My understanding is the Jesus will resurrect Christians and they will rule on this earth with him in the age to come.
At the end of that age, Jesus will resurrect everybody else and then all will live in God's kingdom in the NEW earth.
I strongly doubt that unbelievers will be involved with the NEW earth. It isn't going to happen. In fact, all of God's love, longsuffering and sacrifice for us, has nothing to do with this earth, or another earth like it.
We shall inherit Everlasting life and immortality in our
earthen bodies, being ourselves
that land of promise, in which we each, with God the Father, who dwells in the Son, do now both dwell in each of us as One,
wherein dwelleth righteousness.
You can't beat that!
After all, Jesus didn't come here to die for this earth, but rather for we who are made from the earth, of which He also personally experienced as mortal flesh, and then resurrected into New life, with immortality.
Through faith in Him, that is HOW we are to "follow" Him, that we may know the power of His resurrection, by being born again of His Holy Spirit, partaking in His divine nature.
All of such are now waiting for the fulness of our resurrection, after His likeness, in the day He returns in all His Glory, in flaming fire.
Try to let this sink in: whosoever hath not the Spirit of Christ, he is none of His. Rom. 8:9.