Muslim Beheadings

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Hidden In Him

Well-Known Member
May 10, 2018
10,600
10,883
113
59
Lafayette, LA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
so it helps a bunch, but you would not be moved by it?

It helped a bunch to understand you. That was square one, remember? I think it may take a miracle for me to be moved by your posts, but I'm still remaining open to the possibility, LoL.
well, that would be a diff dynamic from another believer who had just met you and found out you were a believer too,
attempting to then convert you bc they felt you got it all wrong and still needed their help to "find Jesus" imo

What is this fixation on everyone helping people find Jesus. I didn't need anyone's help to find Jesus. Why are you hammering away on this point incessantly?
then nevermind where you think you are going personally, why is Zeus/Jupiter in our Bibles as our Father

What on bloody earth is this?... Look, I like you, ok. I have no problems with you. But I'm not on here trying to socialize and ramble with people. Comments like this are coming so wildly out of left field to me that I feel compelled to tell you I'm out. Again, its not that I don't want to converse, but this line of discussion is not my kind of thing, Byrd. Keep in mind, I am not a social being, and unequivocally NOT someone who enjoys debate for debate's sake. I am a very religious man, NOT a nominal Christian by any stretch of the imagination, and focused primarily on the accurate interpretation and application of both the Old and New Testament.

Like I said, you and I are so diametrically opposed in the way we approach conversations that I'm not sure we even speaking the same language half the time.

Let me bow out for now. Maybe we can pick something up again in the future where you and I have a better chance at a meeting of the minds. Blessings in Christ.
 

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
What is this fixation on everyone helping people find Jesus. I didn't need anyone's help to find Jesus. Why are you hammering away on this point incessantly?
bc many Christian believers have somehow got the idea that Muslims need their help to find Jesus, HiH
What on bloody earth is this?
that is most likely you being still unaware that Zeus is in your Bible as "God."
i guess it is xlated "Jupiter" in later trannies, but search will lead you to either one anyway, or even "is Zeus in the Bible" @ google
Again, its not that I don't want to converse, but this line of discussion is not my kind of thing, Byrd.
ah, then imo avoid the Bible like the plague lol, bc before i am done satan will be God's servant, and absolutely no enemy of yours--or at least not mine, go with your gut there i guess--and etc, ok. Life, more abundantly and Death More Abundantly do not mix imo, they just share the same lexicon
I am a very religious man, NOT a nominal Christian by any stretch of the imagination, and focused primarily on the accurate interpretation and application of both the Old and New Testament.
from the Hegelian pov, certainly. Nothing wrong with that, but there are just more steps on that ladder, ok. Scripture was not written from the Hegelian pov, but with it in mind, and fwiw if you even accept as a working premise that our Scripture was written from the Eastern Dialectic and then start reading from there, you will not even need to ask for proof, and you will not ever go back. The bottom link on pg1 has a fam face, and a simple explanation, fwiw. It's around here somewhere too though
Scripture was written in the Eastern Dialectic - Google Search
 
Last edited:

Naomi25

Well-Known Member
Aug 10, 2016
3,199
1,801
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
ah well, we have a means to determine this, right, and we are surrounded by a cloud of witnesses, Naomi, and International crowd now right, and i am not afraid to "lose" a debate bc then i learn something; so bam now is the time imo, if my understanding is inferior in that area--which it surely still is ok, no arg there--then start your argument!
:)

bbyrd! :rolleyes: This is my point! What argument? How on earth is someone supposed to step back from a conversation with you and go "I know what this guy is arguing for...or against! I will dazzle him with my brilliant argument by showing him x,y or z".
No....you're too busy asking yourself "what did he just say? What did that sentence just mean? What was that in reference to? Is he still talking about that, or has he moved onto something else? Where on earth did that come from, it doesn't seem to have anything to do with our conversation." Or...my favorite, "that simply doesn't make a lick of sense, there IS nothing I can say to that, for or against, because he may as well have just said 'elephants fly' right in the middle of a conversation about the soverignty of God"...or something equally bizare. And in among it all, you're busy trying to insert punctuation, interpret trendy internet short-hand (fine, call me old fashioned), and follow the actual flow of your speech, which tends to flow together confusingly.

