, you have not refuted the Church interpretation at all, so you are still in an ERROR!

Let Scripture interpret Scripture. Selah!
 

JimKnox

Well-Known Member
Jun 27, 2026
691
317
63
Western Idaho
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Nice diversion, but it does not rescue your argument.

Yes, I knew that you are midtrib. Fine. But you are still operating within a premillennial framework, which is exactly what I was addressing. Whether you place the rapture before, during, or at the end of the tribulation does absolutely NOTHING to answer my argument concerning the symbolic thousand years or the Two Witnesses.

Instead of answering Psalm 50:10, Revelation 1:20, Revelation 11:4, or explaining why repetition supposedly makes a symbolic number literal, you grabbed onto one mistaken label and declared me “intellectually dishonest.”

That is an escape, not a refutation.

Correct the label to midtrib premillennialist and my biblical argument remains standing exactly where I left it.

If you think I am wrong, refute the Scriptures and reasoning I presented. Don't hide behind a label and pretend you answered the argument.

You haven't. :laughing:
Well then CALL IT premil instead of pretrib.
Do you wish to be understood or are you flapping in the wind just to be ignored?

Stop lying. I never PRETENDED anything.

Your argument is so ridiculous as to deserve mockery but certainly not intellectual discourse.



I have watched you here long enough to know that all you care about is hearing yourself flap self righteous pablum. Plenty of people (including myself) have answered you and you ignore the answer and repeat your mythological symbolism for terms that are clearly literal.

At a certain point, people get tired of you.
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,170
1,076
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Well then CALL IT premil instead of pretrib.
Do you wish to be understood or are you flapping in the wind just to be ignored?

Stop lying. I never PRETENDED anything.

Your argument is so ridiculous as to deserve mockery but certainly not intellectual discourse.



I have watched you here long enough to know that all you care about is hearing yourself flap self righteous pablum. Plenty of people (including myself) have answered you and you ignore the answer and repeat your mythological symbolism for terms that are clearly literal.

At a certain point, people get tired of you.

LOL! You can mock me, accuse me of “flapping,” call my interpretation ridiculous, and complain that people are tired of me—but none of that refutes a single biblical argument I have made! So you really distracting biblical discussion by attacking me. LOL.

You accuse me of repeating “mythological symbolism,” yet you still have not demonstrated from Scripture why my interpretation is wrong. Personal attacks are not exegesis. Mockery is not a biblical rebuttal. Saying something is “clearly literal” over and over does not make it so. Get this through your thick skull first!

If my interpretation is wrong, then open the Bible and prove it. Deal with the actual texts, their context, their Old Testament foundations, and the symbolic language Revelation itself establishes. Show from Scripture why my arguments fail instead of attacking my character and motives.

You also accuse me of lying and pretending things without demonstrating either accusation. That is serious. If I lied, quote the exact statement that was false and provide the evidence. Otherwise, withdraw the accusation.

And regarding “pretrib” versus “premil”: terminology can be clarified easily. Pretribulationism normally exists within a premillennial framework, but the two terms describe different things: “pretrib” concerns the timing of the rapture relative to the tribulation, while “premil” concerns Christ’s return relative to the millennium. Correcting terminology is fine. Turning that correction into personal ridicule contributes nothing to the biblical discussion. Poor you!

You say you have watched me long enough to know what I “care about.” You do not know my heart. Deal with what I actually write rather than assigning motives to me. :-)

A serious Bible student should be willing to test an interpretation by Scripture, even when he strongly disagrees with it. “I disagree,” “it is obviously literal,” and “people are tired of you” are not arguments.

So put the insults aside and make the biblical case. Chapter and verse. Context and exegesis. Address my actual arguments rather than my personality.

If you cannot do that, then all this mockery demonstrates is that you have plenty to say about me but very little to say in refutation of the biblical position I presented. hlo
 

JimKnox

Well-Known Member
Jun 27, 2026
691
317
63
Western Idaho
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
LOL! You can mock me, accuse me of “flapping,” call my interpretation ridiculous, and complain that people are tired of me—but none of that refutes a single biblical argument I have made! So you really distracting biblical discussion by attacking me. LOL.

You accuse me of repeating “mythological symbolism,” yet you still have not demonstrated from Scripture why my interpretation is wrong. Personal attacks are not exegesis. Mockery is not a biblical rebuttal. Saying something is “clearly literal” over and over does not make it so. Get this through your thick skull first!

If my interpretation is wrong, then open the Bible and prove it. Deal with the actual texts, their context, their Old Testament foundations, and the symbolic language Revelation itself establishes. Show from Scripture why my arguments fail instead of attacking my character and motives.

You also accuse me of lying and pretending things without demonstrating either accusation. That is serious. If I lied, quote the exact statement that was false and provide the evidence. Otherwise, withdraw the accusation.

And regarding “pretrib” versus “premil”: terminology can be clarified easily. Pretribulationism normally exists within a premillennial framework, but the two terms describe different things: “pretrib” concerns the timing of the rapture relative to the tribulation, while “premil” concerns Christ’s return relative to the millennium. Correcting terminology is fine. Turning that correction into personal ridicule contributes nothing to the biblical discussion. Poor you!

You say you have watched me long enough to know what I “care about.” You do not know my heart. Deal with what I actually write rather than assigning motives to me. :-)

A serious Bible student should be willing to test an interpretation by Scripture, even when he strongly disagrees with it. “I disagree,” “it is obviously literal,” and “people are tired of you” are not arguments.

So put the insults aside and make the biblical case. Chapter and verse. Context and exegesis. Address my actual arguments rather than my personality.

If you cannot do that, then all this mockery demonstrates is that you have plenty to say about me but very little to say in refutation of the biblical position I presented. hlo
I bet you thought I was gonna READ all that, huh?
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,801
4,306
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
(yawning). Here you go again.

You keep declaring yourself victorious while STILL refusing to reconcile the very Scriptures placed before you. Repeating “laughable,” “exposed,” and “100% wrong” is rhetoric—not exegesis.

