You accused me of reading Mary's mind. I'm not doing that. I'm pointing to the sequence of events Luke records:
- Gabriel announces that Mary will conceive.
- Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
- Gabriel answers with divine action by the Holy Spirit.
- Gabriel appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception.
- Gabriel concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."
Those are Luke's words, not my speculations.
Now you've responded by saying that Luke is focused on the virgin birth.
...these say absolutely nothing about Joseph and Mary having marital relations.; Maybe you really are that dense!
This is precisely why I said you've stopped addressing my actual argument.
You quoted only the middle section of my post while omitting the part immediately before it where I explicitly said:
"Exactly. That is precisely my point."
"The challenge I presented was never about what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus' birth. The challenge was about Luke 1:34-37 and the logic of the Annunciation narrative."
Then you responded:
"These say absolutely nothing about Joseph and Mary having marital relations."
But I had already agreed with that.
So you're refuting a claim I expressly denied making.
My argument is not that Luke 1:34-37 tells us what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus' birth.
My argument is that your explanation has not accounted for the logic of Luke's narrative:
Gabriel announces a conception.
Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
Gabriel responds with divine action, appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception, and concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."
The question I've repeatedly asked is simple:
If Mary expected the announced conception to occur through ordinary future marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke present her virginity as the difficulty and Gabriel's answer as a solution involving divine intervention and impossibility?
Instead of answering that question, you've responded to a claim I never made.
Prove otherwise! That is the issue. Yopu are amking the assertions of her perpetual virginity so you have to prove it.
That's another shift away from the question.
I'm not asking you to accept perpetual virginity at this point in the discussion.
I'm asking you to explain your interpretation of Luke 1:34-37.
The text says:
• Gabriel announces that Mary will conceive.
• Mary responds, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
• Gabriel answers by describing divine action by the Holy Spirit.
• Gabriel appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception.
• Gabriel concludes, "For with God nothing will be impossible."
My question is simple:
If Mary's expectation was that she would eventually conceive through ordinary marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke portray her virginity as the reason for her question, and why does Gabriel answer with divine intervention and an appeal to impossibility?
Notice that this question does not require me to prove perpetual virginity.
It requires you to explain your reading of the passage.
You have repeatedly asserted that Mary's question is perfectly normal for a woman expecting ordinary marital relations with Joseph.
Fine.
Explain how that understanding fits Luke's narrative.
Appealing to the burden of proof does not answer the question. The moment you offer an interpretation of a text, you also bear the burden of explaining how the details of that text fit your interpretation.
So once again:
Why does Mary present "I know not man" as the difficulty, and why does Gabriel answer with miraculous conception and "nothing will be impossible with God," if ordinary future marital relations with Joseph were expected to explain the announced conception?
Quite simply: I f MAry was to stay a virgin She would have said " How can this be since I will never know a man"? Also they would have broken the Mosaic law by abstaining from sexual relations as husband and wife, unless there was a command from god! where is that command?
You're still not answering the question.
My question wasn't what Mary would have said if perpetual virginity were false or true.
My question was why, from Gabriel's actual words: "You will conceive and bear a Son," Mary would infer a conception prior to the future marital relations that you say she expected with Joseph.
Gabriel does not say:
"You are about to conceive immediately."
Nor does he say:
"You will conceive before you come together with Joseph."
Yet Mary's response is:
"How will this occur, since I know not man?"
So the question remains: why does She treat Her present virginity as relevant to Gabriel's announcement at all if She expected the conception to occur through ordinary future marital relations?]
Simply saying what you think Mary would have said under different circumstances does not explain the words Luke actually records.