So, for goodness sake, when someone struggles to figure out your nonsense, It's rather...absurd...that you then go ahead and claim that peoples confusion and your remarkable 'clarity' is due to your superior "connection" to God.

well, which one is it Naomi? :)
but i've been thinking on this more, or really it just came to me, that...i'm overeducated or something, ok Naomi, bc i have no social skills or whatever, and you are asking me basically to post in proper English, right, believing that you might comprehend it more easily? But IRL it doesn't work like that, ok, i'd be tossing out obsequiouses and onomatopoeias or whatever and then...well, it's worse, ok, not better, and i don't mean for me
Wait? You're too smart to use proper English? You using proper English wouldn't help us poor little plebs? The fact that you can use big words should frighten us into bowing before your obviously superior intellect and give you all the grace you need to be opaque and strange in your arguments? Having no social skills equals poor typing skills? If you're "overeducated" you cannot struggle with written communication too much, surely. Unless its self education, in which case, who's to say you are more or less 'educated' than the people you are talking to? Again, your ego is seriously taking flight.


ty, i'm aware that this still needs improvement, and that is useful stuff for me. Learning to speak the language of the hearer likely comes more naturally to you, you have been through the fire now, you have kids, right? And so you are a mom, and you had no choice imo, something like that. I ordered my early life in such a way so as to avoid all that on purpose, and now i am paying for it i guess
Ok...this. You say that you're still learning, alright, maybe this will help. You say "learning to speak the language of the hearer.." do you mean that English is not your first language? If so, perhaps you should just say so. You follow this up with "you have been through the fire now, you have kids right?" Ok...first...HOW does going through fire have anything to do with speaking a language? Be it first, second or what have you? Second, how does a language or 'going through a fire' have anything to do with having kids?? None of this makes sense in the context of the conversation.
Then you finish with "I ordered my early life in such a way so as to avoid all that on purpose". Are you refering to language still? Or going through fire? Or having kids? But again, how does avoiding having kids mean that you now struggle with language?

Do you see my points here? You may feel like saying the obvious is, well...saying the obvious. But sometimes you need to lay it out, then wrap it up with your point. Just moving straight to your point will often leave people confused and wondering where they are.

yes, surely a valid perspective ok. Imo this is an irrelevant topic, so i was being more dramatic to make a point, mostly, and also trying to speak more generally ok, i didn't necessarily mean for some comment i made to be taken personally. But i would examine any "Muslims need my help to find Jesus" beliefs, ok, and even extend that to "everyone" imo, lest you actually make enemies that would have been friends;

you need Jesus bad imo, Naomi, and i am here to lead you to Him ok

This right here is another astounding proof that you just don't take scripture literally. The bible tells us that God would have ALL mankind come to him. By saying "eh...not everyone needs Jesus", you're, in fact, saying that some are fine going to hell.
The Bible teaches it's one or the other. The only way to heaven is Christ. If you are not in Christ, you are on your way to hell.
So, tell me.....how should I let a man, who doesn't really respect the Bible, or much of what God or Christ says, lead me to Christ?
You have this wonderful way of doing things, that I don't know if you are aware of...if it's deliberate or not. You throw something out there...a statement, a fact, an accusation. And when you are called on it, proved incorrect, you just shrug and say, "well I didn't mean it anyway." Or, "That wasn't my point," or "I don't really believe it anyway, I was just bringing it up".
When you put that together with the things you believe (or don't believe), and I can't quite decide if you are one of the most deceived people on this board, or one of the biggest deceivers. All I know is that I get the most disquieted feeling in my spirit when I read the things you say.
 

