Well, different people have said different things, I'll grant you that.
You guys do get that you base all this weird Mary exaltation stuff on the protoevangelium of James, which is a forgery, which contains numerous inconsistencies with, and outright contradictions of, Scripture, which was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405 AD, and was such a train wreck that when they were considering which books to include in the New Testament canon, it was so bad that it didn't even make the lowest level ("spurious" books)? At least the "spurious" books made it far enough to be discussed and mentioned. The protoevangelium didn't even get to that point it's so bad.
At some point that historical reality HAS to be at least a bit unsettling to you.
Here, I see you are using Pope Innocent's condemnation on Protoevangelium as infallible teaching against our arguments.
While Pope Piux IX spoke on stronger teaching, the ex cathedra pronouncement: the Ineffabilis Deus on Immaculate Conception of Mary, you just reject it.
Is that an inconsistency fallacy?
Last edited: