BreadOfLife
Well-Known Member
- Jan 2, 2017
- 22,773
- 3,837
- 113
- Faith
- Christian
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Male
Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
You say the devotion shown to Mary by Catholics "fits every definition of an idol," but is that according to God's definition of idolatry or your own?
You point to the fact that Mary is given exalted titles, depicted prominently in churches, prayed to frequently in the Rosary, and honored at shrines throughout the world. But where does Scripture teach that these things, in themselves, constitute idolatry?
Scripture condemns treating a creature as a god and rendering to the creature the worship that belongs to the Creator alone. Paul defines idolatry as "worshiping and serving the creature rather than the Creator" (Romans 1:25). The First Commandment forbids having other gods and bowing down to them as objects of divine worship (Exodus 20:3-5).
So the real question is not whether Mary is greatly honored. The question is whether Catholics believe Mary is God, a goddess, the creator, or worthy of the worship due to God alone. Catholic teaching explicitly rejects all of those propositions.
If your argument is that honoring someone, giving them titles, building shrines, or speaking to them in prayer is automatically idolatry, then you'll need to show where Scripture defines idolatry that way. Otherwise, you're arguing from appearances rather than from the biblical definition itself.
You better do a little more homework on this.Well...uh....go back and read Pope Pius IX's "infallible" dogma "Ineffabilis Deus" from 1854. Mary:
- Is utterly sinless, both free from original sin and free from actual sin
- Mary crushed the head of the serpent "with her immaculate foot"

She has been named the "co-redemptrix", despite the Scriptures saying that there is only One Redeemer, Jesus Christ.
You say the devotion shown to Mary by Catholics "fits every definition of an idol," but is that according to God's definition of idolatry or your own?
You point to the fact that Mary is given exalted titles, depicted prominently in churches, prayed to frequently in the Rosary, and honored at shrines throughout the world. But where does Scripture teach that these things, in themselves, constitute idolatry?
Scripture condemns treating a creature as a god and rendering to the creature the worship that belongs to the Creator alone. Paul defines idolatry as "worshiping and serving the creature rather than the Creator" (Romans 1:25). The First Commandment forbids having other gods and bowing down to them as objects of divine worship (Exodus 20:3-5).
So the real question is not whether Mary is greatly honored. The question is whether Catholics believe Mary is God, a goddess, the creator, or worthy of the worship due to God alone. Catholic teaching explicitly rejects all of those propositions.
If your argument is that honoring someone, giving them titles, building shrines, or speaking to them in prayer is automatically idolatry, then you'll need to show where Scripture defines idolatry that way. Otherwise, you're arguing from appearances rather than from the biblical definition itself.
You better do a little more homework on this.
(1) You overlooked the English translation has a footnote [14]
View attachment 93428
the footnote [14] read as:
Wherein, as Christ, the mediator of God and man, having assumed human nature, blotting out the handwritten decrees that were against us, triumphantly nailed them to the cross, so the most holy Virgin, united with him by a most close and indissoluble bond, together with him and through him, exercising eternal enmity against the poisonous serpent, and triumphing most fully over him, crushed his head with her immaculate foot.
(2) Footnote [14] was not added to Ineffabilis Deus later; it is part of the original 1854 text, though modern English translations often format it as a footnote to supply the original Latin.
Poor Beechy doesn't know which of his Catholic Bibles is correct re Gen 3:15You can say it was with Christ, but even the footnote says that SHE crushed the serpent's head WITH HER immaculate foot. She's still, according to this "infallible" dogma, crushing Satan's foot, making her a co-redemptrix in every sense of the word with Christ.
And that is blasphemy. Utter blasphemy, putting a human in a co-salvific role with Jesus Christ.
If a powerful Don of a crime syndicate wants an opposing rival eliminated, he might order his top hitman to do it. If someone remarks, "The Don took care of his rival through his enforcer," or even if they say, "The enforcer smashed the rival with his own hands," does that mean the enforcer is suddenly co-boss, equal in authority to the Don, or stealing the Don's exclusive prerogative? Of course not. The enforcer acts entirely under the authority, power, and will of the principal.You can say it was with Christ, but even the footnote says that SHE crushed the serpent's head WITH HER immaculate foot. She's still, according to this "infallible" dogma, crushing Satan's foot, making her a co-redemptrix in every sense of the word with Christ.
And that is blasphemy. Utter blasphemy, putting a human in a co-salvific role with Jesus Christ.
If a powerful Don of a crime syndicate wants an opposing rival eliminated, he might order his top hitman to do it. If someone remarks, "The Don took care of his rival through his enforcer," or even if they say, "The enforcer smashed the rival with his own hands," does that mean the enforcer is suddenly co-boss, equal in authority to the Don, or stealing the Don's exclusive prerogative? Of course not. The enforcer acts entirely under the authority, power, and will of the principal.
