A Textual Challenge to the “Mary and Joseph Had Later Relations” Position

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Moonwood

Active Member
Aug 24, 2026
714
100
43
Washington
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Female
If Mary was sinless then she would not have needed a savior

Luke 1:47 And my spirit hath rejoiced in God my Saviour.

Mary indeed needed a Savior. Catholics do not believe otherwise. Rather, they believe She was saved in a unique way: not by being cleansed after falling into sin, but by being preserved from sin through the merits of Christ's future sacrifice. The physician who prevents a disease has saved just as surely as the physician who cures one.

"The Most Holy Trinity descended with Its perfections, inhabited with Its Three Persons, enclosed Its infinity in a small space. But It did not debase Itself by doing so, because the love of the Virgin and the will of God widened this space until they rendered it a Heaven. And the Most Holy Trinity made Itself known by Its characteristics:

The Father, being once again the Creator of the creature, as on the sixth day of Creation, had a real, worthy daughter fashioned to His perfect image. The mark of God was impressed so completely and exactly on Mary, that only in the Firstborn was it greater. Mary can be called the Second-born of the Father because, owing to the perfection granted to Her and preserved by Her, and to Her dignity of Spouse and Mother of God and Queen of Heaven, She comes second after the Son of the Father and second in His eternal thought, which ab aeterno took delight in Her.

The Son, being also "Her Son", did teach Her, by the mystery of Grace, His truth and wisdom, when He was but an Embryo, growing in Her womb.

The Holy Spirit appeared amongst men, for an anticipated prolonged Pentecost: Love for "Her Whom He loved", Consolation to men because of the Fruit of Her Womb, Sanctification on account of the Maternity of the Holy One.

God, to reveal Himself to men in the new and complete form, which starts the Redemption era, did not select for His throne a star in the sky, nor the palace of a powerful man. Neither did He want the wings of angels as the base of His feet. He wanted a spotless womb.

Also Eve had been created spotless. But she wanted to become corrupt of her own free will. Mary, Who lived in a corrupt world—Eve was in a pure world—did not wish to violate Her purity, not even with one thought remotely connected with sin. She knew that sin exists. She saw its various and horrible forms and implications. She saw them all, including the most hideous one: deicide. But She knew them solely to expiate them and to be, forever, the Woman who has mercy on sinners and prays for their redemption."
 

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
258
84
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
That's a different question from the one I've been asking.

I've never argued that Mary was mistaken.

My question is why, from Gabriel's words:

"You will conceive and bear a Son,"

Mary would infer a pre-consummation conception rather than a conception through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph.

Whether Mary could be mistaken is a separate issue.

Even if I granted for the sake of argument that Mary could not be mistaken, that still would not explain why She would draw that particular conclusion from Gabriel's announcement in the first place.

That is the point I've been asking about throughout this discussion.

Ok if Mary could not have been mistaken, then she would NOT have inferred from Gabriel that she would be pregnant LATER.

Inescapable conclusion: Mary correctly inferred that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant SOON. (HOW she would know this is unclear from the text - could have been Gabriel's tone, which we can't read from words on a page; could have been Mary's perfect mother's intuition...who knows.)

So you are left with either agreeing with me that Mary correctly assumed she would be pregnant soon, or agreeing with me that Mary was a flawed individual who incorrectly assumed that she would be pregnant later. Which one are you choosing?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Ok if Mary could not have been mistaken, then she would NOT have inferred from Gabriel that she would be pregnant LATER.
Inescapable conclusion: Mary correctly inferred that Gabriel meant she would be pregnant SOON. (HOW she would know this is unclear from the text - could have been Gabriel's tone, which we can't read from words on a page; could have been Mary's perfect mother's intuition...who knows.)

So you are left with either agreeing with me that Mary correctly assumed she would be pregnant soon, or agreeing with me that Mary was a flawed individual who incorrectly assumed that she would be pregnant later. Which one are you choosing?
Ok...then you are now using interpretation 'unclear from the text'....then it is not 'sola scriptura' any more!
You have just violated your own doctrine!

