Is Jesus mortal or not?
You can't have it both ways.
You are correct.....he cannot have both.
Can we just clarify the words “mortal” and “immortal” first?
An
immortal has the power of an indestructible life....nothing can kill an immortal, and at the outset of Yahweh’s creativity only he was immortal. His first creation was his “only begotten son”. (Colossians 1:15; Revelation 3:14)
The Creator has always existed.....always immortal. (1 Timothy 1:17) The pre-human Jesus was not immortal and all the other “sons of God” were likewise not created immortal. In the spirit realm apparently they have what humans were created with, “everlasting life”....but
everlasting life is not
immortality. It is the ability to go on living, but always subject to obedience to the Creator. It would have been extremely foolish to create free willed beings and not have the means to control them. God’s intelligent children in both realms, need to obey God in order to keep the gift of life.
Satan was the first rebel. He is the one who robbed the humans of their idyllic future.
Humans demonstrate their mortality in ways that spirit beings do not. As material beings, we are dependant on external (material) things to keep living...oxygen, water, food and shelter. All living souls depend on these things, which were supplied in abundance by God within the atmosphere of this planet which was designed to be our permanent home.
Since a “soul” is a living, breathing, earth bound creature, they should not be confused with “spirit” creatures who inhabit the realm where God resides....wherever or whatever “heaven” is.
So with that in mind, we believe that Jesus was a spirit being in heaven who was instrumental in creation, as the agency “through” whom the creation of all things, both in the spirit realm and the material realm, came about. Working at his Father’s side (Proverbs 8:30-31) and under his direction, creation came “through him and for him”. (Colossians 1:15-17) He is part of the “us” and “our” in Genesis 1:26.
So because he was not immortal, but enjoyed everlasting life as an obedient spirit son, he could have his life transferred by Holy Spirit to the womb of an earthly woman to become “the son of God” on earth and act as redeemer for all of Adam’s children, born in sin through no fault of their own. He was 100% mortal human....something God could never be.
Upon his return to heaven, Jesus was given a new name and granted immortality as a reward for his faithful course. Those of his elect will have proven ‘faithful unto death’ and will also inherit immortality in the spirit realm. Flesh and blood cannot exist outside of this specially prepared ‘spaceship’ we call Earth.
The devil and his demons will end their existence in the lake of fire, along with all the disobedient and faithless humans who have been misled by them.....it is a symbolic place that means eternal destruction. Even death and the grave are destroyed in this place. (Revelation 20:13-14)