A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Never are we commanded to pray to saints or angels living or dead.
In the scene of Jesus on the cross,
The “bystanders” are presented as allies of Jesus, since one of them gave Him a drink, in the next verse (Matthew 27:48). The next verse (27:49) again shows that this was common belief at the time: “But the others said, ‘Wait, let us see whether Eli’jah will come to save him.'


Thus, it was believed that one could pray to one such as Elijah (who had already died thousand years ago), and that he had power to come and give aid.
 
Last edited:

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Never are we commanded to pray to saints or angels living or dead.
Another scene:
Jeremiah 15:1 Then the LORD said to me, Even if Moses and Samuel stood before me, my heart would not turn toward this people. Send them away from me and let them go

God did not tell Israelite not to pray to Moses or Samuel, the context is even when they asked for Moses and Samuel for help, God will not turn towards the Israelites.

Again, GOD does not see Moses and Samuel dead people! They are 'alive' in heaven and would offer help as intercessors.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Enormous amount of things done in Jesus name are not things that glorify HIm or the Father!
If we are going to audit what is done "in Jesus's name" that fails to glorify the Father, let's look at the mirror.

Modern Non-Denominational Megachurch Branding: Complete with corporate marketing teams, coffee bars in the lobby, and fog machines on stage—none of which glorify the Father any more than a medieval hymn.

b92a7d1b43f1e2aa1317a972d85ae351

Is that a performance or a worship?
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Condemning the book as a fake gospel does not mean every single detail inside it is historically false. The Church holds that some elements within it reflected already-existing early Christian oral traditions.

Because the book (a) is a forgery (it is not written by who itself claims wrote it), (b) directly contradicts Scripture on at least three occasions, (c) was condemned by the pope himself in 405, and (d) never even made it to consideration as being remotely canonical, doesn't mean everything in it is false, but it does mean we have no good reason to trust it at all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Lamb

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You dived into a 19th century teaching and know not the modern ecumenical council of the Church (Vatican II) actually defined in Lumen Gentium (Section 55).

The modern magisterium explicitly places her victory entirely in and through Christ: she is the New Eve who cooperated uniquely with the Redeemer, but Christ alone is the ultimate victor who crushes the head of the serpent.


Like your apps in your phone, they need to be updated!


ETA: I also have explained to forum members why the image of Mary crushing the head of the serpent comes up because of an ancient translation of Genesis 3:15

NEEDED TO BE UPDATED!!!!!?????

Does "updated" here = "corrected"?

How can an infallible ex cathedra papal decree, a church dogma, need to be "updated" or corrected? Pius said what he said. Ex cathedra. Supposedly INFALLIBLE statement.

LOLOL
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If we are going to audit what is done "in Jesus's name" that fails to glorify the Father, let's look at the mirror.

Modern Non-Denominational Megachurch Branding: Complete with corporate marketing teams, coffee bars in the lobby, and fog machines on stage—none of which glorify the Father any more than a medieval hymn.

b92a7d1b43f1e2aa1317a972d85ae351

Is that a performance or a worship?

Look at you! You said something right! Excellent. I wholly agree with you on this.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
NEEDED TO BE UPDATED!!!!!?????

Does "updated" here = "corrected"?

How can an infallible ex cathedra papal decree, a church dogma, need to be "updated" or corrected? Pius said what he said. Ex cathedra. Supposedly INFALLIBLE statement.

LOLOL
The ex cathedra statement is infallible on Mary Immaculate Conception, not Mary is the one to step on the serpent’s head.
Too bad you grabbed a wrong gun.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
The ex cathedra statement is infallible on Mary Immaculate Conception, not Mary is the one to step on the serpent’s head.

The whole thing is infallible (if you believe in the infallibility of ex cathedra statements). You can't pick and choose what in there is true and what isn't true. The whole thing represents his ex cathedra statement.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
The whole thing is infallible (if you believe in the infallibility of ex cathedra statements). You can't pick and choose what in there is true and what isn't true. The whole thing represents his ex cathedra statement.
You probably have overlook Pope’s ex cathedral statement only statement:
Pius IX expresses this in Ineffabilis Deus: Mary, united with Christ, was “with him and through him” at enmity with the serpent and triumphed over it, “crushing his head with her immaculate foot.”

you only cherry pick the words you wanted.
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You probably have overlook Pope’s ex cathedral statement only statement:
Pius IX expresses this in Ineffabilis Deus: Mary, united with Christ, was “with him and through him” at enmity with the serpent and triumphed over it, “crushing his head with her immaculate foot.”

you only cherry pick the words you wanted.

It says that Mary crushed the serpent's head. Yeah, with Christ, sure. But that she was the, uh, what's the word I'm looking for, oh the "co-crusher" of the serpent's head. There's that co-redemptrix idea surfacing idea. Such an idea is completely foreign to Scripture.

Hosea 13:4 - God speaking: "But I am the LORD your God from the land of Egypt; you know no God but me, and besides me there is no savior."

Isaiah 43:11 - "I am the LORD, and besides me there is no savior."

Acts 4:12 - "And there is salvation in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved."

There is no "co-crusher" of the serpent. There is no "co-redemptrix". There is no "co-savior".
 

David Lamb

Well-Known Member
Feb 21, 2025
1,300
903
113
77
Paignton
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
You claim that auxiliary programs and traditions are fine "as long as what they do meets biblical standards," yet you instantly disqualify the communion of saints because there isn't an explicit verse commanding it.

