Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
The key is did GOD really say . Not kenneth copeland . Nor that nar group etc . Thems i refuse to follow .Yes!! Tares are here planting seeds of doubt= did God really say??
God is man's judge not other little men!! Why ask for early judgment??? Those that attack God's family are asking for BIG trouble!!
"For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments." - 1 Jhn 5:3Jesus left us with Two Commandments—- #1 Believe. #2 Love. 1John 3:23
"For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments." - 1 Jhn 5:3
God's definition of love is keeping His commandments, not a human emotion the world calls love. Believing in Christ includes believing what He said. Contrary to what lawless people believe, belief in Christ doesn't just stop at believing He exists. I noticed that you used 1 Jhn 3 to support what is an asinine theology and that you deliberately skipped over how the Bible defines sin in the same chapter:
"Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law." - 1 Jhn 3:4
As the passage clearly teaches, sin is violating God's commandments, not your personal opinions/beliefs. If sin is violating God's commandments, then the clear implication exists that Christians are supposed to keep them. After all, a Christian is biblically defined as someone who follows the example Christ set, and He kept those commandments when He walked this earth.
Furthermore, Christ taught what a person has to do in order to inherit eternal life:
"Now behold, one came and said to Him, “Good Teacher, what good thing shall I do that I may have eternal life?” So He said to him, “Why do you call Me good? No one is good but One, that is, God. But if you want to enter into life, keep the commandments.” He said to Him, “Which ones?” Jesus said, “‘You shall not murder,’ ‘You shall not commit adultery,’ ‘You shall not steal,’ ‘You shall not bear false witness,’ ‘Honor your father and your mother,’ and, ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ ” - Matt. 19:16-19
Again, the passage is 100% clear and doesn't need anyone's personal interpretations. Christ plainly told the young man that anyone who had to keep the 10 commandments if they wanted to receive eternal life and not just believe He exists. Now compare that to what the Bible has to say about the people who refuse to live by God's commandments:
"Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor sodomites, nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners will inherit the kingdom of God." - 1 Cor. 6:9-10
"Now the works of the flesh are evident, which are: adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lewdness, idolatry, sorcery, hatred, contentions, jealousies, outbursts of wrath, selfish ambitions, dissensions, heresies, envy, murders, drunkenness, revelries, and the like; of which I tell you beforehand, just as I also told you in time past, that those who practice such things will not inherit the kingdom of God." - Gal. 5:19-21
“But the cowardly, unbelieving, abominable, murderers, sexually immoral, sorcerers, idolaters, and all liars shall have their part in the lake which burns with fire and brimstone, which is the second death.” - Rev. 21:8
You can present lawless theology as pretty as you want under a pretext of grace and love, but the truth is evident for any true follower of Christ to see that the "Christians" who refuse to keep God's commandments are the kind of religious deceivers the apostles warned against. The Bible doesn't lie, and it says anyone who subscribes to or even preach this theology is a liar.
Ferris..... I know we have had our disagreements, but I never thought you were so far gone that you would give a thumbs up to this poor guy’s Confused “ doctrine”......He May be well- meaning , but he is Clueless when it comes to understanding Salvation....
@Ferris Bueller
It’s confusing to you because you have been lead away from the plain, unadulterated, teachings of the holy scriptures my friend.
I didn't see anything contrary in his post. I understand that the grace denier is the one who does not live in a lifestyle of obedience to God. They are the ones who have denied the gospel of grace, not the ones who live in obedience to God. That's not a confused doctrine. Progressive Christianity has blinded the eyes of so many people today so that they think living in obedience to God is denying grace while living in disobedience is embracing and receiving the gospel of grace. Obedience is automatically considered self righteousness by the church now.Ferris..... I know we have had our disagreements, but I never thought you were so far gone that you would give a thumbs up to this poor guy’s Confused “ doctrine”......He May be well- meaning , but he is Clueless when it comes to understanding Salvation....
And anyone who denies the requirement to ask God to forgive our sins as part of being regenerated, is a false teacher.Tares exist throughout the church, throughout discussion groups and throughout Forum sites like “ Christianity Board”.....They are inevitable and as Jesus makes clear in Matt 13:24 , He has no intention of rooting them out until the Final Days.....they are such effective “ phony” Christians, it will take Angels to identify and sort them out .....it’s extremely difficult for men to do it....but try we must! We have to live with them for now, but we can avoid them and their attempts to “ shipwreck” our Faith If we can identify them.....it takes genuine Spiritual Maturity to do it.....Tares are EXPERTS at Faking it.....
Tares are essentially Religious Phonies.....They think they can be Saved by “ Aping” the Behavior Of a True Christian instead of possessing the New Heart That actually made that True Christian what he truly is now that he has been truly Saved by becoming a “ New Creation” with New Desires and New “ wants”......The Tare is all about “CHANGING” the outside of the cup—— things that HE can do , as opposed to letting God “ TRANSFORM” the inside of the cup—- something ONLY God can do.....they lack the Trust...they lack the Faith to “ let go and let God.” The so- called “ Christians” who are always going around pointing their self-Righteous fingers at others and always have that Judgmental Scowl on their faces? Those are usually your Tares....
