A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,605
2,899
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
St. John Paul II and modern theologians (like Scott Hahn) emphasize that St. Joseph's virginal fatherhood uniquely mirrors the fatherhood of God on earth.
Explaining Jesus' "Brothers." To reconcile the belief that Mary remained a virgin with New Testament mentions of the "brothers and sisters" of Jesus, Origen and Eastern Fathers generally followed the tradition that they were Joseph’s children from a previous marriage.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Explaining Jesus' "Brothers." To reconcile the belief that Mary remained a virgin with New Testament mentions of the "brothers and sisters" of Jesus, Origen and Eastern Fathers generally followed the tradition that they were Joseph’s children from a previous marriage.
This has been well explained by @Moonwood here: #79


go and read for yourself. I don't need 'vain repetitions'!
 

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,605
2,899
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
This has been well explained by @Moonwood here: #79


go and read for yourself. I don't need 'vain repetitions'!
That's one explanation, I offered another.
 

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
714
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
My question is why, from Gabriel's words:

"You will conceive and bear a Son,"

Mary would infer a pre-consummation conception rather than a conception through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph.

HOW she would know this is unclear from the text...

So you are left with either agreeing with me that Mary correctly assumed she would be pregnant soon, or agreeing with me that Mary was a flawed individual who incorrectly assumed that she would be pregnant later. Which one are you choosing?

I think that statement is significant because it identifies the very point under discussion.

My question is not whether a pre-consummation conception ultimately occurred.

My question is what in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to infer that a pre-consummation conception was being announced.

If how Mary would know that is unclear from the text, then what remains unclear is precisely why that should be regarded as the natural inference from Gabriel's words:
"You will conceive and bear a Son."

Especially when you yourself have argued that Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph, including future marital relations.

If future conception through Joseph remained the expectation Mary already had, then I still do not see what would lead Her to infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before those expected marital relations rather than through them.

And this also gets to the dilemma you've presented.

I'm not asking whether Mary's inference, if She made one, ultimately proved correct. Even if, for the sake of argument, I granted that Mary correctly inferred a pre-consummation conception, that still would not explain why She drew that conclusion from Gabriel's words in the first place.

You've said:

"HOW she would know this is unclear from the text."

That is precisely the issue I'm raising.

The question is not whether a pre-consummation conception later occurred. The question is what in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to infer that a pre-consummation conception was being announced, especially when, according to your own position, future conception through Joseph remained the expectation She already had.
 

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
756
129
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
This has been well explained by @Moonwood here: #79


go and read for yourself. I don't need 'vain repetitions'!
HE or SHE Gen 3:15
Now which Catholic Bible get's it right ?
Take you time beech :)
Vulgate she shall crush your head
RSV-CE he shall bruise your head
 

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
714
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
You accused me of reading Mary's mind. I'm not doing that. I'm pointing to the sequence of events Luke records:
  1. Gabriel announces that Mary will conceive.
  2. Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
  3. Gabriel answers with divine action by the Holy Spirit.
  4. Gabriel appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception.
  5. Gabriel concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."
Those are Luke's words, not my speculations.

Now you've responded by saying that Luke is focused on the virgin birth.

...these say absolutely nothing about Joseph and Mary having marital relations.; Maybe you really are that dense!

This is precisely why I said you've stopped addressing my actual argument.

You quoted only the middle section of my post while omitting the part immediately before it where I explicitly said:

"Exactly. That is precisely my point."
"The challenge I presented was never about what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus' birth. The challenge was about Luke 1:34-37 and the logic of the Annunciation narrative."

Then you responded:

"These say absolutely nothing about Joseph and Mary having marital relations."

But I had already agreed with that.

So you're refuting a claim I expressly denied making.

My argument is not that Luke 1:34-37 tells us what Mary and Joseph did after Jesus' birth.

My argument is that your explanation has not accounted for the logic of Luke's narrative:

Gabriel announces a conception.

Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"

Gabriel responds with divine action, appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception, and concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."

