A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
wow.....you are moving goalpoles.

Nope. You are the one who brought up the medieval church and what it allowed. I'm just reminding you that the medieval Catholic Church, uh, had some problems, shall we say.

Are we done on this issue?

I don't mind being done. And not that it matters that much to me, because you have your own life to live, but I'd just like to know if it concerns you even in the LEAST that current Marian theology is all based on this nonsense book the protoevangelium of James. Like, just a teeny-tiny bit? Does it give you at least a nanosecond's worth of pause?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
This is why the Bereans were so careful to even measure Paul's words against Scripture, not against their traditions. It's why we should do the same.
Your self-interpretation of scripture is 100times more dangerous than tradition teaching.!

In Acts 17:10–12, Paul and Silas arrive in Berea and reason from the Hebrew Scriptures, (the New Testament hadn't been written yet) to show that the Messiah had to suffer, die, and rise again, and that Jesus was that Messiah.

What they were actually doing: They were examining the Old Testament prophecies and passages to see if Jesus's messianic claims matched them, not using a private 'Scripture-only vs. Church tradition' test to throw out apostolic teaching or later Christian memory.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
to know if it concerns you even in the LEAST that current Marian theology is all based on this nonsense book the protoevangelium of James. Like, just a teeny-tiny bit? Does it give you at least a nanosecond's worth of pause?
I don't think your pastors have taught you much on Marian theology.
Crushing the head of serpent, typology of Ark, mother of God....not the whole of Marian theology.

Like there is no witness seeing YOU have killed Mr.X.
But when all the forensics point to you, you have your verdict!

There is no direct bible verse telling Mary is perpetual virgin. Yet, when all typologies pointing to this we have that doctrine.
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,790
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Um.... I'm trying to think of a gentle way of explaining this to you. I'll try.

Document 1 - No claim of authorship is made. We don't know who wrote it, and it doesn't say who wrote it.
Document 2 - Claims to have been written by the apostle James. Clearly wasn't written by the apostle James.

What's the difference between these two scenarios? Why is one a forgery and the other not?
Wow – just, WOW.

I already explained to you that the claim of “forgery” is based on the probable pseudonymous authorship, beginning with the fact that it is a SECOND century document and James was already dead.

THIS is why I compared the fact that the Epistles of Peter were ALSO written by someone else.
Are they “forgeries”??

The words of Innocent:
"Likewise of the New Testament: the books of the Gospels four, the epistles of the apostle Paul fourteen, the epistles of John three, the epistles of Peter two, the epistle of Jude, the epistle of James, the Acts of the Apostles, the Apocalypse of John.
But the rest, which are either under the name of Matthias or of James the Less
, or under the name of Peter and John, which were written by a certain Leucius, [or under the name of Andrew, which were written by the philosophers Nexocharis and Leonidas], or under the name of Thomas, and if there are any others, you shall know are not only to be repudiated, but also to be condemned."

Repudiated.
Condemned.


These aren't the words we apply to books that are "Hey this is really good stuff, but just not quite on par with Scripture." These are words that we apply to books that are "uh....these aren't good."
Once AGAIN – they were condemned as Scriptural truth – NOT that they couldn’t be gleaned for HISTORICAL evidence. IF you had taken the time to notice, you would see that he was comparing them you the NEW TESAMENT Books.

Context, son. CONTEXT . . .
I never said any of you "claimed that the protoevangelium was equal to scripture." What I've said is that the ENTIRE MARIAN LEGEND that currently resides in the Catholic Church originated with the protoevangelium of James, which is a pile of crap document.
Tradition is not “Legend”.
It is the truth conveyed ORALLY.

As Paul tells us – we hold fast to what is taught by the Church EITHER by ORAL statement – OR by a Letter (2 Thess 2:15).
Sacred Tradition is sanctioned by GOD to hold the SAME Authority as Scripture.
OR, did you forget that this is the way GOD ordains the Truth??

Let me show you what the BIBLE says about this . . .

Matt. 2:23 - the prophecy "He shall be a Nazarene" is ORAL TRADITION. It is not found in the Old Testament. This demonstrates that the apostles relied upon oral tradition and taught by oral tradition.