A good example of a couple Of Tares would be Ananias and Sapphira.....they were religious fakes .....acting like they were generous like the genuine Believers .....in the end all they were doing was trying to impress others by being Deceptive about the money they had raised by selling their land....they claimed to give it all away like the others , but they secretly held back some of it and lied about it.....Tare Behavior....
Tares can pretend to be “ Righteous” , but a True Believer can always pick up on a certain unease, a certain clumsiness......the Tare always has an Air Of Superiority...their Hearts remain unchanged, their “ superiority” stems from a heart that is 100% legalistic in regard to everything it encounters.....they have no real “ soft spot” for others.....
Tares are not Believers.....all they can do is exist alongside True Believers and hide their true selves , giving lip- service to the Blood as they hypocritically sing songs like “ Nothing But The Blood Of Jesus” and pretending that they understand Grace, etc......anything to get along and fit in. Eventually however, their True Colors will show......they will hide behind their masks, but as True Believers , all we have to do is to look long enough and we will be able to see that “ Stinking Air Of Superiority” underneath the mask.....
The Tares are Legalists.....completely ignorant of Grace because God has not extended it to them because they see no need for it and never ask for it.....their works will get them by— they think....the Tare only wants to see outward changes in people ......he does not understand the Gospel Of Grace .....he doesn’t really care about getting people Saved.....he wants Power.....another Notch on his belt.....yes, it’s all about Power—- not Souls....
The Tare never presents an air of humility in regard to Personal Sins— they simply deny them .....they brag about their ability to live Sinless lives,and THAT, my friend, is the True Defining Trait Of The Full- Fledged Tare......that is when they truly come out of their “ hiding” and show their True selves and start attacking others .....they are now full- fledged “ Accusers Of The Brethren”.....We May be stuck with them until the Angels come and get them and drag them to Hell but at least as we identify them , we can now avoid them.....
Tares are not Believers.Understand that.They are Lost.They lack being “ Born Again” .....their hearts have never truly been made Contrite by the Conviction Of Sin That only the Holy Spirit can provide.....
It is a Contriteness that results from truly seeing their wretchedness before a Holy God.....seeing that without the Grace of God , They would be headed for a well- deserved Hell like a speeding bullet! The unregenerate man MUST come to God , TURN TO GOD ( True Salvation Repentance That Saves! ) as a Lost, Hopeless Sinner That MUST have a Savior to clean him up and make him “ Fit For Heaven” ......God will NOT Save those Trying to Earn Heaven......He will Save ALL that are simply TRUSTING to get to Heaven.....May God bless us all in the understanding of these things....
Again, the passage is 100% clear and doesn't need anyone's personal interpretations. Christ plainly told the young man that anyone who had to keep the 10 commandments if they wanted to receive eternal life and not just believe He exists. Now compare that to what the Bible has to say about the people who refuse to live by God's commandments:
First of all , nobody is claiming one gets Saved because the believe that Jesus existed— how absolutely ludicrous ! Believing Jesus died for your sins and rose from the grave is Paul’s Gospel from 1Cor 15:1-4 and this Gospel Of Grace Plus Nothing is what Saves a soul from Hell.....Absolutely NO mention of “ keeping the Commandments”...... those Commandments are “ weak and useless” according to Paul ,unless you know how to USE them! You don’t know how to use them properly because you lack understanding of the Bible....let me help you .....The 613 Commandments Of God ( not just ten) were given to show that you can not keep them.....they are to show you that you are a Sinner who MUST have a Savior.....That “Savior” being Jesus Christ.....
The Rich , Young Ruler was a Fool.....he actually thought he had kept all of the Commandments .....he was guilty of the Sin Of “ Self-Righteousness” .....He, like all of us can’t even keep the first and most important Commandment——- NOBODY “Ever” Loved God with ALL of their heart , with ALL of their soul, and with ALL of their mind.....not this deluded Young Ruler, not me , and not YOU! Jesus was trying to take the “ Air” out Of this Fools “ self- Righteous Balloon”....... of course, Jesus did this magnificently......The guy went away totally dejected.....it may have been the best thing that ever happened to him——- * IF* it lead him to later see his need for Grace , admitting to himself and God that he was just another Hell- Bound Sinner That needed a Savior.....The Law had not served its true purpose in this guy’s life the day he encountered Jesus.....It appears you and he have a lot in common.....you need Grace and tons of it....why do you reject the only thing that has Saved anybody that ever “ was” Saved ? You need to change your thinking.....that is what the word “ Repent” means.....I hope you repent while there is still time.....you are a victim of some very bad teaching....
