A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Ty RN :)
Sex AFTER the birth of Jesus ? YES
There are NO verses that teach otherwise
Any normal, usual, grammatic reading of Matthew 1::25 tells those who read it, that Mary and Joseph had sex after Jesus' birth.

Just like this example: the children did not go outside until they ate their lunch.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
wow.....bravo!
all of a sudden........the Catholic Popes are infallible! (even to a Protestant)

LOLOLOLOL not so convenient when the successor of Peter, the Pontifex Maximus, condemns the text that you are relying on for your legendary story of Mary, is it?
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If someone says 'I prayed to X,' modern listeners automatically assume X is being treated as God.


The English word 'pray' has undergone a semantic shift over the centuries. In the early 19th century when Pope Pius IX reigned, the linguistic definition of 'to pray' historically meant simply 'to ask, petition, or entreat' (derived from the Latin precari).
For hundreds of years in English, you could 'pray' to anyone—a king, a judge, a neighbor, or God. It meant making a formal or earnest request to a person of authority or a peer.


It happened in a Shakespeare play: 'I pray you, tell me the way'.You angrily accusing them of worshiping a stranger on the street as a deity.

You're leaning entirely on the modern, narrowed English definition of 'pray' while ignoring both historical linguistics and the actual Latin text

So you're seriously arguing that Pope Pius IX didn't mean Catholics should actually pray to Mary?

This is now the second time you've been hoisted by the petard of a Pope.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
By bringing in the tradition told in Protoevangelium of James, Mary and Joseph were not normal , young couple.

Go and read yourself, don't just 'sola on your few scripture'.

I've read it. It's full of utter nonsense, including three out-and-out contradictions of Scripture, and a false claim of authorship - such that Pope Innocent condemned the work.

But THAT's what you want to rely on as your source?

No wonder you guys have such screwed up theology. Yikes.
 

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
618
115
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Any normal, usual, grammatic reading of Matthew 1::25 tells those who read it, that Mary and Joseph had sex after Jesus' birth.

Just like this example: the children did not go outside until they ate their lunch.
A sexless Mary is just another Vatican/Pope delusion to keep the faithful pouring in the money
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
The Bible doesn't tell us in very specific terms WHY Mary asked what she asked. The question we are trying to answer is WHY Mary asked what she asked. I'll sum this up again.

My view: Mary and Joseph were a normal young Jewish couple that was betrothed, but had not yet consummated their marriage by having sex. They, like every other couple that's basically ever existed, planned on having sex when they reached that point. So when Gabriel showed up and told her she would be pregnant, she thought something like, "I've never had sex, and I won't have sex until months from now when we consummate the marriage, so how can I possibly get pregnant under those circumstances?" The idea being that she must have thought Gabriel meant she would be pregnant SOON, before consummating their marriage. It turns out, such an assumption on Mary's part WOULD HAVE BEEN 100% CORRECT (a point you STILL haven't even acknowledged), because that's exactly what did, in fact, happen. Then, according to Matt 1:25, they waited to have sex until after Jesus was born, and then had a fairly normal sex life as a married couple, and produced more children, according to numerous passages in Scripture that refer to Jesus' siblings.

Your view: Mary and Joseph were NOT a normal young Jewish couple. Mary was born to a remarkable woman who consecrated her unto the Lord, such that both her mother and Mary herself vowed that Mary would never have sex. How Joseph felt about that, we are never told (I guess he was okay with marrying someone he not only would never have kids with, but that he would never even have sex with...very, VERY odd for that time - and ANY time in human history actually). So when Gabriel showed up and told her she would be pregnant, she wondered how that would be possible since she'd never had sex - and never WOULD have sex. And Matt 1:25 really means that Joseph never did, and never would, have sex with her. So the references to other siblings of Jesus were either cousins or kids Joseph had from a previous marriage - something never mentioned in Scripture anywhere. (We get this idea from a document that is a mid 2nd century forgery, contradicts Scripture itself in three places, and contains factual and theological errors sufficient that a Pope in 405 condemned the text, but sure, let's trust it!) And Mary, as it turned out, wasn't just consecrated to the Lord by her mother Anne, she actually was perfect, sinless, holy beyond holiness itself, never stained by the "sin" of having sex (or something like that), was really the one who crushed the head of the serpent, was the co-redemptrix, was the mother of heaven, was so holy and glorious that heaven itself hasn't sufficient words to describe her, never ever sinned or was stained by original sin, was perfect in every way, is someone we are called to pray to (says Pope Pius IX in his infallible ex cathedra statement on Mary in 1854), and was assumed bodily into heaven, and rules the universe as the Queen.