Naomi25

Well-Known Member
Aug 10, 2016
3,199
1,801
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
yes, and so now you believe you have been led to go and talk to ppl and convert them, bc after all that is what you even read, yes?
all i can say there is that there's more rungs on that ladder, ok
and what you believe right now is fine imo, i mean look you are here seeking a better understanding every day, just like me i guess
Mmmm. Yet, I notice you don't say, like in your previous argument, that the bible doesn't actually say to do this.
Now you're just trying to claim that my interpretation is faulty. Notice how everytime the bible doesn't say what you want it to say you just try and twist the text like its a wax nose, then claim your understanding and connection to God is superior?
Golly. If only we were all as lucky as you.


all i can say here is that there is more than one interpretation for this, "witness" might be defined differently, etc.
but i am not here trying to tell you to stop doing as you feel led, wadr, bam keep um "witnessing" as best you know how, nothing wrong with that at all imo

Well, pretty much every translation puts it as "witnesses". And pretty much every time it's used in scripture, it's used at "witness". Interestingly, the one time it's often translated as something else, it's used at the stoning of Stephen, when it calls him a "Martyr" in Acts 22:20. That's because the word, while actually meaning "witness", is "martus", where we get the word martyr from. Which, if you recall the beginning of our conversation about this, also rather neatly fits into the notion that God calls us out into the world, often to suffer for his cause. As many Christians have done.
 

Naomi25

Well-Known Member
Aug 10, 2016
3,199
1,801
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
that is most likely you being still unaware that Zeus is in your Bible as "God."
i guess it is xlated "Jupiter" in later trannies, but search will lead you to either one anyway, or even "is Zeus in the Bible" @ google

I've heard some heretical things from you. But this? This is outright Blasphemy.
 

Hidden In Him

Well-Known Member
May 10, 2018
10,600
10,883
113
59
Lafayette, LA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I've heard some heretical things from you. But this? This is outright Blasphemy.
@bbyrd009 please backup this assertion.

He was likely referring to Acts 14:8–13, where the people living in Lystra saw the Apostle Paul heal a lame man, and so they considered Paul and Barnabas to be gods and identified Paul with Hermes and Barnabas with Zeus.

I would have picked up that this what he meant if not for the subtle twists he puts on things, LoL. His exact quote to me was this:
QUOTE="bbyrd009, post: 478901, member: 7326"]then nevermind where you think you are going personally, why is Zeus/Jupiter in our Bibles as our Father[/QUOTE].

He identifies in his profile as a Christian, so the words "why is Zeus/Jupiter in our Bibles as our Father (capitalized)" suggested to me he was saying the Bible says Zeus/Jupiter is our Heavenly Father.

I'm not trying to get him in trouble for saying it. I'm just saying the turn of words he uses sometimes makes me wonder if he is "trying to make me think" or just deliberately messing with my head, LoL.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nancy

lforrest

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Admin
Aug 10, 2012
5,601
6,858
113
Faith
Christian
He was likely referring to Acts 14:8–13, where the people living in Lystra saw the Apostle Paul heal a lame man, and so they considered Paul and Barnabas to be gods and identified Paul with Hermes and Barnabas with Zeus.

I would have picked up that this what he meant if not for the subtle twists he puts on things, LoL. His exact quote to me was this:

He identifies in his profile as a Christian, so the words "why is Zeus/Jupiter in our Bibles as our Father (capitalized)" suggested to me he was saying the Bible says Zeus/Jupiter is our Heavenly Father.

I'm not trying to get him in trouble for saying it. I'm just saying the turn of words he uses sometimes makes me wonder if he is "trying to make me think" or just deliberately messing with my head, LoL.

Unless he can backup his claims he is already in trouble.

