Question: So if that Christian that commits murder and never repents, first, was that murder a sin, and are they still saved?
Hypotheticals . . . sigh!
OK. God chastens His children. God's chastening is effective, and produces the peaceable fruit of righteousness.
I'm not sure your hypothetical is possible in real life.
Let's say a Christian commits a murder. Hypothetically. Not saying Christians are a bunch of murderers. Let's say one does. Are you saying that you are to judge them instead of letting Christ judge them, and that you are to judge them according to a law that God says isn't for them? Is that what you are saying?
So that you can impeach my teaching of complete forgiveness of sin based on an imaginary scenario that doesn't even fit to Scripture?
And will you act the same towards a moment of undeserved hatred for someone?
I can offer another hypothetical, see if it's more likely to actually happen . . .
Someone's axhead flies off of their handle, strikes a man, and kills him. "It was an accident, could happen to anyone!" Under the Law . . . not guilty.
But was he? Did he see the axhead wiggle on the shaft the day before? Not that he ignored it, just that he wasn't paying the best attention because he was becoming so angry with the tree he was trying to chop! Getting nowhere fast! Of course, had he read a little further that morning, it would have been about how wisdom is like a sharper ax, you can do more with it. But he didn't because he was in a hurry to get to work, and get some OT, because that payment was almost due. And he wasn't trusting God. Because he thought God was angry with him. Because he ___________ .
I obviously have too much time on my hands!
Much love!