Which of these is the best explanation?

You've given what you regard as the most natural overall explanation of Mary and Joseph's lives. Fair enough. But my question has never been which broader narrative you find more natural. My question has been much narrower:

Why would Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

You've repeatedly said that Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph, including ordinary marital relations. You've also acknowledged that Luke does not explicitly tell us why Mary asked the question She did.

So the point under discussion is not whether an explanation is needed, but which explanation best accounts for Mary's response.

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

According to your own position, future conception through Joseph was already an available explanation. Yet you propose that Mary instead inferred a conception that would occur prior to those expected marital relations. You keep pointing out that this inference would later prove to be correct. I don't dispute that. The issue isn't whether Mary's inference, if She made it, would eventually turn out to be right. The issue is what would have led Her to make that inference before Gabriel explained anything further.

At the moment Mary asks:

"How will this occur, since I know not man?"

She has not yet been told about the Holy Spirit, the miraculous manner of conception, Elizabeth's pregnancy, or that the conception will occur before consummation. All She has been told is:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

So what remains unanswered is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words than future conception through the marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You've given what you regard as the most natural overall explanation of Mary and Joseph's lives. Fair enough. But my question has never been which broader narrative you find more natural. My question has been much narrower:

Why would Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

You've repeatedly said that Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph, including ordinary marital relations. You've also acknowledged that Luke does not explicitly tell us why Mary asked the question She did.

So the point under discussion is not whether an explanation is needed, but which explanation best accounts for Mary's response.

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

According to your own position, future conception through Joseph was already an available explanation. Yet you propose that Mary instead inferred a conception that would occur prior to those expected marital relations. You keep pointing out that this inference would later prove to be correct. I don't dispute that. The issue isn't whether Mary's inference, if She made it, would eventually turn out to be right. The issue is what would have led Her to make that inference before Gabriel explained anything further.

At the moment Mary asks:

"How will this occur, since I know not man?"

She has not yet been told about the Holy Spirit, the miraculous manner of conception, Elizabeth's pregnancy, or that the conception will occur before consummation. All She has been told is:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

So what remains unanswered is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words than future conception through the marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph.

I'm not going to go through this again. I've explained it nearly a dozen times now. You asking the question for the thousandth time doesn't change the answer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dryhn

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
I'm not going to go through this again. I've explained it nearly a dozen times now. You asking the question for the thousandth time doesn't change the answer.

I don't think we're talking about the same question.

You've repeatedly answered:

"Why did Mary ask the question?"

by saying that She thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation.

What I've been asking is the prior question:

Why should Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

Those are not the same question.

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

And according to your own position, Mary expected a normal marriage and future marital relations with Joseph. So what remains unanswered is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words than future conception through Joseph.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I don't think we're talking about the same question.

You've repeatedly answered:

"Why did Mary ask the question?"

by saying that She thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation.

What I've been asking is the prior question:

Why should Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

Those are not the same question.

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

And according to your own position, Mary expected a normal marriage and future marital relations with Joseph. So what remains unanswered is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words than future conception through Joseph.

I've already dealt with this numerous times. You just keep coming back to it over and over and over as if I haven't already done this.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
So you're seriously arguing that Pope Pius IX didn't mean Catholics should actually pray to Mary?

This is now the second time you've been hoisted by the petard of a Pope.

Do you have difficulty understanding post #457?
The 'praying' Pope Piux IX referring was not the same kind of 'praying' in your mind.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
I've read it. It's full of utter nonsense, including three out-and-out contradictions of Scripture, and a false claim of authorship - such that Pope Innocent condemned the work.

Condemning the book as a fake gospel does not mean every single detail inside it is historically false. The Church holds that some elements within it reflected already-existing early Christian oral traditions.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Any spiritual thing that draws us closer to God MUST meet biblical standards! If the bible doesn't teach it, it is false doctrine and must be resisted!
Things like Sunday school programs, modern worship bands, projector screens, youth ministries, and structured multi-week Advent calendars or Lent devotionals draw millions closer to God every week, yet none of them are explicitly mandated or outlined in Scripture.

If a spiritual practice draws a soul into deeper love, repentance, and communion with God, setting up an unbiblical rule that says 'It must have a direct chapter-and-verse blueprint or it’s invalid' is just an intoxication by 'sola scriptura'.
 
  • Loveit!
Reactions: Lambano

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
I've already dealt with this numerous times. You just keep coming back to it over and over and over as if I haven't already done this.

