What happened to the 10 toes in Daniel 2?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

3 Resurrections

Active Member
Jan 20, 2024
973
241
43
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Your claims of who the iron and the clay are not from the text. You are still not responding to Jesus' pronouncement that their house was left desolate. If the kingdom had actually started, Jesus would not have been weeping. If the kingdom had started, all other powers would have gone away.

In summary, the kingdom of God came very near, among them, then withdrew because they did not recognize their visitation.
The manifestation of the kingdom of God to the first-century people in Israel was not "withdrawn" or put on hold simply because most of Christ's own people rejected His rule. We know that John wrote, "He came unto His own, and His own received Him not."

You are not crediting Christ with enough power to maintain His own kingdom in spite of His enemies. Christ's weeping over Jerusalem was not because His kingdom failed to be realized when they rejected it. Jesus was weeping because the vast majority of His own people at that time were going to be cast out of His kingdom for their unbelief. Their second temple was left "desolate" because it had been utterly corrupted by then, and the new spiritual temple made without hands and composed of "living stones" was going to be the spiritual kingdom's New Jerusalem and New Covenant reality that would stand forever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: covenantee

ThomasDGW

New Member
Aug 30, 2026
21
7
3
69
Cochabamba
Faith
Christian
Country
Bolivia, Plurinational State Of
Gender
Male
I do not disagree with post 317, therefore I am not trying to disprove it. What I disagree with is that you want to say that the things of post 317 are the total of the kingdom of God. Daniel 2 says that the kingdom of God will take over the whole world. That has not happened yet. You still have not explained why Jesus wept over Jerusalem in Luke 19.
 

covenantee

Well-Known Member
Feb 22, 2022
8,187
3,637
113
75
Canada
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
What I disagree with is that you want to say that the things of post 317 are the total of the kingdom of God.
Show where I've said that.
You still have not explained why Jesus wept over Jerusalem in Luke 19.
He was grieving the unbelief of those who rejected Him, which was completely understandable.

He was not grieving the belief of those who accepted Him.
 

ThomasDGW

New Member
Aug 30, 2026
21
7
3
69
Cochabamba
Faith
Christian
Country
Bolivia, Plurinational State Of
Gender
Male
Show where I've said that.

He was grieving the unbelief of those who rejected Him, which was completely understandable.

He was not grieving the belief of those who accepted Him.
You said that when you said that the kingdom began at that time. An incomplete kingdom of God is not God's kingdom.

Jesus explained why he was weeping, which included the unbelief of those who rejected Him, but also included the enemies coming to destroy them. Jesus told Nicodemus in John 3 that only born again people would enter the kingdom. A kingdom where enemies enter is not God's kingdom. Neither does God's kingdom have setbacks.
 

covenantee

Well-Known Member
Feb 22, 2022
8,187
3,637
113
75
Canada
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
You said that when you said that the kingdom began at that time. An incomplete kingdom of God is not God's kingdom.

Jesus explained why he was weeping, which included the unbelief of those who rejected Him, but also included the enemies coming to destroy them. Jesus told Nicodemus in John 3 that only born again people would enter the kingdom. A kingdom where enemies enter is not God's kingdom. Neither does God's kingdom have setbacks.
When do you think that the Kingdom of God began?
 

ThomasDGW

New Member
Aug 30, 2026
21
7
3
69
Cochabamba
Faith
Christian
Country
Bolivia, Plurinational State Of
Gender
Male
The kingdom of God already existed before Jesus was born, so that the New Testament speaks of the kingdom coming, seeing the kingdom, or entering the kingdom, but never of the kingdom beginning. I believe that the kingdom of God began with the creation of man, but the exact time is not crucial to me at this time.

Daniel 2 gives a timeline of earthly kingdoms, repeatedly referring to the whole earth. The people of Israel were focused on that: the reign of God over the earth, so that Jesus found it necessary to emphasize that there was a necessary advance of the kingdom of God in the individual and spiritual area before the kingdom of God would reign over the physical earth.