First, 2 Peter 3:8 does not prove that the thousand years of Revelation 20 must be 1,000 literal calendar years. In fact, your appeal to that verse undermines your own rigid literalism:

“One day is with the Lord as a thousand years, and a thousand years as one day.”

Peter's point is obviously not a mathematical conversion formula. It demonstrates that biblical numerical language must be understood according to its context and purpose. So merely seeing the number “1,000” does not settle whether Revelation 20 intends a literal chronological measurement.
Your assumptions and claims are "false again", I don't believe in nor do I teach of a future 1,000 year kingdom on this earth

Jesus returns in fire and final judgement dissolving this earth by fire (The End)
Second, your claim that Revelation 1:20 has “absolutely no association” with Revelation 11:4 is astonishing. It is the SAME BOOK using the SAME SYMBOL!

Revelation 1:20:

“The seven candlesticks which thou sawest ARE the seven churches.”

Revelation 11:4:

“These are the two olive trees, and the two candlesticks standing before the God of the earth.”

You cannot simply wave Revelation 1:20 away because it causes problems for your interpretation. God has already demonstrated within Revelation that a candlestick can represent a corporate church. That fact does not disappear when you reach chapter 11.

And Zechariah 4 does not rescue you. Zechariah calls them “the two anointed ones.” It does NOT say, “These are two individual supernatural men who will appear thousands of years from now during a future tribulation.” You are importing that conclusion into the text and then calling it the text's “interpretation.”
Once Again, Revelation 1:20 and the word "Candlestick(s) has absolutely no association to Rev 11:3-4 whatsoever "None"

Once Again Zechariah 4:11-14 interprets the olive trees and candlestick and the symbolism represents (The Two Annointed Ones) who are the (Two Witnesses) seen in Revelation Chapter 11, "Yes" scripture interprets itself, and it's not your "False Claim" of this being the Church, that's Baloney, Malarkey, and "Laughable" "A Joke"!
Likewise, saying the witnesses have “bodies,” “die,” “stand,” and “ascend” does not automatically establish your literal interpretation.
Once Again, Yes it does show a literal interpretation of the (Two Witnesses) that have bodies that die, bodies that a literal world will watch dead in a literal Jerusalem street, bodies that will be raised from the dead and stand upon physical feet, bodies that will ascend to heaven as literal human eyes on earth watch

You take all the detailed description of the (Two Witnesses) in Rev Chap 11 and desperately try to claim it represents the "Church" that's Baloney, Malarkey, and "Laughable" "A Joke"!
So before announcing that my “bag of tricks is empty,” deal honestly with the text YOU continually avoid:
Once Again your magic wand and bag of tricks are empty "Exposed"

Once Again, the Candlesticks mentioned in Rev 11:3-4 have absolutely no association to Rev 1:20 as you "Falsely Claim" "None", as is clearly described above

I haven't avoided any text as you falsely claim, your magic wand and bag of tricks is empty, totally exposed

Why does God explicitly define candlesticks as churches in Revelation 1:20, and why should that inspired definition suddenly become irrelevant when John sees candlesticks again in Revelation 11:4?
Don't play Dumb, you have been answered "Several Times" showing that the symbols of the olive trees and candlestick(s) has been clearly interpreted by scripture itself in context in Zechariah 4:11-14 as (The Two Annointed Ones) who are the (Two Witnesses) seen in Revelation Chapter 11

You run about claiming that it represents the Church, giving complete disregard to Zechariah 4:11-14 as if it doesn't exist, that's how far one will go in desperately trying to prop up a false interpretation to suit one's own needs
Let Scripture interpret Scripture.
Follow your own advice, look in the mirror

Jesus Is The Lord
 
Last edited:

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,170
1,076
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You would lose the bet, pal.

Childish game. “You would lose the bet, pal” proves absolutely nothing. Nobody here can verify what you have or have not read, and frankly, that is no longer the issue.

The issue is that after all these exchanges, you still have not produced a serious biblical refutation of the position I presented. Instead of dealing carefully with Scripture, comparing Scripture with Scripture, and demonstrating where my interpretation actually fails, you keep retreating into sarcasm, personal remarks, and games about who read what.

I'm interested in biblical discussion, not an ego contest.

If you could refute my position from Scripture, you had every opportunity to do so. You chose not to engage it substantively.

So I'm finished wasting time on this sideshow. You're being kicked into my dungeon of ignore list. Others can read the arguments and examine the Scriptures for themselves.

“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” — 1 Thessalonians 5:21

Selah and Goodbye Jimmy.

gatebars.gif
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,170
1,076
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Your assumptions and claims are "false again", I don't believe in nor do I teach of a future 1,000 year kingdom on this earth

Jesus returns in fire and final judgement dissolving this earth by fire (The End)

Once Again, Revelation 1:20 and the word "Candlestick(s) has absolutely no association to Rev 11:3-4 whatsoever "None"

Enough. You keep repeating the same assertions, insults, and capitalized words as though repetition somehow constitutes exegesis. It does not.

I do not care whether you believe in a future earthly 1,000-year kingdom or not because you got the millennial kingdom of Revelation 20 all wrong to begin with anyway. This has nothing to do with the argument presently before us.

Your fundamental error remains untouched.

You repeatedly quote Zechariah 4:14:

“These are the two anointed ones, that stand by the Lord of the whole earth.”

And then you simply ASSERT:

“Therefore these must be two individual supernatural men living during a future period.”

Where does Zechariah 4:14 say that? NOWHERE!! It is coming from your carnal mind.

“Two anointed ones” is the inspired identification given in Zechariah's vision. Your conclusion that this requires two future individual men is your interpretation—not something Zechariah 4:14 actually states.

And your insistence that Revelation 1:20 has “absolutely no association” with Revelation 11:4 is particularly revealing.

God says:

“The seven "candlesticks" which thou sawest "ARE" the seven "churches.” — Revelation 1:20

Then the SAME inspired book says:

“These are the two olive trees, and the two "candlesticks" standing before the God of the earth.” — Revelation 11:4

Yet you demand that everyone pretend God's previously established use of the candlestick symbol for churches becomes completely irrelevant seven chapters later. Bad move on your part!

