Should we debate theology on social media? - Advice from John MacArthur

[Matthias]

Agree or disagree?

 

[Patrick1966]

I enjoy discussing doctrine. The problem is that many cannot do so without getting angry. When I'm with other Christians and I stick to the basics, love God, love one another, and try to live a Godly life. Anything beyond that risks negative feedback from others.

 

[Matthias]

I enjoy discussing doctrine. The problem is that many cannot do so without getting angry. When I'm with other Christians and I stick to the basics, love God, love one another, and try to live a Godly life. Anything beyond that risks negative feedback from others.

There are major differences between debate and discussion.

I have no interest in debating. I have much interest in discussing.

 

[Patrick1966]

There are major differences between debate and discussion.

I have no interest in debating. I have much interest in discussing.

I'm with you. Many view such "discussion" as an opportunity to debate or to win an argument.

 

[Matthias]

I'm with you. Many view such "discussion" as an opportunity to debate or to win an argument.

They have their reward, at least in their minds.

I learned a long time ago, the hard way, that debating is a lose - lose proposition for those who engage in them. It causes people (on both sides) to close their minds and to act in ways which they otherwise wouldn’t.

I gave up debating around 20 years ago when I saw what it was doing to me and to others - hardening our hearts.

 

[Matthias]

I read the linked article a couple of days ago and think it makes a number of good points about the advantages of discussion over debate.

Debate and Discussion: Yes, They Are Different

What are the differences between debate and discussion and argument? There are some important ones you need to know, read on to find out more.

www.uopeople.edu

 

[Matthias]

Should we debate theology on social media? I agree with MacArthur that it’s a waste of time. And worse.

Should we discuss theology on social media? I wouldn’t be doing it if I thought that I shouldn’t. And I encourage others to discuss it.

 

[Patrick1966]

They have their reward, at least in their minds.

I learned a long time ago, the hard way, that debating is a lose - lose proposition for those who engage in them. It causes people (on both sides) to close their minds and to act in ways which they otherwise wouldn’t.

I gave up debating around 20 years ago when I saw what it was doing to me and to others - hardening our hearts.

Amen.

 

[Matthias]