"The word was a god"?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Instead of trying to redo the Bible, why not accept what is there?

God is bigger than your reasoning and cunning rewriting of scripture
I'm a little puzzled by your response.

I explicitly acknowledged that John 1:3 says all things came into being through the Logos, that Hebrews 1:8 addresses the Son as God, and that Hebrews 1:10–12 applies language from Psalm 102 concerning the Creator to the Son.

I haven't attempted to dismiss or diminish any of those passages. Quite the opposite. I've acknowledged the strength of the argument they present for your understanding.

What I've asked is how we should interpret them in light of their contexts and the other passages that speak about the Father and Son.

For example, Hebrews 1:8 addresses the Son as God, while verse 9 immediately says, "Therefore God, your God, has anointed you."

Both statements are Scripture. Both deserve consideration.

Likewise, John 1:3 says all things came into being through the Word, but John 1:14 tells us that the Word became flesh. My question concerns how John understands the Word before that event.

I am not trying to cast Scripture down. I am trying to understand how these passages fit together.

Simply repeating that something is clearly written doesn't resolve a disagreement about what those words mean.

If you believe my interpretation is mistaken, I would welcome an explanation of where my reading fails and why yours better accounts for the entire passage.

I am quite willing to reconsider my conclusions when the biblical evidence warrants it.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Creation… is Complete.
What IS, will always exist.
Much of What “Exists”… WILL be IN A different “form”.

That IS the “MAKING”… continually “Changing what is Created / Exists”…

So I do Consider the Two… created and Made / Making as two separate things…Partaking to One created thing.


Gods Hand Formed a man out of the Dust of the Earth…
A creation… the End…? nope
And THEN MADE that created thing… aLIVE.

God created the Heaven… singular
Gen 1:
[1] In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.

And the “Lord”…MADE… the “heaven(S), plural.

It is the beginning introduction… of Layers of Heaven / to Heavens…
Because further study reveals… the purpose for “the layers”…


I don’t spend but a brief time trying to figure out what other languages mean…

I understand English… what limits and expands a word.

I have enough English Scripture to Know…
Heaven, Heavens. above the Heavens, 3rd Heaven, clouds of Heaven. Allowed to be seen (but no human access), allowed to be seen (with human access). Not allowed to be seen and no human Access.

In totality… a division of sorts…4 Heaven (S).
One Heaven Created by God.
Divided into 4 by the Lords MAKING.


Logos… is a Greek term…
Which in Greek most broadly means reason, logic, order, or understanding…

I don’t use that Term… rather simply use… the Word of God…and Whom God Dictated that describes.

Because there IS Nothing “mindfully Logical”
About…
A creator that one can NOT…
see, hear, smell, taste, touch, feel.

God is Life.
Gods Word is Life.
Gods Breath is Life.
Man’s Life IS Blood.

Not merely “next to”
Rather “IN”.
Your Blood Life is not next to you…
Rather “in” you.
You bleed a Lilttle… Blood comes forth…
Yet your blood Life is still “in” you.

Yes…
How? Do you Know?
Why? Do you know?



Examine Why… Why was Jesus Sent?

Gods Word was, is, the same, regardless of when and how and why He appeared.

They ARE ONE God..
Same as your body, your soul, your spirit… called separate things …are you… One man




Reading, paying attention to precise wording.

Created AND made is a beginning clue of distinction.

It does not say…
Created and created
Nor
Made and made.

Glory to God,
Taken
I think I understand the distinction you're making more clearly now.

As I understand you, creation refers to bringing something into existence, while making refers to the subsequent transformation of what has already been created.

I can appreciate that distinction, and I agree that God can transform what He has created.

But I'm not convinced Scripture consistently uses these terms in such separate ways.

Consider Isaiah 43:7:

"Even every one that is called by my name: for I have created him for my glory, I have formed him; yea, I have made him." (KJV)

Here God uses three different expressions—created, formed, and made—to describe His work concerning the same people.

Does that require three separate stages, or are these complementary descriptions of God's creative activity?

Likewise, in Genesis 1:26 God says, "Let us make man in our image," and verse 27 immediately tells us that God created man in His image.

I don't dispute that the Hebrew words bara and asah have differences in meaning. My question is whether those differences establish the absolute distinction you're proposing.

There's another point worth considering concerning heaven and heavens.

You distinguish the singular "heaven" in Genesis 1:1 from the plural "heavens" elsewhere.