Afterall, what 'sola scriptura' actually mean is 'sole interpretation'!
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
So you are left with either agreeing with me that Mary correctly assumed she would be pregnant soon, or agreeing with me that Mary was a flawed individual who incorrectly assumed that she would be pregnant later. Which one are you choosing?
Why would you not agree with me that Mary had took a vow on perpetual virginity to GOD, so she would be surprised GOD asked her to know man?
That makes sense for Gabriel explained to her, her conception would be a miracle, by HOLY SPIRIT, like her cousin Elizabeth.
 
Last edited:

Crazy Ivan

Member
Jun 23, 2026
258
84
28
56
Connecticut
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Why would you not agree with me that Mary had took a vow on perpetual virginity to GOD, so she would be surprised GOD asked her to know man?
That makes sense for Gabriel explained to her, her conception would be a miracle, by HOLY SPIRIT, like her cousin Elizabeth.

Because there's no reason to believe such a nonsense idea. No chance am I trusting a legend created by a forged document that has numerous flat-out contradictions with Scripture, and that was condemned by a pope, of all people.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
You accused me of reading Mary's mind. I'm not doing that. I'm pointing to the sequence of events Luke records:
  1. Gabriel announces that Mary will conceive.
  2. Mary asks, "How will this occur, since I know not man?"
  3. Gabriel answers with divine action by the Holy Spirit.
  4. Gabriel appeals to Elizabeth's otherwise impossible conception.
  5. Gabriel concludes, "For nothing will be impossible with God."
Those are Luke's words, not my speculations.

Now you've responded by saying that Luke is focused on the virgin birth.
And for about the tenth time- these say absolutely nothing about Joseph and Mary having marital relations.; Maybe you really are that dense!
If Mary's expectation was that She would eventually conceive through ordinary marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke portray Her virginity as the difficulty, and why does Gabriel answer with miraculous conception and an appeal to divine impossibility?

Simply saying "Luke is focused on the virgin birth" doesn't resolve the issue. It highlights it.

The entire discussion concerns why Mary asks the question she asks and why Gabriel gives the answer he gives.

If you believe the answer is obvious, then explain the connection between Mary's reference to not knowing a man and Gabriel's appeal to divine intervention.

That's the textual question I've been asking from the beginning, and it still hasn't been addressed.
Prove otherwise! That is the issue. Yopu are amking the assertions of her perpetual virginity so you have to prove it.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Jesus IS our only Mediator since only HIS sacrifice can bring bring peace between us and the Father.
HOWEVER - we are ALL called on to be intercessors for one another . . .
So show me from Scripture where we are to pray to those who have physically died! When you do that I will answer you roff topic question.
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Mary would infer a pre-consummation conception rather than a conception through the future marital relations you say She expected with Joseph.
Quite simply: I f MAry was to stay a virgin She would have said " How can this be since I will never know a man"? Also they would have broken the Mosaic law by abstaining from sexual relations as husband and wife, unless there was a command from god! where is that command?
 

Ronald Nolette

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
17,021
5,030
113
72
South Carolina
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
If Mary's expectation was that She would eventually conceive through ordinary marital relations with Joseph, why does Luke portray Her virginity as the difficulty, and why does Gabriel answer with miraculous conception and an appeal to divine impossibility?
Well a lesson for you. Both in the OT and NT a couple was not considered married until they consummated their marriage by sex! "the two become one flesh". So if Jospeh and Mary never had sex they were never married! Unless of course you canshow that God directly gave them a dispensation to refrain from sex and thus not be married in the way God prescribed for mankind!

Apriest, minister, RAbbi, or Justice of the Peace do not marry people, the ceremony only authorizes the couple to become married in the marriage bed. Even you rRoman priests know that!
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLT63

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,773
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
So show me FROM SCRIPTURE where we are to pray to those who have physically died! When you do that I will answer you roff topic question.
First – YOU need to show me where Sola Scriptura is taught in Scripture.
The idea that EVERYTHING we believe MUST be on the pages of Scripture is condemned by Scripture itself (2 Thess 2:15, Luke 10:16).

You only consider this to be “off-topic” because you CAN’T answer the question . . . . . .
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Unless of course you canshow that God directly gave them a dispensation to refrain from sex and thus not be married in the way God prescribed for mankind!
St Jerome and St. Augustine in their writings actually taught Joseph and Mary remain lifelong virgin.