Matt 23:2 - Jesus relies on the ORAL TRADITION of acknowledging Moses' seat of authority (which passed from Moses to Joshua to the Sanhedrin). This is NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

1 Cor. 10:4 - Paul relies on the ORAL TRADITION of the rock following Moses. It is NOT recorded in the Old Testament. See Exod. 17:1-17 and Num. 20:2-13.

2 Timothy 3:8 - Paul relies on the ORAL TRADITION when speaking of Pharoah’s magicians, Jannes and Jambres. Their names are NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

Heb. 11:37 - the author of Hebrews relies on the ORAL TRADITION of the martyrs being sawed in two. This is NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

Jude 9 - Jude relies on the ORAL TRADITION of the Archangel Michael's dispute with Satan over Moses' body. This is NOT found in the Old Testament.

Jude 14-15 - Jude relies on the ORAL TRADITION of Enoch's prophecy which is NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

Clear ENOUGH for ya – or do I need to supply MORE examples??
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,790
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
For sure. Of course, the medieval Catholic Church also sold indulgences (as the coin in the coffer rings, a soul from purgatory springs) to get money to build St. Peter's and other cathedrals.
Dont you EVER get tired of being WRONG??
Allow me to educate you - AGAIN . . .

First
of all – the Catholic Church NEVER sole Indulgences. Those who make this claim need to furnish a document, Declaration or Decree stating the promulgation of the sakes of Indulgences.

Ummm – can YOU furnish us with that, please?
The Church, if nothing else is a real STICKLER for Church documents . . .

This was an abuse by individuals within the Church like Johanne Tetzel in Germany. It was Tetzel – and NOT the Church who came up with that idiotic slogan that YOU quoted, “When a coin in the coffer rings – a soul from Purgatory springs.”

In fact – the ONLY document the Church put out on this topic (Decree on Indulgences) was a condemnation of this practice as
”evil”.

And there ends the lesson . . .
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Your self-interpretation of scripture is 100times more dangerous than tradition teaching.!

In Acts 17:10–12, Paul and Silas arrive in Berea and reason from the Hebrew Scriptures, (the New Testament hadn't been written yet) to show that the Messiah had to suffer, die, and rise again, and that Jesus was that Messiah.

What they were actually doing: They were examining the Old Testament prophecies and passages to see if Jesus's messianic claims matched them, not using a private 'Scripture-only vs. Church tradition' test to throw out apostolic teaching or later Christian memory.

They fact-checked the Apostle Paul agains the Scriptures.

We should fact-check every religious truth claim against Scripture.

Because we don't really know which traditions are true or not true, but we all agree that the Scriptures are true. They are the only foolproof, infallible rule of faith.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I don't think your pastors have taught you much on Marian theology.
Crushing the head of serpent, typology of Ark, mother of God....not the whole of Marian theology.

I never said it was the "whole of Marian theology".

Like there is no witness seeing YOU have killed Mr.X.
But when all the forensics point to you, you have your verdict!

There is no direct bible verse telling Mary is perpetual virgin. Yet, when all typologies pointing to this we have that doctrine.

Not only is there no direct Bible verse teaching Mary's perpetual virginity, it's not even HINTED at in Scripture. That all comes from outside tradition.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Wow – just, WOW.

I already explained to you that the claim of “forgery” is based on the probable pseudonymous authorship, beginning with the fact that it is a SECOND century document and James was already dead.

THIS is why I compared the fact that the Epistles of Peter were ALSO written by someone else.
Are they “forgeries”??

Dumdum, that you can't see the difference between a document that doesn't claim a certain authorship and was written anonymously, and a document that claims to be written by James and CLEARLY WASN'T, speaks volumes about you.

Once AGAIN – they were condemned as Scriptural truth – NOT that they couldn’t be gleaned for HISTORICAL evidence. IF you had taken the time to notice, you would see that he was comparing them you the NEW TESAMENT Books.

Context, son. CONTEXT . . .

Tradition
is not “Legend”.
It is the truth conveyed ORALLY.

When a tradition contradicts Scripture, it must be thrown out. Would you agree with that?