That isn't comparing Scripture with Scripture. That's isolating the verse from an inconvenient biblical precedent because it conflicts with your interpretation.

And repeatedly shouting “literal bodies,” “literal Jerusalem,” “literal world,” “physical feet,” “literal human eyes” doesn't prove those things are literal. You are merely inserting the word LITERAL before every element of an apocalyptic vision and then presenting your assumption as proof of itself.

Revelation personifies and depicts corporate realities as individual actors throughout the book. Therefore, describing the witnesses as acting, dying, standing, and ascending does not by itself settle whether John intends two individual persons or a corporate reality represented through two witnesses.

That is the actual exegetical question—and you have never demonstrated your conclusion. You have simply repeated it.

So keep the “Baloney,” “Malarkey,” “Laughable,” “magic wand,” “bag of tricks,” and “Exposed” routine. None of those words constitute biblical evidence.

We've gone around this circle enough. Anyone reading this discussion can compare Zechariah 4, Revelation 1:20, and Revelation 11 and decide which interpretation actually allows Scripture to interpret Scripture.

I'm interested in biblical exegesis, not endless repetition and ridicule. Therefore, I'm also putting you on ignore and moving on.

Let the Scriptures stand.

Selah. And Goodbye!


gatebars.gif
 

Truth7t7

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2014
13,801
4,306
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Enough. You keep repeating the same assertions, insults, and capitalized words as though repetition somehow constitutes exegesis. It does not.

I do not care whether you believe in a future earthly 1,000-year kingdom or not because you got the millennial kingdom of Revelation 20 all wrong to begin with anyway. This has nothing to do with the argument presently before us.

Your fundamental error remains untouched.

You repeatedly quote Zechariah 4:14:

“These are the two anointed ones, that stand by the Lord of the whole earth.”

And then you simply ASSERT:

“Therefore these must be two individual supernatural men living during a future period.”

Where does Zechariah 4:14 say that? NOWHERE!! It is coming from your carnal mind.

“Two anointed ones” is the inspired identification given in Zechariah's vision. Your conclusion that this requires two future individual men is your interpretation—not something Zechariah 4:14 actually states.

And your insistence that Revelation 1:20 has “absolutely no association” with Revelation 11:4 is particularly revealing.

God says:

“The seven "candlesticks" which thou sawest "ARE" the seven "churches.” — Revelation 1:20

Then the SAME inspired book says:

“These are the two olive trees, and the two "candlesticks" standing before the God of the earth.” — Revelation 11:4

Yet you demand that everyone pretend God's previously established use of the candlestick symbol for churches becomes completely irrelevant seven chapters later. Bad move on your part!

That isn't comparing Scripture with Scripture. That's isolating the verse from an inconvenient biblical precedent because it conflicts with your interpretation.

And repeatedly shouting “literal bodies,” “literal Jerusalem,” “literal world,” “physical feet,” “literal human eyes” doesn't prove those things are literal. You are merely inserting the word LITERAL before every element of an apocalyptic vision and then presenting your assumption as proof of itself.

Revelation personifies and depicts corporate realities as individual actors throughout the book. Therefore, describing the witnesses as acting, dying, standing, and ascending does not by itself settle whether John intends two individual persons or a corporate reality represented through two witnesses.

That is the actual exegetical question—and you have never demonstrated your conclusion. You have simply repeated it.

So keep the “Baloney,” “Malarkey,” “Laughable,” “magic wand,” “bag of tricks,” and “Exposed” routine. None of those words constitute biblical evidence.

We've gone around this circle enough. Anyone reading this discussion can compare Zechariah 4, Revelation 1:20, and Revelation 11 and decide which interpretation actually allows Scripture to interpret Scripture.

I'm interested in biblical exegesis, not endless repetition and ridicule. Therefore, I'm also putting you on ignore and moving on.

Let the Scriptures stand.

Selah. And Goodbye!
(The Future Two Witnesses, And Biblical Truth)

Zechariah 4:11-14 below clearly "Interprets" the olive trees and candlestick as being (The Two Anointed Ones) who are (The Two Witnesses) seen in Revelation Chapter 11, they are described as having literal physical bodies that die, and their dead bodies are literally raised from the dead before a literal world watching (Future, Literal)

Conclusion: (The Two Witnesses) do not represent the "Church" as posters "Falsely" suggest, the events seen in Revelation Chapter 11 are (Future Unfulfilled)

Future Fulfillment: The (Two Witnesses) will prophesy for 1260 literal days bringing all plagues upon this wicked world at their will, they will be killed and lay dead in a literal Jerusalem street for 3.5 literal days as a wicked world watches in celebration of their deaths exchanging gifts, they will be raised from the dead standing on their feet and they will ascend into heaven as the literal world watches, the same hour there will be a great earth quake in Jerusalem, the 2nd woe is complete and the 3rd woe comes quickly in the 7th Angel-Trump sounding (The End) Final Judgement Seen in Rev 11:18 (The End)

Revelation 11:3-4KJV
3 And I will give power unto my two witnesses, and they shall prophesy a thousand two hundred and threescore days, clothed in sackcloth.
4 These are the two olive trees, and the two candlesticks standing before the God of the earth.

Zechariah 4:11-14KJV
11 Then answered I, and said unto him, What are these two olive trees upon the right side of the candlestick and upon the left side thereof?
12 And I answered again, and said unto him, What be these two olive branches which through the two golden pipes empty the golden oil out of themselves?
13 And he answered me and said, Knowest thou not what these be? And I said, No, my lord.
14 Then said he, These are the two anointed ones, that stand by the Lord of the whole earth.