Now, among large groups of Christians, there is a tendency to make the opposite error, which is to focus on the spiritual aspects of the kingdom of God, based on phrases that say that the kingdom does not come visibly, that the kingdom of God is within and among, to the point of denying that the kingdom of God will ever become visible and physical.

Jesus referred to the advance of the kingdom of God in the hearts of men and women as God is gathering subjects to reign over in their hearts. The stone kingdom of Daniel 2 referred to the culmination when all opposition will be crushed and God's kingdom will come to full, physical fruition on the whole earth. The first advance of the kingdom has happened and continues to happen. The second has not yet happened. I will happen when the toes have been identified, have reigned, and have been crushed.
 

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,676
367
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Jesus referred to the advance of the kingdom of God in the hearts of men and women as God is gathering subjects to reign over in their hearts. The stone kingdom of Daniel 2 referred to the culmination when all opposition will be crushed and God's kingdom will come to full, physical fruition on the whole earth. The first advance of the kingdom has happened and continues to happen. The second has not yet happened. I will happen when the toes have been identified, have reigned, and have been crushed.
Reflective narrative:​

The First Strike and the Final Crushing​

Rethinking Daniel 2:34–35​

As Daniel recounts Nebuchadnezzar’s dream in Daniel 2:31–35, many interpreters read verses 34 and 35 as one instantaneous finale: the Stone appears, the statue shatters, and history ends. Yet Daniel’s own wording encourages us to slow down. He narrates a sequence. First comes the strike. Then comes the crushing. In verse 34, the focus narrows to the feet:

“You continued looking until a stone was cut out without hands, and it struck the image on its feet of iron and clay…”​

This is the moment of impact. The Stone is revealed and strikes the statue precisely where iron and clay are mingled. But Daniel does not yet describe the entire image being pulverized, blown away, or reduced to chaff. That language comes only in verse 35:

“Then the iron, the clay, the bronze, the silver, and the gold were crushed together and became like chaff…”​

That word “then” marks movement within the dream. First, the Stone strikes the feet. Then, the entire image—iron, clay, bronze, silver, and gold—is crushed together and swept away. Daniel separates the moment of impact from the final disappearance. Within this two-stage reading, verse 34 corresponds to the first coming of the Messiah, while verse 35 corresponds to the final harvest and judgment.

The First Strike

When the Stone enters history “in the days of those kings,” He does so during the fourth kingdom—Rome. Yet Christ’s arrival does not topple Rome in a visible political instant. Rome continues. Gentile dominion continues. The kingdoms of this world are not immediately removed.

Instead, the Stone strikes the place where iron and clay are mingled. The iron represents Rome’s hard imperial power. The clay represents the covenant people living within that Roman setting. This is the prophetic location of Christ’s first coming: Israel under Rome, covenant people beneath imperial domination, clay embedded within iron.

The first strike therefore produces separation before destruction. Christ comes to His own, and His presence exposes the true condition of the clay. Some within Israel receive Him and become pliable, moldable in the Potter’s hands, shaped by His Spirit, and drawn into His kingdom. Others harden themselves against Him, remaining outwardly religious but inwardly resistant to their own Messiah.

The cross becomes the great line of division. It is not yet the moment when every earthly kingdom disappears. It is the moment when God’s kingdom enters history decisively, calling out those who receive the Messiah and revealing those who refuse Him.

The Final Crushing

Verse 35 belongs to the end. Here, for the first time, the clay is explicitly listed alongside the metals:

“Then the iron, the clay, the bronze, the silver, and the gold were crushed together…”​

This is not merely Rome collapsing. It is the final removal of everything represented by the image. Every kingdom, every glory, every form of human dominion standing apart from God is reduced to chaff and carried away. The imagery is one of winnowing and finality. Nothing remains but the kingdom God establishes.

In other words, the cross is the point of separation; the end is the point of crushing. The Stone strikes first to divide, expose, call out, and establish. He returns later to crush, remove, and fill the earth with the everlasting kingdom of God.

