BreadOfLife
Well-Known Member
- Jan 2, 2017
- 22,783
- 3,837
- 113
- Faith
- Christian
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Male
Ay, yi, yi . . .First off, the Jewish temple had no consecrated virgins. They had virgins working the temple until they were fourteen or so and then released for they were expected to marry. And no woman ever lived in the temple. And other than a late 2nd century writing that the church found incompatible for Scripture, you have nothing that says Mary was a temple virgin. And she owuld have answered Gabriel not "I know not a man", but " I will not know a man" unless she forgot she supposedly took a vow of absitnence,
Let’s review:
If an angel told a VIRGIN that she was about to become pregnant – WHY would she say, " I will not know a man" if she was going to be pregnant in a few seconds??
I DO NOT know man makes MUCH more sense . . .
And WHO claimed that there was??from AI:
Did the Jewish Temple Have Consecrated Virgins?
No — there is no reliable evidence in Jewish sources for an organized “department” of consecrated virgins serving in the Temple, though some women did perform dedicated liturgical duties there.
Mary was consecrated to the Temple by her parents – not by any “Department of Virgins”.
What an inane argument . . .
And I NEVER claimed that this was a Scriptural fact because I also adhere to Tradition. YOU are the one who demands Scriptural evidence because you are a Sola Scripturist – who actually DENIES being one . . .Biblical and Traditional References
Several passages describe women associated with the Temple:
I will take the Jews word for it other than a writing nearly 2 centuries removed from Mary.
- Exodus 38:8 mentions women “watching” (צָבָא) at the door of the tabernacle.
- 1 Samuel 2:22 refers to “women who waited” (צָבָא) at the tabernacle door.
Actually – this is NOT an official title . . .No I wouldn't. But god is far more specific than man. Especially when the Romanist church has made such a huge fuss about Mary!
Just incase you didn't see this post earlier, some titles Romanism has given Mary:
Co-REdemptrix
I don‘t have a problem with ANY of these . . .Co -Mediatrix
Queen of Heaven
Mother most chaste,
Mother inviolate,
Mother undefiled,
Mother most amiable,
Mother most admirable,, etc . . .
Okay.Feasts Dedicated to the Blessed Virgin Mary
The Catholic Church celebrates numerous Marian feast days throughout the year, including three major solemnities—Mary, Mother of God (Jan 1), the Assumption (Aug 15), and the Immaculate Conception (Dec 8)—plus many other feasts marking key events in Mary’s life and her role in salvation history.
Major Marian Solemnities (Holy Days of Obligation in the U.S. unless on Sat/Mon)
- January 1 – Mary, Mother of God: Celebrates Mary as Theotokos, Mother of God, as confirmed at the Council of Ephesus (431).
- August 15 – The Assumption: Mary was taken body and soul into heavenly glory at the end of her earthly life.
- December 8 – The Immaculate Conception: Mary was preserved from original sin from the first moment of her conception.
Other Principal Marian Feasts
- February 2 – The Presentation of the Lord: Mary’s purification and the presentation of Jesus in the Temple.
- February 11 – Our Lady of Lourdes: Memorial of the apparitions to St. Bernadette.
- March 25 – The Annunciation: Angel Gabriel’s announcement to Mary that she would conceive Jesus.
- May 13 – Our Lady of Fatima: First apparition to the three shepherd children (1917).
- May 31 – The Visitation: Mary visits her cousin Elizabeth.
- July 16 – Our Lady of Mount Carmel: Patroness of the Carmelite Order.
- August 22 – The Queenship of Mary: Mary as Queen of Heaven and Earth.
- September 8 – The Nativity of Mary: Mary’s birth.
- September 12 – The Most Holy Name of Mary: Honors Mary’s name and intercession.
- September 15 – Our Lady of Sorrows: Commemorates Mary’s seven sorrows.
- October 7 – Our Lady of the Rosary: Memorial of the Battle of Lepanto through Rosary intercession.
- November 21 – The Presentation of Mary: Mary’s presentation in the Temple at age 12.
- December 12 – Our Lady of Guadalupe: Memorial of the apparition to St. Juan Diego.
Special ObservancesMonth of Mary: May is traditionally dedicated to Mary.
- Month of the Rosary: October is dedicated to the Rosary.
- Immaculate Heart of Mary: Saturday after the Second Sunday after Pentecost
Again – I don’t see the problem . . .



