Yeah I know GOD's people are judged first. That should be obvious to any student of scripture. It should also be obvious that it is GOD's house that is being judged, and the judgment is in regards to works, not righteousness. There will be many who think that they are going to receive great rewards at that judgment (apparently like yourself), who will be surprised to find that not everything they did or said was from the holy spirit. They will be judged for their idle words, just like the words that came out the mouth's of Job's friends, who were reprimanded by GOD for speaking the things that weren't right. Will they be cast away? Of course not. But neither will they receive the greater rewards of righteousness, just like Job's friends didn't receive the greater honor he received for speaking what was right. Was Peter cast away when he betrayed Jesus? No, but he was greatly humbled.
Since this as far as you can take the eschatological details of your theory, let me tell you the problem with your interpretation that I see.
According to your theory, the vessels of dishonor are resurrected at the first resurrection, then are rejected and cast out at the first judgment. Now as immortal beings. they wander the earth in outer darkness outside of Jerusalem for 1000 years. These people are pretty pissed off at Jesus now and join or become Gog and Magog. Next the devil is loosed, and the hordes of Gog and Magog attack Jerusalem, but are destroyed in fire. But this contradicts your teaching that they live forever wandering in outer darkness.
Bur even if they weren't destroyed in this fire, here is another problem. There will be a new earth in which righteousness, and only righteousness, dwells. GOD the father comes to earth with the new Jerusalem when all sin has been subdued and destroyed. Pissed off, immortal ex-Christians wandering the earth forever doesn't fit that scenario.