Who is Paul discussing in 2 Thessalonians 2?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Earburner

Well-Known Member
Feb 2, 2019
8,511
2,000
113
76
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If Paul had believed that all ethnic Israel would be saved, he would have been beyond ecstatic.

But he wasn't, and we've seen the distinctions that he draws between the Israel that will be saved and the Israel that will not be saved.

The difference being between faithfulness and obedience, and unfaithfulness and disobedience.

A microcosm of the entirety of humanity.
I sincerely believe that when Christians position themselves into this severe dichotomy for understanding, of how it is that "not all of Israel is Israel" and yet we also read that "all of Israel shall be saved", it is all due to the fact that neither of the christian positions are understanding who the symbolic 144,000 of the nation of Israel truly are.

The 144k has nothing to do with the NC. but rather everything to do with the OC. It is from "under the altar" of the OC. that the 144,000 originate from. Mal. 3:16-18; Rev. 6:9-11.
The 144k of OC Israel were each "sealed" with the Holy Spirit of Promise [white robe] upon the day when Christ was "glorified" in His resurrection.
John 7:39 (But this spake he of the Spirit, which they that believe on him should receive: for the Holy Ghost was not yet [permanently] given [to anyone]; because that Jesus was not yet glorified [resurrected].)

In other words, the symbolic number of the 144,000 are from ALL of the tribes of OC. Israel of faith, who lived and died in faith "under the altar" of OC. Israel.

Now, during this present Age of God's Grace, those of Israel who are Born again through faith in Jesus, AFTER His resurrection, they are now OF THE Great Multitude, along with the Gentiles who have also believed.

So yes, in that construct, I believe that all mature Christains who are Born again, do understand that both those of Israel and those of the Gentile nations, who have accepted the Lord Jesus as their Savior are indeed the fulfilment of the words: "and so shall all of Israel be saved"
Rom. 11
25 For I would not, brethren, that ye should be ignorant of this mystery, lest ye should be wise in your own conceits; that blindness in part is happened to Israel, until the fulness of the Gentiles be come in.
26 And so all Israel shall be saved [meaning both Jew and Gentile now have equal opportunity to enter into God's plan of Salvation]: as it is written, There shall come out of Sion the Deliverer, and shall turn away ungodliness from Jacob:

And for that, WE ALL DO KNOW that the Deliverer Jesus HAS COME!
 
Last edited:

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,594
347
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I sincerely believe that when Christians position themselves into this severe dichotomy for understanding, of how it is that "not all of Israel is Israel" and yet we also read that "all of Israel shall be saved", it is all due to the fact that neither of the christian positions are understanding who the symbolic 144,000 of the nation of Israel truly are.

The 144k has nothing to do with the NC. but rather everything to do with the OC. It is from "under the altar" of the OC. that the 144,000 originate from. Mal. 3:16-18; Rev. 6:9-11.
The 144k of OC Israel were each "sealed" with the Holy Spirit of Promise [white robe] upon the day when Christ was "glorified" in His resurrection.
John 7:39 (But this spake he of the Spirit, which they that believe on him should receive: for the Holy Ghost was not yet [permanently] given [to anyone]; because that Jesus was not yet glorified [resurrected].)

In other words, the symbolic number of the 144,000 are from ALL of the tribes of OC. Israel of faith, who lived and died in faith "under the altar" of OC. Israel.

Now, during this present Age if God's Grace, those of Israel who are Born again through faith in Jesus, AFTER His resurrection, they are now OF THE Great Multitude, along with the Gentiles who have also believed.

I am not sure I see Revelation making the connections you are making. Please consider -

Revelation 6 does not identify the souls under the altar as the 144,000. They are described as people who were slain for the word of God and their testimony. Revelation 7 then introduces 144,000 servants who are sealed before judgment is released upon the earth.

Likewise, the white robes given to the martyrs are not identified as the seal of the Holy Spirit. Revelation normally uses white garments to represent righteousness, purity, victory, or vindication, while the 144,000 are specifically sealed upon their foreheads.

John 7:39 teaches that the Holy Spirit was given after Jesus was glorified, but it does not say that faithful Israelites who had already died were then posthumously sealed and numbered as the 144,000.