As Paul tells us – we hold fast to what is taught by the Church EITHER by ORAL statement – OR by a Letter (2 Thess 2:15).
Sacred Tradition is sanctioned by GOD to hold the SAME Authority as Scripture.
OR, did you forget that this is the way GOD ordains the Truth??

Let me show you what the BIBLE says about this . . .

Matt. 2:23 - the prophecy "He shall be a Nazarene" is ORAL TRADITION. It is not found in the Old Testament. This demonstrates that the apostles relied upon oral tradition and taught by oral tradition.

Matt 23:2 - Jesus relies on the ORAL TRADITION of acknowledging Moses' seat of authority (which passed from Moses to Joshua to the Sanhedrin). This is NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

1 Cor. 10:4 - Paul relies on the ORAL TRADITION of the rock following Moses. It is NOT recorded in the Old Testament. See Exod. 17:1-17 and Num. 20:2-13.

2 Timothy 3:8 - Paul relies on the ORAL TRADITION when speaking of Pharoah’s magicians, Jannes and Jambres. Their names are NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

Heb. 11:37 - the author of Hebrews relies on the ORAL TRADITION of the martyrs being sawed in two. This is NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

Jude 9 - Jude relies on the ORAL TRADITION of the Archangel Michael's dispute with Satan over Moses' body. This is NOT found in the Old Testament.

Jude 14-15 - Jude relies on the ORAL TRADITION of Enoch's prophecy which is NOT recorded in the Old Testament.

Clear ENOUGH for ya – or do I need to supply MORE examples??
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Dont you EVER get tired of being WRONG??
Allow me to educate you - AGAIN . . .

First
of all – the Catholic Church NEVER sole Indulgences. Those who make this claim need to furnish a document, Declaration or Decree stating the promulgation of the sakes of Indulgences.

Oh, haha, right. They didn't officially sell indulgences. They just let their appointed people sell indulgences.

Ummm – can YOU furnish us with that, please?
The Church, if nothing else is a real STICKLER for Church documents . . .

This was an abuse by individuals within the Church like Johanne Tetzel in Germany. It was Tetzel – and NOT the Church who came up with that idiotic slogan that YOU quoted, “When a coin in the coffer rings – a soul from Purgatory springs.”

In fact – the ONLY document the Church put out on this topic (Decree on Indulgences) was a condemnation of this practice as
”evil”.

And there ends the lesson . . .

LOL. And you know, Hitler didn't kill any Jews during the Holocaust either. Is he responsible for the murder of six million Jews or not, since, you know, it was his henchmen who did the actual killing?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
I never said it was the "whole of Marian theology".
Not only is there no direct Bible verse teaching Mary's perpetual virginity, it's not even HINTED at in Scripture. That all comes from outside tradition.
You 'know not' does not equal to 'there is none'.
I already gave an easy typology to start with....here

#179 of

Too bad, yoi missed my post. Not too late to get back to it!
 

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
737
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Didn't say you did.

But it's where the whole fantastic Mary story comes from. You know that, right? The only reason YOU believe the fantastic Mary legend is because of that document, that over time became THE Catholic version of events, which is why you read that fantastic Mary legend into the Bible today. Not because the Bible itself teaches this fantastic Mary legend.



I have literally answered this question numerous times. She asked it because she believed for some reason that Gabriel meant that she would be pregnant SOON, when she knew that she wouldn't consummate her marriage by having sex for some time still, and even though she wasn't a biologist, she sure as heck knew how babies were made. So it was an absolutely natural question to ask.

Turns out, her belief on that score was 100% correct, because that is exactly what happened.

You’re just repeating the exact assertion I already refuted in my earlier post—while ignoring every single point of that rebuttal.

Look at the three words right in the middle of your summary:

"She asked it because she believed for some reason that Gabriel meant that she would be pregnant SOON..."

"For some reason" is the entire flaw I already pointed out—and you still haven't answered it:
  1. You have no textual reason why Mary would think "soon": Gabriel used plain future tense ("You will conceive in your womb and bear a son"—the exact same phrasing used in Judges 13:3 for a normal future marital birth). A betrothed woman planning normal marital relations with Joseph (which is what you claim She expected) would simply assume Gabriel meant after Her marriage—unless something in the text signaled immediacy, which you openly admit isn't there ("for some reason").