But the Hebrew word in Genesis 1:1 is shamayim, a grammatically plural form that can refer to heaven, the heavens, or the sky, depending on context.

The KJV renders it "heaven," while other translations render it "heavens."

So I'm not sure we can establish four separate heavens merely from the English singular and plural forms.

And this brings us back to John 1.

You describe God's Word as being within God rather than existing separately alongside Him.

On that particular point, I think we may have considerable common ground.

God's Word is His own Word, just as His wisdom and His Spirit belong to Him.

But the question remains whether John intended us to understand that Word as a distinct, personally existing individual before it became flesh, or as God's own self-expression and creative purpose finding its fulfillment in Jesus Christ.

I agree with you that Jesus was sent for a purpose. John 17:3 identifies the Father as the only true God and Jesus Christ as the one He sent.

I also agree that God is greater than our understanding.

But precisely because God is greater than our understanding, I think we should be cautious about turning distinctions in words into theological conclusions that the passages themselves do not explicitly establish.

I appreciate your willingness to explain your interpretation. I am simply trying to understand whether it follows from the biblical text itself.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
@Taken
@rebuilder 454
@Jack
@Wrangler
@Dryhn

Have you noticed that Mister P appears to be something other than flesh and blood or Spirit? There is a duo letter acromin for that...but I don't want to use it. I have let that know I am aware and have changed my replies accordingly.
Scott, I understand that the language of Father and Son can communicate divine realities through terms familiar to human beings. In that sense, there is certainly an analogical element.

But I think you're confusing two different questions.

The fact that language is analogical does not mean the relationship it describes is merely an analogy.

Jesus does not simply describe God as His Father. He addresses Him, prays to Him, receives authority from Him, and submits His will to Him.

In John 17:3, Jesus addresses the Father as the only true God and identifies Himself as the one whom the Father sent.

In Luke 22:42, He says, "Not my will, but yours, be done."

And in 1 Corinthians 15:24–28, Paul describes the Son ultimately handing the Kingdom to God the Father and becoming subject to Him so that God may be all in all.

I recognize that you interpret these statements through a different understanding of divine unity.

But simply identifying Father–Son language as analogical does not establish that these interactions are merely manifestations of one individual rather than a genuine relationship.

What I am asking is where Scripture tells us that the relationship it repeatedly describes should be understood in the way you propose.

As for your comments about me personally, I would prefer that we discuss the biblical arguments rather than speculate about the person presenting them.

If my interpretation is mistaken, I welcome correction from Scripture.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wrangler

ScottA

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2011
17,016
7,384
113
www.FinishingTheMystery.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Scott, I understand that the language of Father and Son can communicate divine realities through terms familiar to human beings. In that sense, there is certainly an analogical element.

But I think you're confusing two different questions.

The fact that language is analogical does not mean the relationship it describes is merely an analogy.

Jesus does not simply describe God as His Father. He addresses Him, prays to Him, receives authority from Him, and submits His will to Him.

In John 17:3, Jesus addresses the Father as the only true God and identifies Himself as the one whom the Father sent.

In Luke 22:42, He says, "Not my will, but yours, be done."

And in 1 Corinthians 15:24–28, Paul describes the Son ultimately handing the Kingdom to God the Father and becoming subject to Him so that God may be all in all.

I recognize that you interpret these statements through a different understanding of divine unity.

But simply identifying Father–Son language as analogical does not establish that these interactions are merely manifestations of one individual rather than a genuine relationship.

What I am asking is where Scripture tells us that the relationship it repeatedly describes should be understood in the way you propose.

As for your comments about me personally, I would prefer that we discuss the biblical arguments rather than speculate about the person presenting them.

If my interpretation is mistaken, I welcome correction from Scripture.
Whatever the case, my warning of you is not without cause.

As for you asking "where in Scripture" or being corrected "from Scripture" and where the truth is to be found, you are out of context. "All truth" does not come only by what is written as on parchment, but "all truth" comes by the Spirit. Thus, your question is not unlike that of the atheists who do not know God.

Having established the actual terms of what is true from God, then--the scriptures are not lacking, but simply cannot be argued only by literary means. If that means you have hit a wall, we are done, though we need not be--because you have not only been discussing with me, but with the Holy Spirit. In which case there is no contest regarding the knowledge of what is true, but rather the same terms apply that have always been regarding truth from God. God simply speaks to those who have ears to hear, occasionally directly, but most often through one of His choosing, whether a donkey or a king, or even a pagan king.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Whatever the case, my warning of you is not without cause.