Just as Scripture describes believers as participating in Christ's victory, such as Romans 16:20 ("The God of peace will soon crush Satan under your feet"), where ordinary Christians are spoken of as crushing Satan—so too Mary.
Not biblical?!There's a huge, huge, huge difference between God crushing Satan under our feet, and Mary crushing Satan under her feet. In Romans 16:20, the one doing the crushing is God. In Pius' words, the one doing the crushing is Mary.
The first one is Biblical - it's literally right there in the Bible. The second one is not in Scripture anywhere, and is blasphemy.
Not biblical?!
Genesis 3:15: I will put enmity between you and the woman,and between your offspring and hers;
Is it not God the boss, the director of the whole thing behind the scene?
Even though your pastor taught you 'sola scriptura', you are not reading the scripture well enough. You are brainwashed and parroting with anti-RCC materials from your pastor.
Take a deep breath, Ivan. Nobody is giving Mary the crown of a divine cage-fighter.For the love of God, please read with comprehension. I beg you.
What I said wasn't Biblical is the idea that it is MARY that crushes the head of the serpent. Good grief man.
How you got what you wrote above from my previous post, I simply will never know. No clue what goes on inside that skull of yours or how you come up with the things you do.
Yes, it is biblical! (Only you failed to understand it in higher theological level)What I said wasn't Biblical is the idea that it is MARY that crushes the head of the serpent. Good grief man.
Taking quotes and claims out of their proper CONTEXT is nothing more than a desperate attempt to change their meaning to suit YOUR views.Well...uh....go back and read Pope Pius IX's "infallible" dogma"Ineffabilis Deus" from 1854. Mary:
As I’ve already pointed out in an earlier post –- Is utterly sinless, both free from original sin and free from actual sin
That’s NOT what Pius IX’s encyclical said – in CONTEXT.- Mary crushed the head of the serpent "with her immaculate foot"
Holiness simply means, “the quality of being holy”. A person is always more than their description by others. The noun means more than the adjective. Holiness is an ADJECTIVE- Is "more holy than holiness"
You’re only “shocked” by this because you have an axe to grind with Mary and the Church.- Is more holy than the cherubim and seraphim
In the Davidic Kingdom, the wife of the King was NOT the Queen – but rather, his mother was elevated to that station. The title Gebirah (Gebira), meaning “Great Lady” or “Queen Mother” was a royal title and an office which was bestowed upon the mothers of the Kings of Israel but ONLY to those in the line of David.- Is the "Queen of heaven and earth"
This appears NOWHERE in Pius IX’s Encyclical . . .- Is one to whom we are commanded to pray
Take a deep breath, Ivan. Nobody is giving Mary the crown of a divine cage-fighter.
If you actually step back and look at the whole picture instead of hunting for things to scream about, God is behind all the crushing of the serpent's head. Mary is simply the vessel through whom the ultimate victor enters the ring. God mapped it out in Genesis 3:15, and Christ delivered the final blow.
So relax. No one's rewriting theology; we're just acknowledging that when God orchestrates a takedown, He uses human history and willing participants to get the job done. Maybe read the text with that much comprehension next time, and you won't need to beg for a rescue.
Yes, it is biblical! (Only you failed to understand it in higher theological level)
Understanding style of Jewish writing: typological parallelism.
In this Jewish and early Christian literary style, a later event mirrors an earlier one, not simply by repeating it, but by reversing its failure and resetting the story.
For example, at the beginning of the Bible, Man was driven out of Garden Eden, at the end of the book , Man was invited to heaven to join the feast. Peter denied Jesus three times, and later Jesus asked Peter 3 times: 'Do you love me?' to do a 'reset'!
Go back to the scene in Genesis 3. Both Adam and Eve sinned. In theology, Jesus is the type of New Adam, and Mary the type of New Eve.
While it was Adam who disobeyed GOD in Genesis 3, it is Jesus, the new Adam fully obeying God.
While it was Eve who was deceived by the snake, it would be the New Eve (Mary) to crush the snake's head.
That completes the parallelism.
This appears NOWHERE in Pius IX’s Encyclical . . .
“LET THEM CONTINUE to venerate, invoke and pray to the most Blessed Virgin Mary" .Me: (Mary) Is one to whom we are commanded to pray
Then you:
Uh, the first line of the last paragraph of the encyclical:
"Let all the children of the Catholic Church, who are so very dear to us, hear these words of ours. With a still more ardent zeal for piety, religion and love, let them continue to venerate, invoke and pray to the most Blessed Virgin Mary".
“LET THEM CONTINUE to venerate, invoke and pray to the most Blessed Virgin Mary" .
This is at the very MOST an allowance – not a “command.”
It doesn't even imply that we MUST pray to her.
If you’re going to quote Catholic documents – at least TRY to be honest about the fact that you’re taking them WAAAAY out of context . . .