The question I've repeatedly asked is simple:

If Mary expected the announced conception to occur through ordinary future marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke present her virginity as the difficulty and Gabriel's answer as a solution involving divine intervention and impossibility?

Instead of answering that question, you've responded to a claim I never made.

Prove otherwise! That is the issue. Yopu are amking the assertions of her perpetual virginity so you have to prove it.

That's another shift away from the question.

I'm not asking you to accept perpetual virginity at this point in the discussion.

I'm asking you to explain your interpretation of Luke 1:34-37.

The text says:

• Gabriel announces that Mary will conceive.
• Mary responds, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
• Gabriel answers by describing divine action by the Holy Spirit.
• Gabriel appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception.
• Gabriel concludes, "For with God nothing will be impossible."

My question is simple:
If Mary's expectation was that she would eventually conceive through ordinary marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke portray her virginity as the reason for her question, and why does Gabriel answer with divine intervention and an appeal to impossibility?

Notice that this question does not require me to prove perpetual virginity.

It requires you to explain your reading of the passage.

You have repeatedly asserted that Mary's question is perfectly normal for a woman expecting ordinary marital relations with Joseph.

Fine.

Explain how that understanding fits Luke's narrative.

Appealing to the burden of proof does not answer the question. The moment you offer an interpretation of a text, you also bear the burden of explaining how the details of that text fit your interpretation.

So once again:

Why does Mary present "I know not man" as the difficulty, and why does Gabriel answer with miraculous conception and "nothing will be impossible with God," if ordinary future marital relations with Joseph were expected to explain the announced conception?

Quite simply: I f MAry was to stay a virgin She would have said " How can this be since I will never know a man"? Also they would have broken the Mosaic law by abstaining from sexual relations as husband and wife, unless there was a command from god! where is that command?

You're still not answering the question.

My question wasn't what Mary would have said if perpetual virginity were false or true.

My question was why, from Gabriel's actual words: "You will conceive and bear a Son," Mary would infer a conception prior to the future marital relations that you say she expected with Joseph.

Gabriel does not say:

"You are about to conceive immediately."

Nor does he say:

"You will conceive before you come together with Joseph."

Yet Mary's response is:

"How will this occur, since I know not man?"

So the question remains: why does She treat Her present virginity as relevant to Gabriel's announcement at all if She expected the conception to occur through ordinary future marital relations?]

Simply saying what you think Mary would have said under different circumstances does not explain the words Luke actually records.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
258
84
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I think that statement is significant because it identifies the very point under discussion.

My question is not whether a pre-consummation conception ultimately occurred.

My question is what in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to infer that a pre-consummation conception was being announced.

If how Mary would know that is unclear from the text, then what remains unclear is precisely why that should be regarded as the natural inference from Gabriel's words:
"You will conceive and bear a Son."

Especially when you yourself have argued that Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph, including future marital relations.

If future conception through Joseph remained the expectation Mary already had, then I still do not see what would lead Her to infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before those expected marital relations rather than through them.

Do you get that the Scriptures don't always give tone and physical communication (was the voice gentle or sarcastic or gruff? did the person lean in and speak or lean back and speak? did he wink? did he smile as he talked or did he frown?) Most of the time we aren't given any of these cues at all and are left with just the text itself, so the text doesn't give us everything we need to KNOW EXACTLY how or why something occurred.

But consider the following:

Me to you: "Look out, there's trouble coming." You promptly run and hide.

There's nothing in that short two-sentence story that tells us WHY you ran and hid, or what in my words suggested that the trouble was imminent, but your reaction tells us that, in fact, you thought that I meant that trouble was coming IMMINENTLY, which is by far the best explanation for why you did what you did.