As for you asking "where in Scripture" or being corrected "from Scripture" and where the truth is to be found, you are out of context. "All truth" does not come only by what is written as on parchment, but "all truth" comes by the Spirit. Thus, your question is not unlike that of the atheists who do not know God.

Having established the actual terms of what is true from God, then--the scriptures are not lacking, but simply cannot be argued only by literary means. If that means you have hit a wall, we are done, though we need not be--because you have not only been discussing with me, but with the Holy Spirit. In which case there is no contest regarding the knowledge of what is true, but rather the same terms apply that have always been regarding truth from God. God simply speaks to those who have ears to hear, occasionally directly, but most often through one of His choosing, whether a donkey or a king, or even a pagan king.
Scott, I certainly agree that truth comes from God and that the Holy Spirit guides us into truth.

But I wonder how you reconcile your position with Jesus' own approach to Scripture.

In Luke 10:26, Jesus asks:

"What is written in the Law? How do you read it?"

And in Matthew 22:31, He asks:

"Have you not read what was said to you by God?"

Jesus repeatedly appealed to what was written when addressing questions of faith and doctrine.

Even after His resurrection, Luke 24:27 tells us that He began with Moses and the Prophets and explained what the Scriptures said concerning Himself.

And Jesus prayed to the Father:

"Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth." (John 17:17, ESV)

I don't question that the Holy Spirit guides believers. But John also tells us to test the spirits (1 John 4:1), and Paul instructs believers to examine everything carefully (1 Thessalonians 5:21).

Surely that includes examining our own interpretations.

You say that I have been discussing these matters not merely with you, but with the Holy Spirit.

I respect your conviction, but how are we to distinguish a genuine revelation of the Spirit from someone's sincere but mistaken interpretation if we cannot examine that interpretation against Scripture?

I am not suggesting that all truth is confined to words on a page. I am suggesting that the Spirit who inspired Scripture will not be offended when we examine what Scripture actually says.

And when Jesus Himself asked, "How do you read it?" I think He gave us a particularly good example to follow.

That is all I have been asking you to do with me.
 

The Learner

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2022
4,910
1,521
113
70
Brighton
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Your response contains a number of serious accusations, but very little engagement with the Scriptures I presented.

First, you are mistaken in assuming that my understanding of Scripture comes from the Watchtower. My conclusions are based on my own examination of the biblical text. Disagreeing with the traditional understanding of Jesus does not automatically make someone a Jehovah's Witness, nor does it establish that their interpretation is false.

Second, calling an interpretation "diabolical," "evil," or "heretical" does not demonstrate that it is incorrect. That requires an argument from Scripture.

I have not denied Jesus' identity as the Messiah, the Son of God, or His exalted position. What I am questioning is whether certain passages actually teach what later theological traditions claim they teach.

I raised specific questions about ego eimi in John 8:58, its use elsewhere in John's Gospel, the language of Exodus 3:14, and the messianic context of John 8:56. You have not addressed any of those points.

You also accuse me of denying who the Creator is. That is another subject worthy of careful examination, but it deserves the same attention to context and language rather than simply assuming the conclusion.

Jesus Himself addressed the Father as "the only true God" (John 17:3). Surely we should be able to examine those words without being accused of diminishing Christ.

I am willing to have my understanding challenged by Scripture. In fact, that is precisely why I participate in these discussions. But I would ask that you challenge what I actually believe and the biblical arguments I present, rather than assigning me beliefs, affiliations, and motives I have not expressed.

If my interpretation is wrong, demonstrate it from the text. Personal accusations are no substitute for biblical exegesis.
You sound like an Arian to me.
 

Pierac

Well-Known Member
Nov 15, 2021
1,103
320
83
63
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You sound like an Arian to me.
Me, or the Scripture I quoted?

Jesus said to His Father, "that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent" (John 17:3).

I'm simply asking that we examine what Jesus meant by those words.

Calling me an Arian doesn't answer that question. If you believe my interpretation is mistaken, I'd welcome an explanation from Scripture.
 

The Learner

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2022
4,910
1,521
113
70
Brighton
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Me, or the Scripture I quoted?

Jesus said to His Father, "that they may know You, the only true God, and Jesus Christ whom You have sent" (John 17:3).

I'm simply asking that we examine what Jesus meant by those words.