Why the Later Visions Matter

This distinction helps explain why Daniel’s later visions are necessary. If the Stone’s strike in Daniel 2:34 were already the final destruction of the image, then Daniel 7, 8, and 11 would have little historical space left to unfold. Yet those later visions do not treat history as though it ended at the Stone’s first appearance. Instead, they reveal a long and detailed development within the fourth kingdom.

Daniel 7 shows the same four kingdoms again, this time as beasts. The fourth beast is dreadful, devouring, and iron-toothed—Rome again. But Daniel is then shown developments that occur within the continuing fourth-kingdom landscape. Ten horns arise, and later a little horn emerges among them.

These horns do not create a fifth kingdom. They reveal the later phase of the fourth. What was not distinguished in the dream sequence of Daniel 2 becomes more visible in Daniel 7. The ten toes of the image are later developed through the ten horns of the beast. Then, from within that same Roman inheritance, a religious-political power rises that speaks great words, persecutes the saints, and corrupts divine authority.

Such a power presupposes the Messiah’s first coming. It cannot counterfeit what has not yet appeared. It requires a true Gospel to distort, a true Church to imitate, and covenant truth to corrupt. This places the little horn’s activity between the first strike of Daniel 2:34 and the final crushing of Daniel 2:35.

Daniel 8 points in the same direction. The little horn magnifies itself, casts truth down, interferes with what is sacred, and prospers for a season. Its activity functions as a distortion of Christ’s finished work, which only makes sense after the Stone has entered history. Again, the strike has already happened, but the final crushing has not yet come.

Daniel 11 carries the same pattern forward. Medo-Persia and Greece pass quickly, and then the prophecy slows into a long conflict under later prophetic titles. The chapter does not add new kingdoms beyond the four. It develops the long aftermath of the fourth kingdom and its internal transformations after the Messiah has entered the timeline.

The Missing Messiah Problem

This raises an important question: where is the first coming of Christ in Daniel 2 if the Stone appears only at the very end?

If the Stone belongs solely to a final end-time destruction, then the cross—God’s central intervention in history—sits strangely outside the foundational statue vision. The image would move from Babylon to Medo-Persia to Greece to Rome, and then jump directly to the end, leaving the Messiah’s first coming outside the very blueprint that governs the rest of Daniel.

That is difficult to maintain, especially when Daniel 9 places the Messiah’s appearing and being “cut off” at the center of the seventy weeks. The Messiah does not appear outside Daniel’s prophetic timeline. He appears within it.

The two-stage reading resolves this tension. The Messiah appears inside the statue’s timeline, “in the days of those kings,” exactly where the Gospels place Him—within the fourth kingdom, under Rome, among the covenant people represented by the clay.

Why Daniel 2:40–44 Must Be There

This also explains why Daniel’s interpretation in verses 40–44 is essential. Daniel does not treat it as an optional appendix. He explains what the fourth kingdom looks like as it moves from iron legs into iron-and-clay feet: partly strong, partly brittle, mixed but not truly united.

He also says that in the days of those kings, the God of heaven will set up a kingdom that shall never be destroyed. This does not require the immediate disappearance of every earthly kingdom at the first appearance of the Stone. It means God’s kingdom begins within the fourth-kingdom period and will ultimately outlast, overthrow, and replace all human dominion.

If Daniel 2:34 were already the final demolition, there would be little need to describe the internal condition of the fourth kingdom in such detail. Daniel includes these details because the Stone’s first strike begins a kingdom and a separation that continue through history until the final crushing arrives.

Conclusion

The pattern is coherent. Daniel 2:34 marks the Stone’s first appearance and strike. The Messiah enters history during the fourth kingdom, strikes the feet where iron and clay are mingled, separates the clay by response to Him, and establishes God’s kingdom within the Roman world.

Daniel 2:35 describes the final harvest. The entire image—iron, clay, bronze, silver, and gold—is crushed together, reduced to chaff, and blown away until no place remains for it.

