A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Well, different people have said different things, I'll grant you that.

You guys do get that you base all this weird Mary exaltation stuff on the protoevangelium of James, which is a forgery, which contains numerous inconsistencies with, and outright contradictions of, Scripture, which was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405 AD, and was such a train wreck that when they were considering which books to include in the New Testament canon, it was so bad that it didn't even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned. The protoevangelium didn't even get to that point it's so bad.

At some point that historical reality HAS to be at least a bit unsettling to you.

Here, I see you are using Pope Innocent's condemnation on Protoevangelium as infallible teaching against our arguments.

While Pope Piux IX spoke on stronger teaching, the ex cathedra pronouncement: the Ineffabilis Deus on Immaculate Conception of Mary, you just reject it.


Is that an inconsistency fallacy?
 
Last edited:

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,790
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
What do you believe are the actual saving gospel verses that Gal 1:11-12 Christ taught to Paul who then sent Paul Gal 2:2 to teach Peter ?
First of all – in Gal 1:11-12, Paul didn’t mention any “saving” Gospel verses. He was simply telling his readers about HOW he received the Gospel from Jesus.

As for Gal 2:2 - Paul didn’t go to Jerusalem to “teach” Peter or anyone else. He is writing about the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15), where he went to get a consensus from the leaders about what to do regarding the Judaizers in Antioch.

Sooo – what, exactly, is your
question?
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,790
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You guys do get that you base all this weird Mary exaltation stuff on the protoevangelium of James, which is a forgery,
Uhhh, NOT exactly . . .

In fact, the scholarly objections to this document are that James probably didn’t write is – and that it was written pseudonymously. For that matter – the scholarly consensus on the 1st and 2nd Epistles of Peter is that they were ALSO written pseudonymously . . .

Does that make them “forgeries” as well?

... which contains numerous inconsistencies with, and outright contradictions of, Scripture, which was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405 AD, and was such a train wreck that when they were considering which books to include in the New Testament canon, it was so bad that it didn't even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned. The protoevangelium didn't even get to that point it's so bad.
Pope Innocent's condemnation of the Protoevangelium wasa about whether or not it was considered SCRIPTURAL.
THAT matter was already settled at the Coouncil of Rome in 383 AD, where the Canon of Scripture was declared.

Sooo, please show me WHERE any of us have made the claim that the Protoevangelium was equal to Scripture or that it is seen as ANYTHING other than a historical reference.

I’ll wait right here for your findings.
Happy hunting . . .
 
Last edited:

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
You guys do get that you base all this weird Mary exaltation stuff on the protoevangelium of James, which is a forgery, which contains numerous inconsistencies with, and outright contradictions of, Scripture, which was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405 AD, and was such a train wreck that when they were considering which books to include in the New Testament canon, it was so bad that it didn't even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned. The protoevangelium didn't even get to that point it's so bad.
I don't see such wordings:
considering which books to include in the New Testament canon, it was so bad that it didn't even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned.
was included in Pope Innocent's letter to decretal answering seven pastoral and doctrinal questions posed by Exsuperius, the Bishop of Toulouse.
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Uhhh, NOT exactly . . .

Yes, exactly.

In fact, the scholarly objections to this document are that James probably didn’t write is – and that it was written pseudonymously. For that matter – the scholarly consensus on the 1st and 2nd Epistles of Peter is that they were ALSO written pseudonymously . . .

Does that make them “forgeries” as well?

Um.... I'm trying to think of a gentle way of explaining this to you. I'll try.

Document 1 - No claim of authorship is made. We don't know who wrote it, and it doesn't say who wrote it.
Document 2 - Claims to have been written by the apostle James. Clearly wasn't written by the apostle James.

What's the difference between these two scenarios? Why is one a forgery and the other not?

Pope Innocent's condemnation of the Protoevangelium wasa about whether or not it was considered SCRIPTURAL.
THAT matter was already settled at the Coouncil of Rome in 383 AD, where the Canon of Scripture was declared.

The words of Innocent:

"Likewise of the New Testament: the books of the Gospels four, the epistles of the apostle Paul fourteen, the epistles of John three, the epistles of Peter two, the epistle of Jude, the epistle of James, the Acts of the Apostles, the Apocalypse of John. But the rest, which are either under the name of Matthias or of James the Less, or under the name of Peter and John, which were written by a certain Leucius, [or under the name of Andrew, which were written by the philosophers Nexocharis and Leonidas], or under the name of Thomas, and if there are any others, you shall know are not only to be repudiated, but also to be condemned."

Repudiated.
Condemned.

These aren't the words we apply to books that are "Hey this is really good stuff, but just not quite on par with Scripture." These are words that we apply to books that are "uh....these aren't good."

Sooo, please show me WHERE any of us have made the claim that the Protoevangelium was equal to Scripture or that it is seen as ANYTHING other than a historical reference.