You keep looking for things the text doesn't explicitly say AS IF THAT PROVES YOUR POINT. It doesn't. Like, not even close. The most natural reading of what Mary said in response to Gabriel was that she thought - for whatever reason - that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant SOON, which is why she asked what she asked. And that assumption (if I'm right), was, in fact, 100% correct. Maybe it was Gabriel's tone (which the text doesn't give). Maybe it was the way he looked at her (which the text doesn't say). Maybe it was mother's intuition (which the text doesn't say). Maybe it was your fanciful idea that Mary was utterly perfect in every way and wouldn't ever have made a wrong assumption (which the text doesn't say). We don't know exactly from the text WHY she would have assumed that. Just like in my little two sentence story, we don't know exactly why you would have thought I meant that trouble was imminent. But it's clear from Mary's reaction, and it's clear from your reaction in that little story, THAT she thought she would be pregnant soon, and THAT you thought trouble was imminent.

And this also gets to the dilemma you've presented.

I'm not asking whether Mary's inference, if She made one, ultimately proved correct. Even if, for the sake of argument, I granted that Mary correctly inferred a pre-consummation conception, that still would not explain why She drew that conclusion from Gabriel's words in the first place.

You've said:

"HOW she would know this is unclear from the text."

That is precisely the issue I'm raising.

The question is not whether a pre-consummation conception later occurred. The question is what in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to infer that a pre-consummation conception was being announced, especially when, according to your own position, future conception through Joseph remained the expectation She already had.

So: either Mary assumed correctly that she would be pregnant soon, or she was wrong about that, which suddenly makes Mary less than perfect. Which is it? Are you going with the "Mary is perfect and therefore wouldn't have gotten that wrong" option, or the "Mary guessed wrongly and therefore isn't as perfect as the Catholic Church makes her out to be" option? It's one or the other.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
First – YOU need to show me where Sola Scriptura is taught in Scripture.
The idea that EVERYTHING we believe MUST be on the pages of Scripture is condemned by Scripture itself (2 Thess 2:15, Luke 10:16).

You only consider this to be “off-topic” because you CAN’T answer the question . . . . . .
Sorry but this is off topic! This is not a thread on sola scriptura. So answer the topic question first and I will gladly answer you.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
St Jerome and St. Augustine in their writings actually taught Joseph and Mary remain lifelong virgin.

While you focused on Matthew 1:25, you missed 1:20 when angel of Lord appeared and explained to Joseph about Mary's pregnancy with HOLY SPIRIT, bearing the Son of God. Joseph, as a righteous man, accepted this divine mystery and respected her consecration.


Their union achieved the highest spiritual fruit of marriage: mutual holiness, protection, raising the Christ child, and total devotion to God, without requiring physical intimacy.


I see such teachings would never have mentioned by your pastors who were ignorant on them as well.
Show me where it says He respected her consecration! You are just making that up.

Matthew 1:20 is unrelated to the actions of 1:25. 20 concerns the virgin birth and 25 concerns Joseph waiting until Jesus was born before he had marital relations with Mary.

Both Augustine and Jerome were 4th century people. What did they base their conclusions on? the protoevangelium of James? That was writtn towards the end of the 2nd century. what basis did he conclude so! the natural normal reading of Scripture clearly shows that Joseph and Mary had sex after Jesus was born and had at least 6 more children.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
She was stating her intention to remain a virgin and was puzzled by Gabriel’s announcement that she was to have a child. She knew that God was aware of her intentions. Her bewilderment and the words “I do not know”, as opposed to “I have not known”, is clear evidence that she had NO intention of having marital relations.
Hogwash! If she was going to remain virgin she would have said "Since I will not know a man" using the future tense and not the present active indiciative! If we believe God inspire the Bible then she was not speaking at all about future relations.
She was stating her intention to remain a virgin and was puzzled by Gabriel’s announcement that she was to have a child. She knew that God was aware of her intentions. Her bewilderment and the words “I do not know”, as opposed to “I have not known”, is clear evidence that she had NO intention of having marital relations.
And I thought you had a keener sense of grammar! I apologize for being wrong. Do not know is present, have not known is past, will not know is future. No charge for teh grammar lesson.
This is supported by Early Church writings. The 2nd century document, The Protoevangelium explains how Joseph was an elderly man who married Mary as a protector because she was a consecrated Temple virgin.
Yu should check with Jewish sources for their were no such things as temple virgins and Joseph did not take Mary to protect her. She would have made a lousy temple virgin seeing as she lived in Nazareth which was c. 64 miles from Jerusalem!!!

