Well you made many false implications.
In the church age there is only one people of God- the church- not Israel or some phony mistranslation of Galatians calling the church spiritual Israel.
I don't have a prophecy chart so that is another false assumption you make. I just know what Scripture says without reinterpreting it.
Since Pentecost anyone not trusting in the death and resurrection of Jesus is lost whether Jew or Gentile.
Being Abrahams seed does not make you an Israeli- Abraham also had Ishmeal.
And you mistranslate Romans 9 badly-Paul was speaking of physical Israel as the context of 9-11 speaks of in reference to Israel. He contrast Jew and Gentile.
Phillipians -Paul is speaking of saved Jews and not just any Jew. that is known by keeping the verse in context, when he speaks of the concision. Once again a saved versus lost Jew.
Not one place in scripture does any body clearly say the church is now Israel.
However you have to negate nearly the prophesies of the prophets in the OT when they were made to the nation and people of Israel and somehow reinterpret them to fit the church. It just can't be done.
Now let us look at teh New Covenant as God declared it in Jer. and Hebrews:
Jeremiah 31:31-37
King James Version
Let’s walk through this slowly so even Scofield’s ghost can keep up.
You quoted Jeremiah 31 and Hebrews 8 as if that somehow disproves the Church's participation in the New Covenant — when Hebrews explicitly says the New Covenant already began, and you're reading it like it’s still future.
Let’s clarify:
“In that He saith, A new covenant, He hath made the first old. Now that which decayeth and waxeth old is ready to vanish away.”
— Hebrews 8:13
That's not future tense.
That's not “after the rapture.”
That’s the New Testament writer saying it already began.
So who’s in the New Covenant?
Let’s ask Jesus:
“This cup is the New Covenant in My blood, which is poured out for you.”
— Luke 22:20
Not “poured out for national Israel in the future.”
Not “poured out for Jews only.”
Poured out for His disciples — the foundation of the Church.
Let’s ask Paul:
“He is our peace, who has made both one and has broken down the dividing wall… to create in Himself one new man out of the two… reconciling both to God in one body through the Cross.”
— Ephesians 2:14–16
One new man. One body. One covenant.
Not two peoples. Not two plans.
Not “the Church over here and national Israel over there.”
If only “the house of Israel and Judah” can be in the New Covenant, and you’re saying the Church isn’t that — then guess what?
You’re not in it either.
You just cut yourself out of eternal salvation to protect a prophecy chart —
a chart invented by a drunk, divorced, convicted felon named Cyrus Scofield who literally never preached the Gospel,
but somehow convinced millions that unbelieving Jews have a separate VIP covenant with God…
while the blood of Christ gets shoved to the side “until after the Rapture.”
That's not theology.
That's theological idolatry — bowing to a fake map of the end times instead of to the Man who fulfilled the Law and the Prophets.
You say the Church isn’t Israel?
Then you’re not in the covenant.
The New Covenant is with the house of Israel and Judah — absolutely.
But here’s the kicker:
The Church is that Israel, redefined not by flesh, but by faith.
As Paul wrote:
“A Jew is not one outwardly... but inwardly.
And circumcision is of the heart, by the Spirit, not the letter.”
— Romans 2:28–29
So when someone throws out the Scofield classic:
“Nowhere in Scripture does it say the Church is Israel!”
Just respond with:
Wrong.
It says Israel isn’t even Israel unless they’re in Christ (Romans 9:6).
And it says those in Christ are Abraham’s seed (Galatians 3:29).
That’s not allegory.
That’s Paul.
Scofield didn’t rightly divide the Word.
He ripped it in half, and then slapped man-made borders on God’s eternal plan.
You quoted Jeremiah 31?
Perfect — now read the rest of Scripture that tells you who Israel is in the New Covenant era:
“Not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel.” — Romans 9:6
“If you belong to Christ, you are Abraham’s seed and heirs according to the promise.” — Galatians 3:29
“We are the true circumcision, who worship by the Spirit of God…” — Philippians 3:3
So either Paul was “mistranslating” himself…
Or your theology is bankrupt.
Here's the truth for the lurkers:
Christ is the New Covenant (Isaiah 42:6, Luke 22:20).
He made one Body from Jew and Gentile alike.
And only those in Him are the true Israel of God.
Not national borders.
Not ethnic lineage claims.
Not Talmud-thumping unbelievers still rejecting the Son.
You want to quote Jeremiah 31? Fine. But Hebrews 8 already told you it’s fulfilled — in Christ — and the Church is its recipient. You can either join the covenant through Christ, or cling to the shadow that was made obsolete.
“For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek; the same Lord is Lord of all.” — Romans 10:12
So stop trying to resurrect a national covenant God already fulfilled in His Son.
The old is gone. The new has come.
The Church is Israel — reborn from above, not below.
If you're not in Christ...
You're not in covenant.
And that’s not “replacement theology.”
That’s New Covenant reality.