The timing in Revelation 7 seems especially important. The 144,000 are sealed before the winds are released and are called “the servants of our God.” That sounds like preparation for a coming work or trial, rather than simply identifying Old Covenant believers who had already died.

So I am not sure the text itself establishes that:

the souls under the altar are the 144,000,​
their white robes are the Holy Spirit’s seal,​
or the 144,000 consist exclusively of faithful Israelites who died before the cross.​
 

PinSeeker

Well-Known Member
Oct 4, 2021
4,428
1,074
113
Nashville
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The 144k has nothing to do with the NC. but rather everything to do with the OC. It is from "under the altar" of the OC. that the 144,000 originate from. Mal. 3:16-18; Rev. 6:9-11.
Interesting... Here's how I understand it, Earburner. <smile>

The whole of Revelation is about the time from Christ's life on earth to the time He returns. "After this" is the setting, as John says at that outset of his visions in Revelation 4:1, and this is analogous... synonymous with what the writer of Hebrews says in the first chapter, verse 2, of that epistle... "these last days." So it is absolutely about the New Covenant period...

And it's circular, as all of John's writings are, circling back over the same things, in the case of Revelation describing this period in different ways seven times over.

And just on the subject of the New Covenant, Jesus is the New Covenant, the final and full/complete iteration of God's everlasting covenant... God's promises to Adam and Noah (life), Abraham (descendants/nation and land), Moses (the law), and David (a King), all point to and are finally full revealed in the Person of Christ Jesus.

So Revelation 6:11, "...each given a white robe and told to rest a little longer, until the number of their fellow servants and their brothers should be complete, who were to be killed as they themselves had been"... refers to the exact same group Paul is referring to in Romans 11:25-26, "...a partial hardening has come upon Israel, until the fullness of the Gentiles has come in. And in this way all Israel will be saved..." And then in Revelation 7, what John "sees"... and tells us of are two aspects about God's Israel:
  • the first from in verses 1-8, the true Jewish heritage, regardless of ethnicity, of the complete people of God... the fullness of God's Israel
  • the second in 9-17, the total number of the complete people of God, which is actually an innumerable multitude ~ of the same group of people... the complete people of God.
Your citation of Malachi 3 is a good one, but I don't think I would say the 144,000 "originated" from there...

...all mature Christains who are Born again, do understand that both those of Israel and those of the Gentile nations, who have accepted the Lord Jesus as their Savior are indeed the fulfilment of the words: "and so shall all of Israel be saved"
Rom. 11
Right. Absolutely.

...WE ALL DO KNOW that the Deliverer Jesus HAS COME!
Absolutely. And will return. <smile>

Grace and peace to you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CTK

Earburner

Well-Known Member
Feb 2, 2019
8,511
2,000
113
76
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I am not sure I see Revelation making the connections you are making. Please consider -

Revelation 6 does not identify the souls under the altar as the 144,000. They are described as people who were slain for the word of God and their testimony. Revelation 7 then introduces 144,000 servants who are sealed before judgment is released upon the earth.

Likewise, the white robes given to the martyrs are not identified as the seal of the Holy Spirit. Revelation normally uses white garments to represent righteousness, purity, victory, or vindication, while the 144,000 are specifically sealed upon their foreheads.

John 7:39 teaches that the Holy Spirit was given after Jesus was glorified, but it does not say that faithful Israelites who had already died were then posthumously sealed and numbered as the 144,000.

The timing in Revelation 7 seems especially important. The 144,000 are sealed before the winds are released and are called “the servants of our God.” That sounds like preparation for a coming work or trial, rather than simply identifying Old Covenant believers who had already died.

So I am not sure the text itself establishes that:

the souls under the altar are the 144,000,​
their white robes are the Holy Spirit’s seal,​
or the 144,000 consist exclusively of faithful Israelites who died before the cross.​
Unfortunately, church-ianity has everyone locked up into the belief that all of the book of Revelation is only about the future! Well,.... indeed it is,... but BEGINNING in the day of Jesus' ministry to us, while in his mortal flesh.
Please take a good look at Mat. 27:50-54. There is MUCH going on there, that even church-ianity does not know what to do with it.