Calling me an Arian doesn't answer that question. If you believe my interpretation is mistaken, I'd welcome an explanation from Scripture.
both
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
31,161
16,145
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I think I understand the distinction you're making more clearly now.

As I understand you, creation refers to bringing something into existence, while making refers to the subsequent transformation of what has already been created.
Yes.
I can appreciate that distinction, and I agree that God can transform what He has created.

But I'm not convinced Scripture consistently uses these terms in such separate ways.

Consider Isaiah 43:7:

"Even every one that is called by my name: for I have created him for my glory, I have formed him; yea, I have made him." (KJV)

Here God uses three different expressions—created, formed, and made—to describe His work concerning the same people.
Precisely the Point… one thing Created…. The same one thing… made this, made that…ongoing.
Adam “Was” Made GOOD…
Adam’s FREEWILL choices “changed” what was Good…and over a course of time… became again, made Good, by Adam’s Decisions and Gods Response…

God still forms the body’s… but now each comes from a mans seed (pro- creation)…
And … not Believing…
But with the Offer (from God) to BE MADE Good as is established by God and His Acceptance of a mans (FREEWILL)Choice.
Does that require three separate stages, or are these complementary descriptions of God's creative activity?
God has Offered for a man, of a mans seed, to become MADE from Gods SEED…
FREEWILL of man to Accept or Reject Gods Offering.
Likewise, in Genesis 1:26 God says, "Let us make man in our image," and verse 27 immediately tells us that God created man in His image.
Image is a outward Appearence…
Head, trunk, arms, legs, hands, feet…
God has those things as well.

Aside from “image”… there is also “likeness” / beliefs / behaviors…
And that is the primary focus humans have FREEWILL choices to MAKE… and God responds accordingly… to foster and help with the MAKING, by His Power…and our input of desire to Accept.
I don't dispute that the Hebrew words bara and asah have differences in meaning. My question is whether those differences establish the absolute distinction you're proposing.
I do have an express distinction… and trust it is so.
There's another point worth considering concerning heaven and heavens.

You distinguish the singular "heaven" in Genesis 1:1 from the plural "heavens" elsewhere.

But the Hebrew word in Genesis 1:1 is shamayim, a grammatically plural form that can refer to heaven, the heavens, or the sky, depending on context.

The KJV renders it "heaven," while other translations render it "heavens."

So I'm not sure we can establish four separate heavens merely from the English singular and plural forms.
The singular / plural are the hint… to take notice of something different.
The rest is Discovery of Context and what, when, why.

Humans are called A man.
Humans have things they can See…
And we get “glimpses” of a bigger image / place humans eyes can Not Yet See.

Briefly…
Lower heavens (clouds)… we can see, climb mountains, be in clouds, fly in airplanes, see…a glimpse.
Outer heavens, we can see the stars, far off, a glimpse, but not go there.
3rd Heaven as once mentioned in Scripture…
A place Prepared to receive saved, Departed souls / spirits of humans…. Invisible and not possible for living humans to go…

Then about that 4th Heaven… what is That?
That IS “The Heaven ABOVE the heaven(S).

And its purpose?
Gods “Estate”… His alone where no light escapes.
And “scientists” call such “portals” Black holes…and their researches, journals pertaining to that topic from a scientific perspective and non-explaination.


And this brings us back to John 1.

You describe God's Word as being within God rather than existing separately alongside Him.

On that particular point, I think we may have considerable common ground.

God's Word is His own Word, just as His wisdom and His Spirit belong to Him.

But the question remains whether John intended us to understand that Word as a distinct, personally existing individual before it became flesh, or as God's own self-expression and creative purpose finding its fulfillment in Jesus Christ.
Scripture is Knowledge… not understanding of that Knowledge.
Even Satan knows the Scriptures…
Understanding of Gods Word… comes only From the Lord God…
And…Satan’s Dilemma! As well as many “humans”…

I agree with you that Jesus was sent for a purpose. John 17:3 identifies the Father as the only true God and Jesus Christ as the one He sent.

I also agree that God is greater than our understanding.

But precisely because God is greater than our understanding, I think we should be cautious about turning distinctions in words into theological conclusions that the passages themselves do not explicitly establish.
I study what is Gods Shared Knowledge.
For the understanding… the Lord God is my provider… because I ask.

I appreciate your willingness to explain your interpretation. I am simply trying to understand whether it follows from the biblical text itself.
Ok… thanks.

Glory to God,
Taken