The later visions make best sense if this distinction is real. The cross must be inside the statue’s timeline, not outside it. Daniel 2:34 provides that place. It is the moment the Stone appears, not to pulverize everything at once, but to strike the feet, expose the mixture, separate the clay, and begin the kingdom that will one day stand alone when every rival kingdom has been swept away.
 

covenantee

Well-Known Member
Feb 22, 2022
8,187
3,637
113
75
Canada
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
The kingdom of God already existed before Jesus was born, so that the New Testament speaks of the kingdom coming, seeing the kingdom, or entering the kingdom, but never of the kingdom beginning. I believe that the kingdom of God began with the creation of man, but the exact time is not crucial to me at this time.

Daniel 2 gives a timeline of earthly kingdoms, repeatedly referring to the whole earth. The people of Israel were focused on that: the reign of God over the earth, so that Jesus found it necessary to emphasize that there was a necessary advance of the kingdom of God in the individual and spiritual area before the kingdom of God would reign over the physical earth.

Now, among large groups of Christians, there is a tendency to make the opposite error, which is to focus on the spiritual aspects of the kingdom of God, based on phrases that say that the kingdom does not come visibly, that the kingdom of God is within and among, to the point of denying that the kingdom of God will ever become visible and physical.

Jesus referred to the advance of the kingdom of God in the hearts of men and women as God is gathering subjects to reign over in their hearts. The stone kingdom of Daniel 2 referred to the culmination when all opposition will be crushed and God's kingdom will come to full, physical fruition on the whole earth. The first advance of the kingdom has happened and continues to happen. The second has not yet happened. I will happen when the toes have been identified, have reigned, and have been crushed.
I concur.

However, you claim that the Kingdom was rejected.

There are those who believe that the Kingdom which Christ preached was Plan A, a physical political kingdom which He would establish and rule over; but because Plan A was rejected, Plan B, which was the Cross, was substituted.

It's also described as "kingdom postponement".

Are you aware of that?
 
Last edited:

ThomasDGW

New Member
Aug 30, 2026
21
7
3
69
Cochabamba
Faith
Christian
Country
Bolivia, Plurinational State Of
Gender
Male
Yes, I am aware of that suggestion, but it cannot be true because there is no salvation without the cross. The cross was established from the foundation of the world (Rev 3:8) not a plan B response.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CTK and covenantee

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
358
32
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
In Daniel 2, God identified the 4 metal kingdoms in His plan of salvation and restoration for His people and mankind. The four kingdoms are quite easily identified (IMO), as:

1) Gold - Babylon,

2) Silver - Medes- Persia,

3) Bronze - Greece,

4) Iron - Rome

Now, we easily can see that God's 4 kingdoms are all constructer of a different metal type.

But within the 4th iron kingdom of Rome, He places a non-metallic element within the feet of this kingdom - clay. And certainly, we all know that clay and any metal does not combine.

In the beginning of chapter 7, God gives us a new set of symbols for these same 4 kingdoms, but now we notice there has been some significant changes, apart from the different symbol, to the iron kingdom. Now, we see an unidentifiable 4th beast kingdom with 10 horns coming out of it. No more mention of the clay and no more mention of the 10 toes.

