A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Would that be like you not EVER answering which Gen 3:15 HE/SHE is correct ?
Wanna try this time ?
Vulgate or RSV-CE which one gets it right :)
go back and read #414

You are making vain repeatitions....and read what have been posted before you post.
Come back with your counterargument (if any, probably not!) ant not repeating your words.

debating skill::thumbsdown:
 
Last edited:

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
756
129
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
go back and read #414

You are making vain repeatitions....and read what have been posted before you post.
Come back with your counterargument (if any, probably not!) ant not repeating your words.

debating skill::thumbsdown:
Then the question is easy for you :)
Vulgate or RSV-CE, which one gets HE/SHE correct in Gen 3:15 ?


pssst :) :hmhehm

 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
258
84
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
How do you explain the early Protestant Reformers : Martin Luther, John Calvin, and Ulrich Zwingli, who fiercely opposed Vatican like the sale of indulgences, all fiercely defended Mary's perpetual virginity as a biblical and theological truth.

this would be the problem of modern day Protestant deformed doctrines more than by Vatican invention.

Don't forget that Luther was actually a Catholic. THEY excommunicated HIM. He didn't voluntarily leave the church.

Luther also was anti-Semitic. He also relegated some books of the Bible to "lesser" status than others. He was also a glutton and a heavy drinker.

Here's the thing: Protestants don't think their "heroes", if you will, were infallible or didn't have flaws. They were wrong on some things and right on others. Quite different from how you guys view the pope.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
258
84
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Then the question is easy for you :)
Vulgate or RSV-CE, which one gets HE/SHE correct in Gen 3:15 ?


pssst :) :hmhehm


They claim that Mary was the one who crushed the head of the serpent, based on what even Catholic Answers acknowledges is their faulty translation of Genesis 3:15. But because the church does not err, they're stuck with this error.

They claim that Mary was conceived immaculately and was without sin ("more holy than holiness"!), based on a forged text we call the protoevangelium of James, which contains direct contradictions to Scripture, lied about its own authorship, and was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405. But because the church does not err, they're stuck with this error.

They claim that Mary was assumed bodily into heaven, based on an infallible papal dogma that was based on the infallible dogma that declared the immaculate conception. So a falsehood based on a previous falsehood based on a mistranslation of Genesis 3:15. But because the church does not err, they're stuck with this error.

It's error upon error upon error, making the problem worse and worse and worse. You started with a young Jewish girl, engaged to a regular Jewish guy, who God decides to use for a supernatural purpose, and that humble girl who recognized her own need for a savior became, through a series of compounding errors, an infallible, perfect, sinless girl who wasn't even "stained" by legitimate marital sex, who was immaculately conceived, who crushed the head of the serpent, who is "more holy than holiness", who is the Queen of heaven, who is so incredible that heaven itself doesn't have the words to do her justice, who is the co-redemptrix, and to whom we ought to pray.

It's the building of a heinous heresy, brick by brick by brick, all because the church cannot admit error or else it undermines its own authority, which is the absolute non-negotiable for Rome.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dryhn

Dryhn

Active Member
Oct 29, 2026
756
129
43
Australia
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
They claim that Mary was the one who crushed the head of the serpent, based on what even Catholic Answers acknowledges is their faulty translation of Genesis 3:15. But because the church does not err, they're stuck with this error.

They claim that Mary was conceived immaculately and was without sin ("more holy than holiness"!), based on a forged text we call the protoevangelium of James, which contains direct contradictions to Scripture, lied about its own authorship, and was condemned by Pope Innocent in 405. But because the church does not err, they're stuck with this error.

They claim that Mary was assumed bodily into heaven, based on an infallible papal dogma that was based on the infallible dogma that declared the immaculate conception. So a falsehood based on a previous falsehood based on a mistranslation of Genesis 3:15. But because the church does not err, they're stuck with this error.

It's error upon error upon error, making the problem worse and worse and worse. You started with a young Jewish girl, engaged to a regular Jewish guy, who God decides to use for a supernatural purpose, and that humble girl who recognized her own need for a savior became, through a series of compounding errors, an infallible, perfect, sinless girl who wasn't even "stained" by legitimate marital sex, who was immaculately conceived, who crushed the head of the serpent, who is "more holy than holiness", who is the Queen of heaven, who is so incredible that heaven itself doesn't have the words to do her justice, who is the co-redemptrix, and to whom we ought to pray.

It's the building of a heinous heresy, brick by brick by brick, all because the church cannot admit error or else it undermines its own authority, which is the absolute non-negotiable for Rome.
I too have little respect for many of the cath dogmas yet I do admire their ability to help the needy & their ability to bring UNbelievers to Christ who then hopefully learn the truth & turn to a denomination that is not tainted by faulty teachings.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
258
84
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I too have little respect for many of the cath dogmas yet I do admire their ability to help the needy & their ability to bring UNbelievers to Christ who then hopefully learn the truth & turn to a denomination that is not tainted by faulty teachings.

Oh there's no question that the RCC does a lot of awesome things around the world. And historically, they've been a bulwark against modern theological liberalism and has held the line on moral issues like pornography, homosexuality, and abortion. They've founded some great universities and have built great hospitals and such. That's not in question. Nor is that THE question before us now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dryhn

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
714
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
Do you get that the Scriptures don't always give tone and physical communication (was the voice gentle or sarcastic or gruff? did the person lean in and speak or lean back and speak? did he wink? did he smile as he talked or did he frown?) Most of the time we aren't given any of these cues at all and are left with just the text itself, so the text doesn't give us everything we need to KNOW EXACTLY how or why something occurred.

But consider the following:

Me to you: "Look out, there's trouble coming." You promptly run and hide.