Here is the problem that many Christians do not understand:
Israel of faith, while "under the altar" of the OC. never had the permanent indwelling of the Holy Spirit, nor had they partaken in the Gift of Eternal life.
Therefore, though many of those saints of the OC. lived and died, by the "rememberance" of God [Mal. 3:16-18], THEY WERE STILL WAITING for the Promise that was to come. And that He did, in the Day of Jesus death and resurrection. John 7:39. These are the symbolic 144,000 of Israel.
 
Last edited:

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,594
347
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Unfortunately, church-ianity has everyone locked up into the belief that all of the book of Revelation is only about the future! Well,.... indeed it is,... but BEGINNING in the day of Jesus' ministry to us, while in his mortal flesh.
Please take a good look at Mat. 27:50-54. There is MUCH going on there, that even church-ianity does not know what to do with it.

Here is the problem that many Christians do not understand:
Israel of faith, while "under the altar" of the OC. never had the permanent indwelling of the Holy Spirit, nor had they partaken in the Gift of Eternal life.
Therefore, though many of those saints of the OC. lived and died, by the "rememberance" of God [Mal. 3:16-18], THEY WERE STILL WAITING for the Promise that was to come. And that He did, in the Day of Jesus death and resurrection. John 7:39. These are the symbolic 144,000 of Israel.

Matthew 27 does not call the raised saints the 144,000.

Malachi 3 does not identify those remembered by God as the souls under the altar.

Revelation 6 does not say the souls under the altar are all faithful Israelites from the Old Covenant.

The white robes are not identified as the seal of the Holy Spirit.

And John 7:39 does not say that faithful Israelites who had already died were later sealed and became the 144,000.

These connections are being added to the texts rather than stated by them - study and stay within scripture.

Revelation 7 presents the 144,000 as servants sealed before coming judgment, and Revelation 14 presents them as firstfruits who follow the Lamb. That sounds more like a specially prepared company for a prophetic purpose than a complete number of Old Covenant believers who had already died.
 

Earburner

Well-Known Member
Feb 2, 2019
8,511
2,000
113
76
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I am not sure I see Revelation making the connections you are making. Please consider -

Revelation 6 does not identify the souls under the altar as the 144,000. They are described as people who were slain for the word of God and their testimony. Revelation 7 then introduces 144,000 servants who are sealed before judgment is released upon the earth.

Likewise, the white robes given to the martyrs are not identified as the seal of the Holy Spirit. Revelation normally uses white garments to represent righteousness, purity, victory, or vindication, while the 144,000 are specifically sealed upon their foreheads.

John 7:39 teaches that the Holy Spirit was given after Jesus was glorified, but it does not say that faithful Israelites who had already died were then posthumously sealed and numbered as the 144,000.

The timing in Revelation 7 seems especially important. The 144,000 are sealed before the winds are released and are called “the servants of our God.” That sounds like preparation for a coming work or trial, rather than simply identifying Old Covenant believers who had already died.

So I am not sure the text itself establishes that:

the souls under the altar are the 144,000,​
their white robes are the Holy Spirit’s seal,​
or the 144,000 consist exclusively of faithful Israelites who died before the cross.​
When you unpack what you just wrote, you will discover alot of imposed teaching by church-ianity upon you. For example: Ever since Jesus was "glorified" (John 7:39), no one now, ever receives the Gift of the Holy Spirit AFTER THEIR DEATH. It's always before death. Rom. 8:8-9.
 
Last edited:

Earburner

Well-Known Member
Feb 2, 2019
8,511
2,000
113
76
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Matthew 27 does not call the raised saints the 144,000.

Malachi 3 does not identify those remembered by God as the souls under the altar.

Revelation 6 does not say the souls under the altar are all faithful Israelites from the Old Covenant.

The white robes are not identified as the seal of the Holy Spirit.

And John 7:39 does not say that faithful Israelites who had already died were later sealed and became the 144,000.

These connections are being added to the texts rather than stated by them - study and stay within scripture.

Revelation 7 presents the 144,000 as servants sealed before coming judgment, and Revelation 14 presents them as firstfruits who follow the Lamb. That sounds more like a specially prepared company for a prophetic purpose than a complete number of Old Covenant believers who had already died.
Are you falling into the same bracket of church-ianity, thinking that the MANY saints that rose out of their graves UPON the moment of JESUS' DEATH on the cross, were NC saints???
KJV Mat. 27:50-55
Again, WHEN was the permanent indwelling of the Holy Spirit GIVEN???
John 7:39
 
Last edited:

Earburner

Well-Known Member
Feb 2, 2019
8,511
2,000
113
76
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Matthew 27 does not call the raised saints the 144,000.