I understand that you've repeated your explanation numerous times. My point is that repeating the explanation is not the same thing as answering the specific question I'm asking. You've repeatedly answered: "Why did Mary ask the question?" by saying that She thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation.

What I've been asking is the prior question: Why would Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

And according to your own position, Mary expected a normal marriage and future marital relations with Joseph. So what remains unanswered is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words than future conception through Joseph. Simply restating that Mary thought conception would occur before consummation does not explain why She would draw that conclusion from Gabriel's announcement in the first place.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I understand that you've repeated your explanation numerous times. My point is that repeating the explanation is not the same thing as answering the specific question I'm asking. You've repeatedly answered: "Why did Mary ask the question?" by saying that She thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation.

What I've been asking is the prior question: Why would Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

And according to your own position, Mary expected a normal marriage and future marital relations with Joseph. So what remains unanswered is why a pre-consummation conception should be regarded as the more natural inference from Gabriel's words than future conception through Joseph. Simply restating that Mary thought conception would occur before consummation does not explain why She would draw that conclusion from Gabriel's announcement in the first place.

I've already answered this question of yours, despite you asking it for like the dozenth time. How many times do I need to answer it before you agree that I've answered it? What's the magic number?
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I surely know better than YOU.
See the arguments and evidences I put up on the table!
What do you have?

I have the words from the Pope himself.

Read post #446 again. Pope Pius IX said that:

- it was Mary that crushed the serpent's head

- Mary was free from every stain of sin

- she was never free from holiness

- Mary was "more holy than holiness" itself

- heaven doesn't have the words to do justice to her perfection and holiness

- Catholics were to "venerate, invoke, and PRAY TO" the most blessed virgin.


Do you agree with the pope that Mary was "more holy than holiness" itself? Do you agree with the pope that Mary was the one who crushed the serpent's head?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
I have the words from the Pope himself.

Read post #446 again. Pope Pius IX said that:

- it was Mary that crushed the serpent's head

- Mary was free from every stain of sin

- she was never free from holiness

- Mary was "more holy than holiness" itself

- heaven doesn't have the words to do justice to her perfection and holiness

- Catholics were to "venerate, invoke, and PRAY TO" the most blessed virgin.


Do you agree with the pope that Mary was "more holy than holiness" itself? Do you agree with the pope that Mary was the one who crushed the serpent's head?
You dived into a 19th century teaching and know not the modern ecumenical council of the Church (Vatican II) actually defined in Lumen Gentium (Section 55).

The modern magisterium explicitly places her victory entirely in and through Christ: she is the New Eve who cooperated uniquely with the Redeemer, but Christ alone is the ultimate victor who crushes the head of the serpent.


Like your apps in your phone, they need to be updated!


ETA: I also have explained to forum members why the image of Mary crushing the head of the serpent comes up because of an ancient translation of Genesis 3:15
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,009
5,028
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Things like Sunday school programs, modern worship bands, projector screens, youth ministries, and structured multi-week Advent calendars or Lent devotionals draw millions closer to God every week, yet none of them are explicitly mandated or outlined in Scripture.

If a spiritual practice draws a soul into deeper love, repentance, and communion with God, setting up an unbiblical rule that says 'It must have a direct chapter-and-verse blueprint or it’s invalid' is just an intoxication by 'sola scriptura'.
You can have any program, or music ministry you wish. but what they do, not what they are, must meet biblical standards.

Never are we commanded to pray to saints or angels living or dead. Yet Romanism has whole bokks on prayers to saints, angels et. al. this is unbiblical.

Is it a deeper faith walk, or just an emotional high?

Enormous amount of things done in Jesus name are not things that glorify HIm or the Father!
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Lamb

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
You can have any program, or music ministry you wish. but what they do, not what they are, must meet biblical standards.

Never are we commanded to pray to saints or angels living or dead. Yet Romanism has whole bokks on prayers to saints, angels et. al. this is unbiblical.

Is it a deeper faith walk, or just an emotional high?

Enormous amount of things done in Jesus name are not things that glorify HIm or the Father!

You claim that auxiliary programs and traditions are fine "as long as what they do meets biblical standards," yet you instantly disqualify the communion of saints because there isn't an explicit verse commanding it.

That’s like saying: "Driving a car to church is totally fine even though cars aren’t in the Bible, but using GPS navigation on your way there is a sin because no apostle ever used a satellite map."


May be you tell us specifically what you mean by 'biblical standards'.