I never said any of you "claimed that the protoevangelium was equal to scripture." What I've said is that the entire Marian legend that currently resides in the Catholic Church originated with the protoevangelium of James, which is a pile of crap document.

I’ll wait right here for your findings.
Happy hunting . . .
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Here, I see you are using Pope Innocent's condemnation on Protoevangelium as infallible teaching against our arguments.

No, that's not what I'm doing.

I'm pointing out that it's a pile of crap document. It's a known forgery. It's got a ton of simply made-up stuff in it. It's got numerous inconsistencies with, and abject contradictions of, Scripture. It never was even remotely considered to be canonical - so a level below even the "spurious" books, so low on the totem pole that it doesn't even get mentioned for consideration. It was so bad that EVEN Pope Innocent condemned it. I never would claim that Innocent - or any other pope - makes infallible statements. But when a pope abjectly repudiates the document that is the source of the Marian legend, you know it's got REAL problems.

While Pope Piux IX spoke on stronger teaching, the ex cathedra pronouncement: the Ineffabilis Deus on Immaculate Conception of Mary, you just reject it.

Of course. Because it's total nonsense, based on a pile of crap document. You guys should be ashamed to even kinda sorta believe that stuff.

Is that an inconsistency fallacy?

Not even close. I'm sure you thought you were being clever though.

Narrator: you weren't.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I don't see such wordings:

was included in Pope Innocent's letter to decretal answering seven pastoral and doctrinal questions posed by Exsuperius, the Bishop of Toulouse.

I'm sure you wouldn't see it in Innocent's letter. He does mention the Protoevangelium (by a different name).

Innocent's words: "Likewise of the New Testament: the books of the Gospels four, the epistles of the apostle Paul fourteen, the epistles of John three, the epistles of Peter two, the epistle of Jude, the epistle of James, the Acts of the Apostles, the Apocalypse of John. But the rest, which are either under the name of Matthias or of James the Less, or under the name of Peter and John, which were written by a certain Leucius, [or under the name of Andrew, which were written by the philosophers Nexocharis and Leonidas], or under the name of Thomas, and if there are any others, you shall know are not only to be repudiated, but also to be condemned."


Where you don't see it listed is by people like Eusebius, who, when giving the books considered for the canon, lists various works on three different levels: "recognized" (i.e., made the team), "disputed" (i.e., under consideration), and "spurious" (i.e., got cut from tryouts). The protoevangelium isn't listed at all, which means that it was so bad it didn't even make it to tryouts.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
I'm sure you wouldn't see it in Innocent's letter. He does mention the Protoevangelium (by a different name).

Innocent's words: "Likewise of the New Testament: the books of the Gospels four, the epistles of the apostle Paul fourteen, the epistles of John three, the epistles of Peter two, the epistle of Jude, the epistle of James, the Acts of the Apostles, the Apocalypse of John. But the rest, which are either under the name of Matthias or of James the Less, or under the name of Peter and John, which were written by a certain Leucius, [or under the name of Andrew, which were written by the philosophers Nexocharis and Leonidas], or under the name of Thomas, and if there are any others, you shall know are not only to be repudiated, but also to be condemned."

Where you don't see it listed is by people like Eusebius, who, when giving the books considered for the canon, lists various works on three different levels: "recognized" (i.e., made the team), "disputed" (i.e., under consideration), and "spurious" (i.e., got cut from tryouts). The protoevangelium isn't listed at all, which means that it was so bad it didn't even make it to tryouts.

So you finally quote the exact words used by Pope Innocent.
You should not have added extra sauce on Pope's words.
 
Last edited:

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
No, that's not what I'm doing.

I'm pointing out that it's a pile of crap document. It's a known forgery. It's got a ton of simply made-up stuff in it. It's got numerous inconsistencies with, and abject contradictions of, Scripture. It never was even remotely considered to be canonical - so a level below even the "spurious" books, so low on the totem pole that it doesn't even get mentioned for consideration. It was so bad that EVEN Pope Innocent condemned it. I never would claim that Innocent - or any other pope - makes infallible statements. But when a pope abjectly repudiates the document that is the source of the Marian legend, you know it's got REAL problems.



Of course. Because it's total nonsense, based on a pile of crap document. You guys should be ashamed to even kinda sorta believe that stuff.



Not even close. I'm sure you thought you were being clever though.

Narrator: you weren't.
You totally missed my point of argument.
I am telling you not to misuse 'the authority of the Pope' as a source of support to your argument.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
So you finally quote the exact words used by Pope Innocent.
You should not have added extra sauce on Pope's words.

I added nothing. His words were that the protoevangelium was to be "repudiated" and "condemned".

That means that the protoevangelium sucks, if you'll pardon my vernacular.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You totally missed my point of argument.
I am telling you not to misuse 'the authority of the Pope' as a source of support to your argument.