Acts 14:8-13 is about the local's belief that some apostles were gods after seeing them heal someone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nancy and bbyrd009

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
and your remarkable 'clarity' is due to your superior "connection" to God.
ha, i wish lol.
So fwiw reading Scripture dialectically anyone can do, but that doesn't mean i get all of the inferences yet, by any means.
Sorry if i inferred otherwise
Wait? You're too smart to use proper English? You using proper English wouldn't help us poor little plebs? The fact that you can use big words should frighten us into bowing before your obviously superior intellect and give you all the grace you need to be opaque and strange in your arguments?
basically yes, to all of it; as i said, it makes it worse, not better
but i think i'm being pretty clear that imo all i have is an o
If you're "overeducated" you cannot struggle with written communication too much, surely.
well, you might see that any writing style will be received differently by different people, right, so it seems to me at least that my choices then become to condemn you for your lack of hearing, condemn myself for my lack of communication skills, or apologize sincerely and recognize that i can in fact speak differently to different people, or "become all things to all people," and start learning how to do that despite my past preferences.

so i am still learning this "hearing" thing too, i mean it isn't as though you hadn't given me plenty of clues that i was not being "all things to all people" in my posts, huh; so i appreciate it, and i'll try harder at this ok
Ok...first...HOW does going through fire have anything to do with speaking a language? Be it first, second or what have you? Second, how does a language or 'going through a fire' have anything to do with having kids?? None of this makes sense in the context of the conversation.
Then you finish with "I ordered my early life in such a way so as to avoid all that on purpose". Are you refering to language still? Or going through fire? Or having kids? But again, how does avoiding having kids mean that you now struggle with language?
ah, well i thought at the time that the Q "what could God tell you about your kids that you do not already know as a mother" would tie those together; meaning you understand that one of your kids speaks...uses English differently than another, but you understand them both, right, or maybe you don't really "understand" a certain one, but you at least recognize that they are Si...speaking a different language than you?
Do you see my points here? You may feel like saying the obvious is, well...saying the obvious. But sometimes you need to lay it out, then wrap it up with your point. Just moving straight to your point will often leave people confused and wondering where they are.
this is verifying for me, so i appreciate the witness here. This is about my 3rd time around this track lol, and for what it's worth i've tried a couple different things, just asking questions, speaking as generally as possible, a few other things.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Helen and Nancy

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
This right here is another astounding proof that you just don't take scripture literally. The bible tells us that God would have ALL mankind come to him. By saying "eh...not everyone needs Jesus", you're, in fact, saying that some are fine going to hell.
The Bible teaches it's one or the other. The only way to heaven is Christ. If you are not in Christ, you are on your way to hell.
"after you literally die" being understood there, right Naomi?
So, tell me.....how should I let a man, who doesn't really respect the Bible, or much of what God or Christ says, lead me to Christ?
exactly! So now you can imagine how they feel, see?
When you put that together with the things you believe (or don't believe), and I can't quite decide if you are one of the most deceived people on this board, or one of the biggest deceivers.
why can't i be both :D
All I know is that I get the most disquieted feeling in my spirit when I read the things you say.
awesome, that is just what i was going for Naomi.
Determinists seeking Death More Abundantly here, we are now on equal ground, see, we both have a Resource to argue from, and we're surrounded by a cloud of witnesses, right.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Helen

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
Mmmm. Yet, I notice you don't say, like in your previous argument, that the bible doesn't actually say to do this.
Now you're just trying to claim that my interpretation is faulty.
well, that can certainly be inferred from a certain pov, with English scribes helping out, sure; i don't mean to say otherwise. But we have gone over this "witness" thing before, who would be calling you to account for the hope that is in you, after all, Naomi? The way it is pitched to us those would be strangers, right, maybe acquaintances, people we are "witnessing" to? But see how that will not hold up in court?
Notice how everytime the bible doesn't say what you want it to say you just try and twist the text like its a wax nose, then claim your understanding and connection to God is superior?
no, sorry, could you give an example? ty
 
