Who says you have to be one or the other? I am neither.
It all depends on how you define 'catholic'. BreadOfLife sees only the Roman Church as catholic. But catholic just means universal. Look at the 'Apostles Creed'. The word 'catholic' was originally not capitalized. That is because it spoke of the entire body of Christians. And you as a believer in Christ, are part of the catholic church. In other words, you can truthfully recite 'I believe in the holy catholic church'.
A Protestant is one who is aligned with any group of Christians who identify with those who separated (protested) from the Roman Church. And it is possible you do not belong to any of those. But if you consider the Roman Church and it's doctrines, and do not believe you could be a part, then you are protestant in spirit.
But you are still 'catholic'. You just are not 'Roman Catholic'.
Stranger