The protoevangelium was written in the latter half of the 2nd century and was banned from the bible as being non-inspired. You need to do better.
Many of your Protestant Fathers like Martin Luther, John Calvin and Ulrich Zwingli held Mary in high regard venerated her as a sinless person and/or perpetual virgin:
All of these "Fathers" had been Catholic so it is not a stretch for them to hold to Romanist teachings in areas.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Gabriel responds with divine action, appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception, and concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."

The question I've repeatedly asked is simple:

If Mary expected the announced conception to occur through ordinary future marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke present her virginity as the difficulty and Gabriel's answer as a solution involving divine intervention and impossibility?
Your blindness is unbecoming. If you want to make this sensible to your thinking, Mary would have had to say: I haven't known a man yet" indicating the real potential for marital relations in the future as Matt. 1:25 says.

Once again if Mary intended to stay a vbirgin she would have asked this way " How can this be seeing I will not know a man."

Why is her response in teh present and not the future? For the simple fact she was not yet near having sex. C'mon you are better than this

Let me ask you . If you see a sentence that says : "The children did not go outside until they ate their lunch." Would you naturally know that after they ate they went outside?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Show me where it says He respected her consecration! You are just making that up.

Matthew 1:20 is unrelated to the actions of 1:25. 20 concerns the virgin birth and 25 concerns Joseph waiting until Jesus was born before he had marital relations with Mary.

Both Augustine and Jerome were 4th century people. What did they base their conclusions on? the protoevangelium of James? That was writtn towards the end of the 2nd century. what basis did he conclude so! the natural normal reading of Scripture clearly shows that Joseph and Mary had sex after Jesus was born and had at least 6 more children.
While you always shout out: 'Where in the Bible says so!'

The most glaring contradiction in a strict 'Bible-only' stance is nowhere in Scripture does God provide an inspired list of which 66 books belong in the Bible.


Both Augustine and Jerome were 4th century people. What did they base their conclusions on?

Protestants accept the New Testament canon based entirely on 4th-century Church councils too!


Show me where it says He respected her consecration!
You argue that because phrases like 'consecrated virginity' aren't explicitly spelled out in the text, they are made up. The word Trinity never appears in Scripture too.


So, you should find a better gun against the RC.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Let me ask you . If you see a sentence that says : "The children did not go outside until they ate their lunch." Would you naturally know that after they ate they went outside?
Let you tell us why are you so sure that the children, and ALL OF THEM, with no exception, must go outside after they ate?
 
Last edited:

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Show me where it says He respected her consecration! You are just making that up.
Jesus followed his parents to Jerusalem at 12. The scripture had no mention of his siblings.
(or Joseph and Mary brought only the beloved Jesus, leaving those alone at home?)


Joseph must consult an fertility doctor, for childless after 12 years of 'normal sex'.
(or tell the modern couples what kind of contraception method they used, so effective !)

If you want to make this sensible to your thinking
Your thinking (Joseph and Mary are normal couple, having normal sex) doesn't make sense either.
 
Last edited:

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,773
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Sorry but this is off topic! This is not a thread on sola scriptura. So answer the topic question first and I will gladly answer you.
WRONG.

I said nothing “Off-topic”. Your entire argument is based on Sola Scriptura – the idea that we ONLY adhere to what is in Scripture. You told me to prove my point from SCRIOPTURE.
Only a Sola Scripturist would make that challenge.

So, I challenge you again:
Give me BIBLICAL proof for Sola Scriptura.

Something tells me that you’re NOT going to provide this
proof . . .
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,773
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Hogwash! If she was going to remain virgin she would have said "Since I will not know a man" using the future tense and not the present active indiciative! If we believe God inspire the Bible then she was not speaking at all about future relations.
Ummm – WHY would she say that if she ALREADY pledged that to God, hmmmm? WHY would a consecrated Temple Virgin tell God what she ALREADY told him?

Silly argument . . .