Revelation 11:3-18KJV
3 And I will give power unto my two witnesses, and they shall prophesy a thousand two hundred and threescore days, clothed in sackcloth.
4 These are the two olive trees, and the two candlesticks standing before the God of the earth.
5 And if any man will hurt them, fire proceedeth out of their mouth, and devoureth their enemies: and if any man will hurt them, he must in this manner be killed.
6 These have power to shut heaven, that it rain not in the days of their prophecy: and have power over waters to turn them to blood, and to smite the earth with all plagues, as often as they will.
7 And when they shall have finished their testimony, the beast that ascendeth out of the bottomless pit shall make war against them, and shall overcome them, and kill t
8 And their dead bodies shall lie in the street of the great city, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also our Lord was crucified.
9 And they of the people and kindreds and tongues and nations shall see their dead bodies three days and an half, and shall not suffer their dead bodies to be put in graves.
10 And they that dwell upon the earth shall rejoice over them, and make merry, and shall send gifts one to another; because these two prophets tormented them that dwelt on the earth.
11 And after three days and an half the spirit of life from God entered into them, and they stood upon their feet; and great fear fell upon them which saw them.
12 And they heard a great voice from heaven saying unto them, Come up hither. And they ascended up to heaven in a cloud; and their enemies beheld them.
13 And the same hour was there a great earthquake, and the tenth part of the city fell, and in the earthquake were slain of men seven thousand: and the remnant were affrighted, and gave glory to the God of heaven.
14 The second woe is past; and, behold, the third woe cometh quickly.
15 And the seventh angel sounded; and there were great voices in heaven, saying, The kingdoms of this world are become the kingdoms of our Lord, and of his Christ; and he shall reign for ever and ever.
16 And the four and twenty elders, which sat before God on their seats, fell upon their faces, and worshipped God,
17 Saying, We give thee thanks, O Lord God Almighty, which art, and wast, and art to come; because thou hast taken to thee thy great power, and hast reigned.
18 And the nations were angry, and thy wrath is come, and the time of the dead, that they should be judged, and that thou shouldest give reward unto thy servants the prophets, and to the saints, and them that fear thy name, small and great; and shouldest destroy them which destroy the earth.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: TribulationSigns

Luther7

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2025
650
345
63
61
Vineland
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male

Who Are the Two Witnesses of Revelation 11?​

The Bible does NOT teach that the Two Witnesses of Revelation 11 are two literal men who suddenly appear at the end of the world or even the first century. Revelation itself identifies them symbolically:



Elsewhere Scripture identifies the candlesticks as the churches (Revelation 1:20), while the olive-tree imagery is used for God's covenant people (Romans 11). Likewise, Christ calls His people His witnesses (Acts 1:8).

Therefore, the Two Witnesses represent the faithful and Chosen Church—the Elect of God bearing witness to Christ throughout the New Covenant age!

Why "two" witnesses? Because under God's law, a matter is established by the testimony of two witnesses (Deuteronomy 19:15). Jesus even sent His disciples out two by two (Mark 6:7; Luke 10:1). Thus, “two” signifies the divinely established and trustworthy testimony of God's people rather than requiring us to understand them as only two individual men. We, Christians, are the witnesses of Truth. Selah.

Their Power to Prophesy for 1,260 Days​

Revelation 11:3 says:



The 1,260 days are symbolic, representing the period in which the New Covenant Church is commissioned and empowered to carry the Gospel into the world for the purpose of salvation. This corresponds with Revelation 12, where the woman—the Church—is nourished by God for 1,260 days.

What is the “power” given to the witnesses?

It is the Holy Spirit working through the Word of God.

Jesus told His disciples:



This began particularly with the outpouring of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost. Acts 2 connects this with Joel's prophecy that God's servants would prophesy. Therefore, prophesying here does not mean that Christians can predict future events. God's people prophesy when, empowered by His Spirit, they faithfully proclaim the Word God has already given.

For this symbolic 1,260-day period, the Church carries the Gospel throughout the world. Through that Gospel witnessing, God secures His Elect as the church grows...UNTIL...

When Their Testimony Is Finished​

Then Revelation 11:7 says something extremely important:



Notice the timing: when they have "finished their testimony".

The beast cannot come out and kill their witness BEFORE God has completed the purpose for which He commissioned His witnesses. Their Gospel testimony continues UNTIL God's saving purpose through that testimony has been accomplished. Selah!

Compare Christ's words:



Therefore, their death occurs only after their testimony has been completed. God's Elect who were appointed to be gathered through the saving Gospel witness will have been accounted for. Satan cannot stop God's salvation program prematurely.

But what does it mean that the witnesses are “killed”?

It does not necessarily mean every Christian on earth will be "physically murdered."

Rather their death represents the death or silencing of their Gospel witness within the external Church which is a great city. The beast (the body of false prophets and christs) makes war against the saints and overcomes their truthful testimony with their own lies. The faithful Word that once brought living water is rejected, suppressed and finally driven out. The candlestick's light goes out.

Please understand that the true believers themselves remain spiritually alive in Christ. They are the "oil and wine" that will not harm during the Great Tribulation. Anyway what has been “killed” is their effective testimony within the apostate external congregation, right in the streets of the Great city. The street represents public and common space WITHIN external church, where that testimony had been heard. The imagery is not simply that the witneses are somewhere inside a physical city, but rather pictures them lying openly in the place where the people of that city ordinarily gather and where public testimony would be heard. In other words, inside the churches all over the world.

Why Does the Unsaved World Rejoice?​

Revelation 11:10 explains:



Why would anyone celebrate the disappearance of God's truthful testimony of Two Witnesses?

Because the faithful Gospel does more than say, “God loves you.”

It also confronts man with sin, repentance, judgment, and the absolute authority of God.

The Word exposes man's rebellion. It declares that man's own righteousness cannot save him. It tells him that God's law—not man's feelings, traditions, or opinions—is the final authority.

That faithful testimony torments the rebellious conscience. The enemies (professed Christians, false prophets, and christs) hate this so they are trying to silence (kill) them.

Therefore, when the faithful witness is finally silenced, the unsaved rejoice. The voice that continually testified against their sin appears to be gone. They no longer have to hear the uncomfortable testimony of God's judgment. They can preach or do whatever they like to hear in the church.

This is why Revelation specifically says they rejoice "because" the prophets had tormented them with truth and corrections.

Then Comes the Symbolic 3½ Days​

But Revelation does not end with the witnesses lying dead.