So what happend to the 10 toes?
Another view of who the ten toes are and what happened to them. The ten toes are named in Psalm 83. Count them.
Most of them next appear in the battles listed in Isaiah, Jer, Ezek, then Daniel 2,7, not 8, alluded to in Dan 11, then Rev 13, 17.
Dan 7 shows them in verse 7,8 and the 11th appearing among them.
Then in Dan 7.20, 24, three of them are subdued, Dan 11 states who they may be.
Edom, Ammon, Moab. The readon for their reprieve in Dan 11.41 is shown in Deut 2, they occupy Lots land, see Ps 83.8 also.
For the AC to be the king of Assyria, this is the only channel in. As kon in Dan 11.21.
Interesting Dan 8.9 never mentions the 10 toes, only the four wings prior to them, from Dan 7.6.
Where they go?
Because there was 10, then 1 more emerge = 11, then 3 were subdued, and delivered, Dan 11.41.
The initial tally is 7, but becomes 8 on the emerging horn.
That takes us to Rev 13.1-3 with the mention of ten horns and seven heads, due to the subduing, delivering of Dan chapters 7,11.
Rev 17 is a continuation of these verses. The fourth kingdom is not Rome. Why? Because there's no association with Genesis etc, no link whatsoever! It's talking about the battles between the brothers and others against Israel.
Ishmael and Esau, plus Canaanites etc verses Isaac and Jacob - the royal line.
It's why verse 8 says, the beast you once saw, once was, now is not, and yet will come again from the Abyss. See Rev 9.11. It's also why verse 11 says, the beast who once was, and now is not, is an eight king. He belongs to the seven and is going to his destruction.
Hence the 8 of Dan 7.
What finally happens to the remainder of the ten toes. See Rev 17.12. They receive power for one hour. Dan 7.12. Then are destroyed with the Lords coming. Rev 19.17-21 covers that.
Islam are the brothers descendants.
Ottoman Empire is the more likely fourth kingdom- a coalition of Islamic nations/entities, maybe a hamas or hezbollah entity.
The AC prob king of Assyria, he receives the fatal wound, he is the likely last kon in Dan 11.21 plus.
 

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,676
367
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Another view of who the ten toes are and what happened to them. The ten toes are named in Psalm 83. Count them.
Most of them next appear in the battles listed in Isaiah, Jer, Ezek, then Daniel 2,7, not 8, alluded to in Dan 11, then Rev 13, 17.
Dan 7 shows them in verse 7,8 and the 11th appearing among them.
Then in Dan 7.20, 24, three of them are subdued, Dan 11 states who they may be.
Edom, Ammon, Moab. The readon for their reprieve in Dan 11.41 is shown in Deut 2, they occupy Lots land, see Ps 83.8 also.
For the AC to be the king of Assyria, this is the only channel in. As kon in Dan 11.21.
Interesting Dan 8.9 never mentions the 10 toes, only the four wings prior to them, from Dan 7.6.
Where they go?
Because there was 10, then 1 more emerge = 11, then 3 were subdued, and delivered, Dan 11.41.
The initial tally is 7, but becomes 8 on the emerging horn.
That takes us to Rev 13.1-3 with the mention of ten horns and seven heads, due to the subduing, delivering of Dan chapters 7,11.
Rev 17 is a continuation of these verses. The fourth kingdom is not Rome. Why? Because there's no association with Genesis etc, no link whatsoever! It's talking about the battles between the brothers and others against Israel.
Ishmael and Esau, plus Canaanites etc verses Isaac and Jacob - the royal line.
It's why verse 8 says, the beast you once saw, once was, now is not, and yet will come again from the Abyss. See Rev 9.11. It's also why verse 11 says, the beast who once was, and now is not, is an eight king. He belongs to the seven and is going to his destruction.
Hence the 8 of Dan 7.
What finally happens to the remainder of the ten toes. See Rev 17.12. They receive power for one hour. Dan 7.12. Then are destroyed with the Lords coming. Rev 19.17-21 covers that.
Islam are the brothers descendants.
Ottoman Empire is the more likely fourth kingdom- a coalition of Islamic nations/entities, maybe a hamas or hezbollah entity.
The AC prob king of Assyria, he receives the fatal wound, he is the likely last kon in Dan 11.21 plus.
Let me ask you a couple of questions if you do not mind. First, do you agree that the book of Daniel is NOT a history book but one of God's most prophectic books revealing His plan of restoration for His people and His city from Babylon, but on a much larger stage, His plan of restoration and salvation for both Jew and Gentile?

