A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,035
5,039
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Actually, it dates as far back as early as 145 AD, which is a little over 100 years after Jesus walked the earth. Sooo, should we discount Revelation because it was written some 65 years after He ascended?

John 21:25 states emphatically that Jesus did and said MANY things after His Resurrection that were NOT written down. We trust the Sacred Tradition of the Church (2 Thess. 2:15) because Jesus
set it up that way(Matt 16:16-19, 18:15-18, Luke 10:16, John 16:12-15).
So you accept the tradition of burning those accused of witchcraft. Having popes send armies to slaughter Muslims? But all the things you say about Mary do contradict Scripture. so those traditions are lies!

Those traditions were what were handed down by the Apostles and preserved in what is called teh bible.

Paul and Peter warned abour teachings that did not conform to Scripture or back then what was taught by those who laid the foundation of the church.

2 Peter 1:19-21, Gal. 1:6-9, 2 Peter 2:1
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,035
5,039
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You brought up two terms: Catholic Church, and Romanist Church.
What are their differences?
Just make yourself clear before I put up my refutal!
the catholic church (small c) is the organism of all believers in all denominations. The romanist church is the denomination called the roman Catholic Church.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Repeating an assertion five times—and admitting "we don't know exactly from the text WHY"—is not the same thing as answering a rebuttal.

In my last substantive post, I directly addressed your "Heads up" analogy, your murder analogy, your hindsight bias, and your false dilemma. Your reply to all of that was "Ok cool story bro."

Anyone reading the thread can see who actually engaged the arguments and who bowed out with a meme.

When I've already addressed this, and you keep bringing it up as if I haven't, then me mentioning that I've already addressed this is a perfectly fine response to YET ANOTHER demand from you.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
So if it was only a tradition, not backed up by Scripture, we cannot know whether it was a good or bad tradition. She certainly wasn't in the temple at Jerusalem when Gabriel visited her at Nazareth.

When Paul traveled to Berea, he encountered a people who were more noble than the Thessalonians (Acts 17). When Paul - the great apostle himself - preached the gospel, what did the Bereans do? They fact-checked his message to see if what he said was true (Acts 17:11).

Now, what was their standard against which they measured Paul's teaching? They could have used some sort of cultural tradition. They could have used rabbinical teaching. They could have used other works written by well-known people. They could have appealed to their synagogue leaders.

Nope. None of that. What did they use? "Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessalonica; they received the word with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so."

They fact-checked the apostle Paul against the SCRIPTURES. Even though other documents and teachings and traditions may contain truth (some of them may contain a lot of truth, in fact), the ONLY for-sure, 100% reliable, we-all-agree-on-this, source of truth is Scripture.

That's why the proper term isn't "sola" scriptura - it's "prima" scriptura. It's ok that there are other sources of truth out there. But the only one we know FOR SURE is Scripture. So THAT is the standard by which we measure EVERY OTHER TRUTH CLAIM and EVERY OTHER SOURCE.

There's plenty of truth in SOME of the Catholic traditions, and quite obviously, some other Catholic traditions are complete contradictions of Scripture and should be summarily discarded. But the point is that every time a Catholic (lay person or clergy) claims "Tradition", that should be measured against Scripture. Yes, even the pope. If it's good and noble to fact-check the great apostle Paul against Scripture, it's perfectly good and noble to fact check the pope against Scripture too.
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,790
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
So you accept the tradition of burning those accused of witchcraft. Having popes send armies to slaughter Muslims? But all the things you say about Mary do contradict Scripture. so those traditions are lies!
Those things are NOT Traditions. They are flawed human actions, based on fallen human nature.
FAIL . . .
Paul and Peter warned abour teachings that did not conform to Scripture or back then what was taught by those who laid the foundation of the church.
2 Peter 1:19-21, Gal. 1:6-9, 2 Peter 2:1
Please – STUDY your Bible before you vomit out false references from it . . .