B

brakelite

Guest
One thing we can cleave to when reading scripture which may counter the dialectic approach bbrd sees, is to hold Jesus as the absolute focal Truth in all scripture. The center and hub about which the spokes of our reasoning and our limited understanding of the thought processes of the writers may be conveying...Jesus never changes...the same yesterday, today, and forever.
@bbyrd009 Naomi isn't alone trying to grapple with your posts. I love the challenge you present, but I gotta confess I give up more times than I can claim to grasp fully the direction you are coming from...let alone going to. I am sure you and I would have a very interesting conversation in person...but I think there might need to be an interpreter...or even someone who can sign?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helen and Nancy

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
Well, pretty much every translation puts it as "witnesses". And pretty much every time it's used in scripture, it's used at "witness". Interestingly, the one time it's often translated as something else, it's used at the stoning of Stephen, when it calls him a "Martyr" in Acts 22:20. That's because the word, while actually meaning "witness", is "martus", where we get the word martyr from. Which, if you recall the beginning of our conversation about this, also rather neatly fits into the notion that God calls us out into the world, often to suffer for his cause. As many Christians have done.
nice imo
 

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
One thing we can cleave to when reading scripture which may counter the dialectic approach bbrd sees, is to hold Jesus as the absolute focal Truth in all scripture. The center and hub about which the spokes of our reasoning and our limited understanding of the thought processes of the writers may be conveying...Jesus never changes...the same yesterday, today, and forever.
@bbyrd009 Naomi isn't alone trying to grapple with your posts. I love the challenge you present, but I gotta confess I give up more times than I can claim to grasp fully the direction you are coming from...let alone going to. I am sure you and I would have a very interesting conversation in person...but I think there might need to be an interpreter...or even someone who can sign?
ah, well as long as you are trying to "counter" a dialectic approach i'm not sure what might help, sorry.
Tbh i would just put me on ignore? Or ask for explanations that would pin me down, is what i would do i guess
 

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
I've heard some heretical things from you. But this? This is outright Blasphemy.

@bbyrd009 please backup this assertion.
He was likely referring to Acts 14:8–13, where the people living in Lystra saw the Apostle Paul heal a lame man, and so they considered Paul and Barnabas to be gods and identified Paul with Hermes and Barnabas with Zeus.

I would have picked up that this what he meant if not for the subtle twists he puts on things, LoL. His exact quote to me was this:
QUOTE="bbyrd009, post: 478901, member: 7326"]then nevermind where you think you are going personally, why is Zeus/Jupiter in our Bibles as our Father
.
He identifies in his profile as a Christian, so the words "why is Zeus/Jupiter in our Bibles as our Father (capitalized)" suggested to me he was saying the Bible says Zeus/Jupiter is our Heavenly Father.

I'm not trying to get him in trouble for saying it. I'm just saying the turn of words he uses sometimes makes me wonder if he is "trying to make me think" or just deliberately messing with my head, LoL.
well, the theme is further carried to Unknown God when dealing with the Ninevites, and i guess the point here is not to attempt to make Zeus into God for Christians, but to include those who thought that Barnabas was Zeus, the same way the Ninevites were "included" @ "Unknown God."

so, i am not trying to lead you into Zeus worship, ok, but if you would contemplate the irony in a professed Christian who is not aware of the Cult of Sol Invictus at all, determinedly pursuing Death, More Abundantly, suggesting that someone suggesting a Christian consider their spiritual "death" @ baptism and Life, more abundantly at their resurrection--when they come up out of the water iow--to be deceived, if you would
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helen and Nancy
B