There's nothing in that short two-sentence story that tells us WHY you ran and hid, or what in my words suggested that the trouble was imminent, but your reaction tells us that, in fact, you thought that I meant that trouble was coming IMMINENTLY, which is by far the best explanation for why you did what you did.

You keep looking for things the text doesn't explicitly say AS IF THAT PROVES YOUR POINT. It doesn't. Like, not even close. The most natural reading of what Mary said in response to Gabriel was that she thought - for whatever reason - that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant SOON, which is why she asked what she asked. And that assumption (if I'm right), was, in fact, 100% correct. Maybe it was Gabriel's tone (which the text doesn't give). Maybe it was the way he looked at her (which the text doesn't say). Maybe it was mother's intuition (which the text doesn't say). Maybe it was your fanciful idea that Mary was utterly perfect in every way and wouldn't ever have made a wrong assumption (which the text doesn't say). We don't know exactly from the text WHY she would have assumed that. Just like in my little two sentence story, we don't know exactly why you would have thought I meant that trouble was imminent. But it's clear from Mary's reaction, and it's clear from your reaction in that little story, THAT she thought she would be pregnant soon, and THAT you thought trouble was imminent.



So: either Mary assumed correctly that she would be pregnant soon, or she was wrong about that, which suddenly makes Mary less than perfect. Which is it? Are you going with the "Mary is perfect and therefore wouldn't have gotten that wrong" option, or the "Mary guessed wrongly and therefore isn't as perfect as the Catholic Church makes her out to be" option? It's one or the other.

I think your analogy actually highlights the point I'm making.

In your example, we can agree that the person's reaction suggests they understood the warning as imminent.

But if I then asked:

"What in the statement 'Look out, there's trouble coming' indicates immediacy?"

pointing to the person's reaction would not answer that question. It would simply restate the fact that they reacted as though the danger were imminent.

Likewise, you've repeatedly explained Mary's question by saying that She understood Gabriel to mean that She would conceive before consummation.

I understand that explanation.

What I've been asking is the prior question:

What in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to understand it that way?

And here I think your own words are significant:

"HOW she would know this is unclear from the text."

Because that is precisely the point under discussion.

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

Yet you also maintain that Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph, including future marital relations.

So if future conception through Joseph remained the expectation Mary already had, then I still do not see what would lead Her to infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before those expected marital relations rather than through them.

And regarding the dilemma you've presented, I don't think it follows.

Even if, for the sake of argument, Mary correctly inferred that the conception would occur before consummation, that still would not explain why She drew that conclusion from Gabriel's words in the first place.

Correctness of an inference and the basis of an inference are two different questions.

My question has always been about the latter.
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
258
84
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
I think your analogy actually highlights the point I'm making.

No it doesn't. At all. That's wishful thinking on your part.

In your example, we can agree that the person's reaction suggests they understood the warning as imminent.

But if I then asked:

"What in the statement 'Look out, there's trouble coming' indicates immediacy?"

pointing to the person's reaction would not answer that question. It would simply restate the fact that they reacted as though the danger were imminent.

It indicates that the person who reacted THOUGHT it was immediate. If I say "heads up" and you immediately duck, your reaction is an obvious indication that you think I meant that something was about to hit you in the head. Even though there's nothing specific in my words that REQUIRE that interpretation on your part.

Likewise, you've repeatedly explained Mary's question by saying that She understood Gabriel to mean that She would conceive before consummation.

I understand that explanation.

You seem to have absolutely no clue about my explanation in fact, because you KEEP REPEATING THE SAME THINGS OVER AND OVER as if I haven't explained it.

What I've been asking is the prior question:

What in Gabriel's announcement would lead Mary to understand it that way?

And here I think your own words are significant:

"HOW she would know this is unclear from the text."

Because that is precisely the point under discussion.

IT IS IRRELEVANT. That it doesn't make perfectly clear what about his announcement made her think it was going to happen soon, her reaction makes it clear that SHE THOUGHT he meant it would be soon. For whatever reason. I gave a number of possibilities.

My words "heads up" doesn't require you at all to think that something was about to hit you in the head, but your reaction makes it clear that YOU THOUGHT that I meant that something was about to hit you in the head. Why else would you suddenly duck in that context?

Gabriel says only:

"You will conceive and bear a Son."

Yet you also maintain that Mary expected a normal marriage with Joseph, including future marital relations.

That has to be the default position, and evidence has to be marshaled to deviate from that position.

So if future conception through Joseph remained the expectation Mary already had, then I still do not see what would lead Her to infer from Gabriel's announcement that the conception would occur before those expected marital relations rather than through them.

Then if you can withstand some brutal honesty.... this indicates that you just aren't using your head. Or you're not paying attention. Or you're not dealing in good faith here. One of those three.

And regarding the dilemma you've presented, I don't think it follows.

Even if, for the sake of argument, Mary correctly inferred that the conception would occur before consummation, that still would not explain why She drew that conclusion from Gabriel's words in the first place.

Correctness of an inference and the basis of an inference are two different questions.

My question has always been about the latter.

I'll repeat my question:

Was Mary CORRECT that she thought Gabriel means she would be pregnant soon? Or was Mary in error thinking that it would happen later? (since, IN FACT, it DID happen soon)

If Jones murders Smith and we have it on video, complete with DNA evidence and a thousand other pieces of information, but we don't know exactly WHY Jones murdered Smith, does that mean we can't conclude that Jones murdered Smith?

You are using the fact that it isn't abundantly clear WHY Mary would have surmised that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant soon to argue that that therefore means we can't know or reasonably conclude that she DID surmise that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant soon.

Mary's reaction is on video tape. Because you don't know WHY, you're arguing that her reaction didn't happen. It did. And she was RIGHT. Because she did, in fact, get pregnant immediately (or very soon).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dryhn