In Gal. 1:6 - Paul was saying that they should not preach a Gospel other than the one HE and the others PREACHED.
NOTING about the written Word – just the PREACHING of it.

In 2 Peter 1:19-21 – he states that “... no prophecy of Scripture comes from someone’s own interpretation.”
Again – NOTHING about Sacred Tradition, which is upheld by Scripture itself (2 Thess 2:15, Luke 10:16, 2 Thess. 3:6, 1 Cor. 11:2).

2 Peter 2:1 is about false prophets and says NOTHING about the written Word being usurped by Sacred Tradition.

Do your
HOMEWORK . . .
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,790
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Your ignorance not with standing, you err.
In teh NT adelphe or its derivatives is used of those:

Lexicon :: Strong's G80 - adelphos​

ἀδελφός​

Transliteration
adelphos (Key)
Pronunciation
ad-el-fos'
Part of Speech
masculine noun
Root Word (Etymology)
From ἄλφα (G1) (as a connective particle) and delphus (the womb)

KJV Translation Count — Total: 346x
The KJV translates Strong's G80 in the following manner: brethren (226x), brother (113x), brother's (6x), brother's way (1x).
Outline of Biblical Usage [?]
  1. a brother, whether born of the same two parents or only of the same father or mother
  2. having the same national ancestor, belonging to the same people, or countryman
  3. any fellow or man
  4. a fellow believer, united to another by the bond of affection
  5. an associate in employment or office
  6. brethren in Christ
But neve4r cousins or uncles. I trust Strongs Greek more than your Romanist indoctrination!
And a compilation from an AI search:

Like
Dislike

In Greek, adelphos (ἀδελφός) means “brother,” originally referring to someone from the same womb, and by extension a fellow member of a community or faith.​

Detailed Explanation
Core Meaning​

  • Literal meaning: “Brother,” a male sibling born of the same parents or sharing one parent. Bible Hub Bible Hub
  • Etymology: From a- (“together”) + delphus (“womb”), literally “from the same womb.” Bible Hub Bible Hub

Extended and Figurative Uses​

  • Fellow believer / member of the same faith community: Early Christians used adelphos to refer to other Christians as spiritual brothers.
  • Countryman / member of the same people: Used in Jewish and early Christian contexts to refer to someone of the same nation or ethnic group.
  • General fellow human: In some teachings of Jesus, adelphos can mean “neighbor” or “fellow
Sorry but you fail again!
YOUR claim that this NEVER applies to cousins or uncles is patently FALSE.

The Septuagint was a Greek translation of the OT – and the VERY text that the NT writers alluded to over 200 references. In the Septuagint

- In Gen. 14:14, Lot is called Abraham’s "brother", even though Abraham was his UNCLE. (Gen. 11:26–28).

- In Gen. 29:15, Jacob is referred to as the "brother" of his UNCLE Laban.

- Brothers Kish and Eleazar were the sons of Mahli. Kish had sons of his own, but Eleazar’s daughters married their "Adelphoi”, the sons of Kish - who were actually their COUSINS (1 Chr. 23:21–22).

Don’t use words like “Never” unless you’ve done your
HOMEWORK . . .
 

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,636
2,911
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
This
In Gal. 1:6 - Paul was saying that they should not preach a Gospel other than the one HE and the others PREACHED.
NOTING about the written Word – just the PREACHING of it.
LOL
 

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,790
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Lets review again! If as you contend she was a temple virgin (no such thing) and was already consecrated to Stay a virgin, she would have answered in the future imperative which she did not!
Nonsense.

AGAIN, I give you the statement from the ex-drinker or ex-smoker:
“I DO NOT drink.”
“I DO NOT smoke.”

NO
need to say, I won’t drink again when I DO NOT is sufficient . . .