And if you agree that, then the book of Daniel cannot be read and interpreted as we normally read and understand anyone of our history books. Therefore, although He will surely provide His plan of salvation in Daniel, He will still do so through these 4 literal / historical kingdoms. But these kingdoms, their kings, and the conflicts among them are NOT the story but only the structure of the story. So God will weave His prophecies within and through each of the 4 kingdoms and as His people will travel back from Babylon through these same 4 kingdoms. So, these means we must focus on the very different symbols and enigmatic verses in a spiritual manner - because He is not simply repeating the events and actors in our history books but is presenting only those actors and events that are relevant within His plan of salvation.
So, for example, one of the most critical symbols to understand is the clay that sits within the iron feet. Who do they represent? If one were to interpret the clay as another kingdom that arises after Rome, which so many do, they might be missing on what God is trying to reveal to us. And once again, this gets right back to our understanding of what is the purpose for Daniel. It will reveal His people and His city's return back to Jerusalem after the 70 year period so they can restore their Temple, their walls, the city, and all of the levitical practices that they honored before the Babylonian destruction. And the next question we might ask ourselves, is why does God devote an entire book for this "restoration"? Just to see everyone back home? No, because everything that was either destroyed or taken away must be completely restore BEFORE THE COMING OF THEIR MESSIAH. The 70 weeks of years prophecy reveals this - everything that the Jews are physically able to restore will be restored by the end of the 69th week. That will be their God given responsibility. However, there is only ONE piece of furniture they are incapable of restoring - the Ark of the Covenant - the presence of God in His sanctuary. And this is exactly why we come to the most important section of the prophecy - the final 7 years or the last week of the prophecy. Because on the first day of the 70th week Jesus will arrive and be baptized in the Jordan to begin His ministry and He will represent the restoration of the Ark or the presence of God.

So, what does all this have to do with the clay, the 10 toes, etc., as well as all the other symbols we must interpret? Because He as already given us the historical structure of the 4 kingdoms where His prophecies will be inserted. Meaning we must now interpret those unusual symbols in a spiritual manner - how should we interpret this real symbols in accordance with His plan of salvation. The first symbol we find is the clay within the feet of Rome. Who do you might think they represent in the time of pagan Rome?
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
358
32
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male

Let me ask you a couple of questions if you do not mind. First, do you agree that the book of Daniel is NOT a history book but one of God's most prophectic books revealing His plan of restoration for His people and His city from Babylon, but on a much larger stage, His plan of restoration and salvation for both Jew and Gentile?

And if you agree that, then the book of Daniel cannot be read and interpreted as we normally read and understand anyone of our history books. Therefore, although He will surely provide His plan of salvation in Daniel, He will still do so through these 4 literal / historical kingdoms. But these kingdoms, their kings, and the conflicts among them are NOT the story but only the structure of the story. So God will weave His prophecies within and through each of the 4 kingdoms and as His people will travel back from Babylon through these same 4 kingdoms. So, these means we must focus on the very different symbols and enigmatic verses in a spiritual manner - because He is not simply repeating the events and actors in our history books but is presenting only those actors and events that are relevant within His plan of salvation.
So, for example, one of the most critical symbols to understand is the clay that sits within the iron feet. Who do they represent? If one were to interpret the clay as another kingdom that arises after Rome, which so many do, they might be missing on what God is trying to reveal to us. And once again, this gets right back to our understanding of what is the purpose for Daniel. It will reveal His people and His city's return back to Jerusalem after the 70 year period so they can restore their Temple, their walls, the city, and all of the levitical practices that they honored before the Babylonian destruction. And the next question we might ask ourselves, is why does God devote an entire book for this "restoration"? Just to see everyone back home? No, because everything that was either destroyed or taken away must be completely restore BEFORE THE COMING OF THEIR MESSIAH. The 70 weeks of years prophecy reveals this - everything that the Jews are physically able to restore will be restored by the end of the 69th week. That will be their God given responsibility. However, there is only ONE piece of furniture they are incapable of restoring - the Ark of the Covenant - the presence of God in His sanctuary. And this is exactly why we come to the most important section of the prophecy - the final 7 years or the last week of the prophecy. Because on the first day of the 70th week Jesus will arrive and be baptized in the Jordan to begin His ministry and He will represent the restoration of the Ark or the presence of God.