That’s like saying: "Driving a car to church is totally fine even though cars aren’t in the Bible, but using GPS navigation on your way there is a sin because no apostle ever used a satellite map."


May be you tell us specifically what you mean by 'biblical standards'.
Means of transport ("transportation" for Americans) to church services, methods of showing words of hymns to a congregation, and similar things, are not even mentioned in the Bible. Prayer is, many times, and apart from accounts of people praying to false gods, all prayer in the Bible is addressed to God.
 

David Lamb

Well-Known Member
Feb 21, 2025
1,300
903
113
77
Paignton
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
In the scene of Jesus on the cross,
The “bystanders” are presented as allies of Jesus, since one of them gave Him a drink, in the next verse (Matthew 27:48). The next verse (27:49) again shows that this was common belief at the time: “But the others said, ‘Wait, let us see whether Eli’jah will come to save him.'


Thus, it was believed that one could pray to one such as Elijah (who had already died thousand years ago), and that he had power to come and give aid.
Where are we told that the people who said "Let us see whether Elijah will come and save Him" or the people who gave Him vinegar to drink were His allies?

NKJV Mat 27:47 Some of those who stood there, when they heard that, said, "This Man is calling for Elijah!"
Mat 27:48 Immediately one of them ran and took a sponge, filled it with sour wine and put it on a reed, and offered it to Him to drink.
Mat 27:49 The rest said, "Let Him alone; let us see if Elijah will come to save Him."

Surely His allies would not refer to Him as "this Man".
 

David Lamb

Well-Known Member
Feb 21, 2025
1,300
903
113
77
Paignton
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Another scene:
Jeremiah 15:1 Then the LORD said to me, Even if Moses and Samuel stood before me, my heart would not turn toward this people. Send them away from me and let them go

God did not tell Israelite not to pray to Moses or Samuel, the context is even when they asked for Moses and Samuel for help, God will not turn towards the Israelites.

Again, GOD does not see Moses and Samuel dead people! They are 'alive' in heaven and would offer help as intercessors.
But Jeremiah doesn't even hint that people were praying to Moses and Samuel.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Means of transport ("transportation" for Americans) to church services, methods of showing words of hymns to a congregation, and similar things, are not even mentioned in the Bible. Prayer is, many times, and apart from accounts of people praying to false gods, all prayer in the Bible is addressed to God.
Go to #229

catholic pray to God.
 

Moonwood

Member
Aug 24, 2026
690
99
28
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
I've already answered this question of yours...

You're referring to the question:

"Why did Mary ask the question?".

But that's not the question I'm referring to.

The question I'm actually referring to is the one step prior to that:

Why should Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

Those are not the same question.

Your answer to the first question has consistently been:

"Mary thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation."

I understand that explanation.

What I'm asking is why She would draw that conclusion from Gabriel's announcement:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

rather than assume the announced conception would occur through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You're referring to the question:

"Why did Mary ask the question?".

But that's not the question I'm referring to.

The question I'm actually referring to is the one step prior to that:

Why should Mary infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before consummation rather than through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph?

Those are not the same question.

Your answer to the first question has consistently been:

"Mary thought Gabriel meant She would become pregnant before consummation."

I understand that explanation.

What I'm asking is why She would draw that conclusion from Gabriel's announcement:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

rather than assume the announced conception would occur through the future marital relations you argue She expected with Joseph.

Because she asked, How can this be since I've never had sex? If she expected to have sex with Joseph, and she expected this to be a normal human reproductive process, she wouldn't have asked the question like she did.


Now...

When did Mary get pregnant? Soon, or many months later?

We know the answer. It was soon.

Mary, according to Catholic dogma, was perfect in every way. So she wouldn't have had a wrong assumption.

Would Mary have been CORRECT to assume that Gabriel meant that she would get pregnant soon? Yes or no?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Would Mary have been CORRECT to assume that Gabriel meant that she would get pregnant soon? Yes or no?
If I tell you, you would own this luxurious Bently, latest model!
2863b2e6-9cb6-486e-92a3-a2a7e1648c44.jpg

Would you be surprised, answering: 'how could it be? Money I not have!'.....knowing that a large sum of inheritance $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ will arrive next month!
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If I tell you, you would own this luxurious Bently, latest model!
2863b2e6-9cb6-486e-92a3-a2a7e1648c44.jpg

Would you be surprised, answering: 'how could it be? Money I not have!'.....knowing that a large sum of inheritance $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ will arrive next month!

That's a nonsense reply.

Mary RIGHTLY assumed that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant soon. In fact, that's precisely what Gabriel MEANT, and that's precisely what did, in fact, happen.
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
225
20
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
That's a nonsense reply.

Mary RIGHTLY assumed that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant soon. In fact, that's precisely what Gabriel MEANT, and that's precisely what did, in fact, happen.
'Gabriel meant she would be pregnant soon'
I would like to refute you as followers of 'sola scriptura' do:
Where do you find this in the Bible?

Afterall, you are not 'sola scriptura' anymore. You follow your own doctrine.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
202
61
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
'Gabriel meant she would be pregnant soon'
I would like to refute you as followers of 'sola scriptura' do:
Where do you find this in the Bible?

Afterall, you are not 'sola scriptura' anymore. You follow your own doctrine.

OMG you're joking, right? How do we know that Gabriel meant that she would be pregnant soon?

Because she did, in fact, get pregnant soon, dude.

You've gone completely off the rails here, man. Good grief.