The 3½ days represent a short period of spiritual silence following the killing of their testimony. This also parallel to the half an hour of silence in Revelation 8:1. It is because God will finally judges the unfaithful church for being unfaithful and silence His Witneses. Before He judges His House, He wants His chosen Elect to come out so that they will not partake of church's plagues.

Remember the witnesses are not "spiritually dead"—they are always God's Elect and already possess eternal life. Rather, they are “dead” in the particular sense that their Gospel witness has been silenced within the city. You need to understand this first.

Then something dramatic happens:

The Spirit of life from God enters them, and they stand upon their feet.

This means their testimony becomes alive and active again.

There had been silence. Now they speak.

There had been apparent defeat. Now they stand.

There had been immobility of the Elect. Now they are prepared to move OUT of the apostate church, moved by the Spirit of Life.

The imagery parallels Ezekiel 37, where the breath of God enters the dead bones and they stand upon their feet. Revelation uses similar resurrection imagery to describe the revival and mobilization of God's faithful witnesses.

(Continue to next post - "Feet")​

Ahh yes. Symbolically this would represent the 144,000 sealed. Once the last person predestined to eternal life is saved, the tribulation begins.
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,170
1,076
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Ahh yes. Symbolically this would represent the 144,000 sealed. Once the last person predestined to eternal life is saved, the tribulation begins.

There you go!

Satan was restrained since the Cross so that Christ could build his church through His Two Witnesses (Faithful Witnesses throughout Church age). Once the last Elect has been secured, the tesitmony is finished, and the beast will finally comes out and attack them. The Great Tribulation "FOR" the Elect begins.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: JimKnox

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,702
7,490
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Ahh yes. Symbolically this would represent the 144,000 sealed. Once the last person predestined to eternal life is saved, the tribulation begins.
What do you mean by this exactly? How are you defining "the tribulation" here exactly? Based on what is written in 2 Peter 3:8-12, the opportunity for salvation will continue until the day Jesus returns. He is being patient with people giving them the opportunity to repent. Once He decides to not give people any more time to repent, then He will return.
 

Luther7

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2025
650
345
63
61
Vineland
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
There you go!

Satan was restrained since the Cross so that Christ could build his church through His Two Witnesses (Faithful Witnesses throughout Church age). Once the last Elect has been secured, the tesitmony is finished, and the beast will finally comes out and attack them. The Great Tribulation "FOR" the Elect begins.
I totally agree because I see it in scripture. It will be a spiritual assault on our sole conviction that Jesus Christ is God the Son. Many professing christians ( like maybe Mr. Knox?) will quickly adapt to whatever " gospel" keeps them alive and prosperous.
 

Luther7

Well-Known Member
Dec 20, 2025
650
345
63
61
Vineland
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
What do you mean by this exactly? How are you defining "the tribulation" here exactly? Based on what is written in 2 Peter 3:8-12, the opportunity for salvation will continue until the day Jesus returns. He is being patient with people giving them the opportunity to repent. Once He decides to not give people any more time to repent, then He will return.
I thought TribulationSigns said it pretty well. If I may further add, The Holy Spirit protects the word of God in reaching those whom He intends, and then makes His abode with them. When the last person written in the Lambs book of life becomes saved, The work of the Holy Spirit is finished. The world would never end with any other gospel because people are born everyday. In other words, there's a set time for God to fulfill his salvation plan and it seems like it's coming to an end quickly.

So that's when the two witnesses finish their testimony. I wonder who that final person will be who hears the words of God and lives? Who will be the one who received the word "into the good ground" ( Matthew 13:23)?

And to answer your statement, that is when there will be no more time given for people to repent.

1) God's elect are sealed once the two witnesses finish their testimony

2) then and only then can Satan be released or loosed from being bound or not being able to thwart the gospel reaching the elect.

3) Satan continues for whatever amount of time The tribulation is. I don't believe it's going to be 3 and 1/2 years. I believe it more to be 5 months as referencing Revelation 9

3a) this is also the time when the church is in the definitive state of apostasy as in 2nd Thessalonians 2 as you then see that wicked being revealed whom Christ will destroy "at the brightness of his coming"

4) Alleluia! Jesus comes at the last day in fiery judgment, creating a new heaven and a new earth. The chaff is burned and the wheat is gathered. Yes, it will be the time of the harvest. And yes, it may be in the fall of the year on the 8th day of the feast of Tabernacles but then God can come at any time because he doesn't need us to figure things out and he doesn't need to see what Israel is going to do either.
 
  • Loveit!
Reactions: TribulationSigns

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,702
7,490
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I thought TribulationSigns said it pretty well.
I'll have to bite my tongue here. Anyway, what exactly did you think He said pretty well? It seems that you both are not taking 2 Peter 3:8-12 into account here.

If I may further add, The Holy Spirit protects the word of God in reaching those whom He intends, and then makes His abode with them. When the last person written in the Lambs book of life becomes saved, The work of the Holy Spirit is finished. The world would never end with any other gospel because people are born everyday. In other words, there's a set time for God to fulfill his salvation plan and it seems like it's coming to an end quickly.
According to Peter in 2 Peter 3:8-12 the set time for salvation goes right up until the time when God decides to not give man any more time to repent. Peter indicated at that point Jesus will return. He said that the Lord is not being slow in keeping the promise of His return, but is being patient while giving people time to repent. Once that time ends, He will return. But, you have that time ending some time before He returns which contradicts what Peter indicated.

So that's when the two witnesses finish their testimony.
That does not mean no one can be saved after that point. That means Satan's little season will occur at that point and the gospel will be largely silenced by a great deal of false religions and false teaching, but that doesn't mean no one can be saved during that time. It will just be more difficult because of the mass wickedness, deception, apostasy and persecution going on during that time.

And to answer your statement, that is when there will be no more time given for people to repent.
Can you explain how you can reconcile that with what Peter wrote in 2 Peter 3:8-12, which speaks of the Lord's patience while giving people time to repent up until it is time for Jesus to return?