I'm not. Like, at all.

My point is that the protoevangelium is SO BAD that EVEN the pope in 405 said it was to be repudiated and condemned.

I'm not misusing anything. I'm certainly allowed to quote him and reference him. It would be me misusing him if I claimed his words were infallible. But I certainly don't believe that nonsense. But it is saying something that EVEN a pope utterly rejected it.

It's kinda like when you guys say that even Luther accepted the immaculate conception!
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
I added nothing. His words were that the protoevangelium was to be "repudiated" and "condemned".

That means that the protoevangelium sucks, if you'll pardon my vernacular.
so would you retract your phases:' even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned.' in the previous post #616? You put it as if spoken by Pope Innocent.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
so would you retract your phases:' even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned.' in the previous post #616? You put it as if spoken by Pope Innocent.

By the time Pope Innocent spoke, the canon was already decided. Eusebius and others completely left it off their list entirely when the canon was being put together. For some reason these awful books just kept popping up in people's minds, and I guess Innocent had to be like, guys, cut the crap - this book sucks.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
I added nothing. His words were that the protoevangelium was to be "repudiated" and "condemned".

That means that the protoevangelium sucks, if you'll pardon my vernacular.
at least, you have added your own sauce here: ' the protoevangelium sucks'. You quotes Innocent's words repudiated and condemned and translates them in your own words as "the protoevangelium sucks."
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
By the time Pope Innocent spoke, the canon was already decided. Eusebius and others completely left it off their list entirely when the canon was being put together. For some reason these awful books just kept popping up in people's minds, and I guess Innocent had to be like, guys, cut the crap - this book sucks.
Why a bihop wrote to Pope to reconsider a few books to be in the Canon?
Most probably they were widely circulated and read among Christians in that era. That's how traditions were developed.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
at least, you have added your own sauce here: ' the protoevangelium sucks'. You quotes Innocent's words repudiated and condemned and translates them in your own words as "the protoevangelium sucks."

Yeah, because that's what he was saying, albeit in a much more mature and gentlemanly way than I put it.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Why a bihop wrote to Pope to reconsider a few books to be in the Canon?
Most probably they were widely circulated and read among Christians in that era. That's how traditions were developed.

So yeah, now you know that the Marian legend was borne out of a book that was never seriously considered for the canon, that was an objective forgery, that made up a crap-ton of stuff, that in many places outright contradicts Scripture, and that Innocent condemned and repudiated.

AND YET its nonsense just clung to the Church, and they developed an entire Marian legend and theology out of it.

Guys, this HAS to make you at least think twice about the entire Marian legend. It HAS to.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
By the time Pope Innocent spoke, the canon was already decided. Eusebius and others completely left it off their list entirely when the canon was being put together. For some reason these awful books just kept popping up in people's minds, and I guess Innocent had to be like, guys, cut the crap - this book sucks.
Even though Pope Innocent 405AD rejected the Protoevangelium of James, the church did allow paintings and frescoes on Annunication of Mary in church in the Medieval time to use the Protoevangelium of James legend as background story: Mary as the weaving lady.
the-fresco-of-annunciation-by-gabriel-the-archangel-to-virgin-mary-in-the-salesian-church-santa-maria-delle-grazie-holy-mary-of-the-grace-RFJ156.jpg


So what @BreadOfLife said in #623 was right. Pope Innocent rejected the book mainly on its author problem, not its contents.
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Even though Pope Innocent 405AD rejected the Protoevangelium of James, the church did allowed paintings and frescoes in church in the Medieval time to use the Protoevangelium of James legend as background story: Mary as the weaving lady.
the-fresco-of-annunciation-by-gabriel-the-archangel-to-virgin-mary-in-the-salesian-church-santa-maria-delle-grazie-holy-mary-of-the-grace-RFJ156.jpg

For sure. Of course, the medieval Catholic Church also sold indulgences (as the coin in the coffer rings, a soul from purgatory springs) to get money to build St. Peter's and other cathedrals.

Even though the idea of Mary crushing the serpent's head is based on a known mistranslation of Genesis 3:15 (even Catholic Answers acknowledges this), they still allow for statues of Mary crushing the serpent's head.

This is why tradition is so dangerous - once it springs up and takes root, it's nearly impossible to stamp out. This is why the Bereans were so careful to even measure Paul's words against Scripture, not against their traditions. It's why we should do the same.

Traditions can be good and right. Or they can be bad and wrong. The only way to know is to measure it against the one for-sure infallible standard, which is the Word of God.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
For sure. Of course, the medieval Catholic Church also sold indulgences (as the coin in the coffer rings, a soul from purgatory springs) to get money to build St. Peter's and other cathedrals.
wow.....you are moving goalpoles.
Are we done on this issue?