Malachi 3 does not identify those remembered by God as the souls under the altar.

Revelation 6 does not say the souls under the altar are all faithful Israelites from the Old Covenant.

The white robes are not identified as the seal of the Holy Spirit.

And John 7:39 does not say that faithful Israelites who had already died were later sealed and became the 144,000.

These connections are being added to the texts rather than stated by them - study and stay within scripture.

Revelation 7 presents the 144,000 as servants sealed before coming judgment, and Revelation 14 presents them as firstfruits who follow the Lamb. That sounds more like a specially prepared company for a prophetic purpose than a complete number of Old Covenant believers who had already died.


Mal. 3:16-18
16 Then they [under the OC] that feared the Lord spake often one to another: and the Lord hearkened, and heard it, and a book of remembrance was written before him for them that feared the Lord, and that thought upon his name.
(By the way, God the Father had no other option to remember anyone of the OC. except to remember their names in the "book of remembrance", because the "Book of Life", who is Jesus, had not yet come into the world.)

17 And they shall be mine, saith the Lord of hosts, in that day [Age of Grace] when I make up [appoint] my jewels; [lively stones-1 Peter 2:5]
and I will spare [have compassion; save] them, as a man spareth [has compassion; saves] his own son that serveth him.

18 Then shall ye [God/Jesus] return, and discern between the righteous and the wicked, between him that serveth God and him that serveth him not.

By the mind of Christ within us, through the word of God, we are to compare spiritual things with spiritual.
Please read Isa. 55:8-9 and then all of 1 Cor. Ch. 2.
 
Last edited:

CTK

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2024
1,594
347
83
73
Albuquerque
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
IMO anti-Christ, has the sense:
o "anti" = "false"
o "Christ" = Hebrew משיח (Messiah) = "anointed one"

I.e. "usurping the title Christ." See 1John 2:18, also 1Thessalonians 2:4.
Do you agree that anyone can be described as an "anti-christ" - because they preach a different gospel?

But, do you agree there can only be one little horn - that preaches a different gospel, claims the place of God on earth, claims to forgive sin, claims divinity, changes God's laws and commandments, changes the path to salvation, blasphems the Word of God, and so much more?

Quite a difference between one who goes against Christ verses the "ONE" identified in Daniel, 7, 8, 9 and 11 as well as in 2 Thessalonians 2, and certainly in Revelation - don't you think?
 
Apr 7, 2026
613
94
28
75
Lexington KY
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
IMO:

The Bible says, "The Lord will come suddenly to His temple." (Malachi 3:1)

Antichrist ("little horn") is a charismatic leader who brokers a peace agreement with Israel and other Middle-Eastern countries. He then oversees rebuilding of the Jewish temple, after which he takes his seat in the temple, professing himself to be God (2Thesalonians 2:4).

1John2:18 notes "many antichrists have come," professing themselves to be liaisons between God and men.

"Little horn" arises some time after the ten horns (i.e. ten middle-eastern countries) arise. See (Daniel 7:24, Revelation 17:12-13).
 
Last edited:

covenantee

Well-Known Member
Feb 22, 2022
8,033
3,566
113
75
Canada
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Matthew 27 does not call the raised saints the 144,000.

Malachi 3 does not identify those remembered by God as the souls under the altar.

Revelation 6 does not say the souls under the altar are all faithful Israelites from the Old Covenant.

The white robes are not identified as the seal of the Holy Spirit.

And John 7:39 does not say that faithful Israelites who had already died were later sealed and became the 144,000.

These connections are being added to the texts rather than stated by them - study and stay within scripture.

Revelation 7 presents the 144,000 as servants sealed before coming judgment, and Revelation 14 presents them as firstfruits who follow the Lamb. That sounds more like a specially prepared company for a prophetic purpose than a complete number of Old Covenant believers who had already died.
Here are the 144,000.
The Church of the Redeemed through all ages from beginning to end.
Immeasurably Grand and Glorious.