1) God's elect are sealed once the two witnesses finish their testimony
Where does it say that no one can be saved after that?

2) then and only then can Satan be released or loosed from being bound or not being able to thwart the gospel reaching the elect.
Even in Old Testament times Satan was able to thwart the gospel, the word of God, from being heard, but that doesn't mean no one was saved during those times. It was just more difficult for the message to get through because of all the spiritual darkness in the world during those times.

3) Satan continues for whatever amount of time The tribulation is.
I asked you to define "the tribulation" and you didn't do that. What is your understanding of "the tribulation" exactly? Would you equate it with Satan's little season?

I don't believe it's going to be 3 and 1/2 years. I believe it more to be 5 months as referencing Revelation 9
But, there's still a bit more to happen after the fifth trumpet, so what do you call the time period after that and before Jesus returns? Isn't that still a time of tribulation right up until He returns?

3a) this is also the time when the church is in the definitive state of apostasy as in 2nd Thessalonians 2 as you then see that wicked being revealed whom Christ will destroy "at the brightness of his coming"

4) Alleluia! Jesus comes at the last day in fiery judgment, creating a new heaven and a new earth. The chaff is burned and the wheat is gathered. Yes, it will be the time of the harvest. And yes, it may be in the fall of the year on the 8th day of the feast of Tabernacles but then God can come at any time because he doesn't need us to figure things out and he doesn't need to see what Israel is going to do either.
Okay.....
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,170
1,076
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I'll have to bite my tongue here.

Need a Band-Aid? You may want to keep one handy before you bite your tongue!
Anyway, what exactly did you think He said pretty well? It seems that you both are not taking 2 Peter 3:8-12 into account here.

I did take 2 Peter 3:8–12 into account - many times! The problem is that you don't agree with how I understand and apply the passage. Just because you dislike my interpretation doesn't mean I ignored the Scriptures. Perhaps you should address my actual argument rather than repeatedly suggesting that I haven't considered the passage. :rolleyes:

According to Peter in 2 Peter 3:8-12 the set time for salvation goes right up until the time when God decides to not give man any more time to repent.

God determines when He will no longer seal any additional Elect because all the Elect He intended to save have been secured and sealed. Selah!

Have you read Revelation 7:1–4 as I have repeatedly asked you? Do you understand what happens after the final Elect is sealed?

Do you understand what the four winds of the earth represent? What about the earth, sea, and trees that are subjected to harm when those winds are released? Have you studied Revelation 9 and noticed what the trees represent? Men!

And what specifically were the locusts commanded to do? They were permitted to torment those who did NOT have the seal of God in their foreheads (Revelation 9:4).

Now think about the sequence of events. First, the winds are restrained until the servants of God are sealed. Once the sealing is completed, the restraints are removed, and judgment follows.

Does that sound like the Last Day and the Second Coming to you? No!

This is precisely the distinction you keep overlooking. In my understanding, the sealing of the final Elect marks the end of the opportunity for salvation. God's judgment then proceeds against those who remain unsealed, during Satan's little season, before the final resurrection and Second Coming.

Therefore, salvation is no longer available after the last Elect has been sealed, even though the Last Day and the Second Coming have not yet arrived.

You cannot simply assume that the opportunity for salvation must remain open until the very moment of Christ's return. You need to account for the prophetic sequence in Revelation 7–9. That's the very issue you keep avoiding.

Spiritual Israelite:

Based on what is written in 2 Peter 3:8-12, the opportunity for salvation will continue until the day Jesus returns.

Incorrect. You are confusing the completion of God's work of salvation with the Last Day and the Second Coming.

The opportunity for salvation continues until God has finished sealing all His Elect, not until the moment Christ returns on the Last Day.

Read Revelation 7:1–4 over and over until you understand the sequence. The four winds are restrained until the servants of God are sealed in their foreheads. What happens once that sealing is completed? The restraints are removed, and judgment follows.

There is a reason the winds are restrained until the sealing is finished. God is securing every one of His Elect before He releases judgment.

Furthermore, Revelation 9:4 specifically distinguishes between those who have the seal of God and those who do not. That is not describing the final resurrection on the Last Day. It describes a period of judgment following the completion of the sealing.

You are assuming that the opportunity for salvation must remain open until Christ's return. Scripture does not require that conclusion.

In my understanding, there is a short period of judgment after the final Elect is secured and before Christ returns for the final resurrection and judgment.

So, stop conflating the completion of the sealing with the Second Coming. They are not the same event. Selah!
He is being patient with people giving them the opportunity to repent. Once He decides to not give people any more time to repent, then He will return.

False. God is longsuffering and patient because He is giving ALL His Elect the opportunity to repent and be brought into His covenant. His judgment upon the unfaithful whore is withheld until the very last Child of God has been sealed and secured in their forehead FIRST!

This is precisely what Revelation 7:1–4 establishes. The four winds of judgment are restrained until the servants of God have been sealed. Why? Because God will not bring that judgment until He has secured all His Elect.

In this way, the fullness of the Gentiles comes in, and all of God's Elect are brought into Covenant Israel (Romans 11:25–26).

THEN what happens?

The testimony of the Two Witnesses FOR salvation is finished. The beast comes out of the bottomless pit, overcomes the Two Witnesses, and their testimony is silenced (Revelation 11:7). Satan is loosed for his little season, and the great tribulation begins for the Elect who are still alive and remain on earth before the Second Coming.

Do you understand the distinction?

The Gospel testimony FOR salvation and the subsequent testimony associated with judgment are not the same thing. God's purpose in securing His Elect is completed before that final period of judgment unfolds.

So no, SI, salvation will NOT continue until the Last Day, as you keep insisting. You are confusing the completion of God's work of gathering His Elect with the final return of Christ.

Wishful thinking, bud, but that is not what I believe the prophetic sequence of Scripture teaches. You need to account for Revelation 7, 9, and 11 rather than simply assuming that the opportunity for salvation remains open until Christ returns.

Selah!
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,702
7,490
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Need a Band-Aid? You may want to keep one handy before you bite your tongue!
Well, now that you've responded, I won't bite my tongue at all. You have no clue of what you're talking about most of the time, so for him to say you said it well was pretty hilarious. You rarely say anything well.