While you focused on Matthew 1:25, you missed 1:20 when angel of Lord appeared and explained to Joseph about Mary's pregnancy with HOLY SPIRIT, bearing the Son of God. Joseph, as a righteous man, accepted this divine mystery and respected her consecration.


Their union achieved the highest spiritual fruit of marriage: mutual holiness, protection, raising the Christ child, and total devotion to God, without requiring physical intimacy.


I see such teachings would never have mentioned by your pastors who were ignorant on them as well.
 
Last edited:

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,605
2,899
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
St Jerome and St. Augustine in their writings actually taught Joseph and Mary remain lifelong virgin.

While you focused on Matthew 3:25, you missed 3:20 when angel of Lord appeared and explained to Joseph about Mary's pregnancy with HOLY SPIRIT, bearing the Son of God. Joseph, as a righteous man, accepted this divine mystery and respected her consecration.


Their union achieved the highest spiritual fruit of marriage: mutual holiness, protection, raising the Christ child, and total devotion to God, without requiring physical intimacy.


I see such teachings would never have mentioned by your pastors who were ignorant on them as well.
Joseph was a perpetual virgin?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
Joseph was a perpetual virgin?
As I said in above post, you never have heard about this before!

You only know one version of this :
Matthew 1:25 :knew her not till she had brought forth her firstborn son: and he called his name Jesus.

Your over-devotion to the doctrine of 'sola scriptura' actually shuts you out from understanding GOD's words.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: RLT63

BreadOfLife

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2017
22,773
3,837
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Quite simply: I f MAry was to stay a virgin She would have said " How can this be since I will never know a man"? Also they would have broken the Mosaic law by abstaining from sexual relations as husband and wife, unless there was a command from god! where is that command?
First of all – not only CAN God make exceptions to work His will – He DOES make exceptions.
Mary becoming pregnant WITHOUT a man is just ONE of those exceptions . . .

- Genesis 18:32 God made an exception for those in Sodom and Gomorrah . . .
- Matt. 12:3–4
Disciples eating consecrated Tabernacle Bread . . .
- Luke 6:1–5
Disciples pick grain on the Sabbath . . .

If you disagree with God for making exceptions – take it up with HIM . . .

Secondly – Mary’s question to the Angel Gabriel is very telling about her intention to remain a virgin:
Luke 1:34:

Then Mary said to the angel,
“How can this be, since I DO NOT know a man?”

Mary KEW about marital relations. She didn’t say: “How can this be, since I HAVE NOT known a man?”
She said: “How can this be, since DO NOT know a man?”

She was stating her intention to remain a virgin and was puzzled by Gabriel’s announcement that she was to have a child. She knew that God was aware of her intentions. Her bewilderment and the words “I do not know”, as opposed to “I have not known”, is clear evidence that she had NO intention of having marital relations.

This is supported by Early Church writings. The 2nd century document, The Protoevangelium explains how Joseph was an elderly man who married Mary as a protector because she was a consecrated Temple virgin.

Many of your Protestant Fathers like Martin Luther, John Calvin and Ulrich Zwingli held Mary in high regard venerated her as a sinless person and/or perpetual virgin:
 

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,605
2,899
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
As I said in above post, you never have heard about this before!

You only know one version of this :
Matthew 1:25 :knew her not till she had brought forth her firstborn son: and he called his name Jesus.

Your over-devotion to the doctrine of 'sola scriptura' actually shuts you out from understanding GOD's words.
Is Joseph another immaculate conception?
 

RLT63

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2022
4,605
2,899
113
Montgomery
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Joseph did not need immculate conception because he was not the biological father of Jesus.
Jesus did not need his DNA, which carries original sin.
What purpose did it serve for Joseph to remain a virgin?
 

beechan

Member
Oct 28, 2026
255
21
18
Zion
Faith
Christian
Country
Greenland
Gender
Male
What purpose did it serve for Joseph to remain a virgin?
St. John Paul II and modern theologians (like Scott Hahn) emphasize that St. Joseph's virginal fatherhood uniquely mirrors the fatherhood of God on earth.