And I thought you had a keener sense of grammar! I apologize for being wrong. Do not know is present, have not known is past, will not know is future. No charge for teh grammar lesson.
That’s completely irrelevant. She was asking how she could be pregnant if she DOES NOT know a man.
And that doesn’t make sense to you??

So, let me get this straight - YOU would have a problem with an ex-smoker who says, “I DON’T smoke”, as opposed to “I WILL NOT smoke anymore”?? You’re a very confused person . . .

I do not know man simply means
“I don’t do that” . . .
Yu should check with Jewish sources for their were no such things as temple virgins and Joseph did not take Mary to protect her. She would have made a lousy temple virgin seeing as she lived in Nazareth which was c. 64 miles from Jerusalem!!!
The Protoevangelium states that she was consecrated to the Temple at the age of three and retuned home at the age of twelve.
The protoevangelium was written in the latter half of the 2nd century and was banned from the bible as being non-inspired. You need to do better.
"Banned" from the bBble?
You REALLY need to stop watching the History Cannel . . .

Time for a History Lesson -
WHO
do you think declared the Canon of Scripture – some 1200 years BEFORE your Protestant Fathers were even born? Yes, it was the Catholic Church – the Guardian of Scripture thet declared the Canon in 383 AD at the Council of Rome. It was the CHURCH who decided which Books belonged in Scripture - under the guidance of the Holy Spirit (John 16:12-15). Protestants later removed the 7 Deuterocanonical Book from their OT Canoin.

As for the Apocryphal Books like the Letter of Clement, the Protoevangelium, the Shepherd of Hermas, etc. – they were declared NOT to have been inspired. That DOESN’T mean that they don’t contain HISTORICAL truth.

WHERE do you think we get the accounts of the deaths of Peter and Paul?
WHERE
do you think we get the formula for Baptism by immersion and purring?
The Bible doesn’t give us details of ANY of these things . . .

All of these "Fathers" had been Catholic so it is not a stretch for them to hold to Romanist teachings in areas.
I only mentioned the 3 of them. They ALSO believed in MARY other Catholic doctrines, as did their successors. Infant Baptism, Baptism by pouring, Mary’s Immaculate Conception, Perpetual Virginity, etc., to name a few.

Protestants of today have splintered and strayed MILES away from their teachings . . .
 

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,605
2,899
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
It really is irrelevant to me whether Joseph was a perpetual virgin or if Mary was a perpetual virgin or not.
It has no bearing whatsoever on my beliefs.
I don't care if Jesus had brothers or if they were cousins.
I know that some of you are invested in Mary remaining a virgin for life because your religion venerates her
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dryhn

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
756
129
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
It really is irrelevant to me whether Joseph was a perpetual virgin or if Mary was a perpetual virgin or not.
It has no bearing whatsoever on my beliefs.
I don't care if Jesus had brothers or if they were cousins.
I know that some of you are invested in Mary remaining a virgin for life because your religion venerates her
"Mary remaining a virgin for life because your religion venerates her""
Yes, its simple plain Catholic nonsense/dogma designed to keep the faithful pur$e open & feeding the Vatican
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
"Mary remaining a virgin for life because your religion venerates her""
Yes, its simple plain Catholic nonsense/dogma designed to keep the faithful pur$e open & feeding the Vatican
How do you explain the early Protestant Reformers : Martin Luther, John Calvin, and Ulrich Zwingli, who fiercely opposed Vatican like the sale of indulgences, all fiercely defended Mary's perpetual virginity as a biblical and theological truth.

this would be the problem of modern day Protestant deformed doctrines more than by Vatican invention.
 

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
756
129
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
How do you explain the early Protestant Reformers : Martin Luther, John Calvin, and Ulrich Zwingli, who fiercely opposed Vatican like the sale of indulgences, all fiercely defended Mary's perpetual virginity as a biblical and theological truth.

this would be the problem of modern day Protestant deformed doctrines more than by Vatican invention.
Gen 3:15 HE/SHE - a question you continue to run from

Which Catholic Bible gets it right, Vulgate or RSV-CE