I did take 2 Peter 3:8–12 into account - many times!
Oh, really? Then why are you contradicting it with your false belief? That passage is clear that salvation will be available through repentance up until the day Jesus returns. Don't you understand that God's decision of when it will be time for Jesus to return will be when He decides to not give people any more time to repent? That is what 2 Peter 3:8-12 indicates. But, I wouldn't expect you to understand something so simple.

The problem is that you don't agree with how I understand and apply the passage.
That's not a problem. It's a virtue.


Just because you dislike my interpretation doesn't mean I ignored the Scriptures.
I don't actually know exactly how you interpret it, I just know that your belief that salvation ends for some time before Jesus returns contradicts the passage. So, how about telling me how exactly you interpret it for my entertainment.

Perhaps you should address my actual argument rather than repeatedly suggesting that I haven't considered the passage.
What is there to address? It contradicts what is indicated in 2 Peter 3:8-12. That's your problem to fix, not mine.

God determines when He will no longer seal any additional Elect because all the Elect He intended to save have been secured and sealed. Selah!
According to 2 Peter 3:8-12, that will occur when it's time for Jesus to return. Selah!

Have you read Revelation 7:1–4 as I have repeatedly asked you?
I have read it many times without you asking me. And?

Do you understand what happens after the final Elect is sealed?
Yes, that's when it will be time for Jesus to return. Selah!

Do you understand what the four winds of the earth represent? What about the earth, sea, and trees that are subjected to harm when those winds are released? Have you studied Revelation 9 and noticed what the trees represent? Men!
Yes, I know that. Hello! Have I come across to you at some point as being one of those who tries to take the book of Revelation as literally as possible? I'm not. But, unlike you, I don't try to interpret the entire Bible figuratively.

And what specifically were the locusts commanded to do?
To harm, but not kill, only those without the seal of God on their foreheads. Selah!

to do? They were permitted to torment those who did NOT have the seal of God in their foreheads (Revelation 9:4).
Mmmhmmm. So, I guess you assume what is described in Revelation 7 precedes what is described in Revelation 9 chronologically. Does that mean that you think the command given in Revelation 7 to not harm the trees, etc. is given to the locusts who come up from the bottomless pit? If so, where is that indicated? It's not. Instead, it's a command given to the four angels standing at the four corners of the earth. So, the context of each is not the same and they do not have the same timing.

Now think about the sequence of events. First, the winds are restrained until the servants of God are sealed. Once the sealing is completed, the restraints are removed, and judgment follows.

Does that sound like the Last Day and the Second Coming to you? No!
Yes! You are conflating that with Revelation 9, which is obviously not referring to the second coming. And you are contradicting 2 Peter 3:8-12, which you won't acknowledge.

This is precisely the distinction you keep overlooking. In my understanding, the sealing of the final Elect marks the end of the opportunity for salvation.
That happens just before Christ returns, not just before the fifth trumpet. In one passage it's the four angels being told to not harm the trees, etc. and in the other passage it's the locusts being told that. So, though they have similarities, they are not referring to the same thing.

God's judgment then proceeds against those who remain unsealed, during Satan's little season, before the final resurrection and Second Coming.

Therefore, salvation is no longer available after the last Elect has been sealed, even though the Last Day and the Second Coming have not yet arrived.
What would be the point of God allowing life to continue on the earth for a little season of time without salvation being possible? That makes no sense and, again, it contradicts 2 Peter 3:8-12 which indicates that the reason for any apparent delay in the Lord's second coming is not because He is being slow about it, but rather because He is giving people time to repent. Once He determines that He is not giving any more time to repent, why would He wait a little season to return after that? That makes no sense at all.
 

TribulationSigns

Well-Known Member
May 1, 2023
3,170
1,076
113
57
Somewhere west of Mississippi River
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I thought TribulationSigns said it pretty well.

Thank you!

If I may further add, The Holy Spirit protects the word of God in reaching those whom He intends, and then makes His abode with them. When the last person written in the Lambs book of life becomes saved, The work of the Holy Spirit is finished.

Amen! The Holy Spirit "FOR" Salvation of the Elect is finished.

The world would never end with any other gospel because people are born everyday. In other words, there's a set time for God to fulfill his salvation plan and it seems like it's coming to an end quickly.

Once all the Elect have been secured and sealed, they will then endure Satan's little season, however long that period may literally last.

Consider what Christ says:

Mat 24:21-22
  • For then shall be great tribulation, such as was not since the beginning of the world to this time, no, nor ever shall be.
  • And except those days should be shortened, there should no flesh be saved: but for the elect's sake those days shall be shortened.
Think about the significance of this passage. If the Great Tribulation were allowed to continue indefinitely, eventually there would be no Elect left alive on earth to fulfill the prophecy concerning those who are alive and remain at Christ's Second Coming (1 Thessalonians 4:15–17).
This is precisely why the Lord declares that those days will be shortened for the Elect's sake. He will cut short Satan's little season so that the remaining Elect who are still alive on earth will be preserved until the Second Coming and gathered up in the Rapture.

There may be very few Elect remaining by that time, but there will be a remnant alive and remaining to witness the glorious return of our Lord Jesus Christ.

The point is that the Great Tribulation does not continue until every last Elect on earth is destroyed. God has already secured His Elect, and He will preserve the remaining ones until Christ returns. Selah!

So that's when the two witnesses finish their testimony. I wonder who that final person will be who hears the words of God and lives? Who will be the one who received the word "into the good ground" ( Matthew 13:23)?

When the Two Witnesses' testimony is finish, it is their "power" to preach salvation gospel that will come to an end. How will their power end?

Dan 12:7
  • And I heard the man clothed in linen, which was upon the waters of the river, when he held up his right hand and his left hand unto heaven, and sware by him that liveth for ever that it shall be for a time, times, and an half; and when he shall have accomplished to scatter the power of the holy people, all these things shall be finished.
Who is "he?" The answer is Daniel 7:25. It is Satan will have power for a short season which will scatter the power of the holy people.