I do not know A man ( the indefinite article must be added here) is the natural and normal response for a girl who was not yet sexually active!
That's because you're obsessed with sex - and NOT the Spiritual . . .
You did by claiming she was a temple virgin! there was no such thing. And what evidence do you present to show Mary's parents consecrated her to a non existent position and made her a permanent virgin??? Women did not live in teh temple and Mary lived 64 miles away! Hard to ber tem[ple virgin if you can't live in teh temple and you lived 65 miles away. Your ignorance of Jewish history is glaring!
From @Beecham’s post, which you obviously didn’t read . . .

(1)Later Jewish and early Christian texts do record young girls weaving sacred curtains for the Temple. Rabbinic texts record that young girls were brought in for specific projects, such as the Mishnah (Shekalim 8:5), which states that 82 young girls ("virgins") wove the massive curtains for the Temple.

(2)Later Jewish accounts, such as 2 Baruch and Pesikta Rabbati, mention VIRGINS who wove silk and gold for the Temple throwing their work into the flames when the Romans destroyed Jerusalem in
70 AD.

THIS
is why there are many works of art depicting the Annunciation of Mary, where she is presented as 'weaving' lady.

And there is absolutely 0 evidence prior to the 2nd half of the 2nd century to even imply Mary was all you hypothesize!
WRONG.

I already educated you about the fact that Protoevangelium dates as far back as 140 AD – which is BEFORE the 2nd half of the 2nd century . . .

The Pharisees held to tradition and they were condemend by Jesus!
Jesus condemned THEIR traditions – NOT their sacred Traditions.
For example - THEY created temple tax laws that they placed above Scripture and Sacred Tradition. There is not a SINGLE Catholic Tradition that is considered ABOVE Scripture.

While we’re at it, though – show me where the Bible teaches the FALSE Protestant invention oof
Sola Scriptura . . .
I wish you did for then you would not hold to Mary as sinless in action and thought, nor staying a virgin nor anyof the litany of titles tradition and not the Word of God gives her.
Don’t really understand your question the way it’s worded – but I already gave you Biblical evidence of Mary’s Sinlessness and Perpetual Virginity.

YOUR rejection of this evidence is on YOU – not
me . . .
 

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
738
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
When I've already addressed this, and you keep bringing it up as if I haven't, then me mentioning that I've already addressed this is a perfectly fine response to YET ANOTHER demand from you.

Your previous post introduced two brand-new analogies ("Heads up" and a murder video) and a false dilemma—none of which you had addressed before, and all of which I refuted before you replied "Ok cool story bro."
Readers can judge for themselves whether claiming "I already addressed it" counts as a rebuttal.
 

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Your previous post introduced two brand-new analogies ("Heads up" and a murder video) and a false dilemma—none of which you had addressed before, and all of which I refuted before you replied "Ok cool story bro."
Readers can judge for themselves whether claiming "I already addressed it" counts as a rebuttal.

I've addressed all this in numerous different ways. Trying to use different ways of explaining it. That doesn't make them NEW arguments.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
I've addressed all this in numerous different ways. Trying to use different ways of explaining it. That doesn't make them NEW arguments.
That also means you have been reproved all this in numerous different ways, and also by different members, at least: three!
 

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
850
154
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
This
In Gal. 1:6 - Paul was saying that they should not preach a Gospel other than the one HE and the others PREACHED.
NOTING about the written Word – just the PREACHING of it.
LOL
What do you believe are the actual saving gospel verses that Gal 1:11-12 Christ taught to Paul who then sent Paul Gal 2:2 to teach Peter ?
 

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
738
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
I've addressed all this in numerous different ways. Trying to use different ways of explaining it. That doesn't make them NEW arguments.

Whether you call them old or new, you never answered my latest rebuttal to any of them—you just replied "Ok cool story bro."
 

David Lamb

Well-Known Member
Feb 21, 2025
1,333
920
113
77
Paignton
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Yes, the canonical Bible does not mention virgin girls living in the Jerusalem.
But things not included in the Canon do not mean no such tradition and not true.