brakelite

Guest
ah, well as long as you are trying to "counter" a dialectic approach i'm not sure what might help, sorry.
Tbh i would just put me on ignore? Or ask for explanations that would pin me down, is what i would do i guess
First, I have never put anyone on ignore in all my time on forums. I am too interested in people and their worldviews...and of course if in some way graciously contribute to their discussion. Trying to pin you down is like catching the wind. I am not an intellectual. No theology training...no college education...no degrees...not even a trade certificate. Four years high school. That's it. So I do my best to understand people, and hopefully in my responses try not to offend or unnecessarily turn them away. I see a dialectic approach to scripture to be a counter intuitive response to truth. I know from previous conversations that you believe any absolute truth is missing from scripture, and your reasoning, I think, believes everything is fluid, so any current grasp on Bible teaching may change tomorrow, and still be truth. Yes? Or am I chasing the rabbit down the wrong hole? I can understand that, but only in the beholders mind right? He believes it is truth, thus it is truth. To him. Not necessarily to anyone else. They have their own truth. So in a sense there are many truths. And pinning truth down to just one avenue of thought is in your view utterly impossible? And therefore not worth pursuing? So one wonders why you come here to discuss if finding real answers is only a temporary exercise and can provide only temporary solace and hope?
Now take the sermon on the munt as an example. You believe that Jesus was speaking dialectically? That our western minds cannot grasp what He was saying? Or that our modern interpretation is different to what HIs hearers understood at the time? I guess that in a sense you may be right...but here's the thing. In matters of importance, such as the nature of God...the way of salvation...moral principles...prophecy warning against sin and promising a resurrection from the dead...such teachings such as these, the holy Spirit present in believers can cut through the fog and bring truth as it is in Christ...the way, Truth, and life. That so many in the church cannot agree on everything, and "thus all have their own truth", is testament or witness not to the absence of truth, but the absence of the Spirit of understanding in the individual believer. So is it wrong to maintain we have the truth> Is it wrong to maintain that I believe what I have is the truth, and therefore others are wrong? Yes and no. I believe I have the truth. I also believe I may be wrong. And I'm open to correction. Meanwhile, until proved otherwise, I will cling to what I have. Now I don't believe that is dialectic at all is it. To claim one can be immune to "every wind of doctrine" is unacceptable right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helen and Pisteuo
B

brakelite

Guest
well, the theme is further carried to Unknown God when dealing with the Ninevites, and i guess the point here is not to attempt to make Zeus into God for Christians, but to include those who thought that Barnabas was Zeus, the same way the Ninevites were "included" @ "Unknown God."
The unkown God was actually connected to the Athenians, not the Ninevites, but no biggie. The rest of your post I am still trying to decipher. But give me time, I may get it. LOL
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helen and Nancy

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
Trying to pin you down is like catching the wind.
high praise to me, bl.

I don't know anything, ok, maybe that is why? If you even find a conclusion by me here lemme know if you would, so i can go fix it, ty
I see a dialectic approach to scripture to be a counter intuitive response to truth.
this is good, a good pov imo; if you have defined "truth" at least, certainly. So, what is the definition of "truth" here that everyone can/will agree on? ty
believes everything is fluid, so any current grasp on Bible teaching may change tomorrow, and still be truth. Yes?
categorically, yes. But if you have some Quote or demo or thought experiment that suggests otherwise, i am open to the possibility, too. Iow spit some truth that provides a diff pov and let's see ok
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Helen

bbyrd009

Groper
Nov 30, 2016
33,943
12,081
113
Ute City, COLO
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States Minor Outlying Islands
Or am I chasing the rabbit down the wrong hole? I can understand that, but only in the beholders mind right? He believes it is truth, thus it is truth. To him. Not necessarily to anyone else. They have their own truth. So in a sense there are many truths. And pinning truth down to just one avenue of thought is in your view utterly impossible?
um, this last sentence, "pinning truth to an avenue of thought is impossible," is like a...bad frame imo, or i mean can you rephrase this Q? ty
then i can give a better reply to
And therefore not worth pursuing?
ok?
So one wonders why you come here to discuss if finding real answers is only a temporary exercise and can provide only temporary solace and hope?
ah, ok, bc finding real answers is only a temporary exercise and can provide only temporary solace and hope, bl. imo.
As per "He who says he knows anything does not yet know as he ought."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helen