Rev 9:4-6
  • And it was commanded them that they should not hurt the grass of the earth, neither any green thing, neither any tree; but only those men which have not the seal of God in their foreheads.
  • And to them it was given that they should not kill them, but that they should be tormented five months: and their torment was as the torment of a scorpion, when he striketh a man.
  • And in those days shall men seek death, and shall not find it; and shall desire to die, and death shall flee from them.
Therefore, after the salvation no longer avalaible, people who still coming into congregation to seek salvation or desire to receive salvation but they won't receive it. Of course, they probably won't realize this, thinking they are saved. This is why Christ warned:

Mat 24:20-21
  • But pray ye that your flight be not in the winter, neither on the sabbath day:
  • For then shall be great tribulation, such as was not since the beginning of the world to this time, no, nor ever shall be.
We are warned to flee from the house and that it is WOE unto them that give suck. Those that give suck is a phrase signifying the ministers of the church whose job it is to spiritually feed the children. This is taken from the prophecy of Lamentations. You might "carefully" compare scripture with scripture to understand exactly who this passage refers to. Verse 19 clearly refers to the unsaved of God's house who will be under judgment because they are being feed by the false prophets and christs. This is a spiritual famine. They have not fed the children, and they die of starvation and thirst.

So Christ warned us to pray that our flight (flee from Babylon) not in winter or sabbath day. What did he mean by this?
I look at the winter of Matthew 24 as a season of hardship, a time of no growth, meaning no salvation. Christ bids them to pray that their flight is not in winter because in winter it is too late for fruitage or production. The harvest has come and gone. For example, the season for growth is over and there is no more chance for salvation. Sabbath refers to rest where no man can longer work in the Church for salvation. I believe this is just another illustration of WHY the saints have to be sealed "before" this time of the great fall and desolation beacuse there will be no salvation that Matthew 24 speaks of.

Revelation 7:3
  • "Saying, Hurt not the earth, neither the sea, nor the trees, till we have sealed the servants of our God in their foreheads.
Selah!

Good job Luther7 with your post.
 

Spiritual Israelite

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2022
18,702
7,490
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Once all the Elect have been secured and sealed, they will then endure Satan's little season, however long that period may literally last.

Consider what Christ says:

Mat 24:21-22
  • For then shall be great tribulation, such as was not since the beginning of the world to this time, no, nor ever shall be.
  • And except those days should be shortened, there should no flesh be saved: but for the elect's sake those days shall be shortened.
Think about the significance of this passage. If the Great Tribulation were allowed to continue indefinitely, eventually there would be no Elect left alive on earth to fulfill the prophecy concerning those who are alive and remain at Christ's Second Coming (1 Thessalonians 4:15–17).
This is precisely why the Lord declares that those days will be shortened for the Elect's sake. He will cut short Satan's little season so that the remaining Elect who are still alive on earth will be preserved until the Second Coming and gathered up in the Rapture.

There may be very few Elect remaining by that time, but there will be a remnant alive and remaining to witness the glorious return of our Lord Jesus Christ.

The point is that the Great Tribulation does not continue until every last Elect on earth is destroyed. God has already secured His Elect, and He will preserve the remaining ones until Christ returns. Selah!
This shows how lacking in discernment you really are. You try to relate a local event relating specifically to Judea (Matthew 24:15-22) to the global event of Christ's future return. My eyes are rolling in the back of my head right now. The days in 70 AD when Jews were being killed all over Judea and in the city of Jerusalem were cut short because otherwise everyone there would have been killed. But, for the elect who were there and not able to flee as Jesus warned believers to do, God cut the time short in order to spare their lives. You can't turn an event that occurred in Judea and Jerusalem into a global event. You have to resort to twisting the text to make it say what you want it to say.

Therefore, after the salvation no longer avalaible, people who still coming into congregation to seek salvation or desire to receive salvation but they won't receive it. Of course, they probably won't realize this, thinking they are saved. This is why Christ warned:

Mat 24:20-21
  • But pray ye that your flight be not in the winter, neither on the sabbath day:
  • For then shall be great tribulation, such as was not since the beginning of the world to this time, no, nor ever shall be.
We are warned to flee from the house and that it is WOE unto them that give suck. Those that give suck is a phrase signifying the ministers of the church whose job it is to spiritually feed the children.
(Huge eye roll). You go out of your way to spiritualize what is clearly literal text. It's truly unbelievable. The Olivet Discourse is not within the book of Revelation. There is no reason at all to spiritualize what Jesus was saying there. Jesus spoke straightforwardly through most of Matthew 24. The reason He said to pray that their flight FROM JUDEA to the mountains would not be in winter is because it would be more difficult to travel during the winter because of the harsh weather conditions. And the reason that He said to pray that it wouldn't be on the Sabbath day is because it would be difficult for them to get permission to leave the city on that day because of Sabbath day restrictions.

This is taken from the prophecy of Lamentations. You might "carefully" compare scripture with scripture to understand exactly who this passage refers to. Verse 19 clearly refers to the unsaved of God's house who will be under judgment because they are being feed by the false prophets and christs. This is a spiritual famine. They have not fed the children, and they die of starvation and thirst.

So Christ warned us to pray that our flight (flee from Babylon) not in winter or sabbath day. What did he mean by this?
I look at the winter of Matthew 24 as a season of hardship, a time of no growth, meaning no salvation.
Goodness sakes. Talking about twisting and manipulating the text to fit one's view! This is ridiculous! You are turning His simple, straightforward words into a convoluted mess that no one can understand.

Christ bids them to pray that their flight is not in winter because in winter it is too late for fruitage or production.
No, He bids them to pray that their flight would not be in winter because it would've been more difficult to flee from Judea to the mountains in the winter. The weather in the mountains can be brutally cold and harsh during the winter. And it would've been more difficult to flee on the Sabbath because of the restrictions in place on that day. And it would've been more difficult for nursing mothers and pregnant women to flee since trying to flee to the mountains while pregnant or with a baby would obviously be quite difficult.