You may not get very far with your version of "Grace" because you are neglecting the need to deal with being *lawful* in Christianity. There are many, many, many verses dealing with the Christian's need to be *righteous!*
So although I agree that Christ alone did the work of redemption I cannot agree that there is no need to be righteous. There is a difference between being righteous to do the work of redemption and being righteous out of obedience to Christ.
One thing I'm sure we both agree on--we are not called upon, as Christians, to observe the Law of Moses. For one thing, only Jews were given this Law--only Israel was given this Law. But secondly, the Law was broken as a covenant. The Jewish People failed, as a a nation, to even keep the Law. They broke the Law before the Babylonian Captivity. And they broke the Law again when they rejected Christ.
So the covenant of the Law of Moses is death. As you indicated, it is "nailed to the cross," together with its condemnation of Man universally. The Law of Moses merely applied the sentence, in graphic detail, of the Garden of Eden story to Israel, so that they would fully understand that salvation comes by mercy apart from the Law.
When Christians here post what Jesus said about keeping the Law of Moses they forget that Jesus, in his earthly ministry, was speaking primarily to Israel and in a period when they were still under the Law. Now that the covenant of Law has been broken, we are under a new Law, having been redeemed by the atonement of Christ. We are freed from the Law of condemnation, such as was under the Law of Moses, and now are under a Law of Liberty, in which we need no longer fear condemnation, but can be righteous and obey God without fear of damnation.
Our best “ Righteousness” is “ filthy rags” in the eyes of God......The Righteousness that counts is the one IMPUTED to you when you become a Believer.....
Once God has made us “ New Creations” with “ New Hearts” our new Love for God will make us “ want” to be Obedient .....get God's Spirit in you by Resting in the Gospel .....That will spur a love for God within you.....Love for God is the Engine that drives Obedience.....Rest in the Gospel, The Finished Work Of The Cross as God ordered us to in Hebrews 3 and 4 and everything else will follow......
The problem we have with Progressive Christianity is you correctly say that new creations have new hearts and want to be obedient, but then you turn right around and say 'Christians' who don't want to be obedient and who live in their old lives on purpose as a matter of lifestyle are new creations too. That's a contradiction.Once God has made us “ New Creations” with “ New Hearts” our new Love for God will make us “ want” to be Obedient .....get God's Spirit in you by Resting in the Gospel .....That will spur a love for God within you.....Love for God is the Engine that drives Obedience.....Rest in the Gospel, The Finished Work Of The Cross as God ordered us to in Hebrews 3 and 4 and everything else will follow......
I have absolutely no problem with the idea that Christ in us makes us *want* to do righteousness! As I've been saying, all true virtue comes from God.
But I think you misrepresent the passage that speaks of "righteousness being filthy rags." It is *not* saying that nobody can be righteous. This would directly contradict all of the biblical passages that speak of the saints being righteous.
What I believe this passage is really saying is that the autonomous man cannot use a facade of righteousness to cover up inward rebellion against God. Routine offerings at the temple don't impress God if inside the worshiper is a wolf. Perfunctory rituals do not impress God if on the side these same people are coveting other people's property, and even taking them.
This is what "righteousness" refers to--a hollow form of righteousness--not the real thing. It is *all* forms of righteousness that are external that God rejects--not genuine righteousness!
When the Bible says "no one is righteous," it is talking only about those who try to use the appearance of righteousness to cover up their sin. Nobody who does this is any better than someone clothed in filthy rags, because these are not real works of righteousness, but rather, a facade.
This is an admission that all men, who rely on their own works, cannot impress God. Their works must be inspired by divine virtue, as you say. But it is not saying people cannot be righteous at all. All men have access to divine virtue, because that's how God made them. But nobody is righteous apart from Him. And sin has separated all men from God, which is the point Paul is trying to make.
All men must return to God for both righteousness and redemption. Otherwise, they remain filthy.
The problem we have with Progressive Christianity is you correctly say that new creations have new hearts and want to be obedient, but then you turn right around and say 'Christians' who don't want to be obedient and who live in their old lives on purpose as a matter of lifestyle are new creations too. That's a contradiction.
You know when it's right to say that Christians want to do this and be that, but then you turn right around and say Christians can not want to do this and not be this. That's a contradiction. The Bible in no way defends this, for John says the person who lives in his old life is a child of the devil and is not saved.
"Anyone born of God refuses to practice sin, because God’s seed abides in him; he cannot go on sinning, because he has been born of God. By this the children of God are distinguished from the children of the devil: Anyone who does not practice righteousness is not of God... 1 John 3:9-10
Progressive Christianity has been teaching the church to ignore this in the Bible and says that 'Christians' who go on sinning and do not practice righteousness are born of God and are not children of the devil. Progressive Christianity has ruined the church by throwing the doors of the church open to millions of people who are deceived into thinking they can be saved and live in sin. They only deceive themselves. The Bible is clear that you can not be a saved person and live in sin. Progressive Christianity says you can.