The Holy Sacrament is Spiritual

[marksman]

at the lords supper he said do this often in remembrance of me..

Only one of the gospels say that

 

[marksman]

He said whoever eats will never die

I take his word

you do whatever you want..

Correction. You take his words for what you think they mean.

 

[marksman]

Do you have any scripture to support that? I don't see the breaking of bread anywhere in scripture except for the sacrament.

No scripture is necessary as every jew reading or hearing the words would know what the words meant.

 

[Behold]

When you study this subject in its entirety as I have done, there is no such thing as communion

I would never deny what Jesus said during the last supper.
But i would also never conclude that what is honoring Christ..>"do this in Remembrance of me".....is required for Salvation.

See, one of the ways to escape "doctrines of devi's', .... Hebrews 13:9, ... and most center around "Salvation" theology, is simply to ask yourself..

1.) "did that die on the Cross for my Sin"? And if whatever is being presented as "do this to be saved or stay saved" didn't die on the Cross for your sin, then that Theology is a "doctrine of Devil's" being preached or taught by a deceiver.

 

[marksman]

I would never deny what Jesus said during the last supper.

Who is denying anything?

 

[Jim B]

When you study this subject in its entirety as I have done, there is no such thing as communion

This is absurd. "The Eucharist, also known as Holy Communion and the Lord's Supper, is a Christian rite that is considered a sacrament in most churches, and as an ordinance in others." wikipedia

Apparently you haven't studied hard enough and/or you need to go to church and take part in the communion ritual.

 

[Jim B]

When you do a thorough study of this topic you will find that there is no such sacrament.

Reda my post immediately above -- #246.

 

[Jim B]

I never said it was. I am talking about eating someone's flesh and drinking their blood.

Now you're changing the subject. First you wrote that there is no such thing as communion, then you wrote that there is no such sacrament, now you're redefining it.

 

[Jim B]

I know as I have studied Jewish celebrations. I have not talked about sharing bread and wine,

You have "talked" about communion, which is sharing bread and wine. The same activity takes place at the seder..

 

[Jim B]

Correction. You take the words for what YOU think he meant.

Correction. YOU take the words for what YOU think he meant.

 

[Eternally Grateful]

Only one of the gospels say that

Jesus said it

thats all I need to know..

Because jesus was not talking about some Eucharistic pagan ritual. he was talking about the true means to eternal life..

 

[Eternally Grateful]

Correction. You take his words for what you think they mean.

Never die means never die.

if I eat it and I die. Jesus lied.. period

 

[marksman]

Never die means never die.

if I eat it and I die. Jesus lied.. period

I see you don't know what you are talking about

 

[marksman]

Jesus said it

thats all I need to know..

Because jesus was not talking about some Eucharistic pagan ritual. he was talking about the true means to eternal life..

You have a lot to learn. You NEVER make a doctrine out of ONE verse of scripture

 

[marksman]

Correction. YOU take the words for what YOU think he meant.

I haven't taken any of his words.

 

[marksman]

You have "talked" about communion, which is sharing bread and wine. The same activity takes place at the seder..

No I haven't. I have talked about breaking of bread which is eating a meal.

 

[marksman]

Now you're changing the subject. First you wrote that there is no such thing as communion, then you wrote that there is no such sacrament, now you're redefining it.

Have fun going round the houses.

 

[marksman]

Apparently you haven't studied hard enough and/or you need to go to church and take part in the communion ritual.

That is not for you to judge.

 

[marksman]

Well when I took the sacrement I literally felt Jesus body near to mine in a way. And his is Holy and Virtuous. And I think that is what is meant. Sinning close to Jesus' body is bad.

I think you are inventing your own take on things which you will not find in scripture.

 

[dev553344]

I think you are inventing your own take on things which you will not find in scripture.

Must you continue with this nonsense, honestly.