This bears repeating...
The context of "filthy rags" righteousness is NOT a statement that destroys human righteousness...it is an admission of guilt about what certain people were doing. What OT people could compare with was a
true human righteousness compared with
a false human righteousness. All within the power of the flesh. Whether it was coming from the outer man or the inner man.
No one was comparing God's righteousness with a human righteousness at that point. It was comparing what WE do with what is possible to do. Jesus didn't come to call the righteous to repentance...but sinners.
Notice this...
Is. 64:5 Thou meetest him that rejoiceth and worketh righteousness, those that remember thee in thy ways: behold, thou art wroth; for we have sinned: in those is continuance, and we shall be saved.
6 But we are all as an unclean thing, and all our righteousnesses are as filthy rags; and we all do fade as a leaf; and our iniquities, like the wind, have taken us away.
What Isaiah is saying is that God accepts the righteous...but iniquity gets in the way when people assume they are righteous, when in fact they are not.
Peter finally understood this when he said...
34
Then Peter opened his mouth, and said, Of a truth I perceive that God is no respecter of persons:
35 But in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted with him.
Epi, I think you really struck out on this subject. Let me explain it in brief, if I can..
Isaiah 65:1-5...the context and background.
Isaiah the prophet is weighing in and pleading with God on behalf of the remnant of God, his people. Please still save us despite our iniquities and works of true/false human unrighteousness!!
He wanted God to remember when 'they' (their fathers) worked righteousness with joy/rejoiced when God
accepted and were
pleased with them. They knew of your mercies towards them. And now we do unrighteousness or self-righteous acts disapproved by God. He wants God's wrath to cease upon his people.
He hopes that God will reconsider and remember (give them mercy) as he pleads with him that the people are still HIS clay, and he is the potter. It is God they serve and do works for and not apart from you. And we admit (yes in guilt) that form our will and in our power we produced dirt rags of human works of self-righteousness. We will and do your will and commands. Now please save us from your wrath.
You showed favor toward our fathers, when they trusted in you and walked after your commandments and thus worked righteousness. Now please have pity and mercy on us.
God NEVER accepted(s) human powered willed versions of (self) righteousness ever and Peter would agree as he said and mean something quite different from what you took away. It also kills two birds with one stone and reveals your same err of what you think fear of God means.
(Act 10:35) but in every nation anyone who
fears him and does what is right is acceptable to him.(ESV)
(Act 10:35) God is pleased with everyone who
worships him
and does right, no matter what nation they come from. (CEV)
(Acts 10:35) Rather, whoever
respects God and does what is right is acceptable to him in any nation.(GW)
(Acts 10:35) It makes no difference what race of people one belongs to. If they show
deep reverence for God, and are committed to doing what’s right, they are acceptable before him. (TPT)
(Acts 10:35) but in every nation the man who
reveres God and practices doing right is acceptable to Him. (Williams)
Peter already knew that a genuine believer does the will of the Father and does righteousness (verse 35) I do not believe it was a sudden revelation to him, as you said he finally realized.....
BL: Simply put ALL human righteousness are always still 'filthy rags' if not accepted and pleasing to God. It destroys human righteousness in the context of Isaiah, apart or
not sanctified by God, whether one is under the OC/Law or NC/Grace for that matter.
".....true human righteousness compared with
a false human righteousness..." what doe this REALLY mean?
Only genuine believers who worship or have a highly respectful reverence (fear, as of one's human father) for God are acceptable and pleasing to him and do righteous work as they walk in the Kingdom, in Christ every day. Their righteousness is a spiritual activity by 'their hands,' of
how they live/walk and their
holiness reflects on their
character in Christ. Becoming more Christlike.
No sinner, unbeliever, imposter or false teacher does righteousness, ever. They works are always 'dirty rags': human righteousness by their own will and works and not by the will and of the Spirit of God.
And then there are a couple of a few dozen stand-outs I remember off your video:
And we NEVER establish ourselves in righteousness as you said. I believe if we do, we are making more dirty rags....
And repentance is NOT an act of righteousness,, as you favor it is such an act. It is a turn to, for the first time, or a return back to righteousness as a new or maturing believer walking in Christ.