(1)Later Jewish and early Christian texts do record young girls weaving sacred curtains for the Temple. Rabbinic texts record that young girls were brought in for specific projects, such as the Mishnah (Shekalim 8:5), which states that 82 young girls ("virgins") wove the massive curtains for the Temple.

(2)Later Jewish accounts, such as 2 Baruch and Pesikta Rabbati, mention virgins who wove silk and gold for the Temple throwing their work into the flames when the Romans destroyed Jerusalem in 70 AD.

In many artworks depicting the Annunciation of Mary, she is presented as 'weaving' lady:
View attachment 93666
View attachment 93667
View attachment 93668
always having weaving basket, spinning threads at her side.
OK, but even assuming those traditions are true, weaving curtains for the temple is not "being consecrated to the temple," or even living in the temple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLT63

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
That also means you have been reproved all this in numerous different ways, and also by different members, at least: three!

Well, different people have said different things, I'll grant you that.

You guys do get that you base all this weird Mary exaltation stuff on the protoevangelium of James, which is a forgery, which contains numerous inconsistencies with, and outright contradictions of, Scripture, which was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405 AD, and was such a train wreck that when they were considering which books to include in the New Testament canon, it was so bad that it didn't even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned. The protoevangelium didn't even get to that point it's so bad.

At some point that historical reality HAS to be at least a bit unsettling to you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Lamb

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Whether you call them old or new, you never answered my latest rebuttal to any of them—you just replied "Ok cool story bro."

That's about all it deserved. -shrug-

I mean, look, we've been round and round and round on this. At some point you guys are going to have to address the fact that all your exaltation of Mary doctrinal stuff is based on a complete loser of a document (protoevangelium of James). It's because of that, that you read all these Biblical passages the way you do. Without that document, nobody today reads those texts like you guys do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Lamb

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
738
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
You are arguing against a point I never made—and completely missing the actual comparison between our two views.

I am not denying Mary’s reaction. We both see what is "on video": Mary heard "You will conceive and bear a son" and asked, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"

The debate isn't whether She reacted—it’s which explanation actually makes sense of Her reaction:
  • Your explanation requires believing that Mary fully expected to have normal sexual relations with Joseph after her wedding, yet upon hearing simple future-tense words ("You will conceive"), She inexplicably jumped to the conclusion that it would happen before Her wedding—for reasons you openly admit are nowhere in the text ("we don't know exactly from the text WHY... IT IS IRRELEVANT...").

  • My explanation accounts for Her reaction directly from Her own words without needing any unexplained guesswork: if Mary intended to remain a virgin, then any announcement that She would conceive a son immediately raises the question, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"—regardless of timing.
That’s also why your "Heads up!" analogy fails. In English, "Heads up!" is a recognized warning of immediate danger—which is why someone ducks. By contrast, "You will conceive and bear a son" is standard future-tense birth language (identical to Judges 13:3, which referred to a normal future marital birth). There is nothing in those words that signals immediacy to a woman expecting normal marital relations.

And your murder analogy actually proves my point: if two detectives see the same event "on video," and Detective A’s theory relies on an unexplained, invisible motive ("it's irrelevant why he did it"), while Detective B’s theory explains the reaction directly from the suspect's own stated words, Detective B has the stronger explanation.

The fact that Mary conceived soon afterward doesn't solve your problem either—that’s hindsight bias. You’re taking what the reader learns later in Luke 1:35–38 and projecting it backward into Mary’s mind before Gabriel ever explained how the conception would happen. At the moment Mary asked "How can this occur, since I know not man?" (Luke 1:34), all She had heard were simple future-tense words.

If your reading lacks any textual reason why Mary would infer an immediate pre-marital pregnancy from future-tense words in the first place—when, according to you, She expected marital relations with Her husband—then we have no reason to assume that’s what She inferred, especially when Her own words ("since I know not man") already give us a clear, coherent reason without inventing invisible cues.