So, what does all this have to do with the clay, the 10 toes, etc., as well as all the other symbols we must interpret? Because He as already given us the historical structure of the 4 kingdoms where His prophecies will be inserted. Meaning we must now interpret those unusual symbols in a spiritual manner - how should we interpret this real symbols in accordance with His plan of salvation. The first symbol we find is the clay within the feet of Rome. Who do you might think they represent in the time of pagan Rome?
I see the book of Daniel as prophetic, not history. Even Dan 8.17,19,26, Dan 10.14, Dan 11.35,36, Dan 12.1,4,9,13 all say the same idea. The vision is for 'the time of the end' and specifically the 'time of wrath'. Rome is never named, it is a supposition, and if the starting point is wrong, any additional point is probably the same.
Isaiah 46.10. I have told you the end from the beginning.
Where is Rome is Genesis? It's the brothers of Isaac and Jacob who are the problem. Ishmael and Esau settled in the nations surrounding Israel, those who attack Israel in every depiction of the last battle, Psalm 83, Ezek 38,39, Zech 12-14, Rev 16.
 

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,676
367
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I see the book of Daniel as prophetic, not history. Even Dan 8.17,19,26, Dan 10.14, Dan 11.35,36, Dan 12.1,4,9,13 all say the same idea. The vision is for 'the time of the end' and specifically the 'time of wrath'. Rome is never named, it is a supposition, and if the starting point is wrong, any additional point is probably the same.
Isaiah 46.10. I have told you the end from the beginning.
Where is Rome is Genesis? It's the brothers of Isaac and Jacob who are the problem. Ishmael and Esau settled in the nations surrounding Israel, those who attack Israel in every depiction of the last battle, Psalm 83, Ezek 38,39, Zech 12-14, Rev 16.
I have absolutely no idea how you see Daniel. I have no idea why you bring in Genesis, Isaac and Jacob or other references you mentioned. Daniel begins with their exile in 606 BC and it ends at His return. However, I would say that almost 90 % of Daniel takes place between 606 BC and the end of the 70 weeks of years prophecy around 33 AD. Yes, we do have the destruction of the temple in 70 AD, and yes we find the little horn that comes after the cross around the 5th century AD, and yes, there is mention of the end times (but no details and no real discussion of the end times), but Daniel is about the coming of the Messiah and His sacrifice on the cross.

If you would like to offer your interpretation of the clay - for starters, and why, that would be great. But I can assure you Daniel is not an end time focus - but much of Daniel must be properly interpreted because without it one cannot interpret Revelation. So much of Daniel is forwarded to Revelation so it can be understand and unpacked. And one could even look at Revelation as the 13th chapter of Daniel...
 

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,676
367
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
@Wish-it

If you do not mind, both chapters 2 and 7 give us 4 kingdoms in the book of Daniel. Do you agree the first is Babylon? Do you agree that Babylon was conquered by Medes-Persia - the second of the 4? And do you agree that the 3rd kingdom was Greece who conquered Persia and was even identified in chapter 8 by Gabriel as Greece?

Now, if you agree these are indeed the first 3 of the 4 kingdoms, who do you contend is the 4th kingdom of iron mentioned in chapter 2? And, who do you think is the 4th kingdom - the beast that cannot be compared to any creature on earth in chapter 8? There certainly is enough information provided to identify the 4th kingdom and the time of its coming to power? There really is no other kingdom that even compared to their strength and willingness to stamp all over any nation that came before them. So, by following the verses in chapters 2 and 7, who is the 4th kingdom? Thanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: covenantee