The Church and the 144,000

Revelation 7:3-4 describe the 144,000 as “sealed.” That description is reserved in the NT for believers in Christ – His Body and Bride – His Church:

2 Corinthians 1:21-22
Now He who establishes us with you in Christ and anointed us is God, who also sealed us and gave us the Spirit in our hearts as a pledge.

Ephesians 1:13
In Him, you also, after listening to the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation—having also believed, you were sealed in Him with the Holy Spirit of promise,

Ephesians 4:30
Do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption.


The Revelation 7 passage is therefore conveying the insight that the OT Israelitish faithful obedient saints of God are included under the NT banner of the Church. This is further confirmed by the meanings of the names of the listed tribes and substitutes (Levi and Joseph replacing Dan and Ephraim), describing spiritual qualities and experiences of those who comprise the Church:
Judah means “praise” (Genesis 29:35)
Reuben means “see, a Son” (Genesis 29:32)
Gad means “fortunate” (Genesis 30:11)
Asher means “happy” (Genesis 30:13)
Naphtali means “wrestling” (Genesis 30:8)
Manasseh means “forgetting” (Genesis 41:51)
Simeon means “heard” (Genesis 29:33)
Levi means “attached” (Genesis 29:34)
Issachar means “wages” (Genesis 30:18)
Zebulon means “dwelling” (Genesis 30:20)
Joseph means “He will add” (Genesis 30:24)
Benjamin means “Son of the right hand” (Genesis 35:17–18)

Similarly, the meanings of the names of Dan and Ephraim convey the reasons for their exclusion:

Dan means “a serpent by the way”(Genesis 49:17)
Satan in the guise of the serpent was responsible for the fall of mankind in Genesis 3, and for the bruising of Messiah's heel in Scripture's first recorded prophecy of Genesis 3:15. It was the same serpent Satan whose head Messiah bruised at Calvary.

Ephraim means “fruitful in the land of mine affliction” (Genesis 41:52)
The reference to “the land of mine affliction” in Ephraim's name's meaning is to that of Egypt, which in Scripture is both a literal and spiritual reality and symbol of bondage. But the Church, God's Chosen People, do not inhabit a land of spiritual affliction and bondage. Rather, they inhabit the Heavenly Jerusalem on Mount Sion (Hebrews 12:22,23), located in the Heavenly Country that God has prepared for the faithful (Hebrews 11:16).

Of additional significance is the order in which the names are presented, differing from the usual presentation by order of birth. In particular, Judah appears first, in recognition of its role as the tribal progenitor of Christ, the Lion of Judah.

While rebellion and apostasy were repetitive afflictions of the OT Israelites, there were still thousands who remained faithful (1 Kings 19:18). Their number is depicted as 12, a scriptural value representing faithfulness; multiplied by 12, representing the faithful from each of the twelve tribes; multiplied by 1,000 representing the indeterminate but large number (Psalms 50:10; Psalms 91:7; Revelation 5:11) of the total faithful in Israel; thus, 144,000.

Revelation 14 continues the descriptions further reflecting the qualities and experiences of the redeemed – the Church. Absent here is any mention of tribal, ethnic, or other distinctions, thus conveying the reality of the inclusivity and unity of the NT Church which now embraces both Israelite and Gentile. Its number can also be depicted as 12, representing faithfulness; multipled by 12 representing the 12 faithful apostles, who with the prophets comprise the foundation of the NT church, with Christ as the Chief Cornerstone (Ephesians 2:20); multiplied by 1,000 representing the indeterminate but large number of the total faithful in the NT Church; thus, also 144,000.

The NT Church's inclusivity and unity are declared in the following:

Galatians 3:28
There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus.

Ephesians 2:14
For He Himself is our peace, who made both groups into one and broke down the barrier of the dividing wall…

Colossians 3:11
Where there is neither Greek nor Jew, circumcision nor uncircumcision, Barbarian, Scythian, bond nor free: but Christ is all, and in all.


The 144,00 are described as celibate, meaning that as the Bride of Christ, they are not defiled by adultery with the world (James 4:4). They sing a new song of deliverance and victory. They follow Christ wherever He goes. Their residence is heavenly Jerusalem on Mount Zion. (Hebrews 12:22)

No doubt about it…Christ and His Church are written all over the 144,000.