That’s why I reject your false dilemma: both of your options assume Mary was guessing about timing ("pregnant soon"). She wasn't guessing about timing at all—She was responding to a promise of motherhood as someone who did not intend to "know man."

I mean, look, we've been round and round and round on this. At some point you guys are going to have to address the fact that all your exaltation of Mary doctrinal stuff is based on a complete loser of a document (protoevangelium of James). It's because of that, that you read all these Biblical passages the way you do. Without that document, nobody today reads those texts like you guys do.

Notice that I never once mentioned or appealed to the Protoevangelium of James—not a single time.

Every point I made came straight from Luke 1:34, Judges 13:3, and Luke 1:35–38. Changing the subject to an apocryphal text I didn't cite is just another way to dodge the actual textual question you still haven't answered from the text:
  • Why would a woman you say expected normal marital relations with Joseph hear simple future-tense words ("You will conceive and bear a son") and immediately ask, "How can this occur, since I know not man?"
That’s why early Christian thinkers like Gregory of Nyssa and Augustine drew that exact conclusion straight from Luke 1:34 itself—not from the Protoevangelium.

Blaming a document I never used doesn't answer the text of Luke 1. Whenever you're ready to engage what I actually wrote instead of shrugging it off, it's still sitting right above.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
322
26
28
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
OK, but even assuming those traditions are true, weaving curtains for the temple is not "being consecrated to the temple," or even living in the temple.
Your dismissal signals a sola scriptura standard: if it isn't explicitly stated in canonical Scripture as historical fact, it doesn't count.
'Non-canonical legend' isn't the same thing as 'irrelevant.'


Apologists and theologians rarely point to a verse that says 'Mary consecrated to the temple.' Instead, they build a typological and theological case from various key passages showing how Mary is set apart for God and how she bears the presence of God in a way that echoes the Temple/sanctuary.

While the Bible dose not have a verse clearly saying "being consecrated to the temple," , both the Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church hold the Feast Day of Presentation of Mary, and it is TODAY (November the 21st)

Screenshot+2025-10-26+at+1.45.47-PM-1920w.png




If the Romn Catholic Church is corrupted and teaches false doctrines (as Protestants always claim), why should the Eastern Orthodox Churches teach the same 'false doctrine' with the Roman Catholic Church???
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Active Member
Jun 23, 2026
318
111
43
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Notice that I never once mentioned or appealed to the Protoevangelium of James—not a single time.

Didn't say you did.

But it's where the whole fantastic Mary story comes from. You know that, right? The only reason YOU believe the fantastic Mary legend is because of that document, that over time became THE Catholic version of events, which is why you read that fantastic Mary legend into the Bible today. Not because the Bible itself teaches this fantastic Mary legend.

Every point I made came straight from Luke 1:34, Judges 13:3, and Luke 1:35–38. Changing the subject to an apocryphal text I didn't cite is just another way to dodge the actual textual question you still haven't answered from the text:
  • Why would a woman you say expected normal marital relations with Joseph hear simple future-tense words ("You will conceive and bear a son") and immediately ask, "How can this occur, since I know not man?"

I have literally answered this question numerous times. She asked it because she believed for some reason that Gabriel meant that she would be pregnant SOON, when she knew that she wouldn't consummate her marriage by having sex for some time still, and even though she wasn't a biologist, she sure as heck knew how babies were made. So it was an absolutely natural question to ask.

Turns out, her belief on that score was 100% correct, because that is exactly what happened.

That’s why early Christian thinkers like Gregory of Nyssa and Augustine drew that exact conclusion straight from Luke 1:34 itself—not from the Protoevangelium.

Blaming a document I never used doesn't answer the text of Luke 1. Whenever you're ready to engage what I actually wrote instead of shrugging it off, it's still sitting right above.