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
358
32
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
If you do not mind, both chapters 2 and 7 give us 4 kingdoms in the book of Daniel. Do you agree the first is Babylon? Do you agree that Babylon was conquered by Medes-Persia - the second of the 4? And do you agree that the 3rd kingdom was Greece who conquered Persia and was even identified in chapter 8 by Gabriel as Greece?
The first two I agree with except Greece should read as in Hebrew, Javan. Javan and his brothers mostly settled in Turkey.
Some say Javan was part Turkey part Greece. The changing off Javan to Greece appears to have happened in the Septuagint, after the exploits of Alexander. But if we refer to the Dan 8 to Dan 12 passages, the vision was for that time (though that generation of believers thought so) but for a later time, 'the time of the end'.
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
358
32
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
Now, if you agree these are indeed the first 3 of the 4 kingdoms, who do you contend is the 4th kingdom of iron mentioned in chapter 2? And, who do you think is the 4th kingdom - the beast that cannot be compared to any creature on earth in chapter 8? There certainly is enough information provided to identify the 4th kingdom and the time of its coming to power? There really is no other kingdom that even compared to their strength and willingness to stamp all over any nation that came before them. So, by following the verses in chapters 2 and 7, who is the 4th kingdom? Thanks.
I'd suggest the Ottoman empire. Rome certainly appears to fit, but Rome has no link with the book of Genesis or the Torah. Theres a theme throughout scripture. As it began so it will end. The original battles were between the brothers, Isaac and Jacob and Ishmael and Esau.
The are mention in the beginning, in Genesis, through out scripture including Malachi 1.2 and the again in Romans 9.10-13. Watch your TV, even today the battle is continuing. Israel is being attacked, who by? The descendants of Ishmael and Esau, as Rev 17 states, once was, now is not, but will come again.
The problem with Rome, no link to Genesis.
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
358
32
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
I have absolutely no idea how you see Daniel. I have no idea why you bring in Genesis, Isaac and Jacob or other references you mentioned. Daniel begins with their exile in 606 BC and it ends at His return. However, I would say that almost 90 % of Daniel takes place between 606 BC and the end of the 70 weeks of years prophecy around 33 AD. Yes, we do have the destruction of the temple in 70 AD, and yes we find the little horn that comes after the cross around the 5th century AD, and yes, there is mention of the end times (but no details and no real discussion of the end times), but Daniel is about the coming of the Messiah and His sacrifice on the cross.
All Scripture gives us clues as to the meanings. Scripture confirms Scripture, not history, or individuals or groups understanding of history. The whole of Scripture is about the coming of the Messiah and His sacrifice on the cross.
It's the most important aspect, but there's a lot more information for us as well. Escathology is one part of it. As Daniel says in Dan 2.28 but there is a God in heaven who reveals mysteries. And Jer 33.3 similar. We can know more, it the difference between milk and meat. That should be all our desire. To grow.
 

Wish-it

Member
Apr 14, 2025
358
32
28
Wellington
Faith
Christian
Country
New Zealand
Gender
Male
If you would like to offer your interpretation of the clay - for starters, and why, that would be great. But I can assure you Daniel is not an end time focus - but much of Daniel must be properly interpreted because without it one cannot interpret Revelation. So much of Daniel is forwarded to Revelation so it can be understand and unpacked.
For clues to who the clay of Dan 2 is, read these verses Lam 4.2, Isaiah 64.8, Jer Chptrs 18 and 19. Probably the best indicator is Ezek 4.1-3 (niv).
The second indicator is, imo, who the final battles are between, cause surely if the Lords coming is preceded by a last battle then whoever is in that battle are the protagonists and the Victor.
The last battles appear to be depicted in Psalm 83 -(the ten toes), Ezekiel 38,39, Zech 12-14, Rev 16. Who are they a coalition of the nations surrounding Israel, against Israel. Just as we are seeing on TV as we speak. Even the nations listed in Dan 2 are the same nations in power now, previously and in the near future.
Baylon (Iraq) - gone for now, Mede-Persia (Iran) - still on-going, Javan (Turkey) - the rising star, Erdogan has called for an islamic coalition to attack Israel three times since March 2025. (Another reason to consider Javan rather than Greece.)
The clay is Israel, the kon in Dan 11 is the coalition of nations surrounding Israel, the kos is Israel.
My prediction (worthless as it may be, and likely subject to change). We are currently at Dan 11.2 awaiting the fourth king of Persia, who will be richer than all the others, and who will stir up the kingdom of Javan (Turkey) then i expect (maybe incorrectly) we will revert to Dan 8.3+
 
Last edited: