Well, perhaps you should consider these things.
Stranger
***
LOL, and you don't have too, right? I get a laugh out of those who think they are God's gift to men. But the truth is that in your replies on this form it is your way or the highway.
As for your attitude that you want people to see the short comings in the position I am presenting" that is just fine. However, I don't think I would have said that to another person. The way you have expressed it is that I am the one that has short comings and yet I have pointed out what I see as "short comings" of the orthodox view of James 2. Your statement "We have all demonstrated what James is saying and you have not" is a little self-grandiose isn't it? All you have done is express an opinion just as I have. Your opinion does not make it a fact. Nor do I see that others have given you the right to express their views.
A forum is supposed to be a place where a person can express their beliefs without the fear that someone will want to wreck havoc on them for having them. I have been on forums for well over 15-years and people have said all kinds of things about me. I do not feel put out by it. They said those same things to, and about, Jesus. However, when some one gets too aggressive I make the follow comments to them and add their name to my "do not respond to this person under any circumstances" list.
Attitudes:
Some wish to be religious policemen on the forums. They think that they know the truth in the scriptures, feel that others do not, and that the forum must be protected from those that do not believe as they do. When they enter into a discussion it is not to "share" what they believe but to "impose" what they believe on others or to destroy what another believes. This is a very serious attitude problem.
What killed Jesus, Stephen, Paul and Peter? "The attitudes of people did!
It is the same attitude problem that made the Pharisees charge (accuse) Jesus of being wrong and wanting to have Him killed. It is the same attitude problem that made the Pharisees charge (accuse) Paul of being wrong and wanting to kill him. It is the same attitude problem that made the Pharisees charge (accuse) Stephen of being wrong and killing him. It is the same attitude problem that made the RCC charge (accuse) others of heresy and have them burned at the stake. It is the same attitude problem that made Calvin have those of the RCC burned at the stake. It is the same attitude problem that made the religious people in Salem hang those they thought were witches. It is the same attitude problem that causes Muslims to kill others.
This SAME attitude problem is found on forums in some of the posters. If a person dares to give an opinion that is not the same as theirs, then attack them, call them names, make fun of them, and above all else try to make yourself look superior to them by ridiculing them. It is an attitude that makes people rail against others, to denigrate and character assassinate another. It comes from insecurity and an evil heart that does not know what love is. The Children of God will not do it.
Oh, by the way, if the shoe fits wear it.
Having the wrong attitude towards others has killed many in the name of religion. It will also get your name added to my "do not respond list."
H Richard