  2. Pointing to what happened afterward is hindsight bias: Saying "Turns out she was 100% correct, because that is exactly what happened" uses what the reader learns later in Luke 1:35–38 to explain what Mary was thinking before Gabriel ever revealed how the conception would happen—a point I already refuted and you completely skipped.

  3. My reading requires zero "for some reason" guesswork: If Mary intended to remain a virgin, then any announcement that She would bear a son—whether soon or years later—immediately prompts "How can this occur, since I know not man?"
As for the Protoevangelium of James: you ignored that Gregory of Nyssa and Augustine drew this exact conclusion straight from Luke 1:34's own grammar, not from apocrypha—and in fact, I reject the Protoevangelium's claim that Jesus's "brothers" were Joseph's sons from a prior marriage, following the Gospels (Matthew 27:56; John 19:25) and Hegesippus instead.

Repeating "for some reason" and "turns out she was right" without answering my rebuttal to either point doesn't fix your reading of Luke 1.
 
Last edited:

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
737
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
And I agree with your argument. Because Mattherw 1:25 tells us what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus was born! All your meandering and wonderings about Luke does not change the fact that Matthew declares what they did sexually after jesus was born

You've just illustrated my point. The discussion was about Luke 1:34-37 and the logic of the Annunciation narrative. I asked:

Why does Mary present "I know not man" as the difficulty, and why does Gabriel answer with divine intervention, Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception, and "nothing will be impossible with God," if ordinary future marital relations with Joseph were expected to explain the announced conception?

Instead of answering that question, you've switched to Matthew 1:25. But Matthew 1:25 is a different passage. Whether you believe Matthew 1:25 implies later marital relations has no bearing on the question I asked about Luke 1:34-37. In fact, I explicitly stated:

"My argument is not that Luke 1:34-37 tells us what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus' birth."

So when your response is: "Matthew 1:25 tells us what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus was born" you're not refuting my argument. You're changing the subject.

The question remains unanswered:

Gabriel announces a conception.
Mary responds, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
Gabriel answers with divine action by the Holy Spirit.
Gabriel points to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception.
Gabriel concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."

Why does Luke present Mary's virginity as the difficulty and divine intervention as the solution if ordinary future marital relations with Joseph were expected to account for the conception?

Appealing to Matthew 1:25 does not answer that question. It simply moves the discussion to a different text.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
You’re just repeating the exact assertion I already refuted in my earlier post—while ignoring every single point of that rebuttal.

Look at the three words right in the middle of your summary:

"She asked it because she believed for some reason that Gabriel meant that she would be pregnant SOON..."

"For some reason" is the entire flaw I already pointed out—and you still haven't answered it:
  1. You have no textual reason why Mary would think "soon": Gabriel used plain future tense ("You will conceive in your womb and bear a son"—the exact same phrasing used in Judges 13:3 for a normal future marital birth). A betrothed woman planning normal marital relations with Joseph (which is what you claim She expected) would simply assume Gabriel meant after Her marriage—unless something in the text signaled immediacy, which you openly admit isn't there ("for some reason").

  2. Pointing to what happened afterward is hindsight bias: Saying "Turns out she was 100% correct, because that is exactly what happened" uses what the reader learns later in Luke 1:35–38 to explain what Mary was thinking before Gabriel ever revealed how the conception would happen—a point I already refuted and you completely skipped.

  3. My reading requires zero "for some reason" guesswork: If Mary intended to remain a virgin, then any announcement that She would bear a son—whether soon or years later—immediately prompts "How can this occur, since I know not man?"
As for the Protoevangelium of James: you ignored that Gregory of Nyssa and Augustine drew this exact conclusion straight from Luke 1:34's own grammar, not from apocrypha—and in fact, I reject the Protoevangelium's claim that Jesus's "brothers" were Joseph's sons from a prior marriage, following the Gospels (Matthew 27:56; John 19:25) and Hegesippus instead.

Repeating "for some reason" and "turns out she was right" without answering my rebuttal to either point doesn't fix your reading of Luke 1.

Yes...."For some reason" actually